New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Annulment - ???

Ok....... so here how it works....

You contact your catholic diocese office and tell them you want to start an anullment. They ask you a bunch of questions and send you some information. You must be actually legally divorced before you start this process.

They send you a packet of information that is about 5 - 6 pages of short answer questions. By the time I got done writing all my answers - my response was about 20 pages long. The whole point of an anullment is to find out if there was something "wrong" with the couple at the time they were married that would have prohibited that marriage from being a valid marriage according to cannon law.

So.... some of those things are... if you intended to contracept. Since cannon law requires you to be open to life - intending upon your marriage to use contraception would make your marriage invalid because according to the church unless you intended to do anything other than NFP - you shouldn't have been getting married in the first place. So, something was impeding you from giving valid consent. Other examples are things like if when you got married you didn't necessarily intend for it to last until death do you part. So, if you knew there were issues and still got married and figured well if it doesn't work - we can just divorce, that would NOT be valid consent because you were supposed to be intending on till death do you part. If one of you were being coerced - like there was a pregnancy and you felt like you HAD to get married - that could make the marriage in valid. In some cases not having enough pre-marriage counseling or classes so that you can claim you didn't understand the permanence of marriage may be a ground for annulment.

It is not "catholic divorce" and it doesn't make any kids illigitimate. It simply means that at the time of consent you did not or were not able to give complete consent.

So, you do your questionaire, then they assign you an advocate, or will essentially argue in person your "case" before the Tribunal - who are a bunch of cannon experts. Your advocate reviews your questionaire with you, determines what grounds he will ask for and writes some stuff. Meanwhile at least 3 "witnesses' will also get questionaires from the Diocese - they have to essentially fill out questions about you at the time of your marriage and their responses will hopefully back up the grounds that your advocate works out. Then your EX will also get a similiar form.

Then once they get everyone's info back ( they give you 30 days as the ex to respond then they just deem you non responsive) they move the annulment on and it is taken to the tribunal. Your advocate either in person or in writing argues for you, and someone else is appointed to defend the marriage.

Then the tribunal rules if there were sufficient grounds to declare your marriage null. Then if they do, it is given to the appeals board who reviews it, and if they agree - then you receive your annulment.

It is possible with cases where someone is married many times or there seems to be some other psychological issues, that the Tribunal will require that that person have additional counseling or pre-cana or that they have to have a waiting period etc.

The Church will not schedule your wedding until you have received your Declaration of Nullity.

Since, the Church automatically considers any subsequent marriages invalid by the sheer fact that they weren't eligible to be married for second or third or fourth time until they had their prior marriages anulled, annulling the subsequent marriages is considered procedural and while you have to fill out paperwork, etc you will receive the Declaration of Nullity for subsequent marriages without the whole dog and pony show listed above. So, you go through the big process the first time, and the other ones are just paperwork.

There are slight variations from Diocese to Diocese. They cost the same no matter who you are - around $500 bucks, BUT they will still do it if you say you can not pay.

Relatively speaking it is fairly easy to nullify a non-catholic's prior marriage. For one, they probably intended to contracept. They also generally aren't required to do any pre-marriage counseling or classes - so they can claim they weren't prepared and didn't get that marriage was for life - easier than a Catholic can. Because for Catholics, they are supposed to go to the pre-cana, etc, and where they have the permanence of marriage drilled into them - so its hard to claim that.

My anullment as a non-catholic to marry my Catholic DH took about 9 months. They average 18 months. But, I am super organized and anal and got my friends to get their stuff back right away and sort of kept on the process. The time was a bear. I probably spent 60 hours on my questionaire and research to make sure I understood what "grounds" were and following up on things.

ETA - if you are a Catholic who marries outside of the Church - like a justice of the peace wedding - your marriage is considered invalid - and that is a MUCH simpler quick process.

connie

In other words it means that religious beliefs are pure BULLSHIT. What it means is if you can lie good, tell a good story and make others believe it your fair game to breed anyone you want under the guise of marriage vows and they mean not a dam thing. All you need to do is convince yourself that the lie you are telling is true and since religion is nothing much more than lies told as stories, you pay so much and they will make it happen.,

If I remember right most churches want you go through all this garbage that you are now using before you get married, so how can you afterwards say I didn't know, or wasn't sure or any other lie you can come up with. It's like getting a seventh foul in a BB game that calls for 5, saying i didn't really plan on fouling the guy.
 
Common sense screams at the top of it's lungs that children born of a false (putative is the official RCC terminology) marriage are no different than are children born of unwed parents. That said, the RCC claims the power to magically declare these children "legitimate". According to canon law, even children of parents who never attempted, nor intended, to marry may be granted "legitimacy" via Papal Rescript.

Canon 1137 Children who are conceived or born of a valid or of a putative marriage are legitimate.

Canon 1138.1 The father is he who is identified by a lawful marriage, unless by clear arguments the contrary is proven.

Canon 1138.2 Children are presumed legitimate who are born at least 180 days after the date the marriage was celebrated, or within 300 days from the date of the dissolution of conjugal life.

Canon 1139 Illegitimate children are legitimated by the subsequent marriage of their parents, whether valid or putative, or by a rescript of the Holy See.

Canon 1140 As far as canonical effects are concerned, legitimated children are equivalent to legitimate children in all respects, unless it is otherwise expressly provided by the law.
 
Common sense screams at the top of it's lungs that children born of a false (putative is the official RCC terminology) marriage are no different than are children born of unwed parents. That said, the RCC claims the power to magically declare these children "legitimate". According to canon law, even children of parents who never attempted, nor intended, to marry may be granted "legitimacy" via Papal Rescript.

Canon 1137 Children who are conceived or born of a valid or of a putative marriage are legitimate.

Canon 1138.1 The father is he who is identified by a lawful marriage, unless by clear arguments the contrary is proven.

Canon 1138.2 Children are presumed legitimate who are born at least 180 days after the date the marriage was celebrated, or within 300 days from the date of the dissolution of conjugal life.

Canon 1139 Illegitimate children are legitimated by the subsequent marriage of their parents, whether valid or putative, or by a rescript of the Holy See.

Canon 1140 As far as canonical effects are concerned, legitimated children are equivalent to legitimate children in all respects, unless it is otherwise expressly provided by the law.

Thanks Nightswimmer, well that answers the question of whether the children are illigetimate. I still don't get it, but then again I don't understand how a marriage can be annulled in the first place so I suppose I don't need to get it. Apparently the pope giveth and taketh away.
 
In other words it means that religious beliefs are pure BULLSHIT. What it means is if you can lie good, tell a good story and make others believe it your fair game to breed anyone you want under the guise of marriage vows and they mean not a dam thing. All you need to do is convince yourself that the lie you are telling is true and since religion is nothing much more than lies told as stories, you pay so much and they will make it happen.,

If I remember right most churches want you go through all this garbage that you are now using before you get married, so how can you afterwards say I didn't know, or wasn't sure or any other lie you can come up with. It's like getting a seventh foul in a BB game that calls for 5, saying i didn't really plan on fouling the guy.

How does that make religious beliefs BS? The fact that someone can lie doesn't mean that whoever they're lying to is a liar, too. Or fake.

I think what connie described is a system where the Church does the best they can to get at the truth. And I think Greenridgeman said....God sees through any boloney. So if someone lies, and then gets their anullment because they lied well, and ends up having another Catholic wedding.....God will catch up with them.
 
How does that make religious beliefs BS? The fact that someone can lie doesn't mean that whoever they're lying to is a liar, too. Or fake.

I think what connie described is a system where the Church does the best they can to get at the truth. And I think Greenridgeman said....God sees through any boloney. So if someone lies, and then gets their anullment because they lied well, and ends up having another Catholic wedding.....God will catch up with them.

Gigi - actually I think that when people decide to get married - and they're both adults and the marriage is not arranged by others - they are responsible for that marriage. It is just strange that the Catholic church can come along and declare that the marriage is null and void. It seems to make all marriages suspect because one party can decide, after the fact of the divorce, to have the church declare that the marriage never took place at all. Since the reasons the church allows people to use to declare the marriage null (e.g., "I didn't know what I was doing" or "he/she wanted me to use birth control") are so easy to state or to lie about, why is the church getting involved in this? Rather than having people jump through hoops to get their prior marriage(s) annulled, it seems the church would be simply happy to marry them in the church and levy whatever requirements (e.g., raise the children as Catholic) that they believe are important.
 
I know of more than a few Catholics who have done that. I don't understand it either. But if someone wants to marry in the Catholic church and is divorces, it cannot be done............. but apparently anyone can get an annulment if they are able to jump through the hoops. I do not know what the definition of "annulment" is in the Catholic church, but it apparently is something in that definition (and no doubt $$$$) that allows for another marriage in the church even if there were children from the original marriage.
 
I was Christened into the Church, come from over a thousand years of Catholics on one side.

I get my religion from the King James Bible and my theology from Milton.

Milton repudiates all the Church's foolish ritualism, IMHO.

That said, to each as the Spirit moves them.

I have many Catholic friends and relatives, I just do not share the belief that the ritual is important.

A minor difference, we all come to the Father throught the Son.
 
I was Christened into the Church, come from over a thousand years of Catholics on one side.

I get my religion from the King James Bible and my theology from Milton.

Milton repudiates all the Church's foolish ritualism, IMHO.

That said, to each as the Spirit moves them.

I have many Catholic friends and relatives, I just do not share the belief that the ritual is important.

A minor difference, we all come to the Father throught the Son.


Obviously I disagree with you about Catholicism.
But I had to tell you.....I loved your last line there!
 
Gigi - actually I think that when people decide to get married - and they're both adults and the marriage is not arranged by others - they are responsible for that marriage. It is just strange that the Catholic church can come along and declare that the marriage is null and void. It seems to make all marriages suspect because one party can decide, after the fact of the divorce, to have the church declare that the marriage never took place at all. Since the reasons the church allows people to use to declare the marriage null (e.g., "I didn't know what I was doing" or "he/she wanted me to use birth control") are so easy to state or to lie about, why is the church getting involved in this? Rather than having people jump through hoops to get their prior marriage(s) annulled, it seems the church would be simply happy to marry them in the church and levy whatever requirements (e.g., raise the children as Catholic) that they believe are important.

I don't think it's a matter of declaring that the marriage never took place. Rather, the marriage wasn't valid for a number of reasons. But they don't deny that the physical getting married and setting up home actually happened. Anullment says that one or both partners refused to participate in a Catholic marriage, or didn't have the capacity at the time to participate in it.
 
A Christian is a Christian whether they are Catholic or Baptist.

I was Christened into the Church, come from over a thousand years of Catholics on one side.

I get my religion from the King James Bible and my theology from Milton.

Milton repudiates all the Church's foolish ritualism, IMHO.

That said, to each as the Spirit moves them.

I have many Catholic friends and relatives, I just do not share the belief that the ritual is important.

A minor difference, we all come to the Father throught the Son.
 
I don't think it's a matter of declaring that the marriage never took place. Rather, the marriage wasn't valid for a number of reasons. But they don't deny that the physical getting married and setting up home actually happened. Anullment says that one or both partners refused to participate in a Catholic marriage, or didn't have the capacity at the time to participate in it.

It's not so much about INvalidating the prior marriage, as VALidating the new one. The Church should get its props -even from skeptical non-Catholics, for the priority it gives to the future over the past.
 
Why do we have to be so stupid in this matter. If two people can't get along and it ends up causing the marriage to have differences that can't be worked out, its called DIVORCE. EOS. It's basically the same in the catholic Church, as hardly any annulments are not granted except in cases that they don't want the person in their church.

The death do us part should be taken out of marriage vows because it means nothing. Really marriage means noting in the world we live in.
We should have legal partnerships that are drawn up and state what the outcome of different acts of behavior will end up causing, who will get what and so on.

50,000 annulments a year. get real church people, it's a game not an institution.
 
Matthew 19: They *said to Him, “Why then did Moses command to giver her a certificate of divorce and send her away?” Jesus said to them, “Because of your hardness of heart Moses permitted you to divorce your wives; but from the beginning it has not been this way.”

Sounds to me like God in both the Old and New Testament times speaks of divorce as being a very grave matter that has sinful repercussions in many ways to come. And yet, it is granted because He knows human nature and to send anyone to hell for this would be too punitive because too often man cannot bear his situation and must flee.

So the Catholic Church sort of follows the same model and allows annulments in special circumstances only. Remarriage without an anullment remains a serious offense.

So why do certain celebrities or influential people get annulments when it is apparent most others would have those same circumstance denied? I am not sure, but my guesses are that the particular bishop’s office does not want to cause a greater scandal by making it a bigger story of denial. Sinatra got an annulment, so did Teddy Kennedy and if they were denied a sordid story would persist at the Church’s expense as well. You can call it a cop out on the Church’s part, a cowardly act for the sake of saving face for famous people. It is a fault that sullies the Church. Henry VIII should have been so lucky. Times have changed I guess.

----------------------------------------------------------------

If your reason for asking is to merely find some incongruities in Catholic practice you have succeeded. But if this is to be used as Exhibit A to offer proof the whole Catholic faith is based on some farce, it has no bearing. (I was just curious of motives.)
 
So the Catholic Church sort of follows the same model and allows annulments in special circumstances only. Remarriage without an anullment remains a serious offense.


50,000 annulments a year is a special case. The truth is most annulments are granted to keep the catholic base in tack, it has nothing to do much with being what God would want.

Taking communion is just another church thingey, aimed at one time as a way to keep people from divorcing. saying that if you divorced you couldn't partake. Now they just hand out annulments as it was driving too many people from the church.
 
Religion is a hard thing to understand when you look at the effect of people believing in god.


In short, 809 million people have died in religious wars. That’s nearly a billion people. Everyone thinking their ideas are right and others should fall in line with their way of thinking.
 
A Christian is a Christian whether they are Catholic or Baptist.

Many who claim Christianity these days belong to no church whatsoever. They simply rely upon their own, personal "Holy Spirit" to guide them to do whatever they wish. Such an arrangement gives them the best of both worlds. They still have Jesus as a "get out of jail free" card in their back pocket and they aren't required to adhere to any archaic rules or regulations written by ancient political leaders wearing magic robes or underwear.
 
So the Catholic Church sort of follows the same model and allows annulments in special circumstances only. Remarriage without an anullment remains a serious offense.


50,000 annulments a year is a special case. The truth is most annulments are granted to keep the catholic base in tack, it has nothing to do much with being what God would want.

Taking communion is just another church thingey, aimed at one time as a way to keep people from divorcing. saying that if you divorced you couldn't partake. Now they just hand out annulments as it was driving too many people from the church.


I already explained anullments to you as best I could. It's a messy busines with no easy answers, plus it is conducted by sinners, i.e. Catholics. It would still do you well to pay heed to what the Church is trying to say to you.
 
809 million! Not 810 million, or 808.53 million, no precicesly 809 million.

Because YOU said so.

Does that count cavemen who lived on different sides of a river, and fought and kill over which direction the nose bone should be inserted, from right to left, or from left to right?
 
Well, that sums it up tidily for YOU.

I would answer, there is no "personal" Holy Spirit, though, the Holy Spirit can guide one into a personal relationship with Christ.

A Christ, by the way, that surely sees through any "arrangements" one might have made with one's conscience.

I feel for anyone who thinks Jesus is a "get out of jail free" card.

Jesus freed us from "archaic rules and regulations written by ancient political leaders wearing magic robes or underwear".

He did not free us from Hisbasic, simple teachings, nor in any way give us license to openly defy Him.
 
Back
Top