New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Another progressive meme smashed...

Well Geez man, they paid for all that. The employees they hire pay taxes to support that stuff. The only reason to tax business, because, lets face it, even the progressives know (and acknowledge) that business taxes chase business out:
Yet corporations use courts, roads, and regulatory agencies more often than individuals; why should they not pay for the infrastructure that makes their bonus pools possible?
http://wallstreetonparade.com/
"The loony policies of laissez-faire capitalism of Fed Chair Alan Greenspan, whoworshiped at the feet of Ayn Rand, were also bailed out by the events of 9/11. :p

"Members of the Senate Banking Committee praised him on September 20, 2001 for his performance. Amazingly, at this hearing, just nine days after the attack, not one Senator asked Greenspan how much money the Fed had spent or to whom it went.

"The percolating collapse of Wall Street was held off for seven more years until 2008 when it finally became impossible to deny that Greenspan’s brand of financial deregulation and the repeal of the Glass-Steagall Act he had pushed for, had left Wall Street in ruins – without any assault from the skies."
 
Yet corporations use courts, roads, and regulatory agencies more often than individuals; why should they not pay for the infrastructure that makes their bonus pools possible?
http://wallstreetonparade.com/
"The loony policies of laissez-faire capitalism of Fed Chair Alan Greenspan, whoworshiped at the feet of Ayn Rand, were also bailed out by the events of 9/11. :p

"Members of the Senate Banking Committee praised him on September 20, 2001 for his performance. Amazingly, at this hearing, just nine days after the attack, not one Senator asked Greenspan how much money the Fed had spent or to whom it went.

"The percolating collapse of Wall Street was held off for seven more years until 2008 when it finally became impossible to deny that Greenspan’s brand of financial deregulation and the repeal of the Glass-Steagall Act he had pushed for, had left Wall Street in ruins – without any assault from the skies."

No, the employees of the corporations do. The "infrastructure" enables employees to be employed. Customers to get to stores. The packages to be delivered. Again, we know by New York's tax policy that they know that business taxes reduce business opportunities and jobs. So who, other than barking mad anti-capitalists would want to tax businesses?
 
No, the employees of the corporations do. The "infrastructure" enables employees to be employed. Customers to get to stores. The packages to be delivered. Again, we know by New York's tax policy that they know that business taxes reduce business opportunities and jobs. So who, other than barking mad anti-capitalists would want to tax businesses?
You believe corporations bear no responsibility for contributing to deficit reduction or investment in the economic future of the US?

More than two dozen big corps including GE, Verizon, and Boeing paid no federal income taxes over the past four years while "earning" billion$ in profits.

78 of the Fortune 500 paid $0 or less in at least one year between 2008 and 2010 yet they all used government supplied infrastructure in order to amass their profits.

Why should corporations, which would not even exist without a government charter, be allowed to prosper at the expense of natural citizens?

http://www.americansfortaxfairness....rations-should-pay-their-fair-share-of-taxes/
 
You believe corporations bear no responsibility for contributing to deficit reduction or investment in the economic future of the US?

More than two dozen big corps including GE, Verizon, and Boeing paid no federal income taxes over the past four years while "earning" billion$ in profits.

78 of the Fortune 500 paid $0 or less in at least one year between 2008 and 2010 yet they all used government supplied infrastructure in order to amass their profits.

Why should corporations, which would not even exist without a government charter, be allowed to prosper at the expense of natural citizens?

http://www.americansfortaxfairness....rations-should-pay-their-fair-share-of-taxes/

I think businesses have the responsibility to operate honestly while contributing to a growing, more prosperous economy. Any taxes paid by businesses detracts from that primary mission. Why anyone would sacrifice jobs and prosperity on the alter of wealth redistribution, through business taxation, is a complete mystery to me (unless, for some reason their goal is to weaken, rather than strengthen, the economy).

The simple answer to your final question is that "corporations" do not prosper, any more than they do pay the taxation. It is the business owners and customers, every one an individual person, who benefit from corporate growth and also pay the business tax obligations.

Again, we know because the progressives in New York have admitted that it is so, that taxation of businesses reduce the number and size of business entities in an economy. Why, as our economy sputters and slogs along, we would be looking to maintain these anti-job and anti-wealth creating business taxes is quite perplexing, unless, as I said, your goal is to reduce economic opportunity. It may well be, especially for the Marxists among us. But why anyone who isn't a Marxist thinks taxing businesses is a good idea is truly confounding to me.
 
affordable healthcare means either poor patient services, or deferred building maintenance/modernization/repairs.

in the case of Britain, it evidently means both.
 
We're frequently scolded when we point out the ongoing failure that is known as Obamacare.

What you perceive as scolding is just education. As you have been informed, the rate of healthcare costs increases has slowed since Obamacare became law, the percentage of Americans covered by health insurance has grown significantly, and actual public health outcomes have improved, both in absolute terms and relative to many of our peers. Is that a "failure"? Well, I suppose it is if you come from the perspective of an Ayn Rand cultist, where government action is, by definition, failure. But if the goal was to control costs while improving health, it's been a qualified, success, so far.

Granted, our health system still looks worse than the more socialized systems of many other wealthy nations, in terms of both cost and outcome. But it's been an improvement over what we had before, which was an utter train wreck. For decades US health stats slipped relative to other wealthy nations, while our costs grew at a much greater pace, to the point we were spending about twice as much per capita as was typical among wealthy nations while living much sicklier, shorter lives. Next to that kind of unmitigated disaster, pretty much anything would be an improvement.
 
What you perceive as scolding is just education. As you have been informed, the rate of healthcare costs increases has slowed since Obamacare became law, the percentage of Americans covered by health insurance has grown significantly, and actual public health outcomes have improved, both in absolute terms and relative to many of our peers. Is that a "failure"? Well, I suppose it is if you come from the perspective of an Ayn Rand cultist, where government action is, by definition, failure. But if the goal was to control costs while improving health, it's been a qualified, success, so far.

Granted, our health system still looks worse than the more socialized systems of many other wealthy nations, in terms of both cost and outcome. But it's been an improvement over what we had before, which was an utter train wreck. For decades US health stats slipped relative to other wealthy nations, while our costs grew at a much greater pace, to the point we were spending about twice as much per capita as was typical among wealthy nations while living much sicklier, shorter lives. Next to that kind of unmitigated disaster, pretty much anything would be an improvement.

That is, as is typical for you, complete propaganda. The rate of health care "cost increases" slowed actually before the law was even passed. It slowed as a result of the recession (and has been kept in check mostly by the lack of economic recovery). And the vast majority of the "growth" in the percentage of "insured" Americans, as I have repeatedly pointed out to you, was a huge increase in Medicaid.

As for the "more socialized systems" I wonder how they've been doing lately:

https://www.theguardian.com/comment...provide-quality-service-something-has-to-give

Oh wow, so maybe socialism does only work until it runs out of "other people's money..."
 
That is, as is typical for you, complete propaganda. The rate of health care "cost increases" slowed actually before the law was even passed.

Yes. Before the reform was passed, we were in the deep recession Bush had left to Obama, and historically recessions have been associated with slow rates of healthcare cost increase. But, what we hadn't seen before was what came next -- low rates of healthcare cost increase even as the economy grew.


As for the "more socialized systems" I wonder how they've been doing lately

Pretty well, in terms of both per-capita healthcare spending (lower than ours) and most major public health stats like life expectancy, infant mortality, and obesity (better than ours). Were you unaware of that? Well, if so, don't take this education as a scolding.
 
Yes. Before the reform was passed, we were in the deep recession Bush had left to Obama, and historically recessions have been associated with slow rates of healthcare cost increase. But, what we hadn't seen before was what came next -- low rates of healthcare cost increase even as the economy grew.




Pretty well, in terms of both per-capita healthcare spending (lower than ours) and most major public health stats like life expectancy, infant mortality, and obesity (better than ours). Were you unaware of that? Well, if so, don't take this education as a scolding.

That's because the economy "grew" at a lower rate over an entire Presidential administration than it has ever before:

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-...resident-history-never-have-year-3-gdp-growth

So you don't think this job killing law had anything to do with that, do you? Besides, another reason cost increases are moderating is because out of pocket expenses have exploded:

http://www.usnews.com/news/articles...ing-shifts-more-costs-to-consumers-government

Which causes people to put off or even forego treatment.

And, as we see from Great Britain's NHS, the "single payer" option becomes rather expensive itself, outstripping whatever amount politicians allocate to it. And we know the same thing will happen here if you whacko progressives succeed in "socializing" medicine here.

As with all your "boasts" about the "successes" of progressive policies, we continue to rack up evidence of it's repeated and ongoing failures (like the link above). So if one of us needs "educating" here, it isn't me.
 
I think businesses have the responsibility to operate honestly while contributing to a growing, more prosperous economy. Any taxes paid by businesses detracts from that primary mission. Why anyone would sacrifice jobs and prosperity on the alter of wealth redistribution, through business taxation, is a complete mystery to me (unless, for some reason their goal is to weaken, rather than strengthen, the economy).
All citizens have a moral responsibility to pay taxes.
Corporations are citizens.
Corporations have a moral responsibility to pay taxes.
 
All citizens have a moral responsibility to pay taxes.
Corporations are citizens.
Corporations have a moral responsibility to pay taxes.

Corporations are just groups of people. An association of individuals, organized to conduct business. Again, you can certainly pass a law that taxes businesses. I don't dispute that. But what I don't understand is your "moral responsibility" to pass business taxes that then have the effect of reducing economic opportunities for individuals. It's effective, but not efficient.
 
So you don't think this job killing law had anything to do with that, do you?

No. As you recall, despite the claims by the economic know-nothings that it would be a job killer, job creation picked up considerably after the reform was passed. Granted, thanks to austerity measures, job creation has been underwhelming overall, but that's largely because strong private-sector job creation was offset by public-sector job destruction.

Besides, another reason cost increases are moderating is because out of pocket expenses have exploded

If overall costs are down, in part because out-of-pocket costs are up, isn't that something you should be cheering? I mean, a lot of the right-wing whining about the pre-Obamacare system was that insurance was blocking price signals, preventing the market from keeping costs in check. If more price signals are getting through to the end consumer now, resulting in lower rates of health cost increase, isn't that a good thing, so long as it's accompanied by lower rates of overall health cost increase and improving public health results?

And, as we see from Great Britain's NHS, the "single payer" option becomes rather expensive itself

No. As you're aware, it's dirt cheap by US standards. We're at about $9,403 per capita, here, versus $3,935 in the UK:

http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.XPD.PCAP

So, we're spending almost two and a half times as much per person as a more modern, socialized system like the UK's. Granted, US and UK costs have gotten a little closer in recent years, as we've seen the advantage of Obamacare price mitigation, while the UK moved a bit in the other direction.

Anyway, you're at least asking good questions, so I can keep educating you.
 
No. As you recall, despite the claims by the economic know-nothings that it would be a job killer, job creation picked up considerably after the reform was passed. Granted, thanks to austerity measures, job creation has been underwhelming overall, but that's largely because strong private-sector job creation was offset by public-sector job destruction.



If overall costs are down, in part because out-of-pocket costs are up, isn't that something you should be cheering? I mean, a lot of the right-wing whining about the pre-Obamacare system was that insurance was blocking price signals, preventing the market from keeping costs in check. If more price signals are getting through to the end consumer now, resulting in lower rates of health cost increase, isn't that a good thing, so long as it's accompanied by lower rates of overall health cost increase and improving public health results?



No. As you're aware, it's dirt cheap by US standards. We're at about $9,403 per capita, here, versus $3,935 in the UK:

http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.XPD.PCAP

So, we're spending almost two and a half times as much per person as a more modern, socialized system like the UK's. Granted, US and UK costs have gotten a little closer in recent years, as we've seen the advantage of Obamacare price mitigation, while the UK moved a bit in the other direction.

Anyway, you're at least asking good questions, so I can keep educating you.

LOL! More propaganda from the leftist "think tanks." The official job stats "picked up" after Obamacare was implemented. And, as I have repeatedly shown you, those numbers are completely uncredible. We really don't know what has happened in the job market, except that there appears to be a move toward more part time help as a result of Obamacare:

Screen Shot 2016-09-12 at 10.55.35 AM.png
We're adding people but not hours.

When businesses are asked how they are dealing with Obamacare:

http://blogs.wsj.com/cfo/2016/08/16/fed-survey-obamacare-causing-companies-to-cut-jobs/

Well there's the facts that expose your narrative on jobs as propaganda. Strike one!

As for your "out of pocket" argument, of course it would be a good thing if everyone was under the same rules. But what this law did was vastly increase the out of pocket costs for those of us who have to pay for our own insurance, while adding 10 million (85% of the "newly insured") to Medicaid, where they have no out of pocket costs. So those of us who had insurance are now being made to pay more and/or cut back while free care is being provided to the working poor. Which only proves I was right about this as well - it "spreads the health around." Takes it away from more affluent middle class folks and gives it to the poor and working poor. It's socialism in healthcare so I understand why an unrepentant Marxist like you thinks it's great but most people don't share your sentiments:

http://thehill.com/policy/healthcare/271130-poll-majority-of-americans-feel-unaffected-by-obamacare

http://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/politics/current_events/healthcare/health_care_law

So that two fails on your part. Strike two!

But you are correct, Great Britain spends a lot less than we do on healthcare and yet they still can't afford socialized medicine:

https://www.theguardian.com/comment...provide-quality-service-something-has-to-give

Which is where we're headed as well (albeit at an even higher spending level). Which means rationed healthcare and long waits for even emergency care. And ever tightening funding and ever worse (and less) care. Which is exactly what you should expect from government run services.

Strike three...yer out!
 
And, as I have repeatedly shown you, those numbers are completely uncredible

No. As you know, the numbers are consistent with what I said.... but, since they're inconsistent with your economic faith, you have proclaimed that the official numbers aren't to believed, and that we should instead occupy the alternate universe of guys like Tyler Durden, David Stockman, and their fellow economic know-nothings. I quite like the real world, so I have declined to make that relocation to your fantasy realm.

But you are correct, Great Britain spends a lot less than we do on healthcare

Yes, and despite that, they have longer life expectancies and better overall health stats than the US, which shows just how more bang for their buck they're getting.
 
Back
Top