New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Are we safe?

Jen

Senator
With the things going on in this world right now, the Ukraine, the missing 777........... do you trust our government to keep us safe?

What must a government to to make us feel safe?

Is that different from what that same government must to to actually make us safe?
 
With the things going on in this world right now, the Ukraine, the missing 777........... do you trust our government to keep us safe?

What must a government to to make us feel safe?

Is that different from what that same government must to to actually make us safe?

Jen,

I think its a fallacy to think or expect the Government to keep anyone totally safe. And, its that thinking that leads to ridiculous invasions on our privacy and affronts to our liberty.

Life has risks. I do expect the Government to put the time and energy into stoping what they can, but they will never stop it all. And, I would not want to be in a country where they had to have controls so tight that they could. We have got to accept that - we may be bombed and we may be attacked again. And, in the interim, we need to take steps to prepare ourselves for what may happen in that time to a reasonable degree, and just live our lives.

What would help to make us more safe is for your Country to stop picking fights all over the world and invest more time and resources into viable methods of defense ( not a build of of military - but advance weaponing) and intelligence gathering.


connie
 
Jen,

I think its a fallacy to think or expect the Government to keep anyone totally safe. And, its that thinking that leads to ridiculous invasions on our privacy and affronts to our liberty.

Life has risks. I do expect the Government to put the time and energy into stoping what they can, but they will never stop it all. And, I would not want to be in a country where they had to have controls so tight that they could. We have got to accept that - we may be bombed and we may be attacked again. And, in the interim, we need to take steps to prepare ourselves for what may happen in that time to a reasonable degree, and just live our lives.

What would help to make us more safe is for your Country to stop picking fights all over the world and invest more time and resources into viable methods of defense ( not a build of of military - but advance weaponing) and intelligence gathering.


connie

Of course it is impossible for our government to keep us 100% safe. I am libertarian enough to believe that I am responsible for my own personal responsibility.

By the question I didn't mean our personal safety but our safety as a nation and our government may not be able to control every little thing (9/11 happened anyway). But there are things that our government can and should do to keep us feeling that we have some support in our quest for safety. Border security is one of those things. We have no border security. So on that count, we necessarily must feel less safe.

I absolutely agree that our country has no need to intervene in every little fight around the world. We should have avoided taking down Saddam Hussein. We should not have intervened in Libya to help take down Kadaffi. And we should not intervene in the Ukraine.

But there are certain positions that our government should take to make the people of our country feel that our military has our back. The Obama administration comes across as weak and unable or unwilling to do anything.
 
Of course it is impossible for our government to keep us 100% safe. I am libertarian enough to believe that I am responsible for my own personal responsibility.

By the question I didn't mean our personal safety but our safety as a nation and our government may not be able to control every little thing (9/11 happened anyway). But there are things that our government can and should do to keep us feeling that we have some support in our quest for safety. Border security is one of those things. We have no border security. So on that count, we necessarily must feel less safe.

I absolutely agree that our country has no need to intervene in every little fight around the world. We should have avoided taking down Saddam Hussein. We should not have intervened in Libya to help take down Kadaffi. And we should not intervene in the Ukraine.

But there are certain positions that our government should take to make the people of our country feel that our military has our back. The Obama administration comes across as weak and unable or unwilling to do anything.

no, your hollow declarations about BHO being weak and unable make you weak and wholly unable to convince anyone (with half a brain anyway) that you know anything about what you're talking about
 
With the things going on in this world right now, the Ukraine, the missing 777........... do you trust our government to keep us safe?

What must a government to to make us feel safe?

Is that different from what that same government must to to actually make us safe?
I only trust me to keep me and mine safe. Never trust a politician with anything.
 
no, your hollow declarations about BHO being weak and unable make you weak and wholly unable to convince anyone (with half a brain anyway) that you know anything about what you're talking about

Yes. Everyone knows you think I am totally brainless. Nothing new in your post.
How redundant of you to keep mentioning it as if you need cheering on by your little pals.
I'm sure you will get the "likes" you so desperately need any minute now.
 
I only trust me to keep me and mine safe. Never trust a politician with anything.

That is true, Alinvegas. We are responsible for ourselves.

So do our national borders not matter now? Does our country have no responsibility at all? Our Constitution has been pretty much shredded. So maybe it is just the every man for himself scenario now.
 
Of course it is impossible for our government to keep us 100% safe. I am libertarian enough to believe that I am responsible for my own personal responsibility.

By the question I didn't mean our personal safety but our safety as a nation and our government may not be able to control every little thing (9/11 happened anyway). But there are things that our government can and should do to keep us feeling that we have some support in our quest for safety. Border security is one of those things. We have no border security. So on that count, we necessarily must feel less safe.

I absolutely agree that our country has no need to intervene in every little fight around the world. We should have avoided taking down Saddam Hussein. We should not have intervened in Libya to help take down Kadaffi. And we should not intervene in the Ukraine.

But there are certain positions that our government should take to make the people of our country feel that our military has our back. The Obama administration comes across as weak and unable or unwilling to do anything.


Jen,

All you are really talking about is making us "feel" safer. That is what I am saying the fallacy is. Our people should feel the military has "OUR" back which is why I suggested in making sure what we spend is spent on getting the best and most sophisticated weapons and weapons defense systems and intelligence. I also agree that border security is a big hole where they are not doing their job.

But, we were not any more or less safe from Putin today than we were 6 months ago, than we will be in 6 years. That is just part of this illusion and fallacy in placing that trust. We have no choice but to go each day and keep going and doing what we are doing, but we aren't safe, we weren't safe, and we never will be safe. The best we can hope for - is that we are actually prepared.

connie
 
no, your hollow declarations about BHO being weak and unable make you weak and wholly unable to convince anyone (with half a brain anyway) that you know anything about what you're talking about
No hollow declarations there--Obama IS weak. You really don't think he is laughed at in other countries??
 
That is true, Alinvegas. We are responsible for ourselves.

So do our national borders not matter now? Does our country have no responsibility at all? Our Constitution has been pretty much shredded. So maybe it is just the every man for himself scenario now.
what the hell do your national borders have to do with malaysia 370 or crimea?
 
Jen,

All you are really talking about is making us "feel" safer. That is what I am saying the fallacy is. Our people should feel the military has "OUR" back which is why I suggested in making sure what we spend is spent on getting the best and most sophisticated weapons and weapons defense systems and intelligence. I also agree that border security is a big hole where they are not doing their job.

But, we were not any more or less safe from Putin today than we were 6 months ago, than we will be in 6 years. That is just part of this illusion and fallacy in placing that trust. We have no choice but to go each day and keep going and doing what we are doing, but we aren't safe, we weren't safe, and we never will be safe. The best we can hope for - is that we are actually prepared.

connie

The military is being stripped.
A young Lieutenant in the Army just got out of prison for doing his job and killing our enemy...........he didn't abide by the Obama rules of contact, so he went to prison for doing his job. When that sort of thing happens, our military is toothless. The military does NOT have our backs and yes, it is about sophisticated weapons (boots on the ground now come after the war is won. We have drones and other ways of carrying on a war). But when our boots are undermined by the administration and when our Leader's line in the sand is ridiculed by the people that the line is drawn against..........we are not safe and it is foolish to "feel" safe.

1964995_10153931076460088_400431105_n.png
 
The military is being stripped.
A young Lieutenant in the Army just got out of prison for doing his job and killing our enemy...........he didn't abide by the Obama rules of contact, so he went to prison for doing his job. When that sort of thing happens, our military is toothless. The military does NOT have our backs and yes, it is about sophisticated weapons (boots on the ground now come after the war is won. We have drones and other ways of carrying on a war). But when our boots are undermined by the administration and when our Leader's line in the sand is ridiculed by the people that the line is drawn against..........we are not safe and it is foolish to "feel" safe.

1964995_10153931076460088_400431105_n.png
just doing your job was no excuse at nuremberg pal
 
Yes.. clearly safer than when DumDum was president, and said "ok now you've covered your ass" ...... and 3000 people died?

Yes.. clearly safer after 911.
 
With the things going on in this world right now, the Ukraine, the missing 777........... do you trust our government to keep us safe?

What must a government to to make us feel safe?

Is that different from what that same government must to to actually make us safe?



You're never going to be completely safe, and those who put a lot of faith in government are setting themselves up for disappointment. Perhaps the best we can hope for is that those in charge inspire enough fear in thugs and tyrants to discourage them from aggression. Failure to do so emboldens the bullies of the world, and they will do as much as they believe they can get away with.
 
The military is being stripped.
A young Lieutenant in the Army just got out of prison for doing his job and killing our enemy...........he didn't abide by the Obama rules of contact, so he went to prison for doing his job. When that sort of thing happens, our military is toothless. The military does NOT have our backs and yes, it is about sophisticated weapons (boots on the ground now come after the war is won. We have drones and other ways of carrying on a war). But when our boots are undermined by the administration and when our Leader's line in the sand is ridiculed by the people that the line is drawn against..........we are not safe and it is foolish to "feel" safe.

1964995_10153931076460088_400431105_n.png


And, I think it is foolish to feel "safe" at anytime. We are not ever safe. We are not necessarily less safe - from a defensive position. We are not not safe because Russia is invading or seizing Crimea. That does not have a direct material impact on our safety. Are they treatening to launch nukes at us? if not, we are s safe as we were from them 6 years ago.

Don't get me wrong, all this red lines that no one follows through on is BS. But, the weakness is in drawing the redline and not being prepared to back it up. It has nothing to do with wehther our miltary could kick some ASS if put to the test, and I think they could. TBH -I would rather bomb the shit out of somewhere before I put one american boot on foreign soil again.... so it bothers me not at all that we are reducing the size of the active duty personnel. Next time war comes, I hope we spend about as much time worry about collateral damage as our enemies do - which is to say - none at all. But, becasue of that - it must be an extreme situation - and last resort of self defense to wage war. I don't buy into the best defesne is a good offense.

connie
 
With the things going on in this world right now, the Ukraine, the missing 777........... do you trust our government to keep us safe?

What must a government to to make us feel safe?

Is that different from what that same government must to to actually make us safe?

  1. Yes,
  2. Protect us from military/terrorist attack,
  3. No
 
Of course it is impossible for our government to keep us 100% safe. I am libertarian enough to believe that I am responsible for my own personal responsibility.

By the question I didn't mean our personal safety but our safety as a nation and our government may not be able to control every little thing (9/11 happened anyway). But there are things that our government can and should do to keep us feeling that we have some support in our quest for safety. Border security is one of those things. We have no border security. So on that count, we necessarily must feel less safe.

I absolutely agree that our country has no need to intervene in every little fight around the world. We should have avoided taking down Saddam Hussein. We should not have intervened in Libya to help take down Kadaffi. And we should not intervene in the Ukraine.

But there are certain positions that our government should take to make the people of our country feel that our military has our back. The Obama administration comes across as weak and unable or unwilling to do anything.

I wasn't aware we had no border security. Or is it just another righties "be afraid" point.
 
That is true, Alinvegas. We are responsible for ourselves.

So do our national borders not matter now? Does our country have no responsibility at all? Our Constitution has been pretty much shredded. So maybe it is just the every man for himself scenario now.
Constitution shredded?...BULL$HIT...paranoia
 
Back
Top