New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

austerity works

What?



You say neither...does that mean you think the government's debt isn't massive, or it isn't untenable?

Massive is a relative scale... what are you comparing it to? compared to your mortgage? it is massive. But compared to your mortgage on a per-capita basis, it is small

Untenable? again, how is it "untenable"? Particularly since it is well below historic highs that the USA has used to escape previous crashes.

Still waiting for you to give us ONE EXAMPLE of what the GOP Congress has passed, that if enacted would cause you to hire another person.... JUST ONE THING.
 
Really?

We're saddled with close to 16 trillion in debt as it is...and you want to add more?

Tell me, how much more?

And in what do you 'invest' this money?

How much stimulus would it take to bring manufacturing jobs back to the US?
 
What makes it untenable is that it's selling a lie.

And that lie being that 16 Trillion in debt doesn't matter.
Um whether or not it is selling a lie has no bearing on whther or not economically it is tenable (ie viable to be paid back with less catastrophe than not borrowing ).
So right off the bat your analysis is flawed

Secondly you are engaged in a strawman arguement. No one says that $16 Trillion debt "doesn't matter". Just that it MATTERS LESS than not recovering the economy. That cutting the deficit or the debt now - REDUCES LONG TERM WEALTH MORE, than increasing the debt and then having to pay it off.

That's not the same as "doesn't matter". So lets try to be accurate.


Beats me, I'm not up on the jobs bills you speak of.
Well you are the one who told me that those were the Job Creation bills that the GOP had proposed. So if they are, then you must be able to explain how there is something in there that will get you to hire more.

However, if you want to get me to hire more...end federal gasoline taxes
Ahh so what you are actually asking for is for the Federal Government (ie us taxpayers) to subsidize your business by subsidizing your use of the roads and the benefits you get from using fuel who's delivery is protected by the navy paid out of OUR pocketbooks.

IOW you don't believe in "free market" you DO want a subsidy for your business.... OK That might well work. But then don't pretend that deficit spending is "untenable".
 
Tell me, when we had those other 'historic highs' how many jobs had we lost to China? India? Mexico?

You're talking about a totally different type of economy.

A serviced based economy (as ours has become) CANNOT SUSTAIN OR EVER PAY BACK these deficits.

Also, when, in history, has the debt grown so much, so fast?
 
A lot of it is smoke and mirrors however it's not wall st. holding the mirrors.
It's congress and the bureaucracy is blowing the smoke.
 
Really?

We're saddled with close to 16 trillion in debt as it is...and you want to add more?
Yes. Because that "saddling" isn't that big. its about $30k per tax entity in the USA and there is no fixed time in which it needs to be paid back

Tell me, how much more?
About $2trillion. That would drop unemployment to about 6.5% and hold it there for 2 years and that's the start of sustained recovery.

And in what do you 'invest' this money?
Grants to states to rehire teachers.
Mortgage capital write downs
Infrastructure projects
R&D investment in biogenomics
R&D investment in green energy
Massive rebuiliding of the electrical grid
Subsidies for US Built plug in hybrids.
Federal Gas tax subsidies for vehicle intensive businesses
etc.
IE the same things the original stimulus was spent on.

And like the original stimulus, you get about 1% unemployment reduction for every $1 Trillion spent.

How much stimulus would it take to bring manufacturing jobs back to the US?
We haven't lost that many. And that stimulus would actually to a long way towards that.
 
Um whether or not it is selling a lie has no bearing on whther or not economically it is tenable (ie viable to be paid back with less catastrophe than not borrowing ).
So right off the bat your analysis is flawed

The fact that it's NEVER going to be paid back is what makes it untenable.

Secondly you are engaged in a strawman arguement. No one says that $16 Trillion debt "doesn't matter". Just that it MATTERS LESS than not recovering the economy. That cutting the deficit or the debt now - REDUCES LONG TERM WEALTH MORE, than increasing the debt and then having to pay it off.

It's not a 'strawman' when you, yourself, are proposing to add untold trillions more to it.

That's not the same as "doesn't matter". So lets try to be accurate.

No, it's exactly the same thing.

Well you are the one who told me that those were the Job Creation bills that the GOP had proposed. So if they are, then you must be able to explain how there is something in there that will get you to hire more.

Every jobs bill doesn't affect my line of business. As a matter of fact, few do.
Ahh so what you are actually asking for is for the Federal Government (ie us taxpayers) to subsidize your business by subsidizing your use of the roads and the benefits you get from using fuel who's delivery is protected by the navy paid out of OUR pocketbooks.

IOW you don't believe in "free market" you DO want a subsidy for your business.... OK That might well work. But then don't pretend that deficit spending is "untenable".

You asked what would make me hire more....I told you.
 
Tell me, when we had those other 'historic highs' how many jobs had we lost to China? India? Mexico?

You're talking about a totally different type of economy.[/quote]
True. Today we have overseas markets whereas then we did not. So our recovery is likely to be more effective

A serviced based economy (as ours has become) CANNOT SUSTAIN OR EVER PAY BACK these deficits.
Based on what magic? We didn't have overseas markets back then. And there is nothing inherent in the "value" of a big finned Chevy that is different than the value of the latest new bit of software.

Furthermore, we still have a huge manufacturing base. it just is different than the one we used to have. We make high tech needles with nanometer openings for use in silicon-fab facilities. We don't knit T-shirts anymore.

Also, when, in history, has the debt grown so much, so fast?
From 1939-1943 it grew much faster. from 1774-1789 it grew much faster.

Yes and?
 
Simply because we had a monster capacity to manufacture at that time. And we had a world war to win, or had just won
doesn't matter WHY we deficit spent. In point of fact deficit spending on say bombs, is far less efficient than on say a solar cell factory. A bomb can only be used once and then all the value is gone. Solyndra, for all its faults - sold products that STILL ARE GENERATING VALUE TO THE ECONOMY.

. Everyone wanted to be here, or get something made here.
Nope. There were almost ZERO overseas markets for US goods. Today we have huge export markets.

To put it another way, our best days as a global power were ahead of us. Not behind us.
Ah so you want us to engage in austerity to prove that the USA is past its prime? Pretty silly it seems to me.

Economics MATTERS
 
return to honest money. Austerity is the inevitable outcome of the artificial money system that is controlling the globe. Money is a cruel master, artificial money is a monster! It will come here too and it will grow worse and worse. I've posted to degs how Keynesian <politics> (policies) were set up when the world still traded with real money, he didn't get it. Americans have a hard time grasping that central banking is an artificial money system.
 
Yes. Because that "saddling" isn't that big. its about $30k per tax entity in the USA and there is no fixed time in which it needs to be paid back

30k per tax 'entity' in the US will pay off 16 (no, you want 18) trillion in debt. Please show your math.

About $2trillion. That would drop unemployment to about 6.5% and hold it there for 2 years and that's the start of sustained recovery.

Grants to states to rehire teachers.
Mortgage capital write downs
Infrastructure projects
R&D investment in biogenomics
R&D investment in green energy
Massive rebuiliding of the electrical grid
Subsidies for US Built plug in hybrids.
Federal Gas tax subsidies for vehicle intensive businesses
etc.
IE the same things the original stimulus was spent on.

And like the original stimulus, you get about 1% unemployment reduction for every $1 Trillion spent.

First, those 'jobs' you plan on creating...are either temporary government jobs that go away, or 'green' jobs that can be outsourced. Solyndra, anyone?

Grants to states to rehire teachers. - More government jobs.
Mortgage capital write downs - for whom? Everyone? That's a lot more than two trillion.
Infrastructure projects - temporary jobs at BEST.
R&D investment in biogenomics - very few jobs.
R&D investment in green energy - Outsourced jobs.
Massive rebuiliding of the electrical grid - temporary jobs.
Subsidies for US Built plug in hybrids. - Which don't' sell.
Federal Gas tax subsidies for vehicle intensive businesses - Which will help shipping and no one else. (but I do like it!)

So, we get a few more temp and government jobs for an additional two trillion that we have no hope of paying off?

And what happens when that debt start to hammer our currency?
 
doesn't matter WHY we deficit spent. In point of fact deficit spending on say bombs, is far less efficient than on say a solar cell factory. A bomb can only be used once and then all the value is gone. Solyndra, for all its faults - sold products that STILL ARE GENERATING VALUE TO THE ECONOMY.

To the tune of 500 MILLION dollars? No.

Nope. There were almost ZERO overseas markets for US goods. Today we have huge export markets.

Really? No one bought our ships? Our planes? Our cars? So..where did all they stuff sell? Mississippi?


Ah so you want us to engage in austerity to prove that the USA is past its prime? Pretty silly it seems to me.

I never said that austerity was the the way....I merely said that outrageous spending wasn't sound and asked for an alternative.
 
The fact that it's NEVER going to be paid back is what makes it untenable.
First off, why is it "never going to be paid back"?
Secondly - lets pretend - just for arguements sake - that we never pay it back. That it stays at say $18 trillion (after a succesful stimulus) and the US economy starts growing at historic GDP rates of 3.2% (hardly massive growth). in 14 years we stil have an 18 Trillion debt, but GDP is now 23.3 Trillion So Debt/GDP is now down to 77%. in 20 years it is down to 63%.. in 30 years (an avg mortgage) it is down to 47% of GDP...

all without paying a dime on principle... and that is untenable why?

It's not a 'strawman' when you, yourself, are proposing to add untold trillions more to it.
Not untold. just $2 Trillion.
And that still makes your claim a strawman. Because saying that adding to the debt is LESS WORSE than not adding to it and substantially less worse than trying to cut it NOW - is nowhere near the same as saying "it doesn't matter".

So stop putting words in other people's mouths. Address the subject.

No, it's exactly the same thing.
RIGGHTT because you say so.. beause you say that "less worse than" is identical to "doesn't matter"... uhuh.. that's solid reasoning there.

Every jobs bill doesn't affect my line of business. As a matter of fact, few do.
Ahh so then you cannot point to a single think inthe GOP claims of "increse jobs" that would actually increase jobs... please then be honest abou thtat.

You asked what would make me hire more....I told you.
Yup/ You asked for a deficit spending stimulus... after saying that its a bad idea...

So you are in essence saying that doing things that would get you to hire more people is a bad idea....

What a great prescription for how to recover an economy...
 
30k per tax 'entity' in the US will pay off 16 (no, you want 18) trillion in debt. Please show your math.
$15 Trillion Debt.
415 millin tax entities == $36k (sorry - last time I ran the calc the debt was a bit lower). simple as that.

First, those 'jobs' you plan on creating...are either temporary government jobs that go away, or 'green' jobs that can be outsourced. Solyndra, anyone?
Government jobs are only "temporary" if the GDP rate doesn't grow. If it grows, tax reveues go up and the states can take over paying for those jobs.

Solyndra STILL is generating positive GDP contributions. Yes some investments fail. So what?

Grants to states to rehire teachers. - More government jobs.
nothing worng with that

Mortgage capital write downs - for whom? Everyone? That's a lot more than two trillion.
You don't have to write it down for everyone or completely to bottom out the market.

Infrastructure projects - temporary jobs at BEST.
Not quite - because infrastructure improvemnts continue to contribute to GDP via utility. Furthermore the multiplier effect is high here so it becomse self perpetuating. Build an extension to a highway, now you need to build more houses, pull more cable etc.

R&D investment in green energy - Outsourced jobs.
I think you mean OFFSHORED jobs, and most are not offshored.

Massive rebuiliding of the electrical grid - temporary jobs.
All jobs are temporary. Economies shift. but once unemployment is below 7%, the economy becomes selfsustaining.

Subsidies for US Built plug in hybrids. - Which don't' sell.
Sorry data says otherwise.

Federal Gas tax subsidies for vehicle intensive businesses - Which will help shipping and no one else. (but I do like it!)
And shipping cost reductions reduce COGS for pretty much everyone... which in turn increases demand...

So, we get a few more temp and government jobs for an additional two trillion that we have no hope of paying off?
Why do we have "no hope of paying off"? If we pay ONLY THE INTEREST, in the time span of one mortgage, the Debt/GDP rate drops to less than 50%...


A weak dollar is GOOD for exports. It actually IMPROVES our ability to sell to overseas markets and thus it increases GDP growth EVEN FASTER.

That's a GOOD thing. Sure YOU can no longer afford that Masserati you had your eye on... but that GM Hybrid van for your newly hired driver is suddenly a much better deal. So you buy that and add even more to US GDP growth.

All good things.


ECONOMICS MATTERS
but its not quite as simplistic as you make it out to be.

Sorry gotta go. Its sunny and I need to go sail
 
To the tune of 500 MILLION dollars? No.
No but R&D will always have winners and losers. Is Fairchild Semiconductor still making microprocessors? Motorola?
Really? No one bought our ships? Our planes? Our cars? So..where did all they stuff sell? Mississippi?
Pretty much... All of the EU was a bombed out husk - England had food rationing through the early 1960s... China was in Maoist throes, Japan was similarly bombed out and busy selling crap to the USA...

About the only other nations that were untouched were Oz and LatAm.. and LatAm has never had money.

I never said that austerity was the the way....I merely said that outrageous spending wasn't sound and asked for an alternative.
It is sound and the alternative is a recovery that is slow and leaves us falling behind deficit spending nations like the PRC and GErmany (you do realize german GDP outgrew the US by 35% during the GWB years right?)
 
True. Today we have overseas markets whereas then we did not. So our recovery is likely to be more effective

Have you even taken a look at the trade deficit lately?

Based on what magic? We didn't have overseas markets back then. And there is nothing inherent in the "value" of a big finned Chevy that is different than the value of the latest new bit of software.

Furthermore, we still have a huge manufacturing base. it just is different than the one we used to have. We make high tech needles with nanometer openings for use in silicon-fab facilities. We don't knit T-shirts anymore.

Where are the most technologically advanced devices made today? We can't even come close with competing with Taiwan, China and Japan.

Oh, and our manufacturing sector is just fine? In decline and STILL declining.

From 1939-1943 it grew much faster. from 1774-1789 it grew much faster

So, WWII and colonial days? Seriously, you can't do any better than that?
 
Back
Top