New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Ben Carson: The Devil Made Him Do It!!

Indeed. We don't know how much is being caused naturally and how much is the result of burning hydrocarbons.

We don't know precisely, because the climate is a complex aggregation of extremely complex (and very sensitive to minuscule differences) local systems. We do know that models without AGW aren't able to account for the observed warming and that based on solar output alone the atmosphere should be cooling. We know that the non-faith-based models (the ones that do include AGW), which have predicted 3 decades of warming to within a couple hundredths of a degree, predict specified amounts of further warming (with varying levels of confidence depending on the time scale, assumptions about feedback mechanisms, etc., involved) given certain levels of greenhouse gas concentrations.

What we do know is that the left views climate change as a cudgel with which they can beat capitalism to death. I'm certain a deal could be had to use a carbon tax to replace the corporate income tax, but the left isn't as interested in reducing carbon usage as much as they are in reducing private sector for profit business activities. Get back to us when you guys are willing to compromise...

Not so much a cudgel to beat capitalism with as a symptom of capitalism's deadly disregard for human life, and an unassailable argument for the imperative to eliminate it. Treating this symptom with a carbon tax (ineffectual without an emissions cap) would be like taking an antacid for heartburn while ignoring the stomach cancer you knew was causing the heartburn. The fact that you don't like the solution doesn;t change the fact that the problem is real.
 
You can just as easily teach the dog to come running for a treat when you blow a whistle. The dog doesn't understand the meaning of the word "treat" (which would imply sentience). It has just been trained that when its owner says that word, in a certain way no less, that if it comes running the owner will hand it a treat.

It comes running because it likes treats. In other word, because it feels a certain way about certain stimuli. If you don't think this implies sentience, it is because you don't understand the word "sentience." Making you, in this respect, like the dog (according to your supposition).
 
Where is the evidence of the "positive feedback loop" that teaches lefties to support failed economic policies?

Interesting that you can talk about that after advocating a corporate income tax cut a few posts above. How'd that work out under Bush? How about the one under Reagan?
 
Yes I understand there is a movement to include animals in the category of "sentient" beings. That is key to the athiest effort to deny the existence of God and the concept of a human soul.

"The righteous one is aware of the soul of his animal, and the evil withhold compassions."-Proverbs 12:10
"As for the sons of men, God tests them, so that they may see that they themselves are like animals. For that which happens to the sons of men happens to animals. Even one thing happens to them. As the one dies, so the other dies. Yes, they have all one breath; and man has no advantage over the animals, for all is vanity. All go to one place. All are from the dust, and all turn to dust again. Who knows the spirit of man, whether it goes upward, and the spirit of the animal, whether it goes downward to the earth?"-Ecclesiastes 3:18-21

The Bible, of course, also contains talking animals that converse with people. Did some atheist slip all that stuff in there when you weren't looking?
 
I'm in favor of cutting government spending back to the size it was under Clinton (including the military). I would also like to see tax rates restored to the level they were under Clinton. Then focus on getting the Fed out of the business of managing the economy and have it focus instead on keeping the dollar stable. And move the regulatory environment back to roughly the same cost and scope as it was under Clinton. What is "wrong" with any of that?

Presumably, the poor would suffer due to austerity and deregulation.
 
We don't know precisely, because the climate is a complex aggregation of extremely complex (and very sensitive to minuscule differences) local systems. We do know that models without AGW aren't able to account for the observed warming and that based on solar output alone the atmosphere should be cooling. We know that the non-faith-based models (the ones that do include AGW), which have predicted 3 decades of warming to within a couple hundredths of a degree, predict specified amounts of further warming (with varying levels of confidence depending on the time scale, assumptions about feedback mechanisms, etc., involved) given certain levels of greenhouse gas concentrations.



Not so much a cudgel to beat capitalism with as a symptom of capitalism's deadly disregard for human life, and an unassailable argument for the imperative to eliminate it. Treating this symptom with a carbon tax (ineffectual without an emissions cap) would be like taking an antacid for heartburn while ignoring the stomach cancer you knew was causing the heartburn. The fact that you don't like the solution doesn;t change the fact that the problem is real.

No offense, but I'm not willing to start undergoing chemo because some lefty's "model" suggests I have cancer.
 
It comes running because it likes treats. In other word, because it feels a certain way about certain stimuli. If you don't think this implies sentience, it is because you don't understand the word "sentience." Making you, in this respect, like the dog (according to your supposition).

It's a matter of degree. Plants also exhibit signs of discomfort (and allegedly respond better to classical music than rock). Does that make plants "sentient?" What about this:


Is that robot "sentient" because it "understands" the interviewer's questions?
 
Interesting that you can talk about that after advocating a corporate income tax cut a few posts above. How'd that work out under Bush? How about the one under Reagan?

Corporate income taxes were not "cut" under Bush:

Screen Shot 2015-11-03 at 6.47.45 AM.png
The one under Reagan worked pretty good.
 
"The righteous one is aware of the soul of his animal, and the evil withhold compassions."-Proverbs 12:10
"As for the sons of men, God tests them, so that they may see that they themselves are like animals. For that which happens to the sons of men happens to animals. Even one thing happens to them. As the one dies, so the other dies. Yes, they have all one breath; and man has no advantage over the animals, for all is vanity. All go to one place. All are from the dust, and all turn to dust again. Who knows the spirit of man, whether it goes upward, and the spirit of the animal, whether it goes downward to the earth?"-Ecclesiastes 3:18-21

The Bible, of course, also contains talking animals that converse with people. Did some atheist slip all that stuff in there when you weren't looking?

It also suggests killing your own child as a "sacrifice" to God. I'm not a bible thumper so go peddle that somewhere else.
 
No offense, but I'm not willing to start undergoing chemo because some lefty's "model" suggests I have cancer.

Remember that the theory you are rejecting is not "some lefty's," but the scientific community's. Pretending there is not a PROBLEM because you don't like the leftist nature of the only possible SOLUTION is like ignoring the half-dozen doctors who all tell you you have cancer because you don't want to go through chemo.
 
It's a matter of degree.

Absolutely.

Plants also exhibit signs of discomfort (and allegedly respond better to classical music than rock). Does that make plants "sentient?"

I don't know. If you think they actually feel discomfort, rather than merely doing things that we interpret as signs of discomfort, then yes. It seems likely, in light of the research showing that tree roots connect and communicate in much the same way that neurons communicate, that trees, at the very least, are sentient organisms.

What about this:


Is that robot "sentient" because it "understands" the interviewer's questions?

As you said, it's a matter of degree. There is no bright line separating self-awareness from a lack thereof, just as you would be hard-pressed to say whether humans develop sentience at two years old, or one year, or two months, etc. But the ability to pass a Turing test, which computers are beginning to show, demands a self-awareness that cannot be faked.
 
I already knew Ben Carson was a crackpot, and that it would be very dangerous to let this man anywhere near the reins of power. Until I saw this article, though, I had no idea just how much of a crackpot the good doctor is. Wow: he thinks SATAN inspired Charles Darwin to come up with the theory of evolution!

Ben Carson: Evolution Is Satanic and the Big Bang Is a Fairy Tale

By Phil Plait


Burying the evidence.
Drawing from Teach the Controversy T-shirts

At one point in time, GOP presidential candidate Ben Carson may have been best known as an excellent, even groundbreaking, neurosurgeon. In recent years, though, he’s done everything he can to throw that reputation away.

PHIL PLAIT
Phil Plait writes Slate’s Bad Astronomy blog and is an astronomer, public speaker, science evangelizer, and author of Death From the Skies!

It won’t surprise regular readers to know I disagree with him on, well, almost everything. But recently he’s starting to get more heat about his religious views. He’s an outspoken creationist.

This actually goes way back. In 2006 he clearly stated his anti-evolutionary views and has repeated these claims many times since. In 2012 there was controversy over this when he was asked to give the commencement address at Emory University. In 2004 he said that people who accept evolution “dismiss ethics,” a comment he later backed down on a very tiny little bit (later saying they “might have more difficulty deriving where their ethics come from”).

I’d heard about all this before, but an article at BuzzFeed has something I hadn’t heard: In 2012, in a speech at an event called “Celebration of Creation,” he said that Darwin came up with evolutionary theory because the devil made him do it.

I mean that literally. He said, “I personally believe that this theory that Darwin came up with was something that was encouraged by the adversary.” The Adversary is a nickname for the devil; it’s the actual translation of the word “Satan.” So there’s that.

He also dismissed the Big Bang, calling it a “fairy tale.” The irony of this is palpable. When recently called on this claim, he dug in, saying (about people who think the Big Bang is true), “Here’s the key, I then say to them look, ‘I’m not gonna criticize you, you have a lot more faith then I have.’ I couldn’t, I don’t have enough faith to believe that.”

Wow. Where to start?

OK, how about this: The Big Bang is not something you believe in. It’s a scientific model, supported by a truly vast amount of evidence. It doesn’t take faith, it takes science (and, despite Carson’s claims, science is not faith-based).

Creationists who dismiss the Big Bang usually do so because they think the Earth is young, 6,000–10,000 years old. This belief is, to put it simply, wrong. We know the Earth is more than 4.5 billion years old, give or take a few million years. The evidence for this is overwhelming.

We also know the Universe itself is old; a huge number of independent lines of evidence make this clear. It doesn’t take faith to think the Big Bang is true, it takes a profound dismissal of all of science to think it isn’t.


The Big Bang left its imprint in the background radiation of the Universe itself. We see it.
Graphic by ESA–Planck Collaboration

Which brings us to evolution. Young Earth Creationists dismiss this as well due to the age issues, as well as others (for example, the Bible stating that God created Adam fully formed and in his image).

But evolution is a fact. Like the Big Bang, the evidence for it is overwhelming (it’seven been observed).

It bothers me greatly when a presidential candidate is so cavalier in dismissing facts. That’s a route we’ve been down before, and it leads to Very Bad Things.

As for Carson’s statement on ethics, well, humans were ethical long before monotheism came around. His claim that people who accept evolution is true might have difficulty with ethics is profoundly insulting to scientists.

The almost unutterable irony here is how Carson dismisses this all, talking about “high-faluting” scientists. But he was a neurosurgeon. His entire career owes its existence to science, yet he tosses out the men and women over the past few centuries whose expertise allowed him to benefit so greatly from his practice.

I know a lot of the Republican base is very religious, and they have every right to be. But fundamentalism is dangerous; it promotes clearly erroneous claims while simultaneously encouraging people to legislate those beliefs. We’ve seen what happens there; fittingly enough due to the antics of Bobby Jindal, another GOP presidential candidate. It shortchanges our children out of an education they’ll need to survive in our science- and technology-based society.

I also know that the vast majority of creationists have very basic misunderstandings about evolution, the Big Bang, and science in general; I addressed this in depth when I wrote my article “Answers for Creationists.” I tried very hard to be polite in that post, given I was dealing on a personal level with people’s personal beliefs.

I take a different stance when it’s a politician who espouses these views, especially when he’s running for the highest office in America. If someone wants to run this country, then he better show that he has a solid grasp on reality. Dismissing and actively denigrating strongly understood science—whether it’s astronomy, biology, or climatology—is at the very least cause to dump him.

This is a pretty long thread so I done know if it ahs come up or not. But the question Ben Carson has to be asked and he must answer is this.

Would you be willing to violate any and all of your personal religious beliefs to further the interest of the United States of America ?

Because it is not about what a faith commands. It is a matter of whether or not someone who would be the nation's president would put the nation ahead of his own personal religious beliefs.
 
It also suggests killing your own child as a "sacrifice" to God. I'm not a bible thumper so go peddle that somewhere else.

Sorry to have jumped to conclusions. Which mythological/ideological system are you defending against the "atheist effort to deny the existence of God and the human soul"?
 
Do people believe in the existence of Satan?

According to polls conducted by YouGov and Gallup, the answer is yes, they do.

Gallup breaks it down a couple of different ways:

20030225b_2.gif


20030225b_1.gif



http://www.gallup.com/poll/7858/devil-demographic-details.aspx

67% of Democrats? Quite a few, I'd say. Are they crackpots?

YouGov's more recent poll indicated, overall, 57% of people believe in the existence of the devil, 28% do not, and 15% don't know.

http://cdn.yougov.com/cumulus_uploads/document/vhyn6fdnkp/tabs_exorcism_0912132013 (1).pdf


Make of the data what you will.
 
Remember that the theory you are rejecting is not "some lefty's," but the scientific community's. Pretending there is not a PROBLEM because you don't like the leftist nature of the only possible SOLUTION is like ignoring the half-dozen doctors who all tell you you have cancer because you don't want to go through chemo.

http://humanevents.com/2013/12/16/intelligent-design-theories-gaining-steam-in-scientific-circles/

http://www.reasons.org/articles/harvard-scientists-write-the-book-on-intelligent-design-in-dna

Although all of the scientists mentioned believe that life came from non-life through an undirected, naturalistic process, none of them have the slightest clue as to how it actually happened...

http://www.algemeiner.com/2011/08/1...at-life-is-the-result-of-intelligent-design/#
 
Back
Top