New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Ben Carson: The Devil Made Him Do It!!

But you use Breitbart?
So? It's a secure site and no one can edit it to serve their agenda. So you don't like Brietbart. Ho hum. We happen to have a right of free press and free speech in this country. Grow up.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Yet we all know the meaning of the word in that context. No one tries to say...that doesn't work...all 177 aspects of the word run do not apply, therefore, it doesn't apply at all. That's what you're trying to sell...and believe me, I ain't buying.

Where you fail is the elevation, the conflation to "exactness". I never said a dog understanding 165 words was the same as Einstein's understanding of the theory of relativity. There are always degrees to such understanding as we know; few humans understand the theory of relativity.

Dogs feel...and have some limited understanding. They suffer...

No, they are not Einstein. Neither are either of us.

No, what I am trying to say is, just because a dog "understands" what the word "treat" means doesn't make him "sentient." Look, I'm a big animal rights supporter, but that doesn't hinge on their "sentience" - it hinges on our human dignity.
 
No, what I am trying to say is, just because a dog "understands" what the word "treat" means doesn't make him "sentient." Look, I'm a big animal rights supporter, but that doesn't hinge on their "sentience" - it hinges on our human dignity.

What does the word sentient mean?

sen·tient
ˈsen(t)SH(ē)ənt/
adjective
  1. able to perceive or feel things.
able to perceive or feel things.
"she had been instructed from birth in the equality of all sentient life forms"
synonyms: (capable of) feeling, living, live; More

1.
having the power of perception by the senses;conscious.
2.
characterized by sensation and consciousness.
noun
3.
a person or thing that is sentient.


examples from the Web for sentientExpand
Contemporary Examples
 
So? It's a secure site and no one can edit it to serve their agenda. So you don't like Brietbart. Ho hum. We happen to have a right of free press and free speech in this country. Grow up.

Oh,dear, I grew up long ago. I am pretty sure you know that.:) I think Breitbart is funny. But the owner is dead.
 
Oh,dear, I grew up long ago. I am pretty sure you know that.:) I think Breitbart is funny. But the owner is dead.
Yes. Robin Williams was funny and he's also dead. Do you have any other profound observations?
 
Yes, I am aware of their "theory" on that. Are you aware that as the glacier Obama flew to Alaska to stand on as he delivered his anti-capitalist screed over "anthropogenic global warming" recedes, it is revealing a forest of large trees that have been under the ice for 1000 years?

http://www.livescience.com/39819-ancient-forest-thaws.html

So, who was burning all the carbon 1000 years ago?

I was not aware. Of course, the fact that the current, ultra-rapid warming is largely caused by hydrocarbon combustion, as demonstrated by a broad array of observations over a period of decades, does not mean that all warming is caused by hydrocarbon combustion; and, indeed, some of the other mechanisms affecting climate are known, and their influence is ruled out or judged to be limited based on that same broad array of observations.
 
I was not aware. Of course, the fact that the current, ultra-rapid warming is largely caused by hydrocarbon combustion, as demonstrated by a broad array of observations over a period of decades, does not mean that all warming is caused by hydrocarbon combustion; and, indeed, some of the other mechanisms affecting climate are known, and their influence is ruled out or judged to be limited based on that same broad array of observations.
When are y'all gonna start taxing those volcanoes?
 
Yeah, I know what "sentience" means. It means more than a dog comes running when her owner says "treat."

I disagree. The dog shows, for example, far more understanding than an imaginary 1980s robot dog trained to sit, roll over, shake, speak, and come running when one says, "treat." For example, it must first select "treat" from among all the symbols available, not just from a dictionary with 40 or 100 corresponding words built in, but from the entire variety of short combinations of phonemes people are capable of producing. It must learn to distinguish it from words such as "trick" or "sweet." It must make the considered judgment that "treats" are something it particularly likes, while the supper dish being filled is at best a palliative to which a full belly can be indifferent.

There is no convincing a determined solipsist, but I am convinced that dogs show understanding (granted, of a childlike and vague nature) for the same reasons I am convinced that other humans show it (introspection and analogical reasoning). I am not saying that fleas likewise show understanding, or that modern AI programs do not. But really, how can the automaton you describe be man's best friend?
 
Because we're trying to figure out why humans have the capacity to "understand."

1. Human ancestors are predators. Predators tend to be more intelligent than prey species.
2. Human ancestors are pack animals. Pack animals tend to be more intelligent than solitary animals.
3. The signals used by pack animals also provided a basis for the evolution of language, which itself stimulated brain development in a positive feedback loop.
4. Primates tend to be more intelligent than other orders of animals. They are descended from a long chain of predators. They tend to outstrip their food supplies and be forced to adapt quickly, a situation in which intelligence is obviously a big advantage. Their ancestors were arboreal and related to flying, gliding, and echolocating species (colugos, bats, etc.); these adaptations all require a certain minimal brain capacity to calculate the trajectory of a body moving in space.
5. Warm-blooded animals tend to have relatively high metabolisms, especially for their size. A high metabolism increases the evolutionary reward for intelligence.
6. Bipedalism and the growth of intelligence reinforced each other in a positive feedback loop.
7. The opposable thumb and the growth of intelligence reinforced each other in a positive feedback loop.
8. The conditions of the savannah rewarded bipedalism and intelligence, and explain the difference between humans and chimpanzees, which evolved in the forest where rewards for marginal intelligence (as opposed to, say, tree-climbing ability) were smaller.
 
Where, when & how?

Any time species are separated for any reason, they will evolve in separate directions due to genetic drift. If they likewise find themselves in different environments, they will also drift apart due to natural selection preserving different alleles and mutations.
 
It's really quite simple Craig - either the entire scope of the definition applies or it doesn't. If only the most limited connotation works, then there's probably a better word for what you are trying to, well, connote...

A point of information: the numbered items in a dictionary are not elaborations on the same definition, but rather alternative meanings of a word.
 
I was not aware. Of course, the fact that the current, ultra-rapid warming is largely caused by hydrocarbon combustion, as demonstrated by a broad array of observations over a period of decades, does not mean that all warming is caused by hydrocarbon combustion; and, indeed, some of the other mechanisms affecting climate are known, and their influence is ruled out or judged to be limited based on that same broad array of observations.

Indeed. We don't know how much is being caused naturally and how much is the result of burning hydrocarbons. What we do know is that the left views climate change as a cudgel with which they can beat capitalism to death. I'm certain a deal could be had to use a carbon tax to replace the corporate income tax, but the left isn't as interested in reducing carbon usage as much as they are in reducing private sector for profit business activities. Get back to us when you guys are willing to compromise...
 
I disagree. The dog shows, for example, far more understanding than an imaginary 1980s robot dog trained to sit, roll over, shake, speak, and come running when one says, "treat." For example, it must first select "treat" from among all the symbols available, not just from a dictionary with 40 or 100 corresponding words built in, but from the entire variety of short combinations of phonemes people are capable of producing. It must learn to distinguish it from words such as "trick" or "sweet." It must make the considered judgment that "treats" are something it particularly likes, while the supper dish being filled is at best a palliative to which a full belly can be indifferent.

There is no convincing a determined solipsist, but I am convinced that dogs show understanding (granted, of a childlike and vague nature) for the same reasons I am convinced that other humans show it (introspection and analogical reasoning). I am not saying that fleas likewise show understanding, or that modern AI programs do not. But really, how can the automaton you describe be man's best friend?

You can just as easily teach the dog to come running for a treat when you blow a whistle. The dog doesn't understand the meaning of the word "treat" (which would imply sentience). It has just been trained that when its owner says that word, in a certain way no less, that if it comes running the owner will hand it a treat.
 
1. Human ancestors are predators. Predators tend to be more intelligent than prey species.
2. Human ancestors are pack animals. Pack animals tend to be more intelligent than solitary animals.
3. The signals used by pack animals also provided a basis for the evolution of language, which itself stimulated brain development in a positive feedback loop.
4. Primates tend to be more intelligent than other orders of animals. They are descended from a long chain of predators. They tend to outstrip their food supplies and be forced to adapt quickly, a situation in which intelligence is obviously a big advantage. Their ancestors were arboreal and related to flying, gliding, and echolocating species (colugos, bats, etc.); these adaptations all require a certain minimal brain capacity to calculate the trajectory of a body moving in space.
5. Warm-blooded animals tend to have relatively high metabolisms, especially for their size. A high metabolism increases the evolutionary reward for intelligence.
6. Bipedalism and the growth of intelligence reinforced each other in a positive feedback loop.
7. The opposable thumb and the growth of intelligence reinforced each other in a positive feedback loop.
8. The conditions of the savannah rewarded bipedalism and intelligence, and explain the difference between humans and chimpanzees, which evolved in the forest where rewards for marginal intelligence (as opposed to, say, tree-climbing ability) were smaller.

Where is the evidence of the "positive feedback loop" that teaches lefties to support failed economic policies?
 
A point of information: the numbered items in a dictionary are not elaborations on the same definition, but rather alternative meanings of a word.

Yes, but like I keep telling Craig, the fact that a dog "understands" a command/reward situation isn't the same as a human "understanding" of quantum physics. I just don't buy the concept that animals are sentient because they can "feel" pleasure or pain. Studies have proven that plants exhibit an awareness of comfort/discomfort as well - does that mean plants are "sentient?" It's more than that - it's the ability to learn a language, perform arithmetic, and more importantly to teach what one "understands" to another.
 
Yes, but like I keep telling Craig, the fact that a dog "understands" a command/reward situation isn't the same as a human "understanding" of quantum physics. I just don't buy the concept that animals are sentient because they can "feel" pleasure or pain. Studies have proven that plants exhibit an awareness of comfort/discomfort as well - does that mean plants are "sentient?" It's more than that - it's the ability to learn a language, perform arithmetic, and more importantly to teach what one "understands" to another.

As the word means "able to feel", "having the power of perception"...it means they are sentient...That they have senses.

Again...you try to use a ridiculous comparison. No...it is not the same as understanding quantum physics. No one, other than you, argues that it is.

You're again confusing and conflating human intelligence with sentience.


...Based on the overwhelming and universal acceptance of the Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness I offer here what I call a Universal Declaration on Animal Sentience. For the purpose of this essay I am defining "sentience" as "the ability to feel, perceive, or be conscious, or to experience subjectivity(link is external)" (for wide-ranging discussion please click here(link is external).)

Evidence of animal sentience is everywhere": It's a matter of why sentience evolved, not if it evolved

A strong and rapidly growing database on animal sentience supports the acceptance of the fact that other animals are sentient beings. We know that individuals of a wide variety of species experience emotions ranging from joy and happiness to deep sadness, grief, and PTSD, along with empathy, jealousy and resentment. There is no reason to embellish them because science is showing how fascinating they are (for example, mice, rats, and chickens display empathy) and countless other "surprises" are rapidly emerging...

...For example, we share with other mammals and vertebrates the same areas of the brain that are important for consciousness and processing emotions.

We surely are not exceptional or alone in the arena of sentience and indeed, membership in the sentience club is rapidly growing. There are sound biological reasons for recognizing animals as sentient beings. We need to abandon the anthropocentric view that only big-brained animals such as ourselves, nonhuman great apes, elephants, and cetaceans (dolphins and whales) have sufficient mental capacities for complex forms of sentience and consciousness. So, the interesting and challenging question is why has sentience evolved in diverse species, not if it has evolved...



https://www.psychologytoday.com/blo...al-declaration-animal-sentience-no-pretending
 
Back
Top