New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Ben Carson: The Devil Made Him Do It!!

Then why can't animals build their own cities and societies?

If you think animals don't have 'societies', then you are simply not very acquainted with the whole FIELD of animal behavior (ethology), and I would add are simply not very observant.

Yogi Berra (paraphrased): You can observe a lot, just by looking.

As far as 'cities', it would not be too far off or incorrect to view termite mounds as being cities, inasmuch as a single termite mound can be the home for MILLIONS of termites.
 
If you think animals don't have 'societies', then you are simply not very acquainted with the whole FIELD of animal behavior (ethology), and I would add are simply not very observant.

Yogi Berra (paraphrased): You can observe a lot, just by looking.

As far as 'cities', it would not be too far off or incorrect to view termite mounds as being cities, inasmuch as a single termite mound can be the home for MILLIONS of termites.

Yes, but even you would have to admit a city today bears little resemblance to a "city" from the middle ages. Whereas a termite mound today is virtually indistinguishable from one a constructed a thousand years ago. Get back to me when we discover termites building little roads through their mounds and manufacturing little autos to drive along them, and we'll revisit your claim that it is essentially the same thing as human municipal development.
 
Yes, but even you would have to admit a city today bears little resemblance to a "city" from the middle ages. Whereas a termite mound today is virtually indistinguishable from one a constructed a thousand years ago. Get back to me when we discover termites building little roads through their mounds and manufacturing little autos to drive along them, and we'll revisit your claim that it is essentially the same thing as human municipal development.

I hope you are aware, Lukey, that HUMANS have only lived in cities for about six thousand years, an eye-blink in geological time. Perhaps you know that before that, we often lived in caves......
 
I hope you are aware, Lukey, that HUMANS have only lived in cities for about six thousand years, an eye-blink in geological time. Perhaps you know that before that, we often lived in caves......

Yes, which is precisely MY point. In that 6000 or so years man has developed a highly complex society and political economy. While over the same timeframe animals have developed, well, not much. There is a huge difference and the fact of the matter is we don't know a heck of a lot about why that is...
 
Yes, which is precisely MY point. In that 6000 or so years man has developed a highly complex society and political economy. While over the same timeframe animals have developed, well, not much. There is a huge difference and the fact of the matter is we don't know a heck of a lot about why that is...

I think we know a LOT about why that is. Humans have largely replaced biological evolution with cultural and technological evolution, which can proceed at VASTLY higher rates than biological evolution. Cities themselves were amplifiers of social and technological change. The development of writing accelerated the process even further. Later inventions, of paper and the printing press, amplified the rate of change even more. All kinds of positive feedback loops have been involved in human evolution; apes never arrived at that point....
 
Yes, which is precisely MY point. In that 6000 or so years man has developed a highly complex society and political economy. While over the same timeframe animals have developed, well, not much. There is a huge difference and the fact of the matter is we don't know a heck of a lot about why that is...

Funny story: As an economics professor, I was once called on the carpet by the head of the Economics Department, who said he had gotten a complaint from a student that I was 'attacking their religion' in class. I was utterly baffled, and had no idea what that was all about, until my boss mentioned the name of the student. Then I remembered. On the very first day of class, I had said to the students: "In less than ten thousand years, humans have gone from living in caves, to sending spacecraft to the outermost edges of the Solar System, a stunning achievement." And a young woman had objected to this, saying the world had only existed for six thousand years. Because I wanted to continue with my lecture, I am afraid I probably did kind of airily dismiss her complaint, by saying something to the effect that, well, that was NOT what the scientific community thinks.

I related this to the head of the department, and I remember him rolling his eyes and saying, "Oh, one of those."

So I wasn't in trouble, after all......
 
Now I am not a fan of Hillary Clinton or Barack Obama, but I will admit that my opposition to Ben Carson is ideological. But let's unpack what this means. I am opposed to Carson's ideology because it is a threat to things I hold dear--freedom of religion, women's rights, gay rights, a healthy environment, and honesty about history and science. It is also clear that his reactionary ideology reflects a deliberate choice, or a reckless neglect, to consider the factual issues involved rationally.

Rationally? Carson's ideology is the ideology of mainstream patriotic Christian Americans and has been for generations. "Progressives" are the reactionary freaks, not Dr. Carson.
 
I think we know a LOT about why that is. Humans have largely replaced biological evolution with cultural and technological evolution, which can proceed at VASTLY higher rates than biological evolution. Cities themselves were amplifiers of social and technological change. The development of writing accelerated the process even further. Later inventions, of paper and the printing press, amplified the rate of change even more. All kinds of positive feedback loops have been involved in human evolution; apes never arrived at that point....

That's not what I meant. I meant we don't know why humans developed the capacity for language, math, those kinds of innovations you describe, while animals have not.
 
Funny story: As an economics professor, I was once called on the carpet by the head of the Economics Department, who said he had gotten a complaint from a student that I was 'attacking their religion' in class. I was utterly baffled, and had no idea what that was all about, until my boss mentioned the name of the student. Then I remembered. On the very first day of class, I had said to the students: "In less than ten thousand years, humans have gone from living in caves, to sending spacecraft to the outermost edges of the Solar System, a stunning achievement." And a young woman had objected to this, saying the world had only existed for six thousand years. Because I wanted to continue with my lecture, I am afraid I probably did kind of airily dismiss her complaint, by saying something to the effect that, well, that was NOT what the scientific community thinks.

I related this to the head of the department, and I remember him rolling his eyes and saying, "Oh, one of those."

So I wasn't in trouble, after all......

It ain't easy being a teach. I tried teaching college level Statistics once and I was appalled at how dumb the kids were. I would spoon feed them the problem on the board in class, then assign the same problem with different values for homework, and then give them essentially the exact same problem on the test and still two-thirds of them failed the class...
 
That's not what I meant. I meant we don't know why humans developed the capacity for language, math, those kinds of innovations you describe, while animals have not.

OK, so you are just talking about what happened in human evolution much EARLIER, long before we started living in cities. And I STILL say the answer is: positive feedback loops. For whatever reason, our human ancestors started hunting, on the African savannas, while our ape cousins remained in the forest. Using tools and hunting generated powerful positive feedback loops resulting in better hand-eye coordination, better planning, more social cooperation, and yes, bigger brains. In fact, humans are the super-cooperators of the animal world, and this is undoubtedly one of the primary reasons for our success.
 
It ain't easy being a teach. I tried teaching college level Statistics once and I was appalled at how dumb the kids were. I would spoon feed them the problem on the board in class, then assign the same problem with different values for homework, and then give them essentially the exact same problem on the test and still two-thirds of them failed the class...
I know the feeling. I often feel like I'm teaching lefties junior high civics and American history on political forums. Our education system is messed up.
 
It ain't easy being a teach. I tried teaching college level Statistics once and I was appalled at how dumb the kids were. I would spoon feed them the problem on the board in class, then assign the same problem with different values for homework, and then give them essentially the exact same problem on the test and still two-thirds of them failed the class...

As time went on, I was seeing more and more college freshmen who could not do elementary level math: they were frustrated by fractions, dismayed by decimals, perplexed by percentages. All stuff that USED to be considered 6th-grade arithmetic. I could and did literally track the declining math skills of the incoming freshmen. That was one of the reasons I decided to switch into teaching high school, to TRY to do something about that awful trend....
 
Rationally? Carson's ideology is the ideology of mainstream patriotic Christian Americans and has been for generations. "Progressives" are the reactionary freaks, not Dr. Carson.

I REFUSE to believe that "mainstream patriotic Christian Americans" think that Lucifer was implanting insidious and sinister ideas into the brain of Charles Darwin.

If I'm wrong about that, then America is in even more trouble than I already thought.
 
OK, so you are just talking about what happened in human evolution much EARLIER, long before we started living in cities. And I STILL say the answer is: positive feedback loops. For whatever reason, our human ancestors started hunting, on the African savannas, while our ape cousins remained in the forest. Using tools and hunting generated powerful positive feedback loops resulting in better hand-eye coordination, better planning, more social cooperation, and yes, bigger brains. In fact, humans are the super-cooperators of the animal world, and this is undoubtedly one of the primary reasons for our success.

Well I suppose that's the THEORY...
 
I REFUSE to believe that "mainstream patriotic Christian Americans" think that Lucifer was implanting insidious and sinister ideas into the brain of Charles Darwin.

If I'm wrong about that, then America is in even more trouble than I already thought.
Go ahead and think it. It's okay. Lefties believe Bruce Jenner is a woman and the anus is a sex organ. Lefties also believe man made global warming is destroying the earth. So what? We all have crazy ideas floating around in our heads.
 
As time went on, I was seeing more and more college freshmen who could not do elementary level math: they were frustrated by fractions, dismayed by decimals, perplexed by percentages. All stuff that USED to be considered 6th-grade arithmetic. I could and did literally track the declining math skills of the incoming freshmen. That was one of the reasons I decided to switch into teaching high school, to TRY to do something about that awful trend....

Sounds like you couldn't hack it in college and demoted back to high school.
 
Last edited:
Is there a word missing?

should have been couldn't

if I don't proof, server doesn't post what's typed

I guess the devil made Θ use dope and who knows what else, he has all his past hidden.
 
Lefties believe Bruce Jenner is a woman and the anus is a sex organ.

Well, it certainly is hard to explain from the perspective of 'Intelligent Design Theory'. Why did the Great Designer in the Sky choose to put a waste disposal unit right next to a recreation area?!? Seems like bad engineering.

Hardly surprising that some folks get confused, and end up using the waste disposal unit for recreational purposes. Now, the Great Designer don't like that none, no, not at ALL, leastways iffn' ya buhleeve what ya read in the Holey Bibble. But its His own damned FAULT, for puttin' them right next to each other!
 
Lefties also believe man made global warming is destroying the earth.

Not really. In fact, I don't know of any 'lefties' who believe that global warming is destroying the EARTH. The Earth will continue rotating on its axis, and will continue revolving around the Sun, even if the human race goes extinct. What the scientific community says is that if greenhouse gas emissions continue unabated, the ability of the Earth to sustain human societies in a desirable way is in serious question.

By the way, you DO believe the Earth revolves around the Sun, right?
 
Back
Top