New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Ben Carson: The Devil Made Him Do It!!

Oh, wait. Dr. Carson also believes in Jesus. That makes him a double doofus. He probably can't even get on the internet by himself, I betcha.
Carson is a Religious Fundamentalist...Trying to jam his damn dirty religion on others...He will fail
 
Christianity, besides its little infinitely minute offshoots, believes in the big bang. Hell, the theory was discovered by a priest.

Yes, the Roman Catholic priest Lemaitre. The Roman Catholic church has no problem with either evolution or the Big Bang. I think they learned their lesson about tangling with science with the whole Galileo thing.

Dr. Carson OBVIOUSLY has some SERIOUS problems with modern science, though. And America cannot afford a scientifically illiterate President in the 21st century.
 
Yes, it sort of calls the question as to why so much of the left's "settled science" is, well, in fact unsettled...

If you think we have only 135 years worth of data on global temperatures, Lukey, it sort of calls into question how well informed you are about this entire matter.....
 
But can't answer where primordial soup came from.

The primordial soup came from chemicals that were already known to be present on Earth from the beginning. Some more may have been delivered by comet impacts in the early Solar System.

Answering questions like this is WHY both NASA and the European Space Agency have been sending missions to comets. Missions that you, as a scientific illiterate, have ZERO interest in.
 
Yes, and no. Yes, there is no (known) exact moment, nor is there a (currently) known biological transformative mechanism. But no - there is most certainly every good reason to think there would be, unless one is uninterested and/or trying to obscure that fact for some ideological reason.

Until a decade or so ago, there was a respectable hypothesis that humans may have gone through some major neural rewiring some 40 thousand years ago, at the time of the so-called 'Great Leap Forward' in human prehistory. In Europe, this was the time when the Cro-Magnons were in the process of replacing the Neanderthals, and SUDDENLY, humans were making much more sophisticated compound tools; we were creating magnificent art (those majestic cave paintings); we had begun making fish-hooks and fishing nets and harpoons, suggesting a growing interest in exploiting freshwater and marine resources; sewing became widespread; and so on.

However, we now know that many of these cultural traits had appeared in Africa quite a bit earlier, going back more than 100,000 years in some cases. So it was NOT a sudden emergence, a sudden blossoming of the human mind, that resulted in 'the Great Leap Forward' in Europe.

Humans obviously have vastly greater mental abilities than our closest living relatives, the chimpanzees. However, creationists and their allies tend to downplay the abilities of chimpanzees and other apes, quite wrongly. The great apes CAN be taught sign language, for instance, and demonstrate a fair proficiency at problem-solving when it comes to acquiring food. Chimpanzees also understand the basic principles of barter. And so on.

SOMETHING clearly did happen in the transition from chimp-like ancestors to modern humans, to give humans their linguistic and mental abilities. There is just NO reason to believe it all happened at one crucial moment----as you seem to think.
 
I'm continually fascinated with the left and their biased beliefs about Christians somehow being stupid because they believe in a Creator.

Nope. That's not the issue, not at ALL. Many great scientists believe in a Creator; you yourself have pointed out that Einstein did.

There is, however, a certain TYPE of Christian.....the ones who believe in a world-wide flood, the ones who believe the Earth is less than six thousand years old, the ones who believe that humans were instantaneously created, out of dust, and that they did not evolve from lower animals......YES, those Christians are stupid.

The problem is NOT with Christianity. It is with FUNDAMENTALISM.
 
Until a decade or so ago, there was a respectable hypothesis that humans may have gone through some major neural rewiring some 40 thousand years ago, at the time of the so-called 'Great Leap Forward' in human prehistory. In Europe, this was the time when the Cro-Magnons were in the process of replacing the Neanderthals, and SUDDENLY, humans were making much more sophisticated compound tools; we were creating magnificent art (those majestic cave paintings); we had begun making fish-hooks and fishing nets and harpoons, suggesting a growing interest in exploiting freshwater and marine resources; sewing became widespread; and so on.

However, we now know that many of these cultural traits had appeared in Africa quite a bit earlier, going back more than 100,000 years in some cases. So it was NOT a sudden emergence, a sudden blossoming of the human mind, that resulted in 'the Great Leap Forward' in Europe.

Humans obviously have vastly greater mental abilities than our closest living relatives, the chimpanzees. However, creationists and their allies tend to downplay the abilities of chimpanzees and other apes, quite wrongly. The great apes CAN be taught sign language, for instance, and demonstrate a fair proficiency at problem-solving when it comes to acquiring food. Chimpanzees also understand the basic principles of barter. And so on.

SOMETHING clearly did happen in the transition from chimp-like ancestors to modern humans, to give humans their linguistic and mental abilities. There is just NO reason to believe it all happened at one crucial moment----as you seem to think.

So, why haven't apes continued to evolve, like humans?
 
It is still theory based on a "model" as your reference made clear (while simultaneously suggesting that it is anything but). That is exactly the sort of underhanded rhetorical tactics that have allowed the progressives to enact so many policies that result in the exact opposite of their intended effect, while making us militarily and economically weaker every step of the way. It's time we put a stop to it...

Newton's gravitational theory was likewise a theory based on a (mathematical) model, as is the theory of relativity which superseded it.
 
Sort of. At least with the suggestion that evolution = gravity, in that it, at least, can be observed. But with regards to evolution, you still have the issue of the genesis of humanoids. If I'm not mistaken there's still a lot of unproved theory involved in that particular piece of the science of evolution.

The big picture is well understood, while evidence is still being sought to fill in the little details.
 
Yes, and no. Yes, there is no (known) exact moment, nor is there a (currently) known biological transformative mechanism. But no - there is most certainly every good reason to think there would be, unless one is uninterested and/or trying to obscure that fact for some ideological reason.

The mechanism is obvious--increases in brain complexity which at a boundary that is by its nature indefinite passes over into a qualitative difference. Yet that boundary is so not like a specified point that there are animals with much MORE cognitive capacity than some people.
 
I've heard that argument before, and I don't buy it. Obama never ran anything or accomplished anything in his life, yet he was qualified but Dr. Carson who ran entire hospitals isnt. Funny.

Before becoming president, he was editor of the Harvard Law Review, a constitutional scholar, a community organizer, and a senator. Remember?
 
It's not about qualifications. It's about ideology. If Dr. Carson was an Alinskyite like Hillary and Obama, he'd be the smartest man who ever lived.

Now I am not a fan of Hillary Clinton or Barack Obama, but I will admit that my opposition to Ben Carson is ideological. But let's unpack what this means. I am opposed to Carson's ideology because it is a threat to things I hold dear--freedom of religion, women's rights, gay rights, a healthy environment, and honesty about history and science. It is also clear that his reactionary ideology reflects a deliberate, or reckless, neglect to consider the factual issues involved rationally.
 
Last edited:
The big picture is well understood, while evidence is still being sought to fill in the little details.

Then I would suggest you point us to the exact (or even obvious approximate) time, location and mechanism for when and how humans transformed from being animals into sentient beings. And for a bonus question, explain why other animal species have been unable to make the same transition.
 
The mechanism is obvious--increases in brain complexity which at a boundary that is by its nature indefinite passes over into a qualitative difference. Yet that boundary is so not like a specified point that there are animals with much MORE cognitive capacity than some people.

Then why can't animals build their own cities and societies?
 
Back
Top