New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Ben Carson: The Devil Made Him Do It!!

You mean like falsely attributing statements about the Benghazi attacks to the president and secretary of state?
You're confused. I can post my opinions. I don't change anyone's words. Only a propaganda parrot punk would do that.
 
You're confused. I can post my opinions. I don't change anyone's words. Only a propaganda parrot punk would do that.

It wasn't a matter of opinion when you called me a liar for saying that Obama blamed the attack on "extremists and terrorists." It was a matter of fact, and the fact is that in the video that you told me to watch, he did. In other words, you changed his words. What I did to you apparently violated site rules, and I'm sorry about that, but it was far less egregious since the obvious intent was not to obscure the truth about what you said, but only to poke fun at you. (Granted that was rude and I apologize.)
 
Not really. The theory of anthropogenic global warming makes specific predictions (stratospheric cooling, ocean acidification, etc.) that aren't accounted for by alternative hypotheses about the cause of the warming.

Yes, I am aware of their "theory" on that. Are you aware that as the glacier Obama flew to Alaska to stand on as he delivered his anti-capitalist screed over "anthropogenic global warming" recedes, it is revealing a forest of large trees that have been under the ice for 1000 years?

http://www.livescience.com/39819-ancient-forest-thaws.html

So, who was burning all the carbon 1000 years ago?
 
Perhaps the problem is that you don't understand the meaning of the word "sentient." It doesn't mean capable of counting.

sen·tient/ˈsen(t)SH(ē)ənt/
adjective
  1. able to perceive or feel things.

2. to recognize, discern, envision, or understand.

understand
verb un·der·stand \ˌən-dər-ˈstand\

1
a : to grasp the meaning of <understand Russian>

b : to grasp the reasonableness of <his behavior is hard to understand>

c : to have thorough or technical acquaintance with or expertness in the practice of <understand finance>

d : to be thoroughly familiar with the character and propensities of <understands children>
2
: to accept as a fact or truth or regard as plausible without utter certainty <we understand that he is returning from abroad>
3
: to interpret in one of a number of possible ways
4
: to supply in thought as though expressed <“to be married” is commonly understood after the word engaged>
intransitive verb
1
: to have understanding : have the power of comprehension
2
: to achieve a grasp of the nature, significance, or explanation of something
3
: to believe or infer something to be the case
4
: to show a sympathetic or tolerant attitude toward something

Yeah, I know what "sentience" means. It means more than a dog comes running when her owner says "treat."
 
Because, as I explained above, evolution isn't a goal-directed process leading inexorably toward greater and greater intelligence. The development of greater intelligence in human ancestors was the result of a unique conjuncture of environmental pressures.

Yes, you are correct - we have no idea...
 
1. Many other animals have BEGUN to develop the same capacities.
2. The argument works only if those complex mental capacities provide a selective advantage. As I pointed out earlier, there are also selective costs for the modifications involved in making them possible (e.g., longer immaturity periods with all the risks involved for children and adults). Bacteria, which have no intelligence, are the most successful creatures in the world in terms of reproduction. Insects, which have little to no intelligence, are the most prolific animals. Whence the assumption that evolution always selects for greater intelligence?

Because we're trying to figure out why humans have the capacity to "understand."
 
2. to recognize, discern, envision, or understand.

understand
verb un·der·stand \ˌən-dər-ˈstand\

1
a : to grasp the meaning of <understand Russian>

b : to grasp the reasonableness of <his behavior is hard to understand>

c : to have thorough or technical acquaintance with or expertness in the practice of <understand finance>

d : to be thoroughly familiar with the character and propensities of <understands children>
2
: to accept as a fact or truth or regard as plausible without utter certainty <we understand that he is returning from abroad>
3
: to interpret in one of a number of possible ways
4
: to supply in thought as though expressed <“to be married” is commonly understood after the word engaged>
intransitive verb
1
: to have understanding : have the power of comprehension
2
: to achieve a grasp of the nature, significance, or explanation of something
3
: to believe or infer something to be the case
4
: to show a sympathetic or tolerant attitude toward something

Yeah, I know what "sentience" means. It means more than a dog comes running when her owner says "treat."


Seems to me the dog UNDERSTANDS "treat"...

Regardless, the first definition is valid, but you remove that to really focus on UNDERSTANDING.

...According to Dr. Stanley Coren, an expert in canine intelligence, the average dog can understand about 165 words, possibly more with training. Consistency is key, says Coren. If you call his meal "supper" but your spouse calls it "dinner," the label for his nightly kibble might be fuzzy. But if everyone says "dinner," he'll soon perk up anytime you're discussing dinner plans.

http://www.animalplanet.com/pets/how-many-words-do-dogs-know/
 
No, the environmental pressures do not apply "almost equally across all species." The whole point is that populations separated by environmental chance (e.g., the ancestors of humans and of chimpanzees) diverge due to differing environmental circumstances.

Where, when & how?
 
Seems to me the dog UNDERSTANDS "treat"...

Regardless, the first definition is valid, but you remove that to really focus on UNDERSTANDING.

...According to Dr. Stanley Coren, an expert in canine intelligence, the average dog can understand about 165 words, possibly more with training. Consistency is key, says Coren. If you call his meal "supper" but your spouse calls it "dinner," the label for his nightly kibble might be fuzzy. But if everyone says "dinner," he'll soon perk up anytime you're discussing dinner plans.

http://www.animalplanet.com/pets/how-many-words-do-dogs-know/

Yes, that clearly makes them fully capable of "understanding:"

"to have thorough or technical acquaintance with or expertness in the practice of"
 
Yes, that clearly makes them fully capable of "understanding:"

"to have thorough or technical acquaintance with or expertness in the practice of"


It makes them capable of understanding some human words.


un·der·stand
ˌəndərˈstand/
verb
  1. 1.
    perceive the intended meaning of (words, a language, or speaker).
 
It makes them capable of understanding some human words.


un·der·stand
ˌəndərˈstand/
verb
  1. 1.
    perceive the intended meaning of (words, a language, or speaker).

So as long as they qualify on the lowest level connotation, all of the higher meanings associated with the word are rendered, well, meaningless? If you believe that it quite frankly explains a LOT about why progressives continue to have so much unquestioned faith in so many proven bad ideas. So as long as socialism works on some level some where, all the many documented failures are rendered irrelevant. Yeah, I see how that works now...
 
So as long as they qualify on the lowest level connotation, all of the higher meanings associated with the word are rendered, well, meaningless? If you believe that it quite frankly explains a LOT about why progressives continue to have so much unquestioned faith in so many proven bad ideas. So as long as socialism works on some level some where, all the many documented failures are rendered irrelevant. Yeah, I see how that works now...

Meaningless? Absolutely not. They simply don't apply to the circumstance.

The basic definition fits, but you insist on a higher one. Indeed, you removed the first definition as if it did not exist. There's no need to try and enforce your single definition onto the subject when another fits perfectly well.

In addition, as anyone who has read about or known animals, especially canines, at all UNDERSTANDS that they also have a completely different level of senses. Their ability to discern sounds and smells far outweighs yours.
 
Meaningless? Absolutely not. They simply don't apply to the circumstance.

The basic definition fits, but you insist on a higher one. Indeed, you removed the first definition as if it did not exist. There's no need to try and enforce your single definition onto the subject when another fits perfectly well.

In addition, as anyone who has read about or known animals, especially canines, at all UNDERSTANDS that they also have a completely different level of senses. Their ability to discern sounds and smells far outweighs yours.

It's really quite simple Craig - either the entire scope of the definition applies or it doesn't. If only the most limited connotation works, then there's probably a better word for what you are trying to, well, connote...
 
It wasn't a matter of opinion when you called me a liar for saying that Obama blamed the attack on "extremists and terrorists." It was a matter of fact, and the fact is that in the video that you told me to watch, he did. In other words, you changed his words. What I did to you apparently violated site rules, and I'm sorry about that, but it was far less egregious since the obvious intent was not to obscure the truth about what you said, but only to poke fun at you. (Granted that was rude and I apologize.)
I accept your apology. Carry on.
 
It's really quite simple Craig - either the entire scope of the definition applies or it doesn't. If only the most limited connotation works, then there's probably a better word for what you are trying to, well, connote...

It doesn't.

Each definition applies to whatever it applies to.
 
It doesn't.

Each definition applies to whatever it applies to.

Yeah, and like I said, if it only barely applies, and there's large parts of the definition that don't apply, then there's no doubt a better word you could use in that situation.
 
Yeah, and like I said, if it only barely applies, and there's large parts of the definition that don't apply, then there's no doubt a better word you could use in that situation.

Few words have singular meanings. Your contention that the entire scope apply is flat out ridiculous.

The old mill was lovely and the trickle of the stream running past enhanced our visit.

The entire scope...

run
[ruhn]
verb (used without object), ran, run,running.
1.
to go quickly by moving the legs more rapidly than at a walk and in such a manner that for an instant in each step all or both feet are off the ground.
2.
to move with haste; act quickly:
Run upstairs and get the iodine.
3.
to depart quickly; take to flight; flee or escape:
to run from danger.
4.
to have recourse for aid, support, comfort, etc.:
He shouldn't run to his parents with every littleproblem.
5.
to make a quick trip or informal visit for a shortstay at a place:
to run up to New York; I will run over to see youafter dinner.
6.
to go around, rove, or ramble without restraint(often followed by about):
to run about in the park.
7.
to move, roll, or progress from momentum orfrom being hurled, kicked, or otherwise propelled:
The wheel ran over the curb and into the street.
verb (used with object), ran, run, running.
53.
to move or run along (a surface, way, path, etc.):
Every morning he ran the dirt path around thereservoir to keep in condition. She ran her fingersover the keyboard.
54.
to traverse (a distance) in running:
He ran the mile in just over four minutes.
55.
to perform, compete in, or accomplish by or as byrunning:
to run a race; to run an errand.
56.
to go about freely on or in without supervision:
permitting children to run the streets.
57.
to ride or cause to gallop:
to run a horse across a field.
58.
to enter in a race:
He ran his best filly in the Florida Derby.
59.
to bring into a certain state by running:
He ran himself out of breath trying to keep pace.
noun
98.
an act or instance, or a period of running:
a five-minute run before breakfast.
99.
a hurrying to or from some point, as on anerrand:
a run to reach the store before it closes.
100.
a fleeing, especially in great haste; flight:
a run from the police who were hot on his trail.
101.
a running pace:
The boys set out at a run.
102.
an act or instance or a period of moving rapidly,as in a boat or automobile:
a run to shore before the storm.
103.
distance covered, as by racing, running, or duringa trip:
a three-mile run.
104.
an act or instance or a period of traveling ormoving between two places; trip:
a truck on its daily run from farm to market; anonstop run from Louisville to Memphis.
adjective
149.
melted or liquefied:
run butter.
150.
poured in a melted state; run into and cast in amold:
run bronze.
Verb phrases
151.
run across, to meet or find accidentally:
She ran across an old friend at the party. He ranacross her name in the phone book.
152.
run after,
  1. to follow; chase:
    The dog ran after the burglar.
  2. to pursue or court the affections of, especiallyin an aggressive manner:
    He ran after her until she agreed to marry him.
  3. to attempt to become friendly with or part ofthe society of:
    He runs after the country-club set.
153.
run along, to leave; go on one's way:
I have to run along now, but I'll see you tonight.Run along—can't you see I'm busy?
154.
run around,
  1. (often followed by with) to socialize; consortwith:
    She runs around with the strangest people.
  2. to be unfaithful to one's spouse or lover:
    It was common knowledge that he was runningaround.
155.
run away,
  1. to flee or escape; leave a place of confinementor control with the intention of neverreturning:
    He ran away from home three times.
  2. Nautical. to haul on a line by walking orrunning steadily.
156.
run away with,
  1. to go away with, especially to elope with:
    She ran away with a sailor.
  2. to abscond with; steal:
    to run away with some valuable jewelry.
  3. to surpass others in; be outstanding in:
    to run away with academic honors.
  4. to overwhelm; get the better of:
    Sometimes his enthusiasm runs away withhim.
157.
run down,
  1. to strike and fell or overturn, especially todrive a vehicle into (someone):
    to run down an innocent pedestrian.
  2. to pursue until captured; chase:
    The detective swore that he would run downthe criminal.
  3. to peruse; review:
    His eyes ran down the front row and stoppedsuddenly.
  4. to cease operation; stop:
    My watch has run down.
  5. to speak disparagingly of; criticize severely:
    The students were always running down theirmath teacher.
  6. to search out; trace; find:
    to run down information.
  7. Baseball. to tag out (a base runner) betweenbases.
  8. Nautical. to collide with and sink (anothervessel).
  9. Nautical. to sail closely parallel to (a coast).
Idioms
171.
a run for one's money,
  1. close or keen competition:
    The out-of-town team gave us a run for ourmoney.
  2. enjoyment or profit in return for one'sexpense:
    This may not be the best tool kit, but it willgive you a run for your money.
172.
in the long run, in the course of longexperience; in the end:
Retribution will come, in the long run.
173.
in the short run, as an immediate or temporaryoutcome:
Recession may be averted in the short run ifpolicy changes are made now.
174.
on the run,
  1. moving quickly; hurrying about:
    He's so busy, he's always on the run.
  2. while running or in a hurry:
    I usually eat breakfast on the run.
  3. escaping or hiding from the police:
    He was on the run for two years.
175.
run afoul of,
  1. Nautical. to collide with so as to cause damageand entanglement.
  2. to incur or become subject to the wrath or illwill of:
    to run afoul of the law; He argued with hisfather and has run afoul of him ever since.
176.
run for it, to hurry away or flee, especially toevade something:
You had better run for it before anyone elsearrives.
177.
run in place,
  1. to go through the motions of running withoutleaving one's original place.
  2. to exist or work without noticeable change,progress, or improvement.
 
Few words have singular meanings. Your contention that the entire scope apply is flat out ridiculous.

The old mill was lovely and the trickle of the stream running past enhanced our visit.

The entire scope...

run
[ruhn]
verb (used without object), ran, run,running.
1.
to go quickly by moving the legs more rapidly than at a walk and in such a manner that for an instant in each step all or both feet are off the ground.
2.
to move with haste; act quickly:
Run upstairs and get the iodine.
3.
to depart quickly; take to flight; flee or escape:
to run from danger.
4.
to have recourse for aid, support, comfort, etc.:
He shouldn't run to his parents with every littleproblem.
5.
to make a quick trip or informal visit for a shortstay at a place:
to run up to New York; I will run over to see youafter dinner.
6.
to go around, rove, or ramble without restraint(often followed by about):
to run about in the park.
7.
to move, roll, or progress from momentum orfrom being hurled, kicked, or otherwise propelled:
The wheel ran over the curb and into the street.
verb (used with object), ran, run, running.
53.
to move or run along (a surface, way, path, etc.):
Every morning he ran the dirt path around thereservoir to keep in condition. She ran her fingersover the keyboard.
54.
to traverse (a distance) in running:
He ran the mile in just over four minutes.
55.
to perform, compete in, or accomplish by or as byrunning:
to run a race; to run an errand.
56.
to go about freely on or in without supervision:
permitting children to run the streets.
57.
to ride or cause to gallop:
to run a horse across a field.
58.
to enter in a race:
He ran his best filly in the Florida Derby.
59.
to bring into a certain state by running:
He ran himself out of breath trying to keep pace.
noun
98.
an act or instance, or a period of running:
a five-minute run before breakfast.
99.
a hurrying to or from some point, as on anerrand:
a run to reach the store before it closes.
100.
a fleeing, especially in great haste; flight:
a run from the police who were hot on his trail.
101.
a running pace:
The boys set out at a run.
102.
an act or instance or a period of moving rapidly,as in a boat or automobile:
a run to shore before the storm.
103.
distance covered, as by racing, running, or duringa trip:
a three-mile run.
104.
an act or instance or a period of traveling ormoving between two places; trip:
a truck on its daily run from farm to market; anonstop run from Louisville to Memphis.
adjective
149.
melted or liquefied:
run butter.
150.
poured in a melted state; run into and cast in amold:
run bronze.
Verb phrases
151.
run across, to meet or find accidentally:
She ran across an old friend at the party. He ranacross her name in the phone book.
152.
run after,
  1. to follow; chase:
    The dog ran after the burglar.
  2. to pursue or court the affections of, especiallyin an aggressive manner:
    He ran after her until she agreed to marry him.
  3. to attempt to become friendly with or part ofthe society of:
    He runs after the country-club set.
153.
run along, to leave; go on one's way:
I have to run along now, but I'll see you tonight.Run along—can't you see I'm busy?
154.
run around,
  1. (often followed by with) to socialize; consortwith:
    She runs around with the strangest people.
  2. to be unfaithful to one's spouse or lover:
    It was common knowledge that he was runningaround.
155.
run away,
  1. to flee or escape; leave a place of confinementor control with the intention of neverreturning:
    He ran away from home three times.
  2. Nautical. to haul on a line by walking orrunning steadily.
156.
run away with,
  1. to go away with, especially to elope with:
    She ran away with a sailor.
  2. to abscond with; steal:
    to run away with some valuable jewelry.
  3. to surpass others in; be outstanding in:
    to run away with academic honors.
  4. to overwhelm; get the better of:
    Sometimes his enthusiasm runs away withhim.
157.
run down,
  1. to strike and fell or overturn, especially todrive a vehicle into (someone):
    to run down an innocent pedestrian.
  2. to pursue until captured; chase:
    The detective swore that he would run downthe criminal.
  3. to peruse; review:
    His eyes ran down the front row and stoppedsuddenly.
  4. to cease operation; stop:
    My watch has run down.
  5. to speak disparagingly of; criticize severely:
    The students were always running down theirmath teacher.
  6. to search out; trace; find:
    to run down information.
  7. Baseball. to tag out (a base runner) betweenbases.
  8. Nautical. to collide with and sink (anothervessel).
  9. Nautical. to sail closely parallel to (a coast).
Idioms
171.
a run for one's money,
  1. close or keen competition:
    The out-of-town team gave us a run for ourmoney.
  2. enjoyment or profit in return for one'sexpense:
    This may not be the best tool kit, but it willgive you a run for your money.
172.
in the long run, in the course of longexperience; in the end:
Retribution will come, in the long run.
173.
in the short run, as an immediate or temporaryoutcome:
Recession may be averted in the short run ifpolicy changes are made now.
174.
on the run,
  1. moving quickly; hurrying about:
    He's so busy, he's always on the run.
  2. while running or in a hurry:
    I usually eat breakfast on the run.
  3. escaping or hiding from the police:
    He was on the run for two years.
175.
run afoul of,
  1. Nautical. to collide with so as to cause damageand entanglement.
  2. to incur or become subject to the wrath or illwill of:
    to run afoul of the law; He argued with hisfather and has run afoul of him ever since.
176.
run for it, to hurry away or flee, especially toevade something:
You had better run for it before anyone elsearrives.
177.
run in place,
  1. to go through the motions of running withoutleaving one's original place.
  2. to exist or work without noticeable change,progress, or improvement.

Yes, exactly. If you say that the clock is running so fast so it could win a race, you have just used the word in an indistinct connotation. Which is precisely what you are doing when you suggest a dog "understanding" what the word "treat" means is the same exact concept as Albert Einstein's "understanding" the theory of relativity, I'm going to go out on a limb and suggest you take another stab at making your point.
 
I don't know which is more disturbing...

The possibility that Carson, a medical doctor, really disputes evolution, or the possibility that he believes in evolution, but is lying to curry favor with the GOP rabble.

Sheesh.
I choose lying. No Medical Doctor could not believe Science.

Richard Dawkins is talking about Carson right now on CNN.
 
Yes, exactly. If you say that the clock is running so fast so it could win a race, you have just used the word in an indistinct connotation. Which is precisely what you are doing when you suggest a dog "understanding" what the word "treat" means is the same exact concept as Albert Einstein's "understanding" the theory of relativity, I'm going to go out on a limb and suggest you take another stab at making your point.

Yet we all know the meaning of the word in that context. No one tries to say...that doesn't work...all 177 aspects of the word run do not apply, therefore, it doesn't apply at all. That's what you're trying to sell...and believe me, I ain't buying.

Where you fail is the elevation, the conflation to "exactness". I never said a dog understanding 165 words was the same as Einstein's understanding of the theory of relativity. There are always degrees to such understanding as we know; few humans understand the theory of relativity.

Dogs feel...and have some limited understanding. They suffer...

No, they are not Einstein. Neither are either of us.
 
Back
Top