New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Ben Carson: The Devil Made Him Do It!!

Not sure how this is a reply to the post quoted. Wishful thinking and selection of outliers by conservative journalists does not provide evidence of a trend.

It provides evidence that a lot of experts in the field are not so quick to dismiss the notion of intelligent design. I mean, for a rational person, there's simply no other explanation. The solar system is some sort of cosmic accident? Matter simply existed infinitely? Human beings are just more intelligent animals? None of that rings resoundingly logical.
 
My understanding is that deficits skyrocketed under Reagan even as Social Security was cut.

Well, it depends on your definition of "skyrocketing." Yes, they went up and quite a bit. But at least is was (mostly) a result of "investment" in the military and infrastructure - not endless entitlements (or economically destructive wars). And it set the stage for Clinton's economic success and the balancing of the budget when he put the brakes on government spending (and even reduced entitlements). Since then we have gone the other way, first with Bush and now Obama. And none of it is resulting in anything resembling the Clinton "boom." This isn't rocket science.
 
If spending growth is not compared to GDP growth it's apples and oranges. It's like insisting that I am a spendthrift if my budget on my 6-figure income exceeds my budget when I was making minimum wage.

There is simply no reason to tie government spending to GDP levels. Either you need the spending on a per capita basis or you don't. Ideally, government spending as a percent of GDP should decline over time as we should all hope the economy grows faster than government does. But even by that measure we are up too high (compared to Clinton's levels):

Screen Shot 2015-11-05 at 6.50.58 AM.png
This isn't rocket science.
 
This is the very definition of sentience. Your quibble is with the dictionary.



Animals and plants aren't alive now?



No it isn't. But that is an ability we verifiably share with chimps, gorillas, whales, dolphins, and supercomputers.



Call it what you want, what gives us our ability to analyze and synthesize information is organized complexity, which other animals share to a smaller degree. The human brain is the most powerful supercomputer in the known universe. But most likely within our lifetimes we will see AI computers that are more complex ... and they will rightly consider their souls more sensitive than ours just as we consider ourselves superior to chimps, etc.

Well it hasn't always been that way. The Buddhists were way out in front of the issue of granting animals "sentience." I'm certainly not opposed to it as I favor animal rights. But it's not like when I was a kid and learned the definition of the word it was being universally applied to all living things. So I grant you most of what you said here but the idea that supercomputers are "sentient" isn't something I'm ready to accept.
 
Saying that our ancestors diverged (morphologically and genetically) from the ancestors of other apes is saying that there is no difference between us and other animals? Doesn't such a statement, on the contrary, imply that there is a difference?

Yes, a difference on the scale of apes and chimpanzees - not between apes and humans. There's something going on with humans that has not been able to catch hold with any other species. What is it? I don't know. But I'm pretty sure you don't either...
 
It provides evidence that a lot of experts in the field are not so quick to dismiss the notion of intelligent design. I mean, for a rational person, there's simply no other explanation. The solar system is some sort of cosmic accident? Matter simply existed infinitely? Human beings are just more intelligent animals? None of that rings resoundingly logical.

Few people will tell you that matter existed infinitely. I believe it began with the Big Bang. The rest of it seems quite plausible, much more than an unexplained intelligence which did nothing to make it look like it wasn't an accident.
 
Well, it depends on your definition of "skyrocketing." Yes, they went up and quite a bit. But at least is was (mostly) a result of "investment" in the military and infrastructure - not endless entitlements (or economically destructive wars). And it set the stage for Clinton's economic success and the balancing of the budget when he put the brakes on government spending (and even reduced entitlements). Since then we have gone the other way, first with Bush and now Obama. And none of it is resulting in anything resembling the Clinton "boom." This isn't rocket science.

It was mostly the result of the precipitous drop in revenue. Spending on the military commits the nation to future wars. Clinton's budget cuts paved the way for a crash AND swept the rug out from under the poor. Clinton presided over the first jobless recovery. "Full employment" in the post-Reagan era would've been considered recession conditions when Eisenhower was president (and income tax rates were much higher).
 
There is simply no reason to tie government spending to GDP levels. Either you need the spending on a per capita basis or you don't. Ideally, government spending as a percent of GDP should decline over time as we should all hope the economy grows faster than government does. But even by that measure we are up too high (compared to Clinton's levels):

View attachment 28505
This isn't rocket science.

Well, we don't NEED to have a good economy, but if the government spends enough, a lot of us will be better off. BTW Obama increased spending less as a percentage than any president since Eisenhower.
 
Yes, a difference on the scale of apes and chimpanzees - not between apes and humans. There's something going on with humans that has not been able to catch hold with any other species. What is it? I don't know. But I'm pretty sure you don't either...

Chimpanzees and humans are both apes. The difference is on the same continuum that separates apes from monkeys. In a word: intelligence.
 
Few people will tell you that matter existed infinitely. I believe it began with the Big Bang. The rest of it seems quite plausible, much more than an unexplained intelligence which did nothing to make it look like it wasn't an accident.

But what caused the "Big Bang" then? What existed before it occurred? Nothing? Anything? Bueller?
 
Well, we don't NEED to have a good economy, but if the government spends enough, a lot of us will be better off. BTW Obama increased spending less as a percentage than any president since Eisenhower.

A) Not really. The government is spending more than it ever has:

http://www.people-press.org/2015/03...n-have-done-little-to-help-middle-class-poor/

B) So what - Bush exploded spending and then Obama's first year was bloated even further by hundreds of billions more spending in "stimulus." We're still spending more on real a per capita basis than ever before (read: too much):

Screen Shot 2015-11-05 at 9.05.02 AM.png
And it hasn't done a thing (see link above). It's over "johnny" - we shot our wad on big government and it didn't work. Now we have to get busy paying off the debt. That means cutting spending and increasing tax revenues (and in a sub 2% GDP growth environment, that doesn't mean raising tax rates - it means getting the economy growing again. Then we can start raising tax rates in a growth environment (like Clinton did) and get the budget balanced.
 
Chimpanzees and humans are both apes. The difference is on the same continuum that separates apes from monkeys. In a word: intelligence.

Right. We just "lucked out" in the genetic lottery. And every other species lost? That is absurd!
 
Right. We just "lucked out" in the genetic lottery. And every other species lost? That is absurd!

Humans "won" the brain lottery.

Other species won different lotteries...Swimming, sonar, running, climbing, hearing, seeing. Flying. There's one humans didn't win.

Reminds me of the old joke...

Seems that God was just about done creating the universe. The Lord had a couple of leftovers in his bag of creations, so he stopped by to visit Adam and Eve in the Garden. He told the couple that one of the things he had to give away was the ability to urinate while standing up. "It can be very handy," God explained to Adam and Eve. "Would either of you like that ability?"

Adam popped a cork. He jumped up and begged, "Oh, give that to me! It seems the sort of thing a man should be able to do. Please, Lord, let me have that ability. I would be forever grateful."

Eve just smiled and shook her head at Adam's display. She told God that if Adam really wanted it so badly, then she really wouldn't mind if he were the one given the ability to urinate while standing up.

And so, the Lord gave Adam the ability to urinate while standing up. Then, He looked back into his bag of leftover gifts. "Now, what have we here? Oh, yes, multiple orgasms..."

http://www.ebaumsworld.com/jokes/read/81780563/
 
It was mostly the result of the precipitous drop in revenue. Spending on the military commits the nation to future wars. Clinton's budget cuts paved the way for a crash AND swept the rug out from under the poor. Clinton presided over the first jobless recovery. "Full employment" in the post-Reagan era would've been considered recession conditions when Eisenhower was president (and income tax rates were much higher).

That is absurd! Clinton's economy was a job creating super boom. LFPR hit all time highs and it was the last time we had a sustained rise in real median incomes. That's the economic holy grail right there buddy. You really need to get out more and look around. Reality is no longer supporting the (tired) progressive (anti-capitalist) memes...
 
Hey Leroy, since you know so much about Carson's past, tell us what made Slick molest/rape those women___________________GO.
 
But what caused the "Big Bang" then? What existed before it occurred? Nothing? Anything? Bueller?

"Before it occurred" doesn't refer to anything since the Big Bang was the beginning of time. I don't know what caused the singularity, but the presumption that it must have a cause is based on ordinary experience of time and causality ... you should be careful because science has shown that ordinary experience has a tendency to break down when discussing these sorts of liminal areas.

Of course, saying that God caused it is completely useless as an answer, since then you have to explain what caused God. Or else explain why the singularity needs a cause, but God does not.
 
A) Not really. The government is spending more than it ever has:

http://www.people-press.org/2015/03...n-have-done-little-to-help-middle-class-poor/

B) So what - Bush exploded spending and then Obama's first year was bloated even further by hundreds of billions more spending in "stimulus." We're still spending more on real a per capita basis than ever before (read: too much):

View attachment 28507
And it hasn't done a thing (see link above). It's over "johnny" - we shot our wad on big government and it didn't work. Now we have to get busy paying off the debt. That means cutting spending and increasing tax revenues (and in a sub 2% GDP growth environment, that doesn't mean raising tax rates - it means getting the economy growing again. Then we can start raising tax rates in a growth environment (like Clinton did) and get the budget balanced.

Maybe the problem with the stimulus was that it wasn't big enough. Good luck getting the economy growing again by cutting spending. How'd that work out for Europe?
 
That is absurd! Clinton's economy was a job creating super boom. LFPR hit all time highs and it was the last time we had a sustained rise in real median incomes. That's the economic holy grail right there buddy. You really need to get out more and look around. Reality is no longer supporting the (tired) progressive (anti-capitalist) memes...

The dot.com explosion was the "job creating super boom." NAFTA helped too. Balancing the budget helped prevent that boom from sending us down the path to runaway inflation, but it did so by reducing aggregate demand and therefore lassoing the bull market.
 
"Before it occurred" doesn't refer to anything since the Big Bang was the beginning of time. I don't know what caused the singularity, but the presumption that it must have a cause is based on ordinary experience of time and causality ... you should be careful because science has shown that ordinary experience has a tendency to break down when discussing these sorts of liminal areas.

Of course, saying that God caused it is completely useless as an answer, since then you have to explain what caused God. Or else explain why the singularity needs a cause, but God does not.

That sounds like a pseudo-intellectual navel gazer's way of suggesting we not ask questions for which science doesn't have answers because, well, it just causes all sorts of problems with the logic behind our theories. And the fact is that there's a lot of unanswerable questions about time and space and, well, evolution. Yes, there's a little "Deus ex Machina" in assuming a role for a supreme being in all this, but the idea that matter and the universe just, well, happened, is an unsatisfying argument. If we are allowed the luxury of existential thought, it will invariably lead to dead ends that must be filled in with guesses. And your guess is as good as mine when it comes to these holes in the "theory of everything." Do I think God exists? Yeah, I guess I do because I think it highly unlikely that this complex universe and our biodiverse spot in it is all just some big cosmic "happening." But I certainly don't ascribe to any (organized) religious notion of what God is, how He influences and acts upon our current existence and what we must do to be worthy of "Heaven." I suspect the Creator just, well, created the universe (perhaps one of many) and that what happens here is completely free of His influence. And everybody, even Hitler and Pol Pot, ends up in Heaven (there is no hell) and their actions here on earth determines where their spot is in relation to the creator. The worse a dirt bag you were the farther away you are. I certainly don't expect to sit on His shoulder but I don't think I will be banished to hell for not pledging my fealty to some organized religion's version of how to behave or believe here on earth. FWIW...
 
Maybe the problem with the stimulus was that it wasn't big enough. Good luck getting the economy growing again by cutting spending. How'd that work out for Europe?

Europe had a sclerotic economy before the recession. If that is true (it just wasn't "big" enough) then you need to explain why Japan has been unable to get out of their multi-decade slump despite ever increasing rounds of fiscal and monetary "stimulus."

Maybe the problem is we've made our economy too hamstrung with over regulation and government spending to ever recover no matter how much "stimulus" we try. The fact is that all "stimulus" does is borrow growth from the future and we've done so much of that we've gotten all there is to get. There's too much debt associated with that situation and we need to have the economic slump that will clear all the bad paper off the books and let the unworthy enterprises fail, and get the price of money corrected so capitalism can once more begin an organic growth phase. Anyone arguing for more of what hasn't worked to date is really either unable to learn from mistakes or actively seeking to undermine our current economic and government system.
 
Back
Top