Lukey
Senator
Because it's important, and our resident Keynesian "expert" seems determined to ignore it. The problem with the "logic" behind the Keynesian suggestion that government spending should step into the void when the economy slows down. This is based on a completely clueless "understanding" of how the economy works.
The fact is that the economy is not a monolithic jumble of production and income, but rather a distinctly segmented set of sectors with different inputs and outputs and contributions to prosperity. The government sector is NOT a substitute for private economic activity. And frankly, neither is the non-profit sector. Both the government and non-profit sectors are consuming wealth created in the private sector. And even in the private sector, some activities, like mining, refining, agriculture and manufacturing, contribute way more to the strength of the overall economy than services (like insurance, public accounting and, yes, legal services). Without a robust (and growing) "production" component, your economy's long term potential output is actually shrinking (think of it as "running on empty"), even if the overall GDP (which includes all the other "non-productive" sectors) is growing.
The fact of the matter is that most of the US "growth" the lefties are touting is health care spending (and other wonderful "services" like banking and insurance):
While industry is stagnating and agriculture declining. So the fact is that government spending is heavily aimed at the "non-profit" industries of local government (social welfare), education, and health care "services," which means the idea that it somehow is not only a replacement for, but some ways even superior to, private sector production, is an absurdity that should be so obvious that it isn't even up for debate. And so the fact that I have to keep debating this subject with them calls into question either their economic acumen, their sanity, their questionable motivations, or all three.
Government spending is taken from the private sector (in taxes) regardless if it is debt financed or current revenues. Non-profits get the vast majority (yes, some is fee income but not even half - maybe a third, if we're lucky) and the rest comes from government (taxation again) or private donations (not all that different from taxation except that it is voluntary). So the facile argument that a situation such as Ireland's reduced government spending, which is now engendering just the very kind of private sector investment in production:
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/mar/05/ireland-attracts-soaring-level-of-us-investment
http://www.npr.org/sections/paralle...-green-as-they-set-up-shop-in-low-tax-ireland
https://www.equities.com/news/why-are-so-many-health-care-companies-moving-to-ireland
That will pay off in increasing jobs, wealth and tax revenues (that 7% growth rate) and which will end up making the Irish economy so much more long term viable than the socialist paradises the left gushes about, which is where the production in all those links is fleeing, is somehow to be avoided in favor of growing government, soaring unproductive (public sector) investment and a shrinking ability to fund it all, is so wrong on so many fronts, that I really have to say I don't feel the need to keep revisiting these completely juvenile nonsensical economic "analyses" the lefties keep throwing up all over these boards. It really isn't rocket science, but it is slightly more complex than they suggest it is (i.e. that all economic activities are equally good). The idea that a million dollars spent on additional health care services for the indigent is the equivalent of Tony Beets paying a million $ for a gold mining dredge (I'm watching Gold Rush right now) is so incredibly stupid that anyone suggesting it should be immediately rendered unserious as an economic poster here, there, or anywhere...
The fact is that the economy is not a monolithic jumble of production and income, but rather a distinctly segmented set of sectors with different inputs and outputs and contributions to prosperity. The government sector is NOT a substitute for private economic activity. And frankly, neither is the non-profit sector. Both the government and non-profit sectors are consuming wealth created in the private sector. And even in the private sector, some activities, like mining, refining, agriculture and manufacturing, contribute way more to the strength of the overall economy than services (like insurance, public accounting and, yes, legal services). Without a robust (and growing) "production" component, your economy's long term potential output is actually shrinking (think of it as "running on empty"), even if the overall GDP (which includes all the other "non-productive" sectors) is growing.
The fact of the matter is that most of the US "growth" the lefties are touting is health care spending (and other wonderful "services" like banking and insurance):
While industry is stagnating and agriculture declining. So the fact is that government spending is heavily aimed at the "non-profit" industries of local government (social welfare), education, and health care "services," which means the idea that it somehow is not only a replacement for, but some ways even superior to, private sector production, is an absurdity that should be so obvious that it isn't even up for debate. And so the fact that I have to keep debating this subject with them calls into question either their economic acumen, their sanity, their questionable motivations, or all three.
Government spending is taken from the private sector (in taxes) regardless if it is debt financed or current revenues. Non-profits get the vast majority (yes, some is fee income but not even half - maybe a third, if we're lucky) and the rest comes from government (taxation again) or private donations (not all that different from taxation except that it is voluntary). So the facile argument that a situation such as Ireland's reduced government spending, which is now engendering just the very kind of private sector investment in production:
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/mar/05/ireland-attracts-soaring-level-of-us-investment
http://www.npr.org/sections/paralle...-green-as-they-set-up-shop-in-low-tax-ireland
https://www.equities.com/news/why-are-so-many-health-care-companies-moving-to-ireland
That will pay off in increasing jobs, wealth and tax revenues (that 7% growth rate) and which will end up making the Irish economy so much more long term viable than the socialist paradises the left gushes about, which is where the production in all those links is fleeing, is somehow to be avoided in favor of growing government, soaring unproductive (public sector) investment and a shrinking ability to fund it all, is so wrong on so many fronts, that I really have to say I don't feel the need to keep revisiting these completely juvenile nonsensical economic "analyses" the lefties keep throwing up all over these boards. It really isn't rocket science, but it is slightly more complex than they suggest it is (i.e. that all economic activities are equally good). The idea that a million dollars spent on additional health care services for the indigent is the equivalent of Tony Beets paying a million $ for a gold mining dredge (I'm watching Gold Rush right now) is so incredibly stupid that anyone suggesting it should be immediately rendered unserious as an economic poster here, there, or anywhere...