New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Bringing this up top...

Lukey

Senator
Because it's important, and our resident Keynesian "expert" seems determined to ignore it. The problem with the "logic" behind the Keynesian suggestion that government spending should step into the void when the economy slows down. This is based on a completely clueless "understanding" of how the economy works.

The fact is that the economy is not a monolithic jumble of production and income, but rather a distinctly segmented set of sectors with different inputs and outputs and contributions to prosperity. The government sector is NOT a substitute for private economic activity. And frankly, neither is the non-profit sector. Both the government and non-profit sectors are consuming wealth created in the private sector. And even in the private sector, some activities, like mining, refining, agriculture and manufacturing, contribute way more to the strength of the overall economy than services (like insurance, public accounting and, yes, legal services). Without a robust (and growing) "production" component, your economy's long term potential output is actually shrinking (think of it as "running on empty"), even if the overall GDP (which includes all the other "non-productive" sectors) is growing.

The fact of the matter is that most of the US "growth" the lefties are touting is health care spending (and other wonderful "services" like banking and insurance):

screen-shot-2016-03-10-at-3-07-18-pm-png.30317


While industry is stagnating and agriculture declining. So the fact is that government spending is heavily aimed at the "non-profit" industries of local government (social welfare), education, and health care "services," which means the idea that it somehow is not only a replacement for, but some ways even superior to, private sector production, is an absurdity that should be so obvious that it isn't even up for debate. And so the fact that I have to keep debating this subject with them calls into question either their economic acumen, their sanity, their questionable motivations, or all three.

Government spending is taken from the private sector (in taxes) regardless if it is debt financed or current revenues. Non-profits get the vast majority (yes, some is fee income but not even half - maybe a third, if we're lucky) and the rest comes from government (taxation again) or private donations (not all that different from taxation except that it is voluntary). So the facile argument that a situation such as Ireland's reduced government spending, which is now engendering just the very kind of private sector investment in production:

http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/mar/05/ireland-attracts-soaring-level-of-us-investment

http://www.npr.org/sections/paralle...-green-as-they-set-up-shop-in-low-tax-ireland

https://www.equities.com/news/why-are-so-many-health-care-companies-moving-to-ireland

That will pay off in increasing jobs, wealth and tax revenues (that 7% growth rate) and which will end up making the Irish economy so much more long term viable than the socialist paradises the left gushes about, which is where the production in all those links is fleeing, is somehow to be avoided in favor of growing government, soaring unproductive (public sector) investment and a shrinking ability to fund it all, is so wrong on so many fronts, that I really have to say I don't feel the need to keep revisiting these completely juvenile nonsensical economic "analyses" the lefties keep throwing up all over these boards. It really isn't rocket science, but it is slightly more complex than they suggest it is (i.e. that all economic activities are equally good). The idea that a million dollars spent on additional health care services for the indigent is the equivalent of Tony Beets paying a million $ for a gold mining dredge (I'm watching Gold Rush right now) is so incredibly stupid that anyone suggesting it should be immediately rendered unserious as an economic poster here, there, or anywhere...
 
the damnest part, always hearing how Social Security is going BROKE, but, never hear Welfare or now ΘbamaCare is..............
 
the damnest part, always hearing how Social Security is going BROKE, but, never hear Welfare or now ΘbamaCare is..............

That's because SS has a dedicated revenue stream so it's "self funded" (allegedly). The other stuff is just general discretionary spending so when its costs come in way more than any revenue sources included in the legislation, it just gets added to the deficit. And we wonder why we're $20 trillion in debt, eh? And the Keynesians think we should be borrowing and spending even more (as our sustainable economic activities become less and less of our economy). It's the kind of scam that they think businesses do all the time (and should be regulated out of business and/or thrown in jail. But when their progressive pols do it it's just (government) business as usual. The ends justify the means...
 
The idea that a million dollars spent on additional health care services for the indigent is the equivalent of Tony Beets paying a million $ for a gold mining dredge (I'm watching Gold Rush right now) is so incredibly stupid that anyone suggesting it should be immediately rendered unserious as an economic poster here, there, or anywhere...
Are we talking about this greed head?:p
"Tony Beets net worth and salary: Tony Beets is a Canadian miner and reality television personality who has a net worth of $15 million dollars. Born in Wijdenes, Netherlands, Tony Beets worked for his family for many years, and then relocated to Canada to seek better career opportunities"
http://www.celebritynetworth.com/richest-businessmen/business-executives/tony-beets-net-worth/
Gold, and those who hoard and control it, are not solutions. It is the prime reason for endless war and eternal debt, and a big part of the reason why the indigent need health care.
 
Are we talking about this greed head?:p
"Tony Beets net worth and salary: Tony Beets is a Canadian miner and reality television personality who has a net worth of $15 million dollars. Born in Wijdenes, Netherlands, Tony Beets worked for his family for many years, and then relocated to Canada to seek better career opportunities"
http://www.celebritynetworth.com/richest-businessmen/business-executives/tony-beets-net-worth/
Gold, and those who hoard and control it, are not solutions. It is the prime reason for endless war and eternal debt, and a big part of the reason why the indigent need health care.

Haha! Greedhead - good one. Yes, he is "greedy" but so is lovable Parker Schnable and the pious Hoffmans. Entrepreneurs possess the drive to succeed financially - which is a form of greed. The real irony here is how many of the "establishment" PJ lefties share your disdain for all profit seekers, while dishonestly claiming they aren't, like you, a communist.

But the fact is I was right. You simply cannot replace private sector economic activity with government spending. The very notion is absurd, and makes "sense" only through the purposeful failure to distinguish between fully private economic activity (which pays all the bills for government and most of the bills for non-profits, INCLUDING the taxes paid by the employees of government and non-profits) and public spending. Spending hundreds of thousands of dollars treating the diabetes of a morbidly obese welfare recipient counts exactly the same in GDP as spending the same sum on opening a new business. To the extent it is counted identically in the GDP calculation constitutes an illusion of economic activity. That's the profound fallacy in the progressive economic stance, which permits Keynesian Klowns to foolishly suggest that our recent economic performance is superior to Ireland's.

Keynesian government "stimulus" is exactly what has been analogized so well as "taking bucket fulls of water from one end of the pool and dumping it in the other. It is the economic equivalent of "kissing your sister" (hmmmm, do you think that's why it appeals so much to the left?).
 
But the fact is I was right. You simply cannot replace private sector economic activity with government spending. The very notion is absurd, and makes "sense" only through the purposeful failure to distinguish between fully private economic activity (which pays all the bills for government and most of the bills for non-profits, INCLUDING the taxes paid by the employees of government and non-profits) and public spending
Except your vaunted private sector would not have the security infrastructure to exist without government, no courts, cops, or compliant politicians to bribe. It is difficult for me to imagine anyone truly believes the free market is a "natural" phenomenon existing independently of government since it is only through government sponsored rules and regulations that an efficient market can function in. Without rules all you damn capitalists would spend all your time guarding your treasures with no minutes left over competing. btw, do you know the capitalist definition of "competition?" It's when all market players "compete" to create the first monopoly.;)
 
Except your vaunted private sector would not have the security infrastructure to exist without government, no courts, cops, or compliant politicians to bribe. It is difficult for me to imagine anyone truly believes the free market is a "natural" phenomenon existing independently of government since it is only through government sponsored rules and regulations that an efficient market can function in. Without rules all you damn capitalists would spend all your time guarding your treasures with no minutes left over competing. btw, do you know the capitalist definition of "competition?" It's when all market players "compete" to create the first monopoly.;)

Well, of course, police and courts are (Constitutionally) authorized legitimate government activities. But why should we let that get in the way of a good left wing canard, eh? "Free markets" don't require anarchy (in fact quite the opposite). They simply require as much transparency as possible and low barriers to entry. Of course, that's why the anti-capitalists in the Communist, I mean Democratic party support ever more regulation and government interference in the markets. After all, it's not like they are interested in capitalism succeeding, right?
 
Free markets" don't require anarchy (in fact quite the opposite). They simply require as much transparency as possible and low barriers to entry
Are you referring to free markets with numerous buyers and sellers, one where consumers pay the lowest price for the most goods, one with perfect transparency? A free market of perfect competition where every seller is a price taker, not a price maker? Seriously?? Why do you think every civilization for the last five thousand years has felt it necessary to warn against the political influence of their merchant class?
mother_child.jpg

:rolleyes:
 
Are you referring to free markets with numerous buyers and sellers, one where consumers pay the lowest price for the most goods, one with perfect transparency? A free market of perfect competition where every seller is a price taker, not a price maker? Seriously?? Why do you think every civilization for the last five thousand years has felt it necessary to warn against the political influence of their merchant class?
mother_child.jpg

:rolleyes:

You mean why have the collectivists in every civilization for the last five thousand years have felt it necessary to demonize the merchant class in a sustained attempt to destroy capitalism?
 
You mean why have the collectivists in every civilization for the last five thousand years have felt it necessary to demonize the merchant class in a sustained attempt to destroy capitalism?
Possibly, because the merchant class has shown itself willing to support and profit from every kind of inhuman political establishment that has ever existed:

"In the past, citizens who led and participated in this country's social justice movements faced steep concentrations of power and overcame them.

"A brief look at American history is instructive today.

"Common themes occur from the Revolution of 1776 against King George III's empire to the anti-slavery drives and women's suffrage movements of the 19th century, to the farmers' revolt against the large banks and railroads that began in 1887, and on to the trade union, civil rights, environmental and consumer protection initiatives of the 20th century, culminating in the demands for equity by Americans who are discriminated against due to their race, gender, tribal status, class, disability or sexual preference.

"All these movements took on excessive power, pressed for relinquishment or sharing of that power despite vigorous opposition by elements of the dominant business community.

http://www.greens.org/s-r/23/23-02.html

"Many years were lost to the resolutions of these injustices before justice began to prevail and corporate power receded. However, when citizens won, and Tory merchants, cotton slave holders and corporations were compelled to share that power with the people they oppressed or excluded,

"America was a better place for it.

"America became more beautiful.

"Moreover, the companies behaved better and prospered more."
 
Because it's important, and our resident Keynesian "expert" seems determined to ignore it....

Something tells me you are not exactly conversant with Keynesian theory.

The theory basically goes like this, and this a bit of a simplification, but I just hope it encourages you to actually discover what Keynesian theory really is:

In Keynes' theory, one person's spending goes towards another person's earnings, and when that person spends his or her earnings, he or she is, in effect, supporting another person's earnings. This cycle continues on and helps support a normal, functioning economy. When the Great Depression hit, people's natural reaction was to hoard their money. Under Keynes' theory, this stopped the circular flow of money, keeping the economy at a standstill.

Keynes' solution to this poor economic state was to "prime the pump." He argued that the government should step in to increase spending, either by increasing the money supply or by actually buying things itself. During the Great Depression, however, this was not a popular solution. It is said, however, that the massive defense spending that United States president Franklin Delano Roosevelt initiated helped revive the U.S. economy.
​

A large portion of Government spending goes to the private sector, that's why in a depressed economy the government should step in and increase economic activity with money that is necessarily borrowed, and pay that debt down during good economic times.

http://www.wisegeek.org/what-is-keynesian-economics.htm

It works great as long as we don't forget to pay the debt down when we get the chance
 
Something tells me you are not exactly conversant with Keynesian theory.

The theory basically goes like this, and this a bit of a simplification, but I just hope it encourages you to actually discover what Keynesian theory really is:

In Keynes' theory, one person's spending goes towards another person's earnings, and when that person spends his or her earnings, he or she is, in effect, supporting another person's earnings. This cycle continues on and helps support a normal, functioning economy. When the Great Depression hit, people's natural reaction was to hoard their money. Under Keynes' theory, this stopped the circular flow of money, keeping the economy at a standstill.

Keynes' solution to this poor economic state was to "prime the pump." He argued that the government should step in to increase spending, either by increasing the money supply or by actually buying things itself. During the Great Depression, however, this was not a popular solution. It is said, however, that the massive defense spending that United States president Franklin Delano Roosevelt initiated helped revive the U.S. economy.
​

A large portion of Government spending goes to the private sector, that's why in a depressed economy the government should step in and increase economic activity with money that is necessarily borrowed, and pay that debt down during good economic times.

http://www.wisegeek.org/what-is-keynesian-economics.htm

It works great as long as we don't forget to pay the debt down when we get the chance

That's not how it's being done now. We have to deal with the Keynesianism we have, not the Keynesianism we would like to see. The problem is, pols are really good at borrowing and spending, but not so great at raising taxes to pay it down. And the simple fact is that government spending, always and everywhere, is removed from the private sector. So the idea that taking money from the private sector and spending it to "stimulate" the private sector is about as stupid a concept as any economist has ever come up with. Keynes was an ardent anti-capitalist with disdain for markets so the fact that it doesn't work should come as no surprise.
 
That's not how it's being done now. We have to deal with the Keynesianism we have, not the Keynesianism we would like to see. The problem is, pols are really good at borrowing and spending, but not so great at raising taxes to pay it down. And the simple fact is that government spending, always and everywhere, is removed from the private sector. So the idea that taking money from the private sector and spending it to "stimulate" the private sector is about as stupid a concept as any economist has ever come up with. Keynes was an ardent anti-capitalist with disdain for markets so the fact that it doesn't work should come as no surprise.

Some of that is true, and some not so much. You're right about politicians, at least in my view, but we just have to hold their feet to the fire.

Sadly, your idea that government spending is always and everywhere removed from the private sector doesn't wash. Where do you think government gets its paper and paperclips? Government doesn't manufacture them itself, rather buying them from the private sector. Same with practically anything government does. It's employees even go out in the private sector and spend the money they receive from our government quite freely.

And Keynes was mainly interested in mitigating the boom and bust cycle of laissez-faire capitalism using government policy. A goal I surely agree with.
 
Possibly, because the merchant class has shown itself willing to support and profit from every kind of inhuman political establishment that has ever existed:

"In the past, citizens who led and participated in this country's social justice movements faced steep concentrations of power and overcame them.

"A brief look at American history is instructive today.

"Common themes occur from the Revolution of 1776 against King George III's empire to the anti-slavery drives and women's suffrage movements of the 19th century, to the farmers' revolt against the large banks and railroads that began in 1887, and on to the trade union, civil rights, environmental and consumer protection initiatives of the 20th century, culminating in the demands for equity by Americans who are discriminated against due to their race, gender, tribal status, class, disability or sexual preference.

"All these movements took on excessive power, pressed for relinquishment or sharing of that power despite vigorous opposition by elements of the dominant business community.

http://www.greens.org/s-r/23/23-02.html

"Many years were lost to the resolutions of these injustices before justice began to prevail and corporate power receded. However, when citizens won, and Tory merchants, cotton slave holders and corporations were compelled to share that power with the people they oppressed or excluded,

"America was a better place for it.

"America became more beautiful.

"Moreover, the companies behaved better and prospered more."
It is unarguable that nation-states (and governments in general) have, by far, been the greatest abusers of humanity. Nonetheless, the statists continue, undeterred, vilifying private industry and merchants - to the exclusion of the worst offenders.

Unsurprising.
 
It is unarguable that nation-states (and governments in general) have, by far, been the greatest abusers of humanity. Nonetheless, the statists continue, undeterred, vilifying private industry and merchants - to the exclusion of the worst offenders.

Unsurprising.
Nation states working at the behest of their richest merchants and manufacturers have been responsible for the majority of human rights abuses since the fall of man. It's all about those $$$, remember?
 
Some of that is true, and some not so much. You're right about politicians, at least in my view, but we just have to hold their feet to the fire.

Sadly, your idea that government spending is always and everywhere removed from the private sector doesn't wash. Where do you think government gets its paper and paperclips? Government doesn't manufacture them itself, rather buying them from the private sector. Same with practically anything government does. It's employees even go out in the private sector and spend the money they receive from our government quite freely.

And Keynes was mainly interested in mitigating the boom and bust cycle of laissez-faire capitalism using government policy. A goal I surely agree with.

Where do you think the government gets the money to pay for its paper and paperclips? They take the money from the private sector and return it to the private sector. It's like pulling a bucket out of one end of a pool and dumping it in the other end. This is a basic flaw of Keynesian theory - the focus on what is seen and a complete disregard of what is not seen:

http://bastiat.org/en/twisatwins.html

As for mitigating the "boom/bust cycle" - I'm not sure permanent stagnation is a better course...
 
Where does the private sector get its money?

The old fashioned way - it earns it. By creating things of value. At least that was how it used to work before big government crowded out production and turned our money into pieces of confetti with denominations on them. Now shameless con men can simply conjure it out of thin air.
 
The old fashioned way - it earns it. By creating things of value. At least that was how it used to work before big government crowded out production and turned our money into pieces of confetti with denominations on them. Now shameless con men can simply conjure it out of thin air.
Without government, there is no stable money supply, hence no potential for profits, hence no big house, fast cars, or capital gains, right?
 
Back
Top