New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Bush's Third Term

"marvin"....basic questions

1. Is Obama a "Bush 3rd term"...or not?

2. If not...why don't you defend Bush in comparison to Obama?

3. If so....what do you object to that Obama is doing that you also objected to Bush doing?


((And no, I don't expect direct answers....since it would put you in a contradictory position. But fun to ask. :) ))

LOL. I've long referred to Obama as "black George Bush". The fact that you're just now waking up to it is hilarious. You may have to turn in your Obama Human Shield card...
 
Not exactly a deep thought for you. Summarizing an administration as "good" or "bad" is something a lot of people here do, but I expect a little more from you.

OK, I summarize FDR's presidency as the best in American history. Is that better?
 
well, it's merely the good cop/bad cop routine crystallizing into reality for all to see dude.

As a long time critic of the "Big Dog" I see it as little more than a continuation of the tag teaming that started in many ways, with him and the DLC/Third Way BS he was a founding member of.

Let's not forget that if not for the Leminsky affair, BC had a plan for SS too that scandal derailed.

I'm a little more forgiving of Clinton for three reasons. First, his "triangulation" is easier to forgive as a strategy of desperation in the wake of three straight Republican election victories, including two where the Democrats weren't really even competitive. Obama, by comparison, took office in the wake of Republicans only winning the popular vote once in the prior four elections (and that by an extremely narrow margin), so such desperate moving to the right makes less sense as a strategic necessity. Second, Clinton had more of a fighting spirit than Obama. He used the veto and executive orders more aggressively, and shut the government down a couple times, in his standoffs with Republicans. Obama's idea of a standoff is to open by offering his opponents 90% of what they want and then let them talk him out of most of the remaining 10%. Third, the Clinton era was one of spectacular, across-the-board improvement. Poverty fell, record deficits turned to record surpluses, incomes improved at all levels, social problems receded, etc. Even if you think things would have been even better without the "Third Way BS," it's hard to argue with that kind of success.
 
You know, IF Obama had repealed the Patriot Act - signed an executive order immediately halting warantless wiretapping, VETOED NDAA, Dissolved Homeland Security Gestapo, and halted arming/financing al-quada rebels in Syria/Libya, I would have whole heartedly endorsed Obama over the McCain/BUSH cabal.

Never happened before, but, at least this once, I fully agree with you.
 
ai.chzbgr.com_completestore_12_9_26_MfEbcvWhG0GLJsygtc6b_w2.jpg

attachment.php
 
well, I can't disagre with any of that, other than perhaps the success issues raised on the cause front. http://www.google.com/search?q=clinton+success&sitesearch=cepr.net

I also won't quibble with the other distinctions of the style kind.

The only point I was trying to make was the similarities they share of the big biz/etc v little guy kind. The origin of the DLC/Third Way crap had to do with cutting the dem dependency on labor unions and other traditional dem sources of campaign dough, and to tap the money wells of say, those bankers that have largely gotten off scott free.

BC and BHO are two different men that operated on two different political landscapes and occupants of that to some degree. The issues of their personal governing styles, etc, take a back seat to their shared goals as the "good cops" imo, which are certainly more beneficial to the masses than the alternative, but less so than the dems our fathers voted for.

ANd one must consider as well, that BC's admin was the maiden voyage to the land of riches for the newly minted "New Dems", and given the many and varied failures of the Bush admin, "No drama" Obama was typecasted perfectly to further their shared agenda. We could of course brainstorm and come up with other examples of this besides SS now being on the chopping block, which will only support the only point I was making -- the good cops try to do for their monied masters as much as the political realities (like reelection possibilities) and legacy considerations will allow, as opposed to the rightingnuts (bad cops) who shamelessly let us know who is buttering their bread.
 
Obama has made rather remarkable progress, despite rather overwhelming and proximate political odds. Therefore, Obama is a genuine progressive's progressive. One of the especial ways he's accomplished all this, is by being willing to piss off those to his left.

His left has been dreaming of the "perfect", ever since FDR. Obama's at least brought them nearer to their unrealistic and navel-contemplative dream, than anyone since FDR.
 
Michael Lind, a supposed former neocon, fails to mention Bush's illegal invasion of Iraq and the torture regimen. yet suggests Obama did the same? I don't think so. and what's this, "Both involved the country in a foreign war with a Muslim nation.?" I don't get that. does he mean Libya?

the article wasn't as fascinating as you seem to think it was. heck, you write more in depth than this Lind guy (who wrote a book calling Vietnam the necessary war).
 
OK, I summarize FDR's presidency as the best in American history. Is that better?


No, not really. To do so, you would have to gloss over, for example, FDR's interment of Japanese-Americans based on nothing other than ethnicity as if it were a minor point. That's pretty damning, don't you think?
 
To the best of my knowledge, being "the best" does not equal being perfect. Unless we elect a God as our President, I doubt that we'll ever have one who achieves perfection.

No President starts with a clean slate. Instead, they inherit the situation that exists at the time when they are elected. They all make mistakes, since they are often put in the position of making decisions with inadequate information to predict with absolute certainty the final results of those decisions.

I would suggest that the only valid means of ranking past Presidents is to compare the results of their tenure, rather than comparing them to an ideal standard. Barack Obama is not a perfect President. That said, to compare his tenure thus far with that of his predecessor is patently absurd. Barack Obama is no George W. Bush -- and I thank God for that.
 
No, not really. To do so, you would have to gloss over, for example, FDR's interment of Japanese-Americans based on nothing other than ethnicity as if it were a minor point. That's pretty damning, don't you think?

That is really stretching back,Zam! We were in a war with a country that attacked us.You have no idea the feelings we had against the Japanese.

Sure cinch you guys are on the losing side when you go back 70 years.

We only have to go back 5 or 6,to remind you of how lousy your party is!
 
Michael Lind, a supposed former neocon, fails to mention Bush's illegal invasion of Iraq and the torture regimen. yet suggests Obama did the same? I don't think so. and what's this, "Both involved the country in a foreign war with a Muslim nation.?" I don't get that. does he mean Libya?

I agree, Julie. That comparison would have to work it's way up to tenuous, IMO.

who wrote a book calling Vietnam the necessary war

Doesn't seem to be his strong suit. He moved straight from college to Washington. Didn't want to serve in the military under Reagan or Bush1, I guess. Another neocon chickenhawk for whom war is an abstract while he has "better things to do"....like Cheney.

His other titles look more worthwhile than his war critiques.
 
No MaryAnne. Arkady and I got off on a tangent about FDR. That's what we were discussing. If you go back and review the thread you'll see that.
 
To the best of my knowledge, being "the best" does not equal being perfect. Unless we elect a God as our President, I doubt that we'll ever have one who achieves perfection.

No President starts with a clean slate. Instead, they inherit the situation that exists at the time when they are elected. They all make mistakes, since they are often put in the position of making decisions with inadequate information to predict with absolute certainty the final results of those decisions.

I would suggest that the only valid means of ranking past Presidents is to compare the results of their tenure, rather than comparing them to an ideal standard. Barack Obama is not a perfect President. That said, to compare his tenure thus far with that of his predecessor is patently absurd. Barack Obama is no George W. Bush -- and I thank God for that.



'Best" will always be subjective and a product of point-of-view. You're prone to rate liberals higher than I would because that's your ideology. I'd obviously lean towards the more conservative Presidents. It doesn't make either one of us right or wrong, although you won't be able some people of that.
 
No, not really. To do so, you would have to gloss over, for example, FDR's interment of Japanese-Americans based on nothing other than ethnicity as if it were a minor point. That's pretty damning, don't you think?

Yes, it's damning. It's just overwhelmed by the other factors.
 
'Best" will always be subjective and a product of point-of-view. You're prone to rate liberals higher than I would because that's your ideology. I'd obviously lean towards the more conservative Presidents. It doesn't make either one of us right or wrong, although you won't be able some people of that.

You have no idea what I'm "prone" to do. I'd appreciate it it if you wouldn't attempt to judge my character based upon your knowledge of your own, personal character flaws.
 
Back
Top