New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Climate change

There's no paranoia - just a very clear observation that your solutions to all problems involve an activist interventionist state characterized by an ever-increasing span of control. It's like a drug addict whose tolerance for his preferred chemical high requires ever higher dosages. Got a problem? Grow the government, sprout an agency, surrender personal autonomy.

If we just had a sufficiently muscular state, all would be bliss - another few decades of stacking laws, regulations, controlling authorities, and bureaucrats and we'll finally hit that sweet spot.
i agree, state should not be involved in people's sexual behavior and desire to have kids. I also agree ,that the opinions about state involvement in pushing the economical and infrastractural progress can vary as well.
But the matter of huge importance - possible humanity survival or at least huge economical and health effects of global warming can not be left to an individual levels of greed , stupidity and/or FOXian/Pravdian brain rape paid by big oil.
And not even one state, the whole global community is the only possible participant and remedy to the coming threat, no individual efforts, no praying , no using con ignorance etc are going to help-only huge efforts on a global and state levels. No other way, my friend, Ayn Rand is not going to save us...
 
i agree, state should not be involved in people's sexual behavior and desire to have kids. I also agree ,that the opinions about state involvement in pushing the economical and infrastractural progress can vary as well.
But the matter of huge importance - possible humanity survival or at least huge economical and health effects of global warming can not be left to an individual levels of greed , stupidity and/or FOXian/Pravdian brain rape paid by big oil.
And not even one state, the whole global community is the only possible participant and remedy to the coming threat, no individual efforts, no praying , no using con ignorance etc are going to help-only huge efforts on a global and state levels. No other way, my friend, Ayn Rand is not going to save us...

There's no Ayn Rand here. I reject her doctrine of "selfishness is good". I reject her perverse definition of "sacrifice". I'm no randian - and neither am I an anarchist. I do realize, however, that when you collectivize the masses, you likewise pool their frailties. This, in fact, is the very core of conservatism. Well before there was Edmund Burke, there was a fine fellow by the name of Augustine. He, probably more than any other individual, properly grasped the nature of fallen man.

I like spicy food. I enjoy habaneros. But when you pool a large quantity of hot peppers and make an extract, the resultant undiluted, uber-powerful concoction is caustic.

Keep the state decentralized. We need not only the checks and balances of varied government branches - but of varied jurisdictions and states. Centralize power and you remove dilution, concentrating the frailty of man and arming it.
 
i agree, state should not be involved in people's sexual behavior and desire to have kids. I also agree ,that the opinions about state involvement in pushing the economical and infrastractural progress can vary as well.
But the matter of huge importance - possible humanity survival or at least huge economical and health effects of global warming can not be left to an individual levels of greed , stupidity and/or FOXian/Pravdian brain rape paid by big oil.
And not even one state, the whole global community is the only possible participant and remedy to the coming threat, no individual efforts, no praying , no using con ignorance etc are going to help-only huge efforts on a global and state levels. No other way, my friend, Ayn Rand is not going to save us...

Do unborn babies fit under your definition of "humanity survival" or "people's sexual behavior"?
 
So we had rash and implausible theories of global cooling "thirty or forty years ago", and now we have had much more "reliable" theories and models of global warming (read: "climate change") the past thirty or forty... except we've seen no warming now for 16 years.

Maybe it's time to start rethinking the current theory as well.

...no, it is time to recognize the increased levels of carbon, glacial melt and severe weather events - and since you are generally convinced by economic evidence - check out the cost of buying commercial insurance on coastal property in a hurricane zone - then try collecting...
 
There's no paranoia - just a very clear observation that your solutions to all problems involve an activist interventionist state characterized by an ever-increasing span of control. It's like a drug addict whose tolerance for his preferred chemical high requires ever higher dosages. Got a problem? Grow the government, sprout an agency, surrender personal autonomy.

If we just had a sufficiently muscular state, all would be bliss - another few decades of stacking laws, regulations, controlling authorities, and bureaucrats and we'll finally hit that sweet spot.
No. I take a case-by-case approach, and often favor individual choice rather than state-mandated solutions. For example, I oppose public school uniforms. It only looks like I always favor activist state intervention because you're so radical in your opposition to the state, that you're viewing the whole thing from an extreme angle where you can't really observe what's happening. My own approach is fairly centrist, by the standards of wealthy nations generally -- I wouldn't go as far towards the "nanny state" as Scandinavia, for example, but I wouldn't leave people to struggle on their own as much as the current US does. But when you're viewing the whole scene from so far out in right field, even someone in the middle of the array looks like a radical statist.
 
...no, it is time to recognize the increased levels of carbon, glacial melt and severe weather events - and since you are generally convinced by economic evidence - check out the cost of buying commercial insurance on coastal property in a hurricane zone - then try collecting...

Expansion of business and residential properties into hurricane zones IS surely a problem, the climate...that's debatable.
Many studies say temperature changes cause increases in atmospheric CO2 and water vapor- not the other way around.
"Severe weather events" are occurring as normally as can be expected, as they've been a climatic reality since before the dawn of man.
 
you appear oblivious to the recently published news reports that the planet hasn't warmed in a decade, and that artic sea ice this summer may have set all time record for COVERAGE, not melt.
 
It's interesting how this "snapshot" sufficed to explain how the earth was warming between 1980 to 1996. This is what is responsible for the climatic panic the lefties are suffering from even today. But now that those trends have changed, the theories have necessarily changed with them, as have the climate models.

Now this snapshot is no longer reliable, and we must rely on even less dependable testimony even as the old hypotheses have proven totally incorrect.

This has become rather a religion than a science.
What panic are you talking about? I honestly don't have a clue what you're talking about.

Yes, climate models get refined over time, to accommodate new data. That's how science works. But, as of now, the best models available say that global temperature is DEFINITELY rising, and that it's 95% likely that humans are the majority cause.
 
I'm glad you're so sure. Because even the experts on climate change admit being stumped.

Some climate scientists, such as Professor Phil Jones, director of the Climatic Research Unit at the University of East Anglia, last week dismissed the significance of the plateau, saying that 15 or 16 years is too short a period from which to draw conclusions.
Others disagreed. Professor Judith Curry, who is the head of the climate science department at America’s prestigious Georgia Tech university, told The Mail on Sunday that it was clear that the computer models used to predict future warming were ‘deeply flawed’.

Even Prof Jones admitted that he and his colleagues did not understand the impact of ‘natural variability’ – factors such as long-term ocean temperature cycles and changes in the output of the sun. However, he said he was still convinced that the current decade would end up significantly warmer than the previous two.


Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-2217286/Global-warming-stopped-16-years-ago-reveals-Met-Office-report-quietly-released--chart-prove-it.html#ixzz2cVrL2NOF
I'm sure that there's been warming during the last 16 years. If you have a reference to some expert who disagree, provide it. The quotations you provided don't go to that point. They deal with surface temperature readings only. There is considerable uncertainty about where the extra heat will go on various timelines, and as climate models get more refined, they'll need to get better at predicting those things. But the heat is there and continues to rise -- it's just been more in the sea and less on the surface in the last 16 years.
 
Expansion of business and residential properties into hurricane zones IS surely a problem, the climate...that's debatable.
Many studies say temperature changes cause increases in atmospheric CO2 and water vapor- not the other way around.
"Severe weather events" are occurring as normally as can be expected, as they've been a climatic reality since before the dawn of man.

...I tried to find as a-political of a reference as possible for you: http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=climate-change-and-extreme-weather

...severe weather events are trending upwards...
 
For thinking people


That is Arkady's qualifier....if you donyt agree you are not a thinking person...one has to admire the idea that someone would even consider the possibility that people whether on the highly smart level or even on Arkady's level would consider that people dont think...rather the qualifier that only idiots would buy into and lefty has bougt into it hoo line and sinker. It's the "Arkady Effect."

The Gore Effect
The phenomenon that leads to unseasonably cold temperatures, driving rain, hail, or snow whenever Al Gore visits an area to discuss global warming." According to an article at the Politico website: "The so-called Gore Effect happens when a global warming-related event, or appearance by the former vice president and climate change crusader, Al Gore, is marked by exceedingly cold weather or unseasonably winter weather.


That is GOD'S sense of humor...I particularly remember the NYC global warming confernce during the coldest temperatures in 100 years in NYC and Al Gore's excuse was it's hotter at the equator and that rising heat sucks the cold air from the north causing colder temperatures...but only in the northern hemisphere...

But not to laugh too hard at Arkday's preposterous thread this article from Forbes:

Sorry Global Warming Alarmists, The Earth Is Cooling

read more at the thread....just another fine moment in lefty history where Al Gore has duped you ....made millions off you and you bought it hook, line and thinker....get it....hook, line and thinker...damn it lefty dont you get anything....that was effen funny.
 
Climate change has been occurring as long as there has been....climate. Before mankind appeared on this planet, and would continue on even if he became extinct. The folly lies in the arrogant belief that we will control it by diverting funds to the 'right' people (self-annointed grand wizards of the climate change).
I'm all for polluting less, put enriching a charlatan like Al Gore so he can enlarge his already humongous carbon footprint by building another mansion somewhere does nothing worthwhile for the environment. You want to make a difference? Pollute a little less. Put your faith in politicians, on the other hand, and you're going to be fleeced. It's what they do.
Nobody disputes that climate change has always happened. That's a red herring statement. But, lately, we have warming that's happening much faster than any we have any sign happened in the past, and we have soaring levels of CO2 associated with human activities, which have been correctly predicted to keep temperatures rising.

Now, if you want to argue against a particular solution for dealing with the human component to global warming, I'd like to hear the argument. What would you do instead? I'm open to suggestions. But simply trying to turn this into a typical brain-dead conservative personal attack on a disliked Democratic politician is a childish act. We need better from our citizens. CO2 levels are rising rapidly and will keep rising rapidly unless something changes, and most experts are projecting serious problems for mankind if that's allowed to happen. So, what's your plan? Gore, whether you like him or hate him, has provided a suggestion. If you aren't intellectually up to Gore's level, or you lack his courage to engage meaningfully in the debate, then just step aside. But if you think you have a solution to offer, let's hear it.
 
No. I take a case-by-case approach, and often favor individual choice rather than state-mandated solutions. For example, I oppose public school uniforms. It only looks like I always favor activist state intervention because you're so radical in your opposition to the state, that you're viewing the whole thing from an extreme angle where you can't really observe what's happening. My own approach is fairly centrist, by the standards of wealthy nations generally -- I wouldn't go as far towards the "nanny state" as Scandinavia, for example, but I wouldn't leave people to struggle on their own as much as the current US does. But when you're viewing the whole scene from so far out in right field, even someone in the middle of the array looks like a radical statist.

School uniforms? Really? How could I have ever been so misguided? ;-)
 
Nobody disputes that climate change has always happened. That's a red herring statement. But, lately, we have warming that's happening much faster than any we have any sign happened in the past, and we have soaring levels of CO2 associated with human activities, which have been correctly predicted to keep temperatures rising.

Now, if you want to argue against a particular solution for dealing with the human component to global warming, I'd like to hear the argument. What would you do instead? I'm open to suggestions. But simply trying to turn this into a typical brain-dead conservative personal attack on a disliked Democratic politician is a childish act. We need better from our citizens. CO2 levels are rising rapidly and will keep rising rapidly unless something changes, and most experts are projecting serious problems for mankind if that's allowed to happen. So, what's your plan? Gore, whether you like him or hate him, has provided a suggestion. If you aren't intellectually up to Gore's level, or you lack his courage to engage meaningfully in the debate, then just step aside. But if you think you have a solution to offer, let's hear it.


Your hero-worship of the huckster Gore provided me with a good belly-laugh, thank you for that. If you enjoy being played by him, fine and dandy, but please don't hold your breath waiting for me to do likewise.
 
School uniforms? Really? How could I have ever been so misguided? ;-)



Obviously, we need a government program. substantially funded of course, to study the harmful effects of school uniforms on society. My God, think of the children!
 
For thinking people, one of the most convincing things about the mainstream theories about global warming is the trend within the scientific community. This isn't some short-lived fad hypothesis with little testing and investigation behind it. If this were an idea --like the global cooling craze, thirty or forty years ago-- that grew up quickly based on some interesting speculation and some snippets of evidence, we might expect it could vanish just as suddenly. But, instead, this is a theory that has grown slowly and steadily over the course of half a century, on the basis of mountains of research and data collection by many thousands of experts from dozens of fields of science and several dozen countries.

It's important to note that as these mountains of data grow, so does the confidence of the expert community about the theory that human activities are responsible for most of the warming trend. You may not know that if you've sealed yourself up within the airtight sarcophagus of the conservative media. In that crypt, the only stories that are let in are those that cast doubt on the theory. And with many thousands of new findings every year, inevitably there will be a steady trickle of those raising doubts, amidst the flood of findings raising confidence. But when the findings are considered as a whole, their net effect has been to broaden and strengthen the consensus among the experts every few years. The trend has been for a larger and larger portion of the expert community to become convinced, and for their confidence about that conviction to rise with time.

You can watch this playing out by reading the IPCC reports that come out every few years. Those are conservative reports (in the traditional sense of the word), since they require unanimous national consent. And so they've been slow to express the magnitude of the confidence most experts have long felt about the idea that human activities are the majority cause for global warming. But each new report has shown the intensified language that even that conservative consensus is willing to use. Most recently, they'll be hiking the probability they attribute for the theory to 95%:

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/20/s...l=1&adxnnlx=1376996753-gU4inp5yAW/7Vn1MheQkJw

So, what will it take to get you on board for political action? If you're holding out for the experts to tell you it's 100%, it won't happen. That's not how scientists think. We will either need to act with something less than 100% certainty, or we will never act. Think of it in medical terms. If you visited many of the best nutritionists and endocrinologists in the world and their consensus was that there was a 95% chance that your high blood sugar was mostly due to diet and lifestyle, and you'd soon be debilitated by diabetes if you didn't start exercising and improve your diet, would you hold out for 96% before making a change? 97%?


The expectation of 100% certainty is foolish, and only goes to show you how warped the thinking of the deniers is, for the reason you noted.

As I argued years and years ago now, it's also quite hypocritical, given that they base it on some kinda risk/benefit analysis.

For example, they were all for following Cheney's "One percent" doctrine that led us into the costly war in Iraq based on that one percent, but they are fighting and will continue fighting tooth and nail over actions taken based on 95% plus.

They also of course, rely on an "intrusive governement" rationales. Well gee, how intrusive do they think the gov is eventually gonna get when the bottom falls out, and chaos replaces order on various climate-related fronts?

Flat earthers have the thinking capacity and foresight of earthworms, and are more dangerous imo than those "muslim terrorists" they love to rave on about.
 
I would repsond to Arkady but he has used the ignore feature to hide his head from me.

What amazes me the most about the whole thing is that the left continues to insist that a large popluation of experts cannot be wrong. But...wrong about what exactly?

That they cannot tell you. All of the PHD'S and super smart people who are by definition " Smarter and better " than the rest of us have proved nothing more than an uneducated aboriginee who can read a thermometor can prove.....temperature is a changing value in our atmosphere and in our ecosystem....whoah!

None estemed lovers of Anthropogenic GW have ever dealt with the simple question that I have posed to them over and over again...

"By what mechanism did our world exit the last ice age ? ".... Instead they rain a torrent of insults and slights and tag names on me whenever I ask that question...beause they can't answer it with any kind of intellectual honesty.

I work with industrial boilers and power systems for a living. That means that I am constantly in touch with water chemistry. Now I'll tell you that my degrees are not in chemistry....but I will also tell you that working with the water systems every day...day in and day out for the past thrity years ....has given me a rather broad insight into what water does, how it behaves and how it handles the ambient air surrounding it.

To prepare water for entry into a high pressure boiler system one must first heat it up in special vessels known as deareating water heaters...know by the nick name DA in the industry. As the water heast up it drives out the dissolved CO2 and Oxygen that is unattached to the H2O structure and floating feeling about as O2.

This is done because at high temperatures and presssures both of these dissolved gasses attack metal like it was bubble gum. During the initial heating period a large quantity of both O2 and Co2 are expelled in this way. The water is further treated chemically to make sure it is pure enough to go to high pressure conditions.

Now back to the oceans and the solar cycles. It is an established fact ( Unlike Anthropgenic GW ) that the last Solar cycle was very stormy and that we are entering the next cycle that apperas to be fairly calm. This means that during the past fifty years or so the oceans have been absorbing heat from the sun. This is not always apparent in the temperature btw. As the oceans absorbed that heat they did what all bodies of water do as the heat content goes up....expell large amounts of Oxygen and CO2....hmmmmmm

Since the oceans are the single largest body of liquids on earth and since they are made up of WATER....it follows that the atmosphere would recieve a huge dose of CO2 from those oceans as they did heat up in response to the Solar Cycle. Now that they Solar cycle is taking the opposite turn the average temperatures will level out As we are seeing now ( even though Ark and the other lefties love the word debunked.....I swear next to racist it's their favorite word ) and even begin to drop.

As this happens the Co2 wil dissovle back into the oceans and the level will come down ....pretty much wiping out lefty's claim of " The sky is falling...give us your wallets now ! "

JO


Ah shut up idiot. http://www.pmel.noaa.gov/co2/story/Ocean+Acidification

any schoolchild could see you're totally ignoring the oceans uptake of "OUR" co2 for starters, which it has thusfar been unable to to keep up with, hence the increase in atmospheric co2 since the start of the industrial revolution.

and then of course, there's more ignorance in that post than as they use to say, Carter has liver pills.

awww.skepticalscience.com_pics_Solar_vs_Temp_basic.gif

Obviously the suns activity and temps have been going in opposite directions for some time now, contrary to what you wanna "believe".

"Moran"
 
you appear oblivious to the recently published news reports that the planet hasn't warmed in a decade, and that artic sea ice this summer may have set all time record for COVERAGE, not melt.
I linked to a report on a study by the IPCC -- a group of the leading climate experts from all over the world who have spent years reviewing all the scientific literature on this topic. The result of their review has been to increase the probability they attribute to the notion that humans are responsible for most of the warming, from 90% to 95%.... and they are now treating the warming trend itself as indisputable. That's because they read the actual science, rather than relying on the kind of misleading politicized second-hand accounts you rely on.

What happens when you get your climate "news" from ridiculous political sources like Fox News is that you assert things that simply aren't true. It's simply untrue that the planet hasn't warmed in a decade. It has. That claim is based on a 16-year snapshot of global SURFACE temperatures. Total global temperature has continued to rise -- it's just that, due to dominant weather patterns, 16 years ago a lot was showing up on the surface, and so comparing one-year snapshots of just surface temperatures during the start and end year of that time range gives a misleading idea.

As for the idea that arctic sea ice might set a record for coverage, see the graph here:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs...s-dramatically-slows-record-unlikely-in-2013/

As you'll see, the story is that the ice coverage is unlikely to set a new low, after the very low coverage of 2012, but that coverage is still well below the 1981-2010 average.

The denialists play a funny game when it comes to readings of this sort. The worse things are in a given year (the higher the spike in the temperature, the less ice coverage, etc.), the better it is for the denialist misinformation campaign. That sounds paradoxical, but it's true. You see, the worse a particular year is, the longer it's likely to be before the next all-time bad point. If we have one year in the late 90s that's much, much hotter than the overall trend, the alarmists get one year to be particularly alarmed, but then the denialists get 16 years to pretend there's no warming trend, before the next all-time high. Meanwhile, the extended moving averages continue to warm.
 
Back
Top