New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Clinton Emails 'bombshell'...

Yes, they intended to forward classified information - it was forwarded, and it was marked as classified.

First, was it marked as classified? The WaPo story makes no such claim. Second, even if something did have a classified marking, even that's not definitive proof of legal wrongdoing. For example, say you're working as an accountant. Your client sends you some supporting documentation for a write-off he's taking. You read the email, but don't open the attachment, because you're not an expert in that area of the tax law, and your accounting firm has someone else who looks at such material to confirm the transaction is eligible for the write-off. Sadly, unbeknownst to you, on page 62 of 150 in the attachment, there's a classified marking. Now you've forwarded material that was not only classified, but that was marked as classified. Should you be in jail?

That is not, nor is it ever actually part of the intent standard, as you and others well know.

Have you read the relevant law?

It is your job to know, particularly when your entire job revolves around handling sensitive material - to know what is and what is not classified

There is not a single person in the government who knows everything that is and is not classified. Read up on the investigation of the Clinton emails. They didn't have a single person or even team of person going through those emails looking for what's classified, since no single person would know. They farmed them out to various originating agencies, who'd be in a position to know. There could be material, for example, that wouldn't have looked at all classified from the perspective of someone in the state department, but may have looked classified to someone in the DoD or DoE, who knew why specific information was sensitive.

If something passes through your email that you would have no reason to know is classified, would it make sense to jail you for not having the superpower of reading the collective mind of the entire government and figuring it out? If we imposed that standard, we may as well abandon email entirely, in the government, because nobody can ever be sure that information that comes to them doesn't have some unrecognized and unmarked classified component. So if you're risking jail by sharing it, you're better off sharing nothing. And not just in email -- passing along physical copies would have the same issue. And even spoken conversations are risky -- if someone tells you something classified, then mentioning it to someone else would cause the same problem, which you might innocently do if there was no way you could have known it was classified. SO, the only safe way to work in government would be to avoid communicating with anyone else ever.

my contacts in the NSA and CIA tell me that - the default is to treat everything as classified
Then they're lying to you. If the CIA treated everything as classified, then we'd never have a single public statement by the CIA, since, by definition, whatever information was in that public statement should have been treated as if it were classified. They may err on the side of treating things as classified (which brings up the far more important issue of reflexive over-classification), but everybody will share information without being able to be 100% certain none of it is classified. That'll mean occasional innocent disclosure of classified information.

Don't worry, this is easy enough to understand. Just imagine it's a Republican doing it. For example, consider an example of Trump doing it:

http://thehill.com/policy/national-...r-trump-mightve-leaked-classified-information
 
...seems that classified emails were forwarded from Huma to Wiener's computer. Now, can anyone explain why these two aren't in jail?



https://www.washingtonpost.com/worl...aa_story.html?utm_term=.839f3d210bc9#comments

And now we know why he notified Congress. The real question is why aren't people who were trafficking CLASSIFIED information locked up?
Yes. I can tell you exactly why Huma and Weenie aren't in jail. They are Democrats and Democrats have been given permission by the Left and the Media to break the law with impunity. The media either downplays or just doesn't report what they did and they are not held accountable.
 
transparency

A lawyer wouldn't ask such a question
Is it your view that all emails by government workers should be published? If so, it makes sense to start with those of the Trump administration, since they're currently in power and so transparency into what they're doing would have more value to us. Let's start by publishing all their internal communications with and about the Russians.
 
Is it your view that all emails by government workers should be published? If so, it makes sense to start with those of the Trump administration, since they're currently in power and so transparency into what they're doing would have more value to us. Let's start by publishing all their internal communications with and about the Russians.

If Classified...........damn straight.........and any caught with private server in home should be boiled in oil.........dem/lib or repub

I had a security clearance while in service............if I did what Sow In Pant Suits did, I'd still be in federal prison

No wonder you here 24/7 and have no clients (hell, I don't think you even a lawyer).........every administration has communicated with foreign countries..

look boy=====no lawyer on earth has the time to be here or other frays as you do......or even fvcking would want too!
 
If Classified...........damn straight.........and any caught with private server in home should be boiled in oil.........dem/lib or repub

I had a security clearance while in service............if I did what Sow In Pant Suits did, I'd still be in federal prison

No wonder you here 24/7 and have no clients (hell, I don't think you even a lawyer).........every administration has communicated with foreign countries..

look boy=====no lawyer on earth has the time to be here or other frays as you do......or even fvcking would want too!
I wasn't clear on what you were trying to say.
 
Is it your view that all emails by government workers should be published? If so, it makes sense to start with those of the Trump administration, since they're currently in power and so transparency into what they're doing would have more value to us. Let's start by publishing all their internal communications with and about the Russians.

You're not getting the war with Russia Hillary promised you. Or the genocide...
 
I find it odd that such simple concepts still have to be explained to the right-wingers after all this time. The mere fact that emails containing classified information were forwarded by someone on an unsecured system does not, in itself, mean the forwarder committed a crime.

Here, I'll walk you through it. Let's say you have some level of security clearance, And let's say you and I are having a history argument about whether or not US intelligence had a good handle on the political situation in China leading up to the Korean War. In order to argue they didn't, I upload a document here showing that the CIA predicted China wouldn't interfere in the war, just twelve days before they did. Let's say I got it from a published volume the State Department puts out of old memos, etc. You want to take a closer look later, and so you forward the document to your home computer where you can print it out. You don't realize it, but you just emailed a classified document to an unsecured server. It turns out that the document you sent yourself was one of a huge number that were re-classified:

http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/war_stories/2006/02/secret_again.html

Should you be in jail? Obviously not. You didn't know the information was classified, and there's no reason you should have known it. There was no evidence you intended to to anything wrong. Why would you have expected that the previously published document I uploaded, showing nothing but some internal communications from nearly eighty years ago was classified? You acted innocently.

That's the situation we had with the Clinton emails, and with these new ones as well. Abedin and Weiner were investigated for possibly mishandling the material, and then investigators dropped it because they couldn't show intent. Partisan hacks want them jailed, anyway, since they're Democrats, but it's entirely possible neither did anything wrong. Just because you send an email with classified information in it doesn't mean you meant to email classified information.

If you have to make up alternate facts rather than discuss the ones at hand, clearly you realize you have already lost the argument.
 
If you have to make up alternate facts rather than discuss the ones at hand, clearly you realize you have already lost the argument.

This coming from people who think Benedict Donald isn't a traitor or a racist

sigh

KKKonservatives will be arguing about the flatness of the Earth in 4 ... 3.... 2..
 
This coming from people who think Benedict Donald isn't a traitor or a racist

sigh

KKKonservatives will be arguing about the flatness of the Earth in 4 ... 3.... 2..

Flat earth? The last person I heard of making such an argument was Shaquile O'Neil- hardly a KKK member.

As to your first rant paragraph, there seems to be a disconnect between you and I what I posted.
 
We agree, Benedict Donald belonging to Putin's inner circle got him an election in the US ... sounds bout right

You seem to be suffering from TDS. The topic is Hillary Clinton, Huma Abedin and her hebephile husband. Try to focus.
 
First, was it marked as classified? The WaPo story makes no such claim.

Even the left-leaning Politifact spoke up about Hillary's claim she never sent anything marked classified:

tom-false.png

http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-m...ndings-tear-holes-hillary-clintons-email-def/
 
Back
Top