New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Conversation Starter

Arkady

President
Who would you list as the people whose lives did the most damage to the world? If you could, for example, change history so that certain people weren't ever born, who would you pick?

Many of those we could easily agree were bad for the world wouldn't be great picks, because although they had an evil influence, it was a fairly small one on a global/historical scale. For example, if Jeffrey Dahmer had never been born, life would have been immeasurably better for a small handful of people, but the world would look pretty much the same today for everyone else. Those who have the biggest negative impact are generally not those universally seen as evil, because those universally seen as evil don't have their impact multiplied by millions of others picking up their ideas or following their orders.

I'd personally avoid naming scientists and inventors. Even if you think a particular advance was harmful to mankind, chances are it wouldn't be much postponed by taking out a particular scientist. If, for example, Edward Teller hadn't ever been born to be father of the H-Bomb, my bet is someone else or some group of people would have made the same contributions within a few years of when Teller did it, so mankind wouldn't have been much better off.

So, I'd focus more on political leaders and thought leaders, including religious leaders.

Here are some ideas: Karl Marx, Mohammed, Jesus of Nazareth, Ayn Rand, Hitler, Bush, Stalin, Lenin, Adam Smith, Osama Bin Laden, Ludwig Von Mises, Lee Harvey Oswald, Genghis Khan, Attila the Hun, Herbert Hoover, Mao Zedong, Julius Caesar, and Saul of Tarsus.

Of those, the easiest picks might be the worst. For example, the very fact Hitler is pretty much universally reviled today limits the amount of evil he can continue to do to the world. If anything, he's so cartoonishly evil, in the world's mind, that the memory of his existence helps to steer people away from some of the dark paths he took mankind down for a time. So, although the evil he brought about was unimaginably huge for a generation, it's harder to picture him having an ongoing negative influence for centuries into the future.

The most controversial figures are the ones with the greatest potential to have an ongoing evil impact -- the very fact they'd be so controversial is evidence of the continuing power and relevance of their ideas. Marx, Mohammed, Jesus, and, to a lesser extent, Rand, all continue to have an enormous influence in how people frame their understandings of our world, for better or worse. So, if you view those outlooks as having evil consequences, they're consequences that have the potential to be multiplied across billions of people for generations to come.

Just to take the example of Rand, consider the Rand Paul/Paul Ryan/Alan Greenspan types who continue to fall into her thrall in their impressionable youths, and then work her evil on the nation and the world through their political influence. If, as appears highly likely, the world charges headlong into ecological catastrophe by refusing to regulate greenhouse gas emissions, the refusal of the world's leading nation to use its influence aggressively enough to head that off will be a major reason for that disaster, and the role of Ayn Rand acolytes in this country will be a very large factor in that refusal. That could result in premature deaths for billions of humans, and leave many billions more with severely diminished quality of life for millenia to come -- an evil outcome that would vastly outweigh anything Hitler brought to the world.

So, who'd be on your list?
 
Count Leopold von Berchtold, Gavrillo Princip.


I could list a bunch of people whose ideology I disagree with, but that seems small-minded.
 
Well, naturally being PJ, it's going to break down on partisan lines....and our history revisionist Right will of course attribute every good person as a "Christian conservative" and every evil person as a "atheist lib'rul/socialist/commern'nist". (Apparently there never were any rightwing dictators).

But I think your "Teller" point extends even into politics.....who's to say if Hitler had died on the battlefield in World War-I (which he almost did), that some "other Hitler" or "worse Hitler" wouldn't have risen to power in Weimar Germany. Perhaps somebody NOT suffering from obvious mental disorders, just as charismatic and perhaps more strategic in this thinking ....i.e. not invading the Soviet Union until securing a peace with the UK or not allying with the Japanese and thus having to declare war on the US after Pearl Harbor.

Or more recently, what if some "Greg Stilson" (the villain from "The Dead Zone") politician had risen in the late 70s to become the Republican Nominee in 1980. A "mad Reagan" who actually did start a nuclear war with the Soviets out of some clinical paranoia....and not just use a bunch of rhetoric that even Reagan eventually gave up on after 1984?
 
Who would you list as the people whose lives did the most damage to the world? If you could, for example, change history so that certain people weren't ever born, who would you pick?

Many of those we could easily agree were bad for the world wouldn't be great picks, because although they had an evil influence, it was a fairly small one on a global/historical scale. For example, if Jeffrey Dahmer had never been born, life would have been immeasurably better for a small handful of people, but the world would look pretty much the same today for everyone else. Those who have the biggest negative impact are generally not those universally seen as evil, because those universally seen as evil don't have their impact multiplied by millions of others picking up their ideas or following their orders.

I'd personally avoid naming scientists and inventors. Even if you think a particular advance was harmful to mankind, chances are it wouldn't be much postponed by taking out a particular scientist. If, for example, Edward Teller hadn't ever been born to be father of the H-Bomb, my bet is someone else or some group of people would have made the same contributions within a few years of when Teller did it, so mankind wouldn't have been much better off.

So, I'd focus more on political leaders and thought leaders, including religious leaders.

Here are some ideas: Karl Marx, Mohammed, Jesus of Nazareth, Ayn Rand, Hitler, Bush, Stalin, Lenin, Adam Smith, Osama Bin Laden, Ludwig Von Mises, Lee Harvey Oswald, Genghis Khan, Attila the Hun, Herbert Hoover, Mao Zedong, Julius Caesar, and Saul of Tarsus.

Of those, the easiest picks might be the worst. For example, the very fact Hitler is pretty much universally reviled today limits the amount of evil he can continue to do to the world. If anything, he's so cartoonishly evil, in the world's mind, that the memory of his existence helps to steer people away from some of the dark paths he took mankind down for a time. So, although the evil he brought about was unimaginably huge for a generation, it's harder to picture him having an ongoing negative influence for centuries into the future.

The most controversial figures are the ones with the greatest potential to have an ongoing evil impact -- the very fact they'd be so controversial is evidence of the continuing power and relevance of their ideas. Marx, Mohammed, Jesus, and, to a lesser extent, Rand, all continue to have an enormous influence in how people frame their understandings of our world, for better or worse. So, if you view those outlooks as having evil consequences, they're consequences that have the potential to be multiplied across billions of people for generations to come.

Just to take the example of Rand, consider the Rand Paul/Paul Ryan/Alan Greenspan types who continue to fall into her thrall in their impressionable youths, and then work her evil on the nation and the world through their political influence. If, as appears highly likely, the world charges headlong into ecological catastrophe by refusing to regulate greenhouse gas emissions, the refusal of the world's leading nation to use its influence aggressively enough to head that off will be a major reason for that disaster, and the role of Ayn Rand acolytes in this country will be a very large factor in that refusal. That could result in premature deaths for billions of humans, and leave many billions more with severely diminished quality of life for millenia to come -- an evil outcome that would vastly outweigh anything Hitler brought to the world.

So, who'd be on your list?

This is a really good question, thanks for posting it. I'm going to have to give this one a lot more thought before I offer any answers up, though...
 
I don't presume to know. What's your theory?

Probably the same....given von Hötzendorf was as "pro-attack Serbia" as Bercthold.

My only points are that (A) "forces of history" sometimes swamp individuals...and perhaps (B) a bit of Liebniz's "This is the best of all possible worlds".

BTW, the reverse is equally interesting to consider....what if Lester Pearson of Canada had never been born? Would the Suez Crises have become World War-III??? *shrug*
 
Count Leopold von Berchtold, Gavrillo Princip.


I could list a bunch of people whose ideology I disagree with, but that seems small-minded.

Interesting choices. Given the way that WWI destroyed a whole generation and set us up for WWII, and arguably the Cold War, and eventually the post-colonial strife continuing to this day, it's not a bad line of reasoning. If Von Berchtold hadn't been born, do you think it's unlikely his place in history would have been more or less filled by someone else? Similarly, if not for Princip, wouldn't the spark to that tinderbox almost certainly have happened elsewhere? I suppose there are no sure answers to those questions, but they're interesting to think about. To what extent was WWI an inevitable consequence of large-scale political and economic developments, and to what extent was it the arbitrary result of a few specific acts by individual people?
 
Well, are we talking actual history or contrahistory? Among the most harmful people in actual history is Mohammed -- but I'm sure no member of the muslim faith would agree.

As you are excluding, I think erroneously, inventors and other non-political, non-religious figures you perforce leave out many postiive influences (Tesla) and negative ones (Milton Friedman).

Personally, I think those who reduced the individual as a matter of philosophy are the most harmful. Marx, Lenin, Mussolini, Mao -- any who felt that the individual existed to serve the collective rather than vice versa.
 
If we subtract Mikahail Gorbachev from Human History would Reagan be the hero the right worships so much or would he had failed to destroy the old USSR???
 
Probably the same....given von Hötzendorf was as "pro-attack Serbia" as Bercthold.

My only points are that (A) "forces of history" sometimes swamp individuals...and perhaps (B) a bit of Liebniz's "This is the best of all possible worlds".

BTW, the reverse is equally interesting to consider....what if Lester Pearson of Canada had never been born? Would the Suez Crises have become World War-III??? *shrug*

Some of the strongest candidates for being the worst are also candidates for being the best, since the magnitude of their influence, overall, means that if it tilts a little one way or the other, it overwhelms the contributions of less important figures. Jesus and Marx are good examples. You could argue they were among the worst things to happen to mankind or among the best.

With Jesus, you could argue that his teachings were unusual and contagious enough that if he hadn't existed, something akin to Christianity might never have arisen -- that he's one of the rare humans who swamped the forces of history, rather than vice versa. If so, then the question is whether it was, overall, a positive or negative influence. You could argue he brought down the Roman Empire dooming the Western World to a thousand years of darkness, and delaying our progress by that much. Or you could argue that Rome was stalled, and could have remained stalled indefinitely, so that the state of mankind couldn't have advanced without its fall and the eventual rebirth of civilization in the high middle ages, Renaissance, and Enlightenment. Or you could argue he had nothing to do with it, and that Christianity, as a philosophy, had little importance in the course of events of the last two thousand years -- that it took on the flavor of the times, and any other faith would have done the same. I guess I'd come down mostly in favor of that last point. When you look at the expressions of Christianity over time (everything from radical pacifists to conquistadors and crusaders, radical ascetics to "prosperity evangelicals") it looks almost infinitely adaptable to its cultural milieu. So, if some other cult had happened to be the trendy one in the waning days of the Roman Empire, and had been adopted by Rome and then spread throughout Europe in the Dark Ages, it could have filled all the same mental and cultural niches, with only cosmetic differences.
 
This one is easy. Mayer Amschel Rothschild (b. Feb. 23, 1744, Frankfurt am Main—d. Sept. 19, 1812, Frankfurt) and his five sons, Amschel Mayer (b. June 12, 1773, Frankfurt—d. Dec. 6, 1855, Frankfurt), Salomon Mayer (b. Sept. 9, 1774—d. July 27, 1855, Vienna), Nathan Mayer (b. Sept. 16, 1777—d. July 28, 1836, Frankfurt), Karl Mayer (b. April 24, 1788—d. March 10, 1855, Naples), and Jakob, or James (b. May 15, 1792—d. Nov. 15, 1868, Paris). Starting out in a Frankfurt banking house, Mayer and his sons became international bankers, establishing branches in London, Paris, Vienna, and Naples by the 1820s.

The family is still behind the international banking cabal that is systematically bringing the world to it's figurative knees.

The next choice would be David Rockefeller who established the further means to implement world control.
 
Well, are we talking actual history or contrahistory? Among the most harmful people in actual history is Mohammed -- but I'm sure no member of the muslim faith would agree.

Would there have been a Spanish Inquisition or Salem Witch Trials.......without Jesus???

(Both to trap and Arkady's point)
 
This one is easy. Mayer Amschel Rothschild (b. Feb. 23, 1744, Frankfurt am Main—d. Sept. 19, 1812, Frankfurt) and his five sons, Amschel Mayer (b. June 12, 1773, Frankfurt—d. Dec. 6, 1855, Frankfurt), Salomon Mayer (b. Sept. 9, 1774—d. July 27, 1855, Vienna), Nathan Mayer (b. Sept. 16, 1777—d. July 28, 1836, Frankfurt), Karl Mayer (b. April 24, 1788—d. March 10, 1855, Naples), and Jakob, or James (b. May 15, 1792—d. Nov. 15, 1868, Paris). Starting out in a Frankfurt banking house, Mayer and his sons became international bankers, establishing branches in London, Paris, Vienna, and Naples by the 1820s.

The family is still behind the international banking cabal that is systematically bringing the world to it's figurative knees.

The next choice would be David Rockefeller who established the further means to implement world control.

Don't forget the guy who created water fluoridation and the ones who hide Tesla's free energy generators. :smile:
 
Well, naturally being PJ, it's going to break down on partisan lines....and our history revisionist Right will of course attribute every good person as a "Christian conservative" and every evil person as a "atheist lib'rul/socialist/commern'nist". (Apparently there never were any rightwing dictators).

But I think your "Teller" point extends even into politics.....who's to say if Hitler had died on the battlefield in World War-I (which he almost did), that some "other Hitler" or "worse Hitler" wouldn't have risen to power in Weimar Germany. Perhaps somebody NOT suffering from obvious mental disorders, just as charismatic and perhaps more strategic in this thinking ....i.e. not invading the Soviet Union until securing a peace with the UK or not allying with the Japanese and thus having to declare war on the US after Pearl Harbor.

Or more recently, what if some "Greg Stilson" (the villain from "The Dead Zone") politician had risen in the late 70s to become the Republican Nominee in 1980. A "mad Reagan" who actually did start a nuclear war with the Soviets out of some clinical paranoia....and not just use a bunch of rhetoric that even Reagan eventually gave up on after 1984?

Yep. That does make it tricky. Take someone that you and I can agree was horrible, like George W. Bush, and it's possible the world is a much better place because he existed, if maybe the alternative would have been worse. For example, maybe if GW Bush was never born, McCain would have won the 2000 nomination and eventually the election. McCain never struck me as particularly emotionally stable -- what if he used 9/11 as an excuse to use tactical nukes on half the Middle East? What if this had led to a Cold War, or even a hot variety, with the down-wind victims like India and China? I'm not saying that's likely -- I'm just putting forward the idea that it's really hard to think through all the consequences of a change.
 
Fredrick Nietzsche...

He influenced Ayn Rand...

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedrich_Nietzsche

Also add Aristotle...

He influenced many things including Fredrick Nietzsche...

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aristotle

I hadn't considered Nietzsche, but he's a very interesting possibility. He also had an influence on the Nazis.

I did consider Aristotle, and ultimately decided he was a net positive for mankind. His influence was huge, in essentially setting us down the road of the scientific method, but I think overall quality of life is much better because of that, notwithstanding all the individual negative outcomes.
 
Back
Top