New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Conversation Starter

I do not know if I can agree...

Take my choice Aristotle and his influence of mankind...

Aristotle influenced Columbus to sail looking for a faster way to India and doing so he landed on the Dominican Republic... From there Columbus discovery influenced nations like Spain, France, Portugal, and England to settle the uncharted land and genocide the native population of the new world...

Now without Aristotle influence would Columbus have sailed to the New World looking for a faster way to India???

Then you have Nietzsche that was influenced by Aristotle and from Nietzsche you can link Nazism to him and from Nazism we had another World War and the genocide of millions because of the war...

If you remove Aristotle influence from Nietzsche would Nietzsche been the philosopher he was and would his influence been felt in Nazism???

I say one man did influence an entire world and his name was not Jesus, Muhammad, or Buddha, but just Aristotle...
 
You folks should read some of Harry Turtledove's novels of alternate history, they are both entertaining and thought provoking.
 
I have given it some thought and my list pretty much agrees with the TP, with some additions.

Stalin, Idi Amin, Nero, Judas, several of the Popes, and Rush Limbaugh.
 
Ruppert Murdoch...

Fox cancelled Firefly...

The man is the most evil being ever!!!

( Thinking of Sheldon from Big Bang Theory )
 
You are forgetting one thing... Christianity gave rise to the world's universities.

Although the modern university can be traced to Christian theological education, the idea of centers for higher education long predate Christianity:

http://veda.wikidot.com/tip:world-first-university-takshila

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platonic_Academy

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taixue

So, I don't think Christianity was necessary to give rise to modern universities. If Christianity had never existed, I think more or less the same concept could have arisen from Islam, Hinduism, or, especially, Confucianism. The concept is so obvious that something akin to it has been independently established in all kinds of religious traditions:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Academy_of_Gundishapur
 
I've only shortened your post as a matter of layout -- overall I agree with it. If you were starving in China in 1948, Mao looked pretty good compared to Chiang.

I don't agree that there is room for a synthesis of communism with any other philosophy. Marx and Lenin both said there could be no compromise.

Personally, I wouldn't want to live in one of those social-democratic states -- too little incentive. But that's outside the scope of this discussion.

I don't think it matters what Marx and Lenin said about the possibility of compromise. The simple facts on the ground are that compromise is everywhere, between capitalism and communism. In the US, for example, our retirement system is a compromise between tax-advantaged, market-driven private savings (IRAs and 401Ks), and government social insurance programs (Social Security, plus pension systems for government workers).
 
Ruppert Murdoch...

Fox cancelled Firefly...

The man is the most evil being ever!!!

( Thinking of Sheldon from Big Bang Theory )

Hehe. I'd considered Rupert Murdoch for his role in pointing the way to a much dumber form of "news." I hadn't even considered the atrocity of Firefly's cancellation. There's really no forgiving that.
 
I don't think it matters what Marx and Lenin said about the possibility of compromise. The simple facts on the ground are that compromise is everywhere, between capitalism and communism. In the US, for example, our retirement system is a compromise between tax-advantaged, market-driven private savings (IRAs and 401Ks), and government social insurance programs (Social Security, plus pension systems for government workers).

I don't think that is a synthesis of communism and capitalism. Social "insurance" programs are more socialist than communist (they're unconstitutional, too, but that's another thread).
 
On what basis?


Hearst with his expanded yellow journalism, newspapers and magazines that helped Ansliger spread his vile racist charges against blacks and Mexicans and allow duPont to gain footholds in chemical industries and displace other sources in favor of petroleum.

Just a sordid tale all around...maybe not Pope level...
 
Can't blame him because Tabloid News does sell...

Is there any way we can connect Murdoch to Aristotle???

If so then I have discover the one man that influenced the world more than Jesus, Mohammad, Buddha, oh hell even God!!!
 
In my opinion, no individual has changed the course of civilization for better or worse. Some may've changed its course in the near term (a century or less), but no individual changed it for "all time" (so to speak).

Because....if it wasn't them, it'd have been someone else. I find it more useful to think in terms of the society giving rise to the individual, rather than the individual giving rise to the society.

Since history is a collection of individual actions, EVERYONE must have changed the course of civilization to some extent. The question is just whether any individual can make a significant difference visible from the perspective of centuries. I tend to think so, though of course I can't prove it. Think of the butterfly effect. Complex, iterative systems can have extreme sensitivity to initial conditions.

Think of it in medical terms, for a second. One random cancerous cell can, in the long run, kill the organism. It may initially be outnumbered to the point of seeming negligible, so that the random circumstance of it becoming cancerous might seem meaningless. But that random event could wind up being of absolute consequence to the individual. I think people can be like that. One cancerous individual can wind up having a huge impact that would be visible even centuries later.

I think the prime candidates for that are those whose mental leaps are far out of line with what was happening in their era before them, so that it's possible someone else wouldn't have come along anytime soon to provide the same influence. I'm thinking of Einstein, since, unlike other great thinkers like Newton, I see a leap of imagination there that I don't think was on the "tip of the tongue" for scientific minds in general. I think relativity (and all its indirect consequences) might have taken generations for people to stumble on, without him. I can picture myself, in the right place, at the right time, with the right inspiration and hard work, coming up with most of the scientific breakthroughs in history, but I can't picture myself having that intuitive and counter-instinctive leap to relativity.
 
Can't blame him because Tabloid News does sell...

Is there any way we can connect Murdoch to Aristotle???

If so then I have discover the one man that influenced the world more than Jesus, Mohammad, Buddha, oh hell even God!!!


Murdoch is merely continuing the tradition begun by Pulitizer and expanded and perfected by Hearst. Appeal, loudly, to emotions through a large assortment of information delivery systems...
 
OK -- arguable then the most harmful person in history was Euclid, or maybe Miltus of Thales, or Muhammad ibn Mūsā al-Khwārizmī. They developed advanced mathematics, which led to the development of physics, which led to the development of the hydrogen bomb.

Or, another take -- Nikolaus Otto, who made the internal combustion engine ubiquitous and caused global warming.

If you think the world is either miserable or becoming miserable, there are a lot of places to assign blame.
 
I see what you're saying but...how do we know that the individual we're crediting with the "mental" leap, necessarily "deserves" all the credit, or might he simply be the one lucky enough to have history associate him with the leap?

For instance..take U-J's Aristotle. We associate Aristotle with a new way of thinking. But, did Aristotle create that new way of thinking, out of whole cloth (as it were), as a unique "Aristotlean function"? OR, was that new way of thinking already floating around in the intellectual etherea of his time, and he's simply the person who grabbed the "franchise" on it?
 
I do not think the world is miserable anymore than it was when the first Human utter it first words...

Also I always wonder what were the first actual words ever spoken by the first human???

Also just my opinion the most evil vile thing humanity ever created was God...
 
Suggesting that humanity "created" God, is like suggesting that humanity created air. And, I'm not coming from a mystical/spiritual place on this. Virtually ALL societies, throughout history, even those isolated from all the rest, have recognized the concept of God. That suggests that "God exists" - whatever God is.
 
Like the Shakespeare theory...

Some believe the bard did not write all of his stories but history has made them his...

So as I use Aristotle as my link to all that shaped history it is true Aristotle most likely was not the first to think his way and learnt it from others...

So Aristotle was most likely the Shakesspeare of his time...

It still ponders if you remove Aristotle from the timeline would those like Niccolo Machiavellie or Christopher Columbus become the men that they became???

So I do believe one individual can shape the fate of humanity...

If that does not work for you then what if Emperor Constantine had not embraced Christianity???

How would Christianity look today???

Would it be the same, or would it be a dead religion that was consider myth???

How one man ( Constantine ) changed the fate of one religion ( Christianity ) than the man that is worshiped ( Jesus )...
 
Back
Top