New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Conversation Starter

Yep. That does make it tricky. Take someone that you and I can agree was horrible, like George W. Bush, and it's possible the world is a much better place because he existed, if maybe the alternative would have been worse. For example, maybe if GW Bush was never born, McCain would have won the 2000 nomination and eventually the election. McCain never struck me as particularly emotionally stable -- what if he used 9/11 as an excuse to use tactical nukes on half the Middle East? What if this had led to a Cold War, or even a hot variety, with the down-wind victims like India and China? I'm not saying that's likely -- I'm just putting forward the idea that it's really hard to think through all the consequences of a change.

We see McCain's attitudes....mostly based on a desire to "re-write Vietnam" as applied to the Middle East. But he just as easily would have ONLY focused on Afghanistan as President after 9/11....as likely Gore would have, rather than embark on Dubya's ideological (even personal) crusade into Iraq.

Also just as likely McCain would have lost to Gore....given the distrust the Hard Right had for him for his "mavericky'ness" or he might have made a stupid Veep pick....as he did in 2008.
 
Well, are we talking actual history or contrahistory? Among the most harmful people in actual history is Mohammed -- but I'm sure no member of the muslim faith would agree.

As you are excluding, I think erroneously, inventors and other non-political, non-religious figures you perforce leave out many postiive influences (Tesla) and negative ones (Milton Friedman).

Personally, I think those who reduced the individual as a matter of philosophy are the most harmful. Marx, Lenin, Mussolini, Mao -- any who felt that the individual existed to serve the collective rather than vice versa.

It's too bad we don't have a Muslim here to make the case for Mohammed. It's not one I can make, but surely there must be a case to be made. In my mind, he's got all the typical negative influence of a religious leader (in diverting attention from the real world, promoting superstition and mindless ritual, and creating arbitrary rules and harsh punishments). Plus, he's much more militaristic than a lot of early religious leaders.

I'd find it much easier to make the case for, say, Lenin. The Russian people may have had it bad under communism, but they actually had it a lot worse before communism. It was effectively a dirt-poor third-world hell-hole under the czars, for all but the small economic elite. Under communism, education and life expectancy sky-rocketed, and for all the brutality of the communist regime, people had arguably more freedom and civil rights than as serfs in a quasi-feudal society, which was the status of most Russians before communism. There's a reason that millions risked life and limb to leap into the great unknown with that revolution -- the alternative was terrible. As for the impact of Lenin outside Russia, you can argue it was quite positive. The Soviets played a major role in bringing down fascism, and the Soviet superpower was part of the reason for the relative peace of the second half of the twentieth century -- a Cold War that compared favorably to the two giant bloodbaths of the first half of the century. They also encouraged the US to new heights, through competition -- we certainly got into space much earlier than we would have if the Soviets weren't also pushing that way, and so many of the moderns of the modern world (satellite communications, etc.), might have been delayed decades without Lenin. The pressure of the Communist ideology also encouraged us to make reforms that might otherwise have been even longer delayed (protection of worker rights, integration of the races, etc.) Without Moscow sneering at our racism, and without the lure of Communism for disaffected workers, might we not have found it easier to ignore our problems for longer?

To put it in more formal terms, Communism, as an antithesis for pure Capitalism, could have been necessary for the eventual evolution of a modern Synthesis like the social democratic systems that all the countries with high qualities of life practice today. Lenin, indirectly, may have given us things like Social Security, Medicare, OSHA, etc.
 
Interesting choices. Given the way that WWI destroyed a whole generation and set us up for WWII, and arguably the Cold War, and eventually the post-colonial strife continuing to this day, it's not a bad line of reasoning. If Von Berchtold hadn't been born, do you think it's unlikely his place in history would have been more or less filled by someone else? Similarly, if not for Princip, wouldn't the spark to that tinderbox almost certainly have happened elsewhere? I suppose there are no sure answers to those questions, but they're interesting to think about. To what extent was WWI an inevitable consequence of large-scale political and economic developments, and to what extent was it the arbitrary result of a few specific acts by individual people?



Those are things we'll never know. There is no one single catalyst for WWI. There is no question, however, of the 'contributions' made by the two individuals I named. I can only go by what is known.
 
Those are things we'll never know. There is no one single catalyst for WWI. There is no question, however, of the 'contributions' made by the two individuals I named. I can only go by what is known.

True...and as we've discussed...perhaps WORSE scenarios. Like...what if WW-I had occurred 10 years later...with more technological advances leading to an even bloodier conflict AND (if history followed the same path)...the rise of a Hitler and Nazis in the 1940s....with Germany being able to develop mutli-stage rockets and nuclear weapons during an "alternative World War-II" that occurred in the 1950s????
 
As great Aristotle was he influenced some of the most radical minds in mankind history...

Take Nietzsche and he was influenced by Aristotle and many others but without Aristotle influence in Nietzche life would Nietzche have been the radical philosopher that he was???

As you also pointed out Nietzsche influence could be felt in Nazism but it also was felt here in America...

So I ponder if Aristotle were not born would Nietzche had been the world known Philosopher that Ayn Rand was influenced by or that Nazism worshipped???

Another one I was going to add was Niccolo Machiavelli and his contribution to the world society...

From a religious spin of it if we subtract Buddha from the timeline what effect would it had on those like Jesus and Muhammad???

Some people believe Buddha influence was just in the regions of China, Afghanista, Pakistan, and India but as you study Jesus you can see Buddha influence in his teachings also...

Also if you remove Jesus from history would Muhammad have ever rose to being a Prophet???

Let say if you subtract Moses would there be a Israel today or even a Jewish society???
 
You forgot Opus Dei... I swear no respect, just no respect...
 
To put it in more formal terms, Communism, as an antithesis for pure Capitalism, could have been necessary for the eventual evolution of a modern Synthesis like the social democratic systems that all the countries with high qualities of life practice today. Lenin, indirectly, may have given us things like Social Security, Medicare, OSHA, etc.

I've only shortened your post as a matter of layout -- overall I agree with it. If you were starving in China in 1948, Mao looked pretty good compared to Chiang.

I don't agree that there is room for a synthesis of communism with any other philosophy. Marx and Lenin both said there could be no compromise.

Personally, I wouldn't want to live in one of those social-democratic states -- too little incentive. But that's outside the scope of this discussion.
 
Let me ask that if you subtract Aristotle what changes would have taken place in Christianity and Jewish Philosophy???
 
You are forgetting one thing... Christianity gave rise to the world's universities.
 
Very true...

Niccluas Copernicus, Galileo Galilei, and Leonardo DaVinci would have been altered without Aristotle works...

Christopher Columbus would have never sailed to Dominican Republic without Aristotle works...
 
In my opinion, no individual has changed the course of civilization for better or worse. Some may've changed its course in the near term (a century or less), but no individual changed it for "all time" (so to speak).

Because....if it wasn't them, it'd have been someone else. I find it more useful to think in terms of the society giving rise to the individual, rather than the individual giving rise to the society.
 
well, "we all stand on the shoulders of giants".

If AGW can be seen as the product of our science, then all roads lead back to Democritus, or his teacher Leucippus.

In this context, one could make the case that JC was instrumental in slowing its progress based on examples like Galileo, and the role that played in delaying the scientific revolution.
 
Back
Top