New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Debate polls

If the general public sees this debate as a draw that is a victory for Trump.
Instead, based on the CNN/ORC poll, they see it as the second-most severe butt-kicking in modern presidential debate history. Trump was beaten even worse than expected (poll respondents had expected a 58-32 Clinton win, and instead rated it a 62-27 Clinton win).

Trump could still bounce back. Think back to 2012, when Obama got beaten badly by Romney in the first debate and then won the next two plus the election. Obama underestimated his opponent and showed up ill-prepared. Trump clearly did the same -- thinking he could just lie and buffalo his way through the way he had in the Republican debates. But there's a big difference between trying to get noticed by some hard-core right-wingers in a crowded field, and trying to appeal to mainstream America in a one-on-one contest. He wasn't ready, and it showed. Will he do his homework before the next match? Or is he enough of an egotist that he'll expect to get by on his intellect (which he appraises highly) and "charm"? Clinton, whatever her faults, is a hard worker, and showed up ready. It really showed... if she wasn't relaxed, she had at least mastered a damned fine simulation of it. Everything Trump did to try to needle her was met with a grin and a ready rejoinder.
 
Yep. With online polls, you can set up bots. I remember how, for years, Ron Paul would absolutely dominate online polls during Republican primaries, even while he got infinitesimal support in real polls, and almost nobody turned up for him on election day. He just had a handful of hard-core zealots willing to sit around voting a hundred times by hand, or savvy enough to program a simple bot to do it for them, along with plenty willing to mail a link to the poll around to any friends they knew liked the guy. It's utterly meaningless.

true. thus, participants on both sides may be casting multiple 'bot' votes.
 
I found on showing Clinton winning, but by not so broad a margin.
Was that the one that tracked throughout the debate? I saw one like that, showing a tie early on, then a big lead for Clinton late on. When you averaged the results, you wind up with a smaller Clinton win.
 
Was that the one that tracked throughout the debate? I saw one like that, showing a tie early on, then a big lead for Clinton late on. When you averaged the results, you wind up with a smaller Clinton win.



something to that effect...yes.
time will tell
 
Instead, based on the CNN/ORC poll, they see it as the second-most severe butt-kicking in modern presidential debate history. Trump was beaten even worse than expected (poll respondents had expected a 58-32 Clinton win, and instead rated it a 62-27 Clinton win).

Trump could still bounce back. Think back to 2012, when Obama got beaten badly by Romney in the first debate and then won the next two plus the election. Obama underestimated his opponent and showed up ill-prepared. Trump clearly did the same -- thinking he could just lie and buffalo his way through the way he had in the Republican debates. But there's a big difference between trying to get noticed by some hard-core right-wingers in a crowded field, and trying to appeal to mainstream America in a one-on-one contest. He wasn't ready, and it showed. Will he do his homework before the next match. Or is he enough of an egotist that he'll expect to get by on his intellect (which he appraises highly) and "charm"?

Ummmm nobody cares.

These debates are not scored as if they are taking place in a college debating club. If they were scored on points then absolutely he got trounced. However, it doesn't matter.

Did Trump say enough to appeal to working class people? Did he say enough on trade to reach the people in the states he absolutely needs to win?
The bar for Trump is very low, all he has to do is show up and be plausible as President. He just needs people, especially people who do not like Hillary, to go "meh, he could be President"..........

Nobody expects him to show up and beat someone in a debate that has been doing this for 30yrs. But the fact that she cannot knock him out is telling.
 
It's a real poll. I'm not sure how to interpret its validity relative to the weighting of the audience towards the Democrats (relative to the weighting of likely voters). Presumably, since more people are Democrats, poll audiences tend to be weighted that way most of the time, so it should at least be a useful comparison to prior years.
Well of course it's a real poll just like your global warming and Obama reducing the deficit. In the short term seems lime it's real but in the long run...10 trillion of lefty debt later....meaningless.
 
So you're saying Trump is "unwell"? There are many reasons people sniff. Howard Dean may have hit the nail on the head.

You were addressing me.
Not sure where you see that I was addressing trump and sniffles...other than by your own design.
 
Instead, based on the CNN/ORC poll, they see it as the second-most severe butt-kicking in modern presidential debate history. Trump was beaten even worse than expected (poll respondents had expected a 58-32 Clinton win, and instead rated it a 62-27 Clinton win).

Trump could still bounce back. Think back to 2012, when Obama got beaten badly by Romney in the first debate and then won the next two plus the election. Obama underestimated his opponent and showed up ill-prepared. Trump clearly did the same -- thinking he could just lie and buffalo his way through the way he had in the Republican debates. But there's a big difference between trying to get noticed by some hard-core right-wingers in a crowded field, and trying to appeal to mainstream America in a one-on-one contest. He wasn't ready, and it showed. Will he do his homework before the next match? Or is he enough of an egotist that he'll expect to get by on his intellect (which he appraises highly) and "charm"? Clinton, whatever her faults, is a hard worker, and showed up ready. It really showed... if she wasn't relaxed, she had at least mastered a damned fine simulation of it. Everything Trump did to try to needle her was met with a grin and a ready rejoinder.

Agreed. There's no question Hillary won IMHO. Hillary looked fine and she had several if not more moments where she clearly knew and showed she was in control. Trump has his work cut out for him. If he's smart, he'll.... hell, I should have just given you an agree. Your entire post is spot on.
 
Yep. With online polls, you can set up bots. I remember how, for years, Ron Paul would absolutely dominate online polls during Republican primaries, even while he got infinitesimal support in real polls, and almost nobody turned up for him on election day. He just had a handful of hard-core zealots willing to sit around voting a hundred times by hand, or savvy enough to program a simple bot to do it for them, along with plenty willing to mail a link to the poll around to any friends they knew liked the guy. It's utterly meaningless.

A nice theory.. any proof?
 
Agreed. There's no question Hillary won IMHO. Hillary looked fine and she had several if not more moments where she clearly knew and showed she was in control. Trump has his work cut out for him. If he's smart, he'll.... hell, I should have just given you an agree. Your entire post is spot on.

To me, neither came off incredibly well over the other.

Hillary didn't look like she was taking anything seriously, and was very robotic. It appeared her strategy was to just smile and laugh at stuff as much as possible.

I mean, these are serious issues we're talking about, and if you're unwilling to be serious in talking about them, well, that's kind of odd.

I think the predictable happened:

Hillary recited her platitudes without any substance
Trump stumbled through long vague sentences.

Trump at least made a far greater effort to cite actual real instances, and he made many of them. Clinton stayed away from being detailed. She skimmed over the top of intellectualism and was 100% fluffy.

Trump looked annoyed at times, but who wouldn't be when your opponent refuses to debate topics and simply go into auto-tron mode.

The debates are already horrible as far as getting into any depth of issues, and then you have a Hillary Clinton who purposefully filibusters with platitudes.. it makes for very pointless events.
 
I wouldn't put too much stock in any "debate" poll. It's all just noise. I'm more interested in how the election polls change over the next few days. That will tell you who "won" the debate.

There was an interesting discussion this morning on my local FM morning music station. This isn't talk radio, it's a music station, but they were conducting a poll on who won the debate. About 20 minutes into it, the results were heavily favoring Trump, so the DJ, who I've never heard say anything particularly partisan, broke cover and implored listeners to go on the poll and "vote for Hillary to make it fair". I thought that was hilarious, and very telling, given this is Sacramento, CA. Not exactly red country.
 
Like Lukey I don't pay attention to debate polls or debates for that matter. And I didn't watch last night. My reason being the issues are more or less framed by the questions posed by the moderator. Whereas most voters consider other issues as well.

Hillary's health as an example. Or immigration. Or war. Think about it...whereas Democrats used to be anti-war, going back to LBJ's Viet Nam and GWB's Iraq, there's nary a peep from them on the last 8 years, which is partly owned by Hillary.

Were any of these issues discussed? Whether or not is immaterial...debate notwithstanding they are still issues of concern to voters.
 
Back
Top