New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Debate polls

Like Lukey I don't pay attention to debate polls or debates for that matter. And I didn't watch last night. My reason being the issues are more or less framed by the questions posed by the moderator. Whereas most voters consider other issues as well.

Hillary's health as an example. Or immigration. Or war. Think about it...whereas Democrats used to be anti-war, going back to LBJ's Viet Nam and GWB's Iraq, there's nary a peep from them on the last 8 years, which is partly owned by Hillary.

Were any of these issues discussed? Whether or not is immaterial...debate notwithstanding they are still issues of concern to voters.

Democrats haven't been anti-war since Vietnam. There was no anti-war movement during the Bush administration, it was just an anti-Bush movement, as evidenced by the fact it disappeared completely as soon as Obama took over.

Obama's administration has been marked by warfare, terrorism and bloodshed from day 1 to today, nearly eight solid years of war, and nothing from the left. They simply don't care. In fact, in the case of Hillary Clinton and her supporters, they actively long for it. War with Russia (and probably Syria, too) is inevitable if she becomes president.
 
Which poll(s) is the official poll of reference to enlighten interested parties as to the outcome of the debate last night?


Only poll I marginally buy into is the final tally on election day...

Everything else (poll wise) leading up to it is just manipulated fodder from either side.
 
PPP has a poll as well..still favoring Clinton, but not nearly as steep a margin. http://www.publicpolicypolling.com/pdf/2015/PPP_Release_PostDebatePoll_92616.pdf

real poll? where yes, perhaps the drubbing wasnt so bad.
Interesting. That's got a 41 to 32 split, Democrat to Republican (27 independent or third party). So, the difference probably comes down largely to PPP sampling more Republicans than CNN did.

One reason for Clinton supporters to be hopeful is that turnout favors Democrats. In mid-terms, which are decided by who has the hard-core voters who will turn out even in off-years, Republicans tend to out-perform. In presidential years, more people show up, which helps Democrats, since there are more Democrats in this country than Republicans, and more people who support liberal policies than conservative ones. This election is interesting enough that we'd expect high turnout, making the vote totals look more like America. That makes things tough on pollsters, though. If they peg "likely voters" to models based on past-year performance, they might under-sample those marginally-engaged Democrats and liberals. But if, instead, they just measure registered voters, they'll blow it badly if there isn't unusually high turnout.
 
Last edited:
. There was no anti-war movement during the Bush administration, it was just an anti-Bush movement.

I stand corrected. Street dems may have been against it, but the upper crust in Congress paved the way.

As for my topic of voter issues not addressed in the debate (as far as I know) another comes to mind....the FBI Director running interference for Hillary will surely influence right minded voters from both parties.
 
To me, neither came off incredibly well over the other.

Hillary didn't look like she was taking anything seriously, and was very robotic. It appeared her strategy was to just smile and laugh at stuff as much as possible.

I mean, these are serious issues we're talking about, and if you're unwilling to be serious in talking about them, well, that's kind of odd.

I think the predictable happened:

Hillary recited her platitudes without any substance
Trump stumbled through long vague sentences.

Trump at least made a far greater effort to cite actual real instances, and he made many of them. Clinton stayed away from being detailed. She skimmed over the top of intellectualism and was 100% fluffy.

Trump looked annoyed at times, but who wouldn't be when your opponent refuses to debate topics and simply go into auto-tron mode.

The debates are already horrible as far as getting into any depth of issues, and then you have a Hillary Clinton who purposefully filibusters with platitudes.. it makes for very pointless events.
Laughing Gas

Hillary won in the clinches but Trump threw some devastating punches. The strongest was about politicians painting pretty pictures but never getting anything done, which blew her nice presentation into a soap bubble.
 
Democrats haven't been anti-war since Vietnam. There was no anti-war movement during the Bush administration, it was just an anti-Bush movement, as evidenced by the fact it disappeared completely as soon as Obama took over.

There was definitely an anti-war movement. The Iraq War drew the biggest protests in history. For some that may have been anti-Bush, but you can't assume that just based on the protests losing steam once Obama took office, since Obama was doing what the protesters demanded. You don't protest success.

The anti-war fury had been about Iraq, not Afghanistan (there were few protests about Afghanistan in 2001, but plenty about Iraq in 2003), and Obama was drawing down our troops in Iraq quickly. We lost less than half as many troops in Iraq in 2009 as 2008, and less than half as many in 2010 as 2009. By 2012, we were down to just a single troop lost in Iraq. It's not easy organizing an anti-war protest for a war that's already being shut down at that pace. People were willing to grant Obama the benefit of the doubt, when it came to having a few years to wind things down, since he hadn't been the one who started the war.
 
Laughing Gas

Hillary won in the clinches but Trump threw some devastating punches. The strongest was about politicians painting pretty pictures but never getting anything done, which blew her nice presentation into a soap bubble.
To put it in sports terms, Trump took a few bites out of Clinton's ear, after getting frustrated about being out-boxed, but in the end it was a unanimous decision for Clinton. There's no sign he landed any devastating punches, judging by the very large victory numbers showing up in the post-debate polls for Clinton.
 
Which poll(s) is the official poll of reference to enlighten interested parties as to the outcome of the debate last night?
I think you would score this like Olympic diving.

throw out the 2 "outliers" (highest and lowest), then average the remaining ones.

on that basis trump appears to have more than 50%. Full disclosure - I did not actually watch the debate, because I do not intend to vote for either candidate, and don't want to get any more agitated than I already am.
 
Interesting. That's got a 41 to 32 split, Republican to Democrat (27 independent or third party). So, the difference probably comes down largely to PPP sampling more Republicans than CNN did.

One reason for Clinton supporters to be hopeful is that turnout favors Democrats. In mid-terms, which are decided by who has the hard-core voters who will turn out even in off-years, Republicans tend to out-perform. In presidential years, more people show up, which helps Democrats, since there are more Democrats in this country than Republicans, and more people who support liberal policies than conservative ones. This election is interesting enough that we'd expect high turnout, making the vote totals look more like America. That makes things tough on pollsters, though. If they peg "likely voters" to models based on past-year performance, they might under-sample those marginally-engaged Democrats and liberals. But if, instead, they just measure registered voters, they'll blow it badly if there isn't unusually high turnout.


41 to 31 dem over Rep (see Q13)
Democrat 41% ........................................................ Republican 32% ...................................................... 27% Independent/Another party .
 
41 to 31 dem over Rep (see Q13)
Democrat 41% ........................................................ Republican 32% ...................................................... 27% Independent/Another party .
I'm not sure what your response is supposed to mean. Q13 has a 41/32/27 split, consistent with what I said in my post, not 41/31.
 
I'm not sure what your response is supposed to mean. Q13 has a 41/32/27 split, consistent with what I said in my post, not 41/31.

typo on the 31/

you had it conflated.. democrats constituted 41%, not Repubs.. so a greater sampling of democrats in this instance as well
 
typo on the 31/

you had it conflated..
Sorry, you're right. My bad. I knew that it oversampled Democrats as well, but reversed that when I typed it. My point, though, is that PPP sampled more Republicans than CNN (32, which is more than CNN sampled).
 
Sorry, you're right. My bad. I knew that it oversampled Democrats as well, but reversed that when I typed it. My point, though, is that PPP sampled more Republicans than CNN (32, which is more than CNN sampled).

cool beans. point is, gap isnt so large...in this instance.
 
Instead, based on the CNN/ORC poll, they see it as the second-most severe butt-kicking in modern presidential debate history. Trump was beaten even worse than expected (poll respondents had expected a 58-32 Clinton win, and instead rated it a 62-27 Clinton win).

Trump could still bounce back. Think back to 2012, when Obama got beaten badly by Romney in the first debate and then won the next two plus the election. Obama underestimated his opponent and showed up ill-prepared. Trump clearly did the same -- thinking he could just lie and buffalo his way through the way he had in the Republican debates. But there's a big difference between trying to get noticed by some hard-core right-wingers in a crowded field, and trying to appeal to mainstream America in a one-on-one contest. He wasn't ready, and it showed. Will he do his homework before the next match? Or is he enough of an egotist that he'll expect to get by on his intellect (which he appraises highly) and "charm"? Clinton, whatever her faults, is a hard worker, and showed up ready. It really showed... if she wasn't relaxed, she had at least mastered a damned fine simulation of it. Everything Trump did to try to needle her was met with a grin and a ready rejoinder.

Clinton News Network would see that
 
Back
Top