New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Debunking the Nutting Debunking

Spamature

President
Sure he points out that bush's spending averaged 20.5% of GDP over his entire term. What he leaves out is the fact that it jumped to 25.24% in 2009 while it was on average much lower for the previous years. And what he's also hiding is which big spending programs had those increases between 2008 and 2009.

Defense
Jumps from 5.08% to 5.70% of GDP a 0.62% increase

awww_usgovernmentspending_com_usgs_line_php_c3fbfb681de29344c28e324a5c68b855._.png

Health Care

Jumped from 4.67% to 5.48% of GDP a 0.81% increase

awww_usgovernmentspending_com_usgs_line_php_52c54c2a796cc9643647e0320253413c._.png

Unemployment

Jumped from 0.32% to 0.88% of GDP a 0.56% increase and as the fall out from the bush era financial collapse mushroomed to 1.1% of GDP. pushing up the Obama total by 0.49%.

awww_usgovernmentspending_com_usgs_line_php_9bf24aeb683cb7461c596b9fce9ffea1._.png


Pensions
Jumped from 4.59% to 5.24% of GDP a 0.65% increase

awww_usgovernmentspending_com_usgs_line_php_14cff1c0f3e8aa04e713d4d6190de59a._.png


Spending increased under bush as a % of GDP by 2.64% from 2008 to 2009. With another 0.49% added on for good measure. And it not just because GDP dropped in 2008 to 2009. The increases are their when you use dollar values as well.

awww_usgovernmentspending_com_usgs_line_php_8cfe0d123a9312a398dce22e041a586d._.png


awww_usgovernmentspending_com_usgs_line_php_f0fd5a2c184ecf8d6a2247d776ccf2e9._.png


awww_usgovernmentspending_com_usgs_line_php_88e234b6fff4287083dea7aec2366650._.png


awww_usgovernmentspending_com_usgs_line_php_2360cc67a7e9f9143ca4a30b30424f06._.png


awww_usgovernmentspending_com_usgs_line_php_5449bc99e093be694ef97bb64ba25d82._.png



So we have bush in that year increasing spending in ways that weren't reversible by Obama without serious repercussions. What was he supposed to do. Become President Soup Nazi and tell retirees and the disabled, "no medicare or SS for you" ? Or Suddenly pull the troops off the battlefield in a massive "Cut and Run" (remember that slogan) Strategy ? Or to let the unemployed fall of edge of the earth while the economy was in a death spiral ?

The reason for Obama's higher spending as a percentage of GDP is because bush left a structural and crisis related spending lump of sh*t in his stocking after the election.
 
This is more about the things Obama won't do (and those that he did) rather than what Bush did.

This is one whole term, four years, and unemployment is STILL higher than when he took over, and we're only spending more money than the reckless Bush, while Obama kept in place the "reckless and destructive" Bush tax rates.

But you just want to keep making excuses. Unreal.
 
This is more about the things Obama won't do (and those that he did) rather than what Bush did.

This is one whole term, four years, and unemployment is STILL higher than when he took over, and we're only spending more money than the reckless Bush, while Obama kept in place the "reckless and destructive" Bush tax rates.

But you just want to keep making excuses. Unreal.

See now that isn't true if you look at his first full month in office the UE rate was 8.3% it's now 8.1% and there are more people employed today than during his first full month.

And don't start carping about tax cuts you support at the same time denouncing them. That is just personally dishonest.
 
I see you've already drawn the predictable response from Dino. Responsible governance has never been a republican strong point.
 
Obama is the one decidedly dishonest, as are the asskissers who kvetched endlessly as to all the damage these tax cuts did. Obama never had the courage to do away with them, and you Dems haven't had the intellect or the cojones to explain how they're damaging anything now. Just excuse-making.
Thanks for agreeing that unemployment is higher now than when he took over. Nice try with the cute spin, but I was right huh?
 
Obama is the one decidedly dishonest, as are the asskissers who kvetched endlessly as to all the damage these tax cuts did. Obama never had the courage to do away with them, and you Dems haven't had the intellect or the cojones to explain how they're damaging anything now. Just excuse-making.
Thanks for agreeing that unemployment is higher now than when he took over. Nice try with the cute spin, but I was right huh?

They did do damage and they still are. But what did more damage was setting up the economy to crash. Now the economy isn't in the kind of shape to end them without doing more damage. Obama from the outset said he wouldn't end the lower ones back before he was elected. I don't know why you are confused about that ?
Besides you were right there on the sidelines cheering on the Republicans holding the Unemployed hostage in order to have the very top end tax cuts extended. So I guess I can understand why you can't. You're confusing balls with brains and compassion.
 
You are totally mistaken, and perhaps ignorant.

I wanted to hold no one hostage. I was right here, explaining how actually unproductive extending the unemployment benfits was. I did this showing numerous studies from economists from all points on the political spectrum making their unerring case. That was not a point taken "hostage" it was shrewdly and crudely manipulated, to the country's damage, by Obama himself even though his advisers told him how unproductive the extension was.
He does things for POLITICAL reasons and you buy into it, while the country reaps the whirlwind.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/08/30/alan-krueger-unemployed-jobless_n_941713.html

Even President Obama’s pick for head of the Council of Economic Advisers, Alan B. Krueger, has acknowledged that increasing unemployment benefits prolongs unemployment, as conservatives were quick to point out when he was nominated in August.

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/07/b...nsion-of-jobless-benefits.html?pagewanted=all

http://illinoisreview.typepad.com/illinoisreview/2010/11/dont-extend-unemployment-benefits.html

http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2011/09/extended-ui-payments-do-not-benefit-the-economy

http://spectator.org/blog/2011/12/19/extending-unemployment-insuran

any stimulus from UI benefits will be counteracted by the anti-stimulus of the higher taxes needed to pay for them. Many states have been raising their UI taxes on businesses in order to replenish their unemployment funds, and these tax increases are surely harming job creation.

Another negative effect of UI benefits is that they increase unemployment because they reduce the incentive for people to find work. Higher UI benefits delay the need for people to make tough choices about their careers, such as switching industries, taking lower pay, or moving to a different city. It's a basic rule that when the government subsidizes something, we get more of it.
 
You have too many facts there, Spam. There will be no serious rebuttals. A chorus of crickets and a hate rant or two is all you'll get from the right on this one.

Obama could cure cancer and they'd say they liked cancer better. Or Mittwit would say he did it by calling for all funding for cancer research to be terminated. (It doesn't have to make sense. They'll buy it.)
 
Yeah, honesty sure is "predictable" in the fact of liberal lies and spin.

Whooops, Spam stepped in shit and you followed him in to point it out.
 
Since when has honesty been a republican hallmark???

Not since Ike. The next Republican was Nixon and they've gone steadily downhill from there. Every Republican President since Nixon has lied as much or more than he did and about more critical matters. Pugs call treachery against the country patriotism.

Now one has to be a shameless liar to be a loyal Republican, it would seem. Mittwit is the Messiah for liars and hypocrites. He has it down to a science and he knows his guinea pigs.
 
Simple question. During this period what was the average of job seekers per job opening ?

I ask this question because you and your links present the idea that ending UE benefits would somehow increase job openings. It looks to be that they and your were in fact arguing the failed policy of austerity. Where the govt reduces spending to bolster business. It was argued back then that it wouldn't work. And has by now been proven NOT to work. In fact just this week the G8 members decided to back Obama's view as opposed to those who support austerity.
 
It's all bullsh!t. They are trying to charge Bush with the Porkulus giveaway money. It's underhanded stuff but so ridiculous that not even Democrats will buy into it.
Shows how desperate you are.
 
Nope

Only 85 billion of the stimulus was even spent by Sept 1 of the of Fiscal Year 09 The fiscal year ends on the 30th. Tax cuts made up most of the cost of stimulus used in that fiscal year. Not even sure if it was included in the charts. As I pointed out to a poster the other day. 40% of the stimulus that was actual spending and not tax cuts is still unspent including allocated and unallocated funds.
 
Lots of "facts", however the chronology and who the spending is attributed to sure was skewed, wasn't it?

Oh wait. You didn't bother to check, never mind.
 
So, like, then why hasn't he been able to reduce spending from that "emergency" elevated level in any of the subsequent years that he has been in office?
 
Back
Top