New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Deportation

The President has indicated he wants to speed up deportations of those entering the country illegally. Easier said than done:

Thousands of children from Central America are undertaking a perilous journey to the U.S. border despite warnings from the U.S. that they will be sent back. In fact, many will get to stay.

Data from immigration courts, along with interviews with the children and their advocates, show that few minors are sent home and many are able to stay for years in the U.S., if not permanently. That presents a deep challenge for President Barack Obama and lawmakers as they try to shore up an overburdened deportation system.

In fiscal year 2013, immigration judges ordered 3,525 migrant children to be deported, according to Justice Department figures. Judges allowed an additional 888 to voluntarily return home without a formal removal order.

Those figures pale in comparison with the number of children apprehended by the border patrol. In each of the last five years, at least 23,000 and as many as 47,000 juveniles have been apprehended. Those totals include Mexicans, who often are sent home without formal deportation proceedings and so may not be among those ordered removed last year.


There are many reasons children end up staying. Some see their cases linger in backlogged courts and administrative proceedings. Some win the legal right to remain in the U.S. And some ignore orders to appear in court.

Children who enter the U.S. illegally often are trying to reunite with family members or escaping gang violence and poverty. The U.S. has been overwhelmed finding shelters for them, and Mr. Obama has repeatedly said that they won't be allowed to stay. But the reality on the ground—that so few are returned to their home countries—will continue to encourage more to make the journey north, said Doris Meissner, director of the Immigration Policy Program at the nonpartisan Migration Policy Institute.

"They're here, and they're staying, and whatever else might happen to them is at least a year or more away," said Ms. Meissner, a former Immigration and Naturalization Service commissioner. "Until people's experience changes, more are going to continue to come, because they're achieving what they need: safety and reunification with their families."


http://online.wsj.com/articles/few-children-are-deported-1405036369


It's not going to be an easy fix, and both political parties know that. The one thing that Congress and President Obama have in common is incompetence. Both sides will angle to ascribe blame for this mess on the other side, and I'm sure some partisan hacks will gobble that up with a spoon. None of that will help even when child.

Faith in politicians is faith wasted.

Thanks for posting this one. It's a useful and objective recitation of the facts around all this. But, I don't agree that it's a matter of incompetence. I think it's more a matter of all sorts of conflicting and unspoken agendas.

I'll offer up just one example out of many. This one revolves around the GOP, but there are just as many involving Dems.
It's useful for a GOP to speechify that these children should be deported. BUT...the last thing that GOP wants is to be associated with a specific story about a specfic child being strapped into a plane and flown off to the hellhole from whence she came.
 
Thanks for posting this one. It's a useful and objective recitation of the facts around all this. But, I don't agree that it's a matter of incompetence. I think it's more a matter of all sorts of conflicting and unspoken agendas.

I'll offer up just one example out of many. This one revolves around the GOP, but there are just as many involving Dems.
It's useful for a GOP to speechify that these children should be deported. BUT...the last thing that GOP wants is to be associated with a specific story about a specfic child being strapped into a plane and flown off to the hellhole from whence she came.

Indeed, they would rather have target practice on the kids. The Righties shall be positioned up in tower and below someone would let the kids go.. And to prove how sporting they (Righties) are they would give the kids a count of 8 head start before they started opening fire at him (or her) with their laser sights or their scopes mounted on their .223 or .308 caliber semi auto rifles.

Oh what fun they would have!!! Rick Perry is already down there. He, like most of his Righty comrades, has a TERRORIST HUNTING LICENSE decal on his truck and he can't wait for it to be open season on these disease riddled dirty filthy illegal kids! Kids that are all Obama's fault. He invited them and wants them to infect America cause he hates America, the REAL America, is how the Righties actually think!
 
the press has been largely silent on two questions:

1 - how serious/notable are the "warnings" by the USA that new arrivals will be sent back. Do they have examples of such warnings? And if they do, are such warnings credible if no one is - in fact - being sent back?

2 - "reunite with relatives" is heard constantly, and is becoming a cliche. Are the relatives these "kids" seek to reunite with ACTUAL parents, or siblings, aunts/uncles, etc? And what right do you have to reunite with your parents if THEY are here illegally, and simply awaiting apprehension and deportation for illegal entry?
Thanks for posting this one. It's a useful and objective recitation of the facts around all this. But, I don't agree that it's a matter of incompetence. I think it's more a matter of all sorts of conflicting and unspoken agendas.

I'll offer up just one example out of many. This one revolves around the GOP, but there are just as many involving Dems.
It's useful for a GOP to speechify that these children should be deported. BUT...the last thing that GOP wants is to be associated with a specific story about a specfic child being strapped into a plane and flown off to the hellhole from whence she came.
America is constantly urging nations around the world to receive refugees from their neighbors, but when children come streaming to our borders from our neighbors, we say "no way, dont come here for refuge"

Somewhere at the base of the statute of Liberty, there's a plaque with a poem about sending your huddled masses yearning to be free, but its just an old poem about yester-year. America is no longer a refuge for anybody.
 
America is constantly urging nations around the world to receive refugees from their neighbors, but when children come streaming to our borders from our neighbors, we say "no way, dont come here for refuge"

Somewhere at the base of the statute of Liberty, there's a plaque with a poem about sending your huddled masses yearning to be free, but its just an old poem about yester-year. America is no longer a refuge for anybody.

That was a great sentiment when you came here and lived or died by your own perseverance, or good or bad luck.

Now you come here you get medical care,food and an education all on someone else's dime. If you want to go back to the time when they lived or died based on their own good fortune, did not attend schools they didn't pay for, eat food they didn't purchase with their own money... then we can go back to refugees. Moreover.... in other countries with refugees they are kept under guard, not allowed to leave and merge into the population. If that is how you want us to handle that - I guess that is also fine. Whatever will reduce the burden to the country at large to have to absorb people who will be nothing but a drain on resources. Several years of living in what amounts to a concentration camp may make their homeland more attractive.

connie
 
That was a great sentiment when you came here and lived or died by your own perseverance, or good or bad luck.

Now you come here you get medical care,food and an education all on someone else's dime. If you want to go back to the time when they lived or died based on their own good fortune, did not attend schools they didn't pay for, eat food they didn't purchase with their own money... then we can go back to refugees. Moreover.... in other countries with refugees they are kept under guard, not allowed to leave and merge into the population. If that is how you want us to handle that - I guess that is also fine. Whatever will reduce the burden to the country at large to have to absorb people who will be nothing but a drain on resources. Several years of living in what amounts to a concentration camp may make their homeland more attractive.

connie



"Ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your country."

Funny how some people sneer at that notion now. Some believe the country should be doing for them all day long every day.

Pity.
 
America is constantly urging nations around the world to receive refugees from their neighbors, but when children come streaming to our borders from our neighbors, we say "no way, dont come here for refuge"

Somewhere at the base of the statute of Liberty, there's a plaque with a poem about sending your huddled masses yearning to be free, but its just an old poem about yester-year. America is no longer a refuge for anybody.

Republicans: Not in my backyard Queens!
 
That was a great sentiment when you came here and lived or died by your own perseverance, or good or bad luck.

Now you come here you get medical care,food and an education all on someone else's dime. If you want to go back to the time when they lived or died based on their own good fortune, did not attend schools they didn't pay for, eat food they didn't purchase with their own money... then we can go back to refugees. Moreover.... in other countries with refugees they are kept under guard, not allowed to leave and merge into the population. If that is how you want us to handle that - I guess that is also fine. Whatever will reduce the burden to the country at large to have to absorb people who will be nothing but a drain on resources. Several years of living in what amounts to a concentration camp may make their homeland more attractive.

connie
I don't know Connie, that reads like someone who hasn't any idea what really happens to refugees that come here. Come to Chicago and I'll show you what they are really doing ... working 60 hours a week at slave labor jobs.
 
I don't know Connie, that reads like someone who hasn't any idea what really happens to refugees that come here. Come to Chicago and I'll show you what they are really doing ... working 60 hours a week at slave labor jobs.

Indeed Connie and Carol seem to have decided they want to remain firmly imbedded in LaLa land and no amount of truth or facts will affect them! They prefer being dumb and angry! (Mostly over things that are not true!)
 
379656_166179776891990_161814321_n.jpg
 
Indeed Connie and Carol seem to have decided they want to remain firmly imbedded in LaLa land and no amount of truth or facts will affect them! They prefer being dumb and angry! (Mostly over things that are not true!)

It's spectacular to watch, in that horrible car wreck way.

It doesn't appear there is a way to reach the minds of many on the right. Once a bit of information, most likely entirely incorrect, gets into their brain, it cannot be dislodged.

People keep talking about Mexico...even as every article explains that this border problem doesn't feature Mexicans. They keep asking "when" these people became refugees and they cannot find room in their brain for the law that Bush signed in 2008. And the Homeland Security law signed in 2002.

They of course will never mention that the Senate passed an immigration bill, S.744, last year and it has been sitting on Boehner's desk for 15 months.
 
I would say to all those believe that what is happening on the border is business as usual, or that it is no big deal, that if possible you should take a trip to the Rio Grande Valley and see it for yourself. Until you do, you will be profoundly ignorant of what is taking place there. See it with your own eyes, and then pontificate.
 
I would say to all those believe that what is happening on the border is business as usual, or that it is no big deal, that if possible you should take a trip to the Rio Grande Valley and see it for yourself. Until you do, you will be profoundly ignorant of what is taking place there. See it with your own eyes, and then pontificate.
my understanding is we are receiving refugees from Central America. I seem to remember the same thing when Reagan was president, but I can't remember anyone blaming it on Reagan. BTW, I moved to NYC in 1987 and lived with one of those refugees; he came to NYC at the age of 15 and he was a trader on Wall Street. See, when Christians behave like Christians and help out, good things happen. But when Christians behave like dry rot and refuse to help out, bad things happen. That's why St Paul admonished us to maintain good works.

When I discover posters on the forum preaching genocide against muslems, and the idiot thinks he's a Christian, and the supposed Christian mods won't ban the POS, then I really question how far the supposed Christians on the forum have fallen from the faith. America has always been a refuge for the poor of the world because it was a Christian nation. Christians didn't believe in genocide. And not too long ago, anyone preaching genocide on this forum would have been banned in a heartbeat.

update: I guess the guy is a zionist... does that make preaching genocide against muslems okay?
 
Last edited:
.......border agents have even found muslim prayer rugs............

Your Bigotry and Xenophobia knows no boundry, Dawgy. Prayer rugs in your polluted brain automatically means terrorist. Shut Bill O'Reilly OFF. He is ruining the last few brain cells you possess, Dawgy.
 
I don't know Connie, that reads like someone who hasn't any idea what really happens to refugees that come here. Come to Chicago and I'll show you what they are really doing ... working 60 hours a week at slave labor jobs.

yes, they work for slave labor jobs - and you know what that qualifies them for - benefits. And lots of them. The vast majority of them will be net tax drains. they will take more in Gov't services then they will ever pay in in taxes. I never said they didn't work or were otherwise lazy, but yes, they will cost us a bundle. They will cost us in the services they consume. They will cost food stamps. They will cost in section 8 housing, Their kids will cost more than average to educate. If they live to be old - they will cost more in medicare than they will have ever paid in, including employer contributions. I am tired of importing poverty that I am then expected to pay for.
 
Indeed Connie and Carol seem to have decided they want to remain firmly imbedded in LaLa land and no amount of truth or facts will affect them! They prefer being dumb and angry! (Mostly over things that are not true!)

What truth.. that these people will consume resources out of my tax dollar. That is the only truth I care about. I am not angry nor am I dumb. But, I am apathtetic of their problems and am by far more concerned about how much money this will cost me.

connie
 
yes, they work for slave labor jobs - and you know what that qualifies them for - benefits. And lots of them. The vast majority of them will be net tax drains. they will take more in Gov't services then they will ever pay in in taxes. I never said they didn't work or were otherwise lazy, but yes, they will cost us a bundle. They will cost us in the services they consume. They will cost food stamps. They will cost in section 8 housing, Their kids will cost more than average to educate. If they live to be old - they will cost more in medicare than they will have ever paid in, including employer contributions. I am tired of importing poverty that I am then expected to pay for.

Connie, have you ever applied for medicare? Do you really believe that illegal immigrants can get those benefits? I'm on medicare, I can assure you, it isn't given out willy nilly to anyone who asks for it. Even food stamps are not available to those people, that's why Obama is asking Congress for money to care for the refugees, the system wont take care of them; illegal immigrants are a pain in the ass duplicating Soc Sec numbers, but guess what; the govt knows what is going on.

At any rate, these kids coming from Central America are not illegal immigrants from mexico, these are refugees. Do you understand the difference?
 
Connie, have you ever applied for medicare? Do you really believe that illegal immigrants can get those benefits? I'm on medicare, I can assure you, it isn't given out willy nilly to anyone who asks for it. Even food stamps are not available to those people, that's why Obama is asking Congress for money to care for the refugees, the system wont take care of them; illegal immigrants are a pain in the ass duplicating Soc Sec numbers, but guess what; the govt knows what is going on.

At any rate, these kids coming from Central America are not illegal immigrants from mexico, these are refugees. Do you understand the difference?

No they can not get medicare while they are illegal. They can go to the hospital though and skip out on the bill with basically no recourse.

My points were about once they are absorbed and made legal. It is importing poverty. If you want to house them as refugees and not allow them to slip into the system and be ultimately forced to return... fine. I am all for having some food drives and some blanket drives, etc. But, No, i do not support allowing them to be a drain on the local tax payer - particularly via education that they don't pay for and free and reduced lunches they will qualify for. I know they don't all come from Mexico. I don't care where they come from.. I simply don't want to pay to educate them or feed and house and clothe them. Send them back from wherever it was to they came from. And, if we can't do that - keep them in refugee camps and provide the bare necessities as happens in the rest of the world.

connie
 
No they can not get medicare while they are illegal. They can go to the hospital though and skip out on the bill with basically no recourse.

My points were about once they are absorbed and made legal. It is importing poverty. If you want to house them as refugees and not allow them to slip into the system and be ultimately forced to return... fine. I am all for having some food drives and some blanket drives, etc. But, No, i do not support allowing them to be a drain on the local tax payer - particularly via education that they don't pay for and free and reduced lunches they will qualify for. I know they don't all come from Mexico. I don't care where they come from.. I simply don't want to pay to educate them or feed and house and clothe them. Send them back from wherever it was to they came from. And, if we can't do that - keep them in refugee camps and provide the bare necessities as happens in the rest of the world.

connie

Its a lot cheaper to educate them and make them productive members of society.
 
Its a lot cheaper to educate them and make them productive members of society.

You assume they would actually be productive members of society. You presume they would get a job at upper middle class - which is what they would need to get in order to cover all the costs since they came here.

The reality is - we make hte process expensive with all the legal rangling. It is very simple. You either produce a birth certificate, green card or other info - your back you go. Bus them back over the the border and let them off. Or fly them back to whatever country they claim as their home country - and that is it. one or two days, max. After they arell shipped back time and time again, they will quit coming.

connie
 
Back
Top