New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Deportation

You assume they would actually be productive members of society. You presume they would get a job at upper middle class - which is what they would need to get in order to cover all the costs since they came here.

The reality is - we make hte process expensive with all the legal rangling. It is very simple. You either produce a birth certificate, green card or other info - your back you go. Bus them back over the the border and let them off. Or fly them back to whatever country they claim as their home country - and that is it. one or two days, max. After they arell shipped back time and time again, they will quit coming.

connie

Bullshitt, connie. You do NOT have any idea of "the costs". Most contribute far more than they "cost". This RIGHT WING LIE about these people who come here to work or escape prosecution is just made up hate and not based on any reality. I live in area where illegals are used to pick grapes. They work hard and complain little and pay taxes. So, stop with all the Rush LimbBalls LIES about these people costing us or getting all this FREE shitt, They don't. Most live in the shadows and work very very very hard. Far harder than most "real" Americans!
 
You assume they would actually be productive members of society. You presume they would get a job at upper middle class - which is what they would need to get in order to cover all the costs since they came here.

The reality is - we make hte process expensive with all the legal rangling. It is very simple. You either produce a birth certificate, green card or other info - your back you go. Bus them back over the the border and let them off. Or fly them back to whatever country they claim as their home country - and that is it. one or two days, max. After they arell shipped back time and time again, they will quit coming.

connie
You assume a lot of hard costs to educate them. Its not really the case. We have a public school system that is going to operate, regardless, and employing more teachers is not exactly the same thing as throwing money into a black hole. They don't have to become upper middle class to carry their own weight, lower middle class doesn't qualify for food stamps or medical benefits, so if they reach that high, its a success story. I've spent my whole life helping people reach for that... its a very rewarding vocation.
 
Bullshitt, connie. You do NOT have any idea of "the costs". Most contribute far more than they "cost". This RIGHT WING LIE about these people who come here to work or escape prosecution is just made up hate and not based on any reality. I live in area where illegals are used to pick grapes. They work hard and complain little and pay taxes. So, stop with all the Rush LimbBalls LIES about these people costing us or getting all this FREE shitt, They don't. Most live in the shadows and work very very very hard. Far harder than most "real" Americans!

I don't know what the F- Rush Limbaugh has to say on the topic. But, I do know taxes. I know darn well what people pay in taxes - and I can tell you that your average family of 4 making less than 60K a year COSTS the system in services they receive - including the education of their kids - more than they pay in fed, state, property and sales taxes combined.

I am not denying they work hard. But, that does not equate to actually paying more in to the system than they get out of it. Get over your emotional reaction to this issue and look at it from strictly dollars and cents. THAT is all that matters.
 
You assume a lot of hard costs to educate them. Its not really the case. We have a public school system that is going to operate, regardless, and employing more teachers is not exactly the same thing as throwing money into a black hole. They don't have to become upper middle class to carry their own weight, lower middle class doesn't qualify for food stamps or medical benefits, so if they reach that high, its a success story. I've spent my whole life helping people reach for that... its a very rewarding vocation.

I know that it costs an average of 11K per kid per year. So if you have two kids you put through public education it costs $264,000 to educate those kids. What low income family do you know who has paid that much in taxes over the course of 20 years? - let alone what other benefits they may have gotten from time to time, and forgetting the social security and medicare taxes they will get more out of than they pay in.

They do have to become upper middle class to carry their weight. Most middle class taxpayers - who have a family - are not paying in what they get or have available for services. Period. Certainly low income families are not. Not when you look at the average amount they will collect from SS, from medicare expenses, from education expenses, to emergency services, other subsidies and aid they may qualify for, etc.

Seriously - sit down and do the math. Look at your own paystub or tax return. And, then go look up the per capita cost of fire and emergency services. Look up how much you have used in medicare services since you have been on it. Calculate how much you and your employer paid in for SS taxes and look at how much you are getting back and likely to get back.

connie
 
I don't know what the F- Rush Limbaugh has to say on the topic. But, I do know taxes. I know darn well what people pay in taxes - and I can tell you that your average family of 4 making less than 60K a year COSTS the system in services they receive - including the education of their kids - more than they pay in fed, state, property and sales taxes combined.

I am not denying they work hard. But, that does not equate to actually paying more in to the system than they get out of it. Get over your emotional reaction to this issue and look at it from strictly dollars and cents. THAT is all that matters.

I am looking at it from dollars and sense and also from a standpoint of Truthyness. Most people who come here to work, work hard and live in the shadows and are NOT parasites like so many "real Americans" actually are. I have family members who are far right wing nuts. They call themselves "Real Americans" and they love Sarah Palin. They hear some story about the foreigners getting all these benefits and they repeat the lie. Meanwhile they are BOTH retired / disabled and they are huge drains on the system because they are always at the doctors and "needing" western medicine for their blood pressure, bad heart, bad knees etc etc etc.

Stop telling me I am emotional.

You are blinded by your right wing ideals.
 
I am looking at it from dollars and sense and also from a standpoint of Truthyness. Most people who come here to work, work hard and live in the shadows and are NOT parasites like so many "real Americans" actually are. I have family members who are far right wing nuts. They clal them selves "real Americans" and they love Sarah Palin. They hear some story about the foreigners getting all these benefits and they repeat the lie. Meanwhile they are BOTH retired / disabled and they are huge drains on the system because they are always at the doctors and "needing" western medicine for their blood pressure, bad heart, bad knees etc etc etc.

Stop telling me I am emotional.

You are blinded by your right wing ideals.


You are emotional - look at your blabbering about Sarah Palin. I didn't deny that there are plenty of american sucking off the system costing more than they have ever or will ever pay in. I would to ship them out, too . But, what we don't need is to import more of the same. And, from a strictly dollars to cents perspective a middle to lower middle class family of 4 - is a net drain on what they pay in and what they get back out. That is quantifiable. Spend some time doing the math yourself. I don't care what they do or how hard they work... That is immaterial. How much will they pay in in taxes - and how much will they get back in benefits and services. Very simple question. And, while they live in the shadows they may be paying more in - but when they are legitimized and can claim social security and medicare - it is a different ball game. It is a different situation too if they are single or if they have a family. Which is why I do support a guest worker program where people can come and work hard- and keep the expensive stuff - their dependents - back home.

connie
 
I know that it costs an average of 11K per kid per year. So if you have two kids you put through public education it costs $264,000 to educate those kids. What low income family do you know who has paid that much in taxes over the course of 20 years? - let alone what other benefits they may have gotten from time to time, and forgetting the social security and medicare taxes they will get more out of than they pay in.

They do have to become upper middle class to carry their weight. Most middle class taxpayers - who have a family - are not paying in what they get or have available for services. Period. Certainly low income families are not. Not when you look at the average amount they will collect from SS, from medicare expenses, from education expenses, to emergency services, other subsidies and aid they may qualify for, etc.

Seriously - sit down and do the math. Look at your own paystub or tax return. And, then go look up the per capita cost of fire and emergency services. Look up how much you have used in medicare services since you have been on it. Calculate how much you and your employer paid in for SS taxes and look at how much you are getting back and likely to get back.

connie
It doesn't flesh out badly at all if they achieve lower middle class. Its way worse if you pen them up somewhere and pay for everything their whole lives. Have you averaged in the occasional millionaire that comes from these refugees? Billionaire? See the whole picture and it makes much more sense to educate them and give them opportunity. A little bit of dignity pays big dividends. Strip them of that and you will create another monster far worse than the one you are dealing with.
 
It doesn't flesh out badly at all if they achieve lower middle class. Its way worse if you pen them up somewhere and pay for everything their whole lives. Have you averaged in the occasional millionaire that comes from these refugees? Billionaire? See the whole picture and it makes much more sense to educate them and give them opportunity. A little bit of dignity pays big dividends. Strip them of that and you will create another monster far worse than the one you are dealing with.

No penning them up is not a good option. Shippping them back from whence they came until they can prove they are fully self supporting and a likely net tax contributor is the best thing. And, yes, I am familiar with millionaires and billionaires that come from them. How many do you think they make up for/ How many ultimately decide then to take their millions and billions and go back home or to some other tax favorable country - like one of the founders of facebook or was it google... anyway... the reality is in this country - if you are a middle income tax payer with a family - you are barely breaking even as a tax contributor. I am quite frankly tired of financing the ones already here. I am damn sure I don't want to finance any others. Send them back until they can prove they are self supporting AND will contribute to the coffers.
 
No penning them up is not a good option. Shippping them back from whence they came until they can prove they are fully self supporting and a likely net tax contributor is the best thing. And, yes, I am familiar with millionaires and billionaires that come from them. How many do you think they make up for/ How many ultimately decide then to take their millions and billions and go back home or to some other tax favorable country - like one of the founders of facebook or was it google... anyway... the reality is in this country - if you are a middle income tax payer with a family - you are barely breaking even as a tax contributor. I am quite frankly tired of financing the ones already here. I am damn sure I don't want to finance any others. Send them back until they can prove they are self supporting AND will contribute to the coffers.
Isn't the core idea behind receiving refugees built around the reality that they are running for their lives? I thought the whole reason you don't send refugees back is because it is a death sentence, that they ran from where ever because they would not survive there. Are you saying that you don't really believe they are refugees or are you really that cold hearted? The money is all created out of thin air any way, the real measure of cost is whether we will give of our lives, and that has a way of paying you back.
 
Isn't the core idea behind receiving refugees built around the reality that they are running for their lives? I thought the whole reason you don't send refugees back is because it is a death sentence, that they ran from where ever because they would not survive there. Are you saying that you don't really believe they are refugees or are you really that cold hearted? The money is all created out of thin air any way, the real measure of cost is whether we will give of our lives, and that has a way of paying you back.

I do not believe they are really refugees. I think that life likely really sucks where htey come from and that some may have been in danger where they lived in their country but could likely be resettled elsewhere in their own country and be out of imminent harm. The idea behind refugees from war is that they stay along the border of the country they come into- which in this case would have been Mexico first, then when the violence tamps down they are sent back home. By and large they are not integrated by their host countries. If you want to treat these refugees like that fine but that does not involve integrating and educating them. I am content to provide them the bare necessities for their survival until they can be returned to their own country.

connie
 
I do not believe they are really refugees. I think that life likely really sucks where htey come from and that some may have been in danger where they lived in their country but could likely be resettled elsewhere in their own country and be out of imminent harm. The idea behind refugees from war is that they stay along the border of the country they come into- which in this case would have been Mexico first, then when the violence tamps down they are sent back home. By and large they are not integrated by their host countries. If you want to treat these refugees like that fine but that does not involve integrating and educating them. I am content to provide them the bare necessities for their survival until they can be returned to their own country.

connie
My gist on this, and I am not sure also, is these are economic refugees, not war refugees. Which would explain why they didn't stop in Mexico. It does seem weird for children to be traveling all the way from Central America to USA. That, in itself, speaks of desperation. We get a lot of illegal immigrants from Mexico seeking a better life, but they would not be dead on arrival if we return them. It is kind of like dipping water from the lower pond and returning it to the upper pond; they just come back over and over. Law enforcement is built on the idea of punishment for those living here, it doesn't work on volumes of people crossing borders. Arizona doesn't have the facilities to jail millions of people at their borders. So there's no real answer. The refugees from Central America seem to have coincided with the Mexican wave and we are lumping the two together, but they are separate events requiring separate solutions. We can't just dump these kids into Mexico, they didn't come from there.

Its frustrating, but the best solution is to just open our hearts and wallets and educate them and hope for the best.
 
My gist on this, and I am not sure also, is these are economic refugees, not war refugees. Which would explain why they didn't stop in Mexico. It does seem weird for children to be traveling all the way from Central America to USA. That, in itself, speaks of desperation. We get a lot of illegal immigrants from Mexico seeking a better life, but they would not be dead on arrival if we return them. It is kind of like dipping water from the lower pond and returning it to the upper pond; they just come back over and over. Law enforcement is built on the idea of punishment for those living here, it doesn't work on volumes of people crossing borders. Arizona doesn't have the facilities to jail millions of people at their borders. So there's no real answer. The refugees from Central America seem to have coincided with the Mexican wave and we are lumping the two together, but they are separate events requiring separate solutions. We can't just dump these kids into Mexico, they didn't come from there.

Its frustrating, but the best solution is to just open our hearts and wallets and educate them and hope for the best.


Yeah um.. no that is not the best solution. The best solution for the taxpayers of the US is to send them home or send them back across the border they illegally crossed. I they are turned away time and time again, if they are immediately shipped back - not in weeks, months years, but in days. They will stop coming. I am sorry but i have no intention of tacking the poverty problems in Mexico, Central America or anywhere else. I am far more intersted in protecting my lifestyle, my way of life and the lifestyle I hope to provide for my children. I will not pay, at any expense to my children's future, for a better future for someone else's kid. I won't go out of my way to hurt them, take from them, etc.. but this is a battle between what is best for my kids and what is best for someone else's kids. And, I choose mine.

connie
 
Back
Top