New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Does anyone else find it confounding...

Lukey

Senator
That the lefties, who rail about market derived prices being too high as a result of the "greed" of capitalists, will turn around and tell you that whatever your taxes are, that just the "price" of living in society and you should pay them without question? It's one of life's little mysteries...
 
That the lefties, who rail about market derived prices being too high as a result of the "greed" of capitalists, will turn around and tell you that whatever your taxes are, that just the "price" of living in society and you should pay them without question? It's one of life's little mysteries...

Its just evidence of their hypocrisy and hubris.
 
Yes, according to the left, markets are "greedy" but governments never are.

What they never grasp or intentionally ignore, is that Gov'ts like Markets, are simply made up by humans. and anything touched by humans can be corrupted. And, day after day when we sit here and argue with each other, and call each other stupid, idiots, whatever... keep in mind that those same people can work for the Gov't. Can be making calls that affect their lives. Why then if so many other people are stupid arseholes, would we want them to have anything more than the absolutely bare minimum say over us? I wouldn't. But, it never fails to amaze me how whenever we talk of Gov't - it is good and noble.. but people themselves, are not. There must be some magical power that turns greedy arsehold people into benevolent masters when they get into gov't. That kind of naivete is mind boggling.
 
What they never grasp or intentionally ignore, is that Gov'ts like Markets, are simply made up by humans. and anything touched by humans can be corrupted. And, day after day when we sit here and argue with each other, and call each other stupid, idiots, whatever... keep in mind that those same people can work for the Gov't. Can be making calls that affect their lives. Why then if so many other people are stupid arseholes, would we want them to have anything more than the absolutely bare minimum say over us? I wouldn't. But, it never fails to amaze me how whenever we talk of Gov't - it is good and noble.. but people themselves, are not. There must be some magical power that turns greedy arsehold people into benevolent masters when they get into gov't. That kind of naivete is mind boggling.

I think it all goes back to the innate lefty desire to control what others can and can't do. Each and every one of them (even the so-called "social libertarians"), deep down inside, would rather we all be under the thumb of government than free to associate (as in markets). They are closet authoritarians. It's not really the markets that they fear, it's the freedom. Their fear is that some where some one might be doing something they do not approve of...
 
I think it all goes back to the innate lefty desire to control what others can and can't do. Each and every one of them (even the so-called "social libertarians"), deep down inside, would rather we all be under the thumb of government than free to associate (as in markets). They are closet authoritarians. It's not really the markets that they fear, it's the freedom. Their fear is that some where some one might be doing something they do not approve of...

I completely agree. I always laugh when I hear a lefty say "there needs to be a rule". Why? WTF do we need more rules?Why the hell can't you just go about your business, mind your own Fning business and allow me to mind mine? But, like you said, I think they like rules, they like to be bossed around and controlled and to control. It is a strange phenomenon. Like HOA's. I got into an argument with Bo about them years ago. But, I find it funny that anyone who is "liberal" would want to live in a place that had rules about what you could or could not do on your own property ( outside true public safety and environmental hazards). Why would anyone subject themselves to that. But, then yo ufind out those freaks are the ones on the board, and what they really want to do is control what everyone else is doing.

and, its like helmet laws and seatbelt laws. Look, if you want to make yourself a projectile at 65 MPH - that is your call. I won't cry for you when you do though, and your stupidity should not be anyone else's cost to bear. But, I'll be damned if I will insist that there is a rule that you have to buckle yourself in.
 
I completely agree. I always laugh when I hear a lefty say "there needs to be a rule". Why? WTF do we need more rules?Why the hell can't you just go about your business, mind your own Fning business and allow me to mind mine? But, like you said, I think they like rules, they like to be bossed around and controlled and to control. It is a strange phenomenon. Like HOA's. I got into an argument with Bo about them years ago. But, I find it funny that anyone who is "liberal" would want to live in a place that had rules about what you could or could not do on your own property ( outside true public safety and environmental hazards). Why would anyone subject themselves to that. But, then yo ufind out those freaks are the ones on the board, and what they really want to do is control what everyone else is doing.

and, its like helmet laws and seatbelt laws. Look, if you want to make yourself a projectile at 65 MPH - that is your call. I won't cry for you when you do though, and your stupidity should not be anyone else's cost to bear. But, I'll be damned if I will insist that there is a rule that you have to buckle yourself in.

It's the "collective" mentality. The hive is more important than the bees to them (which, of course, is absurd).
 
It's the "collective" mentality. The hive is more important than the bees to them (which, of course, is absurd).

We had a get together with friends a few weeks ago and living in this blue state, quite a few are democrats and they were busy with their rules, and how things should be, etc. And, I siad, why really can we not all simply be polite yet ignore each other. I don't want to know my neighbors. I want to come home, go into my house, and be polite and considerate but ignore everyone else who is not a friend or relative. Sure, if your house catches fire, I will be out there with blankets, and offering support, and a place to stay or throwing water buckets as the case may be. But, beyond that, if we were all simply polite and considerate, why couldn't that simply be enough. Why must we make a hive, a group, a collective. I'll pay for my share of the public utilites and the public roads and the public schools. But, why must I have to have anything more to do with you. I don't really want to be part of your "community". I don't want to be rude, or mean, or destructive. I just don't want to know you and I don't want you to know me. Why can't that be enough?

And, they have no answer... because - in their juvenile way, they can't stand the thought that people don't want to be part of the clique or the group. You see them...they are the ones on facebook posting every little thought. The PTA moms who control all the happenings at school, the band parents, the dance parents. The joiners, the ones who like to still, decades after high school, determine who is in, and who is out? Why the hell would anyone like to live their life like that? They create situations where they actually create their own pecking order, not treat everyone like equals. There are boards and committees instead of just people on equal footing whose opinion matters.

It is really a completely bizarre way to live ones life. But, I guess as Orwell knew.. all animals are equal, some are just more equal than others.
 
Yes, according to the left, markets are "greedy" but governments never are.

The mendacity is breathtaking. Government most certainly can be greedy. In our modern world, they are greedy for war.
 
We had a get together with friends a few weeks ago and living in this blue state, quite a few are democrats and they were busy with their rules, and how things should be, etc. And, I siad, why really can we not all simply be polite yet ignore each other. I don't want to know my neighbors. I want to come home, go into my house, and be polite and considerate but ignore everyone else who is not a friend or relative. Sure, if your house catches fire, I will be out there with blankets, and offering support, and a place to stay or throwing water buckets as the case may be. But, beyond that, if we were all simply polite and considerate, why couldn't that simply be enough. Why must we make a hive, a group, a collective. I'll pay for my share of the public utilites and the public roads and the public schools. But, why must I have to have anything more to do with you. I don't really want to be part of your "community". I don't want to be rude, or mean, or destructive. I just don't want to know you and I don't want you to know me. Why can't that be enough?

And, they have no answer... because - in their juvenile way, they can't stand the thought that people don't want to be part of the clique or the group. You see them...they are the ones on facebook posting every little thought. The PTA moms who control all the happenings at school, the band parents, the dance parents. The joiners, the ones who like to still, decades after high school, determine who is in, and who is out? Why the hell would anyone like to live their life like that? They create situations where they actually create their own pecking order, not treat everyone like equals. There are boards and committees instead of just people on equal footing whose opinion matters.

It is really a completely bizarre way to live ones life. But, I guess as Orwell knew.. all animals are equal, some are just more equal than others.

Just let them be, right? Let them run their little boards et al...and you get to whine about them. Everyone is happy.
 
Just let them be, right? Let them run their little boards et al...and you get to whine about them. Everyone is happy.

When they create those little boards et al, they make rules, which ultimately affect me. No, I am not content to just whine about it. What I want people to do is leave each other the F alone. and I will keep promoting policies, keep speaking out against each little encroachment to an individual's liberty that I can. And, I will keep pointing out the arrogance, the controlling nature and the intrusions that those kind of people make to save myself and those I care about from further erosion of our liberty. If you don't like it - you can ignore it.
 
When they create those little boards et al, they make rules, which ultimately affect me. No, I am not content to just whine about it. What I want people to do is leave each other the F alone. and I will keep promoting policies, keep speaking out against each little encroachment to an individual's liberty that I can. And, I will keep pointing out the arrogance, the controlling nature and the intrusions that those kind of people make to save myself and those I care about from further erosion of our liberty. If you don't like it - you can ignore it.

As you are not content to whine, the course is to then engage in an attempt to take control. Which then makes you part of the problem of "trying to set rules".

Face it...people cannot...and will not...leave others alone. Were that not so, there would be no need for any government, nor even any institutions of any type.

The only way to be truly left alone...is to leave society.
 
As you are not content to whine, the course is to then engage in an attempt to take control. Which then makes you part of the problem of "trying to set rules".

Face it...people cannot...and will not...leave others alone. Were that not so, there would be no need for any government, nor even any institutions of any type.

The only way to be truly left alone...is to leave society.

I am not attempting to take control. I am attempting to shake off additional control. I don't care if collectivists want to go form their own little hive and live by their own little rules. I however, reject any attempt by them to put additional rules and conditions or requirements of payments on me to support thier visions. I don't want to control anyone. I want people to respect an individual's autonomy and liberty. Nothing more, nothing less.


The fact that we have not learned to leave each other alone doesn't mean that isn't the ideal we should strive for. This whole "leave society" cannard is so old and tired. Why can't "society" simply be less... society. Why can't we decide to pool our resources, but not engage beyond that. We can - if we continue to strive to reject the hive and collectivist mentalities.
 
I am not attempting to take control. I am attempting to shake off additional control. I don't care if collectivists want to go form their own little hive and live by their own little rules. I however, reject any attempt by them to put additional rules and conditions or requirements of payments on me to support thier visions. I don't want to control anyone. I want people to respect an individual's autonomy and liberty. Nothing more, nothing less.


The fact that we have not learned to leave each other alone doesn't mean that isn't the ideal we should strive for. This whole "leave society" cannard is so old and tired. Why can't "society" simply be less... society. Why can't we decide to pool our resources, but not engage beyond that. We can - if we continue to strive to reject the hive and collectivist mentalities.

Because we are humans...and humans are a social lot.

I find the word collective fascinating. It's obviously an attempt to politicize any social spending by the government. I find it ignores all the other terms that basically mean the same...union, united, common, general...that are spread throughout our founding documents.

Collective...

col·lec·tive
kəˈlektiv/
adjective
  1. 1.
    done by people acting as a group
 
Because we are humans...and humans are a social lot.

I find the word collective fascinating. It's obviously an attempt to politicize any social spending by the government. I find it ignores all the other terms that basically mean the same...union, united, common, general...that are spread throughout our founding documents.

Collective...

col·lec·tive
kəˈlektiv/
adjective
  1. 1.
    done by people acting as a group


Lukey and I have been speaking of the collectivist mentality, which is basically yes, allegiance is owed to the group... along with your money and possessions and as such, the group is more important.

No thanks.
 
Lukey and I have been speaking of the collectivist mentality, which is basically yes, allegiance is owed to the group... along with your money and possessions and as such, the group is more important.

No thanks.

You do not believe in citizenship, then.

Square that attitude with school's recitations of the Pledge of Allegiance.
 
You do not believe in citizenship, then.

Square that attitude with schools recitations of the Pledge of Allegiance.

The group is separate from the idea of the country. I owe my allegiance to the ideas this country was founded on. Not necessarily the other people who happen to live here and occupy the same geography.

connie
 
The group is separate from the idea of the country. I owe my allegiance to the ideas this country was founded on. Not necessarily the other people who happen to live here and occupy the same geography.

connie

Disagree. The idea of country is a collective one. As is United States...a more perfect union...common defense....and general welfare...

The idea is self determination through voting and representation.
 
Disagree. The idea of country is a collective one. As is United States...a more perfect union...common defense....and general welfare...

The idea is self determination through voting and representation.

And that is separate from the collectivist mentality. The idea of this country is a group of people who wanted to pool their resources, and the "more perfect union" they discussed was one were there were not lords and rulers, but where individual people had liberty and where the Gov'ts job was to protect that liberty, not control it. The more perfect union is one that I described. Where individuals pool their resources by choice but who value liberty above all else. And, the point where pooling resources becomes infringing on liberty is too far.

That is well - the complete opposite from teh collectivist mentality that exists in modern day america.
 
That the lefties, who rail about market derived prices being too high as a result of the "greed" of capitalists, will turn around and tell you that whatever your taxes are, that just the "price" of living in society and you should pay them without question? It's one of life's little mysteries...

The only thing confounding is your need to create strawmen "saying" things that no one says.

You should debate real people.

;-)
 
Back
Top