New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Does anyone rember ?

*Patton wouldn't have been allowed to draw up invasion plans if an invasion hadn't at least been contemplated.
*New International's article "1945: When U.S. Troops Said No" is a good source of information about the "bring us home" movement. Joseph Hansen's "On Dulles" confirms it.
*I talked about the NLF (so-called Viet Cong) and their homemade and captured weapons. You talked about the NVA, which was hardly even present in S. Vietnam until about 1969, when the majority of South Vietnamese were confined to concentration camps where they couldn't hurt the U.S.
*The fact that the U.S. did not finally insist on Japan's unconditional surrender proves that it was a matter of strategy and not of principle. Sure, some of Japan's victims were glad Japan lost, just as some of the U.S.'s victims were sorry. But the real winner was the cosmopolitan party of imperialism which went on to greater brutalities yet. Btw, "When war breaks out, it is preferable that Japan appears to be the aggressor.Our policy is therefore to starve Japan to this end," is Cordell Hull's statement on it. And, duh, tractors, for example, require fuel oil and scrap metal.
*Of course Clinton got into wars: Haiti (twice), Bosnia, and Yugoslavia, not to mention the bombings of Iraq, Afghanistan, and the Sudan.
*The 1st Amendment gives you a right to join what political group you will without losing your rights. The 14th Amendment guarantees citizenship to all people born in the U.S. and does not allow for revocation of the associated rights. An extrajudicial "finding" that a given citizen is a terrorist is a "bill of attainder" and specifically prohibited by the Constitution. Obama has also violated the Constitution by waging war without Congressional declaration and by violating treaties including the Geneva Convention which prohibits holding POWs after a war (e.g., in Iraq) has been declared over, or the Convention Against Torture, under which he is required to prosecute Bush and Bush administration officials who admittedly ordered torture.
*No exaggeration. The Washington Post reports nearly 3000 killed by drone strikes.
 
What a load of unadulterated crap. You automatically believe anything anti-US without question.
1. Prove Patton ever "drew up invasion plans". He advocated for continuing the war against the Russians. Whether or not he sat at his desk and "drew up" any plans is not indicative of support from anyone higher up than him.
2. "When U.S. Troops said no" gets exactly four hits and one of them is your post. None of the other three mention sending troops to China. None of them say anything about U.S. Troops refusing to deploy.
3. The VietCong were well armed and supplied by the North. While they may have been using weapons that the US made available to them when they fought the Japanese, or on those they captured or stole....that was early on. You hardly ever see pictures of VC with M-14s (the weapon our soldiers deployed with in the early 60s) or M-16s which were the usual weapon in the later 60s and early 70s.
4. "The majority of South Vietnamese were confined to concentration camps"? What a stupid fycking statement.
5. Tractors? In 1940 Japanese agriculture? I don't fycking think so. You think the Japanese went to war because their farmers didn't have gas for tractors and they couldn't manufacture enough farm equipment? The embargo was all about telling the Japanese that they had to withdraw from occupied territory. I'm surprised that you hate the US enought to defend Imperial Japan. Just who was sad that the Japanese lost? Are you actually saying that the US should not have been allowed to decide not to sell our own oil or scrap metal to a nation at war? Is it that you are pro-facist or just desperately anti-US?
6. If you declare war on the US we don't have to have a trial to take away your citizenship. This isn't about joining a political group. It is about making war. If you join a party to hostilities against the US we may apprehend you if possible, but the law does not protect you from acts normally associated with war.....in other words, you may get your ass blown up.
http://hamilton.usconsulate.gov/loss_of_citizenship.html

7. I happen to think Bush/Cheney were engaged in criminal acts for engaging in an invasion of Iraq.
8. Acting against the Serbs in Bosnia was a humanitarian act. The Serbs should have been stopped sooner. Sebrenecia should have been the point at which the Serbian army ran up against a determined Nato force....but the Dutch troops there to protect the Muslims backed down and 8,000 men and boys were murdered. We should have bombed Afghanistan until Bin Laden and Al Qaeda were destroyed. That would have prevented 911 and saved a lot of lives. Iraq was bombed to enforce a no-fly zone meant to stop the slaughter of Shiia and Kurds. Agan, a humanitarian act.
9 Gee, what did you say about drone strikes? Oh yeah...."he has ordered thousands of drone attacks". No, he has ordered about 250 to 300. Whether or not 3,000 people have been killed is a new attempt at deflection. How many were killed when Al Qaeda hijacked four airliners and flew them into buildings? The people who were complicit in those attacks are our targets and rightly so. If innocent people are killed that is certainly to be avoided, but the moral is "Don't hang out with Al Qaeda or Taliban members". AQ set out to kill innocent people. That is a huge difference between the two sides.
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_color-coded_war_plans



Look out Canada

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_Plan_Red


''Nova Scotia and New Brunswick:
Occupying Halifax, following a poison gas first strike, would deny the British a major naval base and cut links between Britain and Canada.
The plan considers several land and sea options for the attack and concludes that a landing at St. Margarets Bay, a then undeveloped bay near Halifax, would be superior to a direct assault via the longer overland route.
Failing to take Halifax, the U.S. could occupy New Brunswick by land to cut Nova Scotia off from the rest of Canada at the key railway junction at Moncton.''
 
Don't agree; Patton was a meglomaniac. I have no doubt that he would have devised such a plan completely on his own.

*Patton wouldn't have been allowed to draw up invasion plans if an invasion hadn't at least been contemplated.
*New International's article "1945: When U.S. Troops Said No" is a good source of information about the "bring us home" movement. Joseph Hansen's "On Dulles" confirms it.
*I talked about the NLF (so-called Viet Cong) and their homemade and captured weapons. You talked about the NVA, which was hardly even present in S. Vietnam until about 1969, when the majority of South Vietnamese were confined to concentration camps where they couldn't hurt the U.S.
*The fact that the U.S. did not finally insist on Japan's unconditional surrender proves that it was a matter of strategy and not of principle. Sure, some of Japan's victims were glad Japan lost, just as some of the U.S.'s victims were sorry. But the real winner was the cosmopolitan party of imperialism which went on to greater brutalities yet. Btw, "When war breaks out, it is preferable that Japan appears to be the aggressor.Our policy is therefore to starve Japan to this end," is Cordell Hull's statement on it. And, duh, tractors, for example, require fuel oil and scrap metal.
*Of course Clinton got into wars: Haiti (twice), Bosnia, and Yugoslavia, not to mention the bombings of Iraq, Afghanistan, and the Sudan.
*The 1st Amendment gives you a right to join what political group you will without losing your rights. The 14th Amendment guarantees citizenship to all people born in the U.S. and does not allow for revocation of the associated rights. An extrajudicial "finding" that a given citizen is a terrorist is a "bill of attainder" and specifically prohibited by the Constitution. Obama has also violated the Constitution by waging war without Congressional declaration and by violating treaties including the Geneva Convention which prohibits holding POWs after a war (e.g., in Iraq) has been declared over, or the Convention Against Torture, under which he is required to prosecute Bush and Bush administration officials who admittedly ordered torture.
*No exaggeration. The Washington Post reports nearly 3000 killed by drone strikes.
 
I guess what he's trying to say is that the war department would have taken away his pen and paper to prevent him from "drawing up" such a plan...
 
Generals don't just consider invasions on the basis of plans they draw on maps. They query their subordinates to determine their operational needs and capabilities, to their superiors to gauge levels of political support, to their peers to avoid being stabbed in the back, to rich people to judge the bankroll. They've been doing so since before Caesar's time.
The U.S. called them "strategic hamlets" but when all the people of a region are driven from their homes by violence and confined to a military-controlled area I call it a "concentration camp."
Of course the embargo was aimed at Japan's war effort, and unlike Pearl Harbor (which I by no means think was justified) as not an act of war. Nonetheless it is true that tract2ors are metal and need fuel and that Japan fed itself with Chinese imports and that Japan was allowed to keep recently conquered Hokkaido because that was a strategic outpost against the USSR. And, finally, the Korean War shows how much the U.S. was motivated by concerns for the conquered people and how much by the wish to take Japan's place, and that's the basis on which we should judge the proportionality of measures used to win the war.
Bush and Cheney did commit crimes in going to war on Iraq. Crimes against peace and crimes against humanity. Clinton/Gore also committed such crimes when they went to war with Serbia, violating specific terms of specific treaties including the UN Charter. Obama is obligated under various treaties including
the UN Charter to prosecute them or he is also culpable.
Congress has not "declared war" on al-Qaeda. And people associated with al-
Qaeda have, as far as I know, been convicted in connection with only 3 deaths
at the WTC in a civilian court, in a highly irregular (in fact, unconstitutional)
trial. I would guess more people associated with Operation Rescue are
responsible for more American deaths than that as proven in courts of law--
should the government be able to ban them? The Minutemen? The Black
Panthers? The Democratic or Republican Party? Because someone in the
government SAYS they're responsible for more deaths?
Again, motivations and means are important. The U.S. backedthe genocidal
Croatian regime of Franjo Tudjman, as well as al-Qaeda and other jihadists, as
part of a coalition against Milosevic--because Milosevic's even more genocidal
bunch was backed by France and Russia. They did so with almost no support
from non-NATO countries and in violation of the UN Charter. They
deliberately and openly attacked infrastructure--bridges, water depots,
hospitals--and bombed civilian population centers. This deliberately going after civilians is a violation of the Geneva Convention. Turning to Iraq, the
U.S. helped Saddam Hussein slaughter the Shi'ite Marsh Arabs in 1991, and
supported Turkey when it invaded Iraq to force fleeing Kurds back into
Saddam Hussein's hands. So was it humanitarianism? Or realpolitik? I have to
question your realism when you say bombing Afghanistan until every last al-
Qaeda (which it is claimed has cells in dozens of countries) was killed wouldn't
have cost far more lives than were lost on 9/11. But of course some lives
don't count for some people.
 
Yes, I remember it well. Did you know there was a Soviet hero? His name was Vasili Arkhipov, commander of the Soviet sub fleet that entered the Sargasso Sea carrying nuclear torpedoes. When the commander of sub B-59, Capt Valentin Savitsky, was going to launch his nuclear torpedo Arkhipov stopped him and ordered the sub to surface. Had Savitsky launched that torpedo, every ship withing a 10 mile radius would have been gone. All four subs left the Sargasso Sea with no event.

He died later from radiation poisoning from an incident that took place earlier in his career on K-19.
 
By the way, the next time I saw a Soviet sub was when one surfaced off our starboard side in the Tonkin Gulf in 1966.
 
America regailed on its deal with the World not to make too much money, when the World agreed that the Dollar would be The Oil currency. The USA through the Federal Reserve got into debt because Vietnam was so expensive and then it got greedier and greedier ...it dishonoured its agreement with the World.

Saddam and Gaddafi went over to Euros as Iran is doing . There is Oil off the coast of Gaza but Saudi is also flirting with the Euro now
Why do we suppose the Banks crashed the Euro ? ................. The USA is the most evil and dishonerable Power the World has ever known, sure we have seen more Barabric but not such dishonerable, and we see by this thread alone how its people are so completely and totally brainwashed, even seemingly intellegent people, to believe that it is the opposite of what it is.

It is 11.30, if the American people do not open their eyes any minute now their Masters will blow us all to kingdom come ........ they will see for themselves what they have imposed on the rest of the World for the last 60 years .... Bastards ! And I include the puppets they have imposed on my peoples, all peoples too with their murdering for the Right and pillaging for Democracy and imprisoning and tortureing to feed their blood lust.

Sorry,Queenie.I disagree with you on this one. Both my Father, Husband ,3 BIL
sand, all my Uncles fought to save England. You may not remember that first hand.I do! I also know the Marshall plan helped to rebuild all of Europe. So when you hand us that crap about the US making money you are dead wrong.

They all fought in England too. My BIL married an English girl while there.

We may have many faults as a nation but that war and after wards is not one of them. Do not forget many of us are still around and do not like History revision.

Your anger at this nation is misplaced and I will not sit idly by while you post this kind of stuff. Your Leaders jumped right into this war too. Not to mention the crooks you had in office along with ours!
 
Bullshit. One of the few things that Obama has done that is actually right and you try to say it is a violation of the Geneva Convention. The two <img src=images/smilies/animated/censored.gif>s were terrorists, Americans by deception. They were turned into stew-meat; and that is a good thing.


My Lord,I agree with Jack. Obama is trying to get us out of wars,not putting us in. Not sure where all this blame America is coming from,but it is sadly wrong. You will notice I say nothing about the other countries who went to war right along with Bush and his neocons.
 
Sorry,Queenie.I disagree with you on this one. Both my Father, Husband ,3 BIL
sand, all my Uncles fought to save England. You may not remember that first hand.I do! I also know the Marshall plan helped to rebuild all of Europe. So when you hand us that crap about the US making money you are dead wrong.

They all fought in England too. My BIL married an English girl while there.

We may have many faults as a nation but that war and after wards is not one of them. Do not forget many of us are still around and do not like History revision.

Your anger at this nation is misplaced and I will not sit idly by while you post this kind of stuff. Your Leaders jumped right into this war too. Not to mention the crooks you had in office along with ours!

http://vho.org/GB/Journals/JHR/13/2/WeberRaven4.html

Mary Anne what I think and say of my Politicians is far far worse than what I think and say of yours. I don't voice it here because the few times I have no one has had any interest and of course most would have no idea who I was taling about not knowing the History ...but then do we even know who we are talking about ? Since this new breed has suddenly come out of no where.

Soldiers job is 'to do and die' on here though we do ask the question, why ? If we do not our hopes will always 'do and die'. We talk about the Politicians not their propagandas.

And specifically I was speaking of the Petro Dollar and the legacy of Vietnam being more far reaching and devastating than most of us realise.

If we do not find some objectivity or should I say, if the American people do not find some objectivity, we will be into WWIII before we know what has hit us. Ad please do not tell me that Obama will not do that .....he will, non of these Powerful people are 'good people' non of them MA. It is the people who have to keep these Powers in check we can never believe they are saviours ......they never are, they are Politicians.
 
My Lord,I agree with Jack. Obama is trying to get us out of wars,not putting us in. Not sure where all this blame America is coming from,but it is sadly wrong. You will notice I say nothing about the other countries who went to war right along with Bush and his neocons.


To keep the Petro Dollar in place MaryAnne, nothing else.
 
I presume you are responding to me....

Generals don't just consider invasions on the basis of plans they draw on maps. They query their subordinates to determine their operational needs and capabilities, to their superiors to gauge levels of political support, to their peers to avoid being stabbed in the back, to rich people to judge the bankroll. They've been doing so since before Caesar's time.

How is this an answer to my post? The statement was made that Patton had a plan to invade the Soviet Union at the end of WWII. My answer was that, if he did, it was not one that was accepted or encouraged by anyone higher than him.....


The U.S. called them "strategic hamlets" but when all the people of a region are driven from their homes by violence and confined to a military-controlled area I call it a "concentration camp."

You must not know what a concentration camp is or you just want to use language that condemns the US in the worst possible way. No, "most" Vietnamese were not relocated to strategic hamlets. No, those hamlets were not "concentration camps".


Of course the embargo was aimed at Japan's war effort, and unlike Pearl Harbor (which I by no means think was justified) as not an act of war. Nonetheless it is true that tract2ors are metal and need fuel and that Japan fed itself with Chinese imports and that Japan was allowed to keep recently conquered Hokkaido because that was a strategic outpost against the USSR.

What is your point?


And, finally, the Korean War shows how much the U.S. was motivated by concerns for the conquered people and how much by the wish to take Japan's place, and that's the basis on which we should judge the proportionality of measures used to win the war.

So you don't know much about the Korean war, either.

Bush and Cheney did commit crimes in going to war on Iraq. Crimes against peace and crimes against humanity.
Yup.


Clinton/Gore also committed such crimes when they went to war with Serbia,

Are you nuts? Even after the Serbs massacred 8,000 men and boys at Sebrenecia, you think the US or any other civilized country had no obligation to stop the slaughter?


Congress has not "declared war" on al-Qaeda. And people associated with al-
Qaeda have, as far as I know, been convicted in connection with only 3 deaths
at the WTC in a civilian court, in a highly irregular (in fact, unconstitutional)
trial.


1. Yes, Congress did declare war on Al Qaeda. It was entitled the "Congressional Authorization for the Use of military force in Afghanistan".

I would guess more people associated with Operation Rescue are
responsible for more American deaths than that as proven in courts of law--
should the government be able to ban them? The Minutemen? The Black
Panthers? The Democratic or Republican Party? Because someone in the
government SAYS they're responsible for more deaths?
Again, motivations and means are important.


2. You assume that after an attack like 911 that there has to be a trial prior to any action against those who attacked us. You are wrong. Bin Laden took credit. The terrorists who hijacked the planes were tracked back to Al Qaeda. Bin Laden issued his famous declaration of war against the US....Remember that we already had substantial evidence that Bin Laden had been involved in the Kobar tower attack, the embassies in Africa and the attack on the USS Cole. Remember that there was no trial to find the Japanese to blaim for Pearl Harbor.....We do not owe anyone from Al Qaeda a trial.



The U.S. backedthe genocidal Croatian regime of Franjo Tudjman, as well as al-Qaeda and other jihadists, as part of a coalition against Milosevic--because Milosevic's even more genocidal bunch was backed by France and Russia. They did so with almost no support from non-NATO countries and in violation of the UN Charter. They
deliberately and openly attacked infrastructure--bridges, water depots,
hospitals--and bombed civilian population centers. This deliberately going after civilians is a violation of the Geneva Convention
.

Once again you don't know what you are talking about. There was a weapons embargo. We shipped no weapons to the Croats (or anyone else) involved in that conflict. No, we did not attack hospitals nor did we target civilians....and if we had just wanted to kill civilians there wouldn't be anything left of Belgrade.


Turning to Iraq, the U.S. helped Saddam Hussein slaughter the Shi'ite Marsh Arabs in 1991

No we didn't.

Supported Turkey when it invaded Iraq to force fleeing Kurds back into
Saddam Hussein's hands.


The Kurds have operated their own state since 1991. Turkey acted against Kurds who had been attacking into Turkey from across the border in Iraq. When are you talking about that Turkey invaded Iraq?

I have to question your realism when you say bombing Afghanistan until every last al-Qaeda (which it is claimed has cells in dozens of countries) was killed wouldn't have cost far more lives than were lost on 9/11. But of course some lives
don't count for some people.


Killing those who are intent on attacking you is a legitimate act of defense. Attempting to equate the lives of the terrorists with those who would become their victims is an example of just how bizarre your logic is.
 
The U.S. fought Germany mostly because Germany was allied with Japan, and also because they couldn't dominate a Europe under German rule. They fought for British independence because it suited their interests, and against Burmese independence for the same reason.
Let's consider the Marshall Plan: it meant a massive export of American capital, with political strings attached, to rebuild Europe's economy in a way that made future growth depend on trade with the U.S. In other words, classic, by-the-book imperialism.
It is not "anti-American" to judge the motivations of American policy-makers to be similar to those of other policy-makers throughout history. Italy claimed noble motives for attacking Ethiopia; Japan claimed noble motives for attacking China; Germany claimed noble motives for attacking Poland; but instead of taking their claimed motives at face value, we look at what interests were served. No one who did otherwise would be taken seriously. All I'm asking is that we apply the same standards to the U.S.
 
@middleview:
1) The point is, Patton could nor have been ready to launch an invasion without previouslyhaving assured himself of substantial support from higher up.
2) MostS. Vietnamese were relocated to strategic hamlets around the time of the administration of Nguyen Cao Ky, an open admirer of Hitler.
3) The S. Korean dictatorship buried 100,000 dissidents in mass graves. Meanwhile the U.S. used biological weapons in N. Korea and bombed the country to the last target, "including huts." What did Japan do to the Koreans that was worse?
4) The question isn't whether you think theBosnia intervention was a good idea, but whether as a matter f international law it was a crime against peace. The UN Charter isvery clear that ONLY the Security Council has the authority to sanction acts of force; but the U.S. couldn't get security council support for an invasion that involved working with the Ustashist militias, bombing nearly every hospital in Serbia, and bombing Belgrade more heavily than Germany did in WWII. Meanwhile Russia was killing more Chechens every week than the number killed at Srebrenica, with U.S. backing.
 
5) In 1991, when the U.S. made the decision to preserve "stability" by leaving Hussein in power, they abandoned the Marsh Arabs and sanctioned the Turkish offensive into N. Iraq. It was after Hussein's slaighter of Shi'ites and Kurds that the U.S. imposed the no-fly zones to create a counterweight to his regime.
6) The idea that everyone in Afghanistan is a terrorist and no civilians would be harmed by endless bombing is plain racist.
7) Bin Laden "took credit"? Bukharin confessed too, and millions of Russians saw it. They torture prisoners, don't they? So really, all we have is the government's say-so that al-Qaeda was responsible--not a single finding to that effect by a court of law. Unlike the declaration of war on Japan, the 2001 authorization of military force makes no specific reference to al-Qaeda. So next week you could have a new "confession" by Louis Farrakhan, and the Nation of Islam would be outlawed by the same logic, and you would be here arguing that anyone the government SAYS is an NOI member can be imprisoned or killed without trial.
 
Back
Top