New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Does anyone rember ?

1. Bullshit
2. Bullshit

Got any evidence of anything you post? You clearly do not know what "carpet" bombing would entail or what the results would look like.
 
The US fought Germany mostly because Germany declared war on the US.

You pull your "facts" out of your ass. What "political" strings were attached to the Marshall plan? What are the details of how Europe became dependent on trade with the US? The fact is that growth was dependent on trade with the US because we were the only major economy that wasn't devastated by the war.....

Italy, Germany and Japan claimed noble motives, but replaced the governments of the countries they invaded. The Germans looted the occupied countries as did the Japanese. America did not loot either Germany or Japan when we occupied those countries. Your comparison of the US to the facists is entertaining.....carry on.
 
Go back and re-read the thread. The allegation was made that Patton was readying plans to invade Russia and they were put on hold. That isn't true, there were no plans in play to invade the USSR at the end of WWII....war games are done all the time. Nobody was proposing a war with Great Britain.
 
Joining NATO was a tacit condition of receiving Marshall Plan aid; even if the threat to cut off aid was not explicit, it took no genous to see that one must please the paymasters. And the aid was based on Amerocan investments to build companies that relied on American parts, exports from American colonies, etc. If Marshall Plan aid didn't come with strings attached, why did the USSR and its allies reject it?

You're right that the U.S. didn't replace the government of Nazi Germany, leaving the Nazi legal code as the basis of law in the joint (W. German) occupation zone and leaving all but the most high-ranking Nazi officials in place, but that's hardly to their credit. Japan, meanwhile, was placed under MacArthur's military rule, to say nothing of native governments being replaced in S. Korea, the Philippines, Indonesia, Indo-China, Burma, Greece, etc. These countries had little left to loot, and as I already mentioned the Chinese revolution stole the winners' biggest prize from them, but the U.S. did compel the W. German population to conduct forced labor for the occupying army's benefit.
 
1. The point is that Patton did not have support from anyone to invade the Soviet Union. I've seen no evidence that he had a plan. He certainly had an opinion.
2. Most S. Vietnamese? How many? Got a link?
3. Proof? Where is your proof? No the US did not use bio weapons in N. Korea. MacArthur wanted to use nukes against the Chinese and Truman wouldn't let him....
4. A crime against peace? It stopped the slaughter of the Bosnians by the Serbs. There was no peace. There was war between the Serbs and Muslims and we intervened. The war between the Serbs, Croats and Bosnians had been going on for years. Are you saying either that we should not have intervened or that we did so for our own economic gains? If so, I'd love to know what we gained. I think we should have intervened in Rwanda. Nobody did and 700,000 people were hacked to death.

Every hospital in Serbia? Bullshit.
Bombing Belgrade more than the Germans did? Bullshit.
US backing? Just how were we "backing" the Russian campaign against the Chechens?
 
1. As I said before, generals are too wily to just willy-nilly advocate invasions without having specific battle plans in place.
2. en.wikipedia.org/Strategic_hamlet
3. en.wikipeida.org/Korean_war
4. What the U.S. gained was keeping the French and Russians from controlling a strategic corridor useful for smuggling and/or large-scale invasions. Clinton publicly supported the Chechnya campaign, comparing it to the Union effort in the U.S. civil war. And, again, "crime against peace" is not a vague accusation but a specific term defined by international law, and by THAT definition any initiation of hostilities without Security Council authorization, except to repel an immediate threat to one's own country, is a crime against peace.
 
5. Yes, the US decided not to invade Iraq. We did encourage Iraqis to rise up and sadly did not help to arm them. That is a far cry from what you accused the US of.
6. "Sanctioned"? The Turks acted against Kurds who had been raiding into Turkey. So? As far as I can tell, the US had nothing to do with it....got any proof or do you think your opinions are enough?
7. We had substantial evidence of Bin Laden and Al Qaeda involvement going back to the Khobar towers attack and including the African embassies, the USS Cole and the WTC attack....Too bad Bin Laden was so frequently bragging up the 911 attack thru Al Jazeera....Court of Law? Just how would that have been done? Would Bin Laden have come to the US to conduct a legal defense? No. So how do you conduct such a trial? Sorry....Due Process is not something that we owe to foreign nationals on foreign soil who attack the US and kill US citizens....as a matter of fact, Due Process ends at the waters edge. The two US citizens who left the country to join Al Qaeda lost any right to legal protections by being in another country and participating in attacks on the US....

That is way different than a group in the US. They are subject to Due Process and legal representation. It is silly for you to offer the comparison. The next step is to say that German citizens killed by our bombing Dresden, Frankfurt or Berlin may be entitled to some kind of repayment for their survivors because we didn't charge them with crimes prior to executing them. Don't go to war against the US and you won't have a problem. If you do declare war (as Bin Laden did) and then engage in military actions against us, the only rights you have are specified in the Geneva convention.
 
1. does not prove that Patton had a plan nor that the plan was put on hold.
2. You said majority. The link you provided said about 4 million people were in strategic hamlets. That is nowhere near "most". There were about 19 million people in South Vietham in 1960. The guy pushing the program was Diem, not Ky.
3. What is your point? Yes there was a war in Korea. The US didn't start that war. We had few troops in South Korea when the North crossed the border to take over the south. That is why both the US troops and South Korean troops were quickly run back to the Pusan.
4. The US gained a corridor to invade who? You really are off in the weeds.

- The US did not initiate hostilities. We intervened in hostilities already under way.
- We did not "support" the Russians.
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/clinton-links-treaty-to-chechnya-740264.html
 
Go back and re-read the thread. The allegation was made that Patton was readying plans to invade Russia and they were put on hold. That isn't true, there were no plans in play to invade the USSR at the end of WWII....war games are done all the time. Nobody was proposing a war with Great Britain.

Oh, OK sorry. I don't know about Patton but Churchill definately had a plan or two to invade Russia. Unthinkable ...................
 
No, joining Nato was not a requirement. Look at the countries that received aid vs. who joined Nato....(by the way, Nato didn't exist at the start of the Marshall Plan). Did you know that Switzerland never joined Nato or that West Germany didn't join Nato until 1955, long after the end of the Marshall Plan? You complain that the US lent money that the recipients used to buy American goods. So? Guess what, every country's foreign aid works exactly that way. In any case, where would they go to buy cars and trucks? How about machine tools or steel?

If Marshall Plan aid didn't come with strings attached, why did the USSR and its allies reject it?

The Poles and Czech's both wanted the money. Stalin wouldn't allow it. He feared it would erode his control over the east block.

I guess you never heard of the de-nazification program? Yes, many former Nazis did keep their jobs. So? If they hadn't committed a crime, why should they have been stripped of their jobs? That was a huge mistake Bush made in Iraq. No, the Nazi criminal code was repealed and replace. Elections were held as quickly as possible and Germans once again had their own government.

What native government existed in South Korea? How about the Phillipines? What American ruled the Phillipines? How about South Korea?

We did order Germans to register for labor. If they did not then they lost their ration cards. So? It wasn't for the benefit of the US army. It was required to clear roads and rubble. What would you have done? Should the allied armies have withdrawn from Germany as soon as the surrender was signed? You offer a lot of criticism, much of which seems to say you read minds or you just believe any anti-American crap you read.
 
The Philippiness were seized from Japan and put back under direct American colonial rule ... they only became independent in 1946 after the troops' "bring us home" movement. In Korea, nationalists had driven the Japanesee Army out of much of Korea and established a multiparty government with popular support. The Soviets in their zone recognized this government, but the U.S. disbanded it and set up a military dictatorship under their hand-picked ruler Syngman Rhee. A similarr thing hhappened in Germany, where the Soviets banned all former Nazis from the civil service and military commissions, while the U.S. decidedly did not, and the Soviets annulled all legislation passed by the Nazis, while the U.S. just repealed a few items such as the Nuremberg decrees and the Enabling Act. Denazification was so shallow in the American-French-British zone that ex-Nazis became chancellor of West Germany, secretaries-general of the UN, and directors of Interpol in decades to come. Meanwhile while the U.S. was compelling Germans to forced labor, the Soviet authorities were making a deal with the unions to employ union labor for reconstruction.
19 million is the population figure for 1974, not 1968. Try 12 million at the
last census. Subtract 1.5 million ARVN, 500,000 in the GVN bureaucracy, 1.5 million killed, 700,000 incorporated into the People's Army of Vietnam (NVA), and 1 million fled to N. Vietnam or Cambodiaa, and you have 6.7 milllionn remaining civilians, of whom 4 million had been relocated to "strategic hamlets." (I'm not counting VC as nomcombatants here because virtually all S. Vietnamese peasants performed missions for the VC.) But even 20% would be too many.
The other link should be en.wikipedia.org/Germ_warfare_in_the_korean_war ... note that although the U.S. described them as "allegations" the Chinese and N. Koreans responded not merely with allegations but also with emergency quarantine stations, anti-bacteriological warfare units, inoculation programs, etc.
 
http://vho.org/GB/Journals/JHR/13/2/WeberRaven4.html

Mary Anne what I think and say of my Politicians is far far worse than what I think and say of yours. I don't voice it here because the few times I have no one has had any interest and of course most would have no idea who I was taling about not knowing the History ...but then do we even know who we are talking about ? Since this new breed has suddenly come out of no where.

Soldiers job is 'to do and die' on here though we do ask the question, why ? If we do not our hopes will always 'do and die'. We talk about the Politicians not their propagandas.

And specifically I was speaking of the Petro Dollar and the legacy of Vietnam being more far reaching and devastating than most of us realise.

If we do not find some objectivity or should I say, if the American people do not find some objectivity, we will be into WWIII before we know what has hit us. Ad please do not tell me that Obama will not do that .....he will, non of these Powerful people are 'good people' non of them MA. It is the people who have to keep these Powers in check we can never believe they are saviours ......they never are, they are Politicians.

Queenie,I simply do not agree with you on Obama,For once we have a leader who is trying toi un do the orevious 8 years.
If you read your last post that is not what you said.It was a blanket condemntation of everyone in this country and a gross mis information of WW2.

I lived during that time and Roosevelt was not hungry for war. He was rebuilding our own Country that the PTB and Republicans had destroyed. Say what you wish about your own Country,I don't on WW2 because I know it was a horrible time for England and we had little choice but to help out. But spare me the rant about the US making money on that war.We rebuilt Europe after the war with the Marshall plan.
as far as WW3,yes if the Neocons had their way we may have been headed that way.You should be glad that Obama was re-elected.He is bringiing us out as fast as he can.You cannot end a war like this over night,but we are well on the way. Again,you blame the American people. Yet you fail to note the same American people elected Obama in a landslide.

I do find some honorable people in Politics.Not all,but some.
 
The fact that the U.S. had plans in place for a war with both Japan and Britain shows that if Japan had kept its WWI-era alliance with Britain, the U.S. would've been on the German side. For someone who didn't want war, Roosevelt les the charge to put the economy on a war footing, repeal the Neutrality Act, and embargo Japan with the (privately) expressed purpose of provoking Japan to an act of overt hostility.
 
From a friend in the Philippines who,along with the rest of her village was on her knees,waiting to be shot,The Americans came in and saved them. She loved this country for saving her life and those of her family. She hated the Japanese with a passion.One of my best friends,until she died of Kidney failure. A School Teacher we brought here and supported her until she got on her feet. Just one of many.
 
American imperialism is plunging toward WW3 regardless of whether Obama or "the neocons" (read: Feith, Perle, Wolfowitz--i.e., Jews) are in power. First, long-term profit rates have plummetted worldwide, due to the excess (compared with markets with a profit margin) of goods sitting to rot in warehouses. The imperialists' only means of rescuing the capitalist system is by destroying enough wealth to restore long-term growth, or by re-dividing the world to give their particular countries an advantage. The U.S. has never had economic growth in peacetime since WWII, but the scale of the current downturn--even in time of war on the scale we've become accustomed to--is something we haven't seen for decades, more specifically since the decade before WWII. Neither can Spain, for example, continue to maintain capitalist expansion without world war. On top of that, the U.S. has declined since the 1960s as an economic and political power, but has maintained its military superiority over all other countries. Its rulers will be tempted to use this military superiority to rewrite the rules of the game before that too slips away.
 
Who do you mean by Bush's "neocon cronies"? Bush attacked Iraq because it is oil-rich, strategically located, and had the potential to build a nuclear weapon. Clinton helped pave the way by maintaining the sanctions and by repeated large-scale bombings.

That is not what Bush and his cronies said.They claimed he" had massive Weapons of destruction!"

But,thanks for telling the truth about the war that Cheney,Bush,Halliburton and all the rest cashed in on.
We know Inspectors found no WMDs so it is good to know you told the truth about the oil.

If you do not know by now who the Neocons are it is a little late. They lost this time around.Take a look
at Romney's adviser's and you will know who they are.
 
Queenie,I simply do not agree with you on Obama,For once we have a leader who is trying toi un do the orevious 8 years.
If you read your last post that is not what you said.It was a blanket condemntation of everyone in this country and a gross mis information of WW2.

I lived during that time and Roosevelt was not hungry for war. He was rebuilding our own Country that the PTB and Republicans had destroyed. Say what you wish about your own Country,I don't on WW2 because I know it was a horrible time for England and we had little choice but to help out. But spare me the rant about the US making money on that war.We rebuilt Europe after the war with the Marshall plan.
as far as WW3,yes if the Neocons had their way we may have been headed that way.You should be glad that Obama was re-elected.He is bringiing us out as fast as he can.You cannot end a war like this over night,but we are well on the way. Again,you blame the American people. Yet you fail to note the same American people elected Obama in a landslide.

I do find some honorable people in Politics.Not all,but some.


MA when we speak of Nations in a Political context we are speaking of the Political Policies not the people.

EatTheRich has answered you properly. I will just add ..... are you refering to me saying that American people on the whole do not know what is really going on ? Well they don't MA, they just do not. I think I was particularly upset by one 'lefty' refering to Palestinians as 'unclean savages' when I wrote whatever it is you are objecting too but that reference by a 'lefty' just strengthens my case.

There is always a very very high cost to American loans ................... They are all in the 'sanity clause'. The biggest lie of all is that the US politically does anything out of kindness ......utter utter Bull Shit .No country does anything for another with out getting at least twice as much back. there are always strings, and there are no friends in Politics ......there is a saying here in the Political World 'If you want a friend get a dog'

Rebuilt Europe ?! After destroying 800 year old Cities, how do you rebuild the 800 year old Europe ? I know people who were in those Cities ...what we did was inexcusably wicked. Which is why we so vilified the Germans .....................'....if the people really knew' has been said many a time by many a politician especially during War.

In the past I can think of a handful of honorable people in Politics too .Not now not one, it is an impossibility for a decent person to get through the ranks and live.
 
Back
Top