New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Does anyone rember ?

It's "diversion" to object to the claim that nuclear war is only a hypothetical possibility when in fact "nuclear weapons" (a term I used correctly, and you used incorrectly--the "distinction" you mention was never in scientific, political, military, or popular parlance, and I challenge you to show otherwise) were used to kill Japanese civilians
and children at a rate Eichmann could only envy? Showing a crumb of respect for the victims of this crime by not allowing a bald denial of its very existence to go unquestioned?

I'll grant, though, that "war" may be an unsuitable term since the nuclear weapons were only on one side. Perhaps " nuclear aggression," "nuclear massacre," or "nuclear genocide" would be more
appropriate.

I do admire your revision of history.You might do better if you listened to those who know what they are talking about.Gramps,for instance. He was there for the signing of the Armistice.

I am with the poster who said you would find a gentler way to end the war. Plain unadulterated BS. War is not pretty but you better fight to win,or you lose. Harry Truman ended the war and I am sure it was not an easy decision.
 
I do admire your revision of history.You might do better if you listened to those who know what they are talking about.Gramps,for instance. He was there for the signing of the Armistice.

I am with the poster who said you would find a gentler way to end the war. Plain unadulterated BS. War is not pretty but you better fight to win,or you lose. Harry Truman ended the war and I am sure it was not an easy decision.


My family had bombs raining down on them, the craters of which I know well, and I grew up surrounded by men who had fought the whole six years of the War and the War before and other Wars before .they were all without a doubt honest about what really happened and now this new generation I find are saying the same things that my Ma said about the Warmongering Old Men. My Grandfathers, one of whom was a 'Hero' of WWI said the same, even though they would have and nearly did, laid down their lives.


This generation can look at it objectively
 
From a friend in the Philippines who,along with the rest of her village was on her knees,waiting to be shot,The Americans came in and saved them. She loved this country for saving her life and those of her family. She hated the Japanese with a passion.One of my best friends,until she died of Kidney failure. A School Teacher we brought here and supported her until she got on her feet. Just one of many.


Do you really want someone to pull up footage of US soldiers doing that very same thing and shooting ? In Vietnam in Iraq in every one of the 69 countries the USA has invaded since WWII ?

Of Testimony of US atrocities from before WWII from all the many many places inside and outside your borders before WWII ?

Emotional arguments are valid against All War they are not valid as propaganda for one side of a War against an other, we are all guilty. The Victors always vilify the Conquered and write the History.


American Philippine War, 1899-1902

CASUALTIES, February 4, 1899 - July 4, 1902:

Filipinos : 20,000 soldiers killed in action; 200,000 civilians died

Americans : 4,390 dead (1,053 killed in action; 3,337 other deaths)
 
1. You say the US seized the Phillipines. Most would say that we liberated them. The battle for the Phillipines ended in August of 1945. Elections were held in April of 1946. No "bring us home" movement had anything to do with it. The promise of independence in 1946 had been made back in 1898.

2. There was no Korean nationalist government in 1945. The Japanese army still controlled Korea. Russian troops entered Korea from the north and American troops were sent after it was feared that the Russians would control all of Korea....Face it, the Soviets would only recognize a communist government.

-- Do you read your links? The international red cross and the world health organization said there was no evidence of biological warfare. You, of course, would prefer the confessions of tortured prisoners of war and the "world peace council".....

3. Much like the Baath party in Iraq, you couldn't have a job in government unless you belonged to the Nazi party. Deciding that you could "convict" former members of the Nazi party, solely based on membership is just wrong. It was a disaster in Iraq and would have been a mess in Germany. A new constitution was adopted for West Germany in 1949. You seem to think the Russians were a pretty magnanimous lot when they occupied Germany. How many German soldiers were captured by the Russians and how many were alive at the end of the war? What year was it that the last German POWs were allowed to return to Germany? How many forced laborers were conscripted by the Russians? How many tens of thousands of those imprisoned by the Russians died while in captivity, after the war?

4. Your numbers on Vietnam are just silly. The strategic hamlet program ended long before 1968 and by the time Diem died there certainly had not been 1.5 million killed.....nor had there been 700,000 southerners signing up with the NVA....The 4 million number includes people who were still living in the villages where they'd been born, but the village was now called a "strategic hamlet".....it does not identify the number of people who were relocated. It was a dumb program, but it was not equivalent on any level with the millions of people relocated to camps by either the Soviets or the Nazis.

You are so anti-American that you accept any fiction you can find....
 
1. You say the US seized the Phillipines. Most would say that we liberated them. The battle for the Phillipines ended in August of 1945. Elections were held in April of 1946. No "bring us home" movement had anything to do with it. The promise of independence in 1946 had been made back in 1898.

2. There was no Korean nationalist government in 1945. The Japanese army still controlled Korea. Russian troops entered Korea from the north and American troops were sent after it was feared that the Russians would control all of Korea....Face it, the Soviets would only recognize a communist government.

-- Do you read your links? The international red cross and the world health organization said there was no evidence of biological warfare. You, of course, would prefer the confessions of tortured prisoners of war and the "world peace council".....

3. Much like the Baath party in Iraq, you couldn't have a job in government unless you belonged to the Nazi party. Deciding that you could "convict" former members of the Nazi party, solely based on membership is just wrong. It was a disaster in Iraq and would have been a mess in Germany. A new constitution was adopted for West Germany in 1949. You seem to think the Russians were a pretty magnanimous lot when they occupied Germany. How many German soldiers were captured by the Russians and how many were alive at the end of the war? What year was it that the last German POWs were allowed to return to Germany? How many forced laborers were conscripted by the Russians? How many tens of thousands of those imprisoned by the Russians died while in captivity, after the war?

4. Your numbers on Vietnam are just silly. The strategic hamlet program ended long before 1968 and by the time Diem died there certainly had not been 1.5 million killed.....nor had there been 700,000 southerners signing up with the NVA....The 4 million number includes people who were still living in the villages where they'd been born, but the village was now called a "strategic hamlet".....it does not identify the number of people who were relocated. It was a dumb program, but it was not equivalent on any level with the millions of people relocated to camps by either the Soviets or the Nazis.

You are so anti-American that you accept any fiction you can find....

http://www.worldfuturefund.org/wffmaster/Reading/war.crimes/US/U.S.Philippines.htm
 
1. Go to the display dropdown in the upper right. Select threaded or hybrid view. That way you can see the threads and others can tell who you are responding to.

2. Having a plan for any eventuality isn't evidence of anything. Yes, FDR prepared for war. Good thing.

Got any proof that FDR wanted to provoke the Japanese? We did arm the Nationalist Chinese and we did provide US pilots for the Flying Tigers....all under the pretense of neutrality. We also provided naval vessels to accompany convoys to Britain. We also embargoed sales to Germany and Italy....So? We had two US destroyers attacked by German subs (USS Reuben James and USS Greer).

Given that the US population was fairly split on the issue of being involved in a war, as well as the clearly evil regimes in control of Germany and Japan, would you blame FDR for having acted as he did? Remember that the Japanese sank an American ship in China (USS Panay) in 1937. Too bad that wasn't enough for FDR to declare war. It would have worked out far better for the US....
 
Which has nothing at all to do with the thread....but thanks for dropping in.


Does Patton ? The Cuban Crisis is what the thread is about.

Rommel wanted to assassinate Hitler and join forces with Britain to fight the Russians and Patton spoke openly about his hatred of them calling them "Mongolian apes" whether or not he had a plan he spoke openly about attacking them and the fact that he thought America had fought the wrong enemy, The Germans.

Before WWII America was trying to build an Empire Cuba was a part of that enterprise ..........we all forget these little 'inconveniences' ..........
 
1. I didn't bring Patton into the conversation. You'd have to bring that up to the author of that post. The intent of that post was clearly to add more anti-American crap into the thread.
2. Yes, in the late 1800s and early 1900s most western powers were deeply involved in attaining colonies or establishing spheres of influence. So?
3. Patton's attitude towards Russia and communism isn't the issue. The statement was made that Patton had a plan to continue WWII and that it was put on hold. That there was a plan that was actually being considered by Truman is untrue. Truman wanted the war to end and was not about to keep us involved in a continuation against the Russians.
 

Sorry, what is your point? In 1898 there was a race between western powers, France, Germany, the UK, the Dutch and the Japanese as well, to establish colonies around the world. All of those efforts were wrong. The Phillipines was going from a colony of Spain to a colony of the US....the Phillipinos wanted independence. They should have gotten it.

That having been said...the world was a different place in 1945.
 
1. You say the US seized the Phillipines. Most would say that we liberated them. The battle for the Phillipines ended in August of 1945. Elections were held in April of 1946. No "bring us home" movement had anything to do with it. The promise of independence in 1946 had been made back in 1898.

2. There was no Korean nationalist government in 1945. The Japanese army still controlled Korea. Russian troops entered Korea from the north and American troops were sent after it was feared that the Russians would control all of Korea....Face it, the Soviets would only recognize a communist government.

-- Do you read your links? The international red cross and the world health organization said there was no evidence of biological warfare. You, of course, would prefer the confessions of tortured prisoners of war and the "world peace council".....

3. Much like the Baath party in Iraq, you couldn't have a job in government unless you belonged to the Nazi party. Deciding that you could "convict" former members of the Nazi party, solely based on membership is just wrong. It was a disaster in Iraq and would have been a mess in Germany. A new constitution was adopted for West Germany in 1949. You seem to think the Russians were a pretty magnanimous lot when they occupied Germany. How many German soldiers were captured by the Russians and how many were alive at the end of the war? What year was it that the last German POWs were allowed to return to Germany? How many forced laborers were conscripted by the Russians? How many tens of thousands of those imprisoned by the Russians died while in captivity, after the war?

4. Your numbers on Vietnam are just silly. The strategic hamlet program ended long before 1968 and by the time Diem died there certainly had not been 1.5 million killed.....nor had there been 700,000 southerners signing up with the NVA....The 4 million number includes people who were still living in the villages where they'd been born, but the village was now called a "strategic hamlet".....it does not identify the number of people who were relocated. It was a dumb program, but it was not equivalent on any level with the millions of people relocated to camps by either the Soviets or the Nazis.

You are so anti-American that you accept any fiction you can find....


You think the Spanish American War was to liberate the peoples of the Spanish colonies ? Oh sweet heart who is it who reads the fiction books on this thread ? The USA was intent on taking over the Spanish Empire and beyond. 'The White Mans Burden' ?
 
My family had bombs raining down on them, the craters of which I know well, and I grew up surrounded by men who had fought the whole six years of the War and the War before and other Wars before .they were all without a doubt honest about what really happened and now this new generation I find are saying the same things that my Ma said about the Warmongering Old Men. My Grandfathers, one of whom was a 'Hero' of WWI said the same, even though they would have and nearly did, laid down their lives.


This generation can look at it objectively

Yes,Queenie and mebers of my family were right there as well. None called themselves hero's. They came back home,went to work ,raised families and did not want to talk about the war.They carried ths scars of war all their lives,but did not discuss it.I saw the scars on my Husband where he was wounded on Normandy Beach so you are touching a very sore spot with me.

If what you are saying is an example of"Objectivity," I feel sorry for this generation. The ignorance in some of these posts is astounding.
 
Sorry, what is your point? In 1898 there was a race between western powers, France, Germany, the UK, the Dutch and the Japanese as well, to establish colonies around the world. All of those efforts were wrong. The Phillipines was going from a colony of Spain to a colony of the US....the Phillipinos wanted independence. They should have gotten it.

That having been said...the world was a different place in 1945.

yeah, by 1945 America had switched over to economic colonization.
 
Yes,Queenie and mebers of my family were right there as well. None called themselves hero's. They came back home,went to work ,raised families and did not want to talk about the war.They carried ths scars of war all their lives,but did not discuss it.I saw the scars on my Husband where he was wounded on Normandy Beach so you are touching a very sore spot with me.

If what you are saying is an example of"Objectivity," I feel sorry for this generation. The ignorance in some of these posts is astounding.


My Grandfather did not call himself a Hero either, I heard after his death of his War record.

What are you actually trying to say about The Europeans ? That they didn't go back to work and rebuild and have families ? This is what you seem to be insinuating.

The Battle of Britain was already fought and won by us .neither of our countries were fighting in their own defence by the time the US came in and we could quite easily have left it to the Russians who won it anyway. There were even arguments that we should have helped the Germans fight Russia .............millions died horribly and needlessly and still do.

Objectivity is all we have to fight against War with. Tears most definatly haven't worked, yet ...........


And the USA lent Europe the money to rebuild ...it was a loan not charity as you all like to think of it and US loans always come at a very high price..

Britains' loan is paid in full but somewhere in there we had to make promises one of the cruelest, to my mind, was that we would not build anymore ships. We, an Island Race, and you wonder why you are so hated by the World, it is these unseen underhand deals that have been forced on Nations by your Policies and all because you welshed on the Petro Dollar, honor bound, deal you had with us all because Vietnam had cost you so much.


One little African Country had to promise you it would not fertilize its' land !!!! crops failed and people starved ....that was the intent.
 
Back
Top