New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Does it make me a commie...

Lukey

Senator
If I read this:

http://www.thenation.com/article/is-it-time-for-a-new-new-deal/

And I don't hate it?

I'd love to find like minded moderates who think a policy agenda that incorporates some of this with a deregulatory effort (smaller government) to free up markets and make the really large corporations more vulnerable to smaller competitors makes sense. There's something in it for both sides.

I don't know why so many people who like the ideas in that linked article can't also like free markets and a better environment for small businesses.
 
here's how a credentialed economist might respond to this article:

  • universal basic incomes have never worked, anywhere. they simply accelerate the transition from unskilled labor to automation/robotics. The only successful path to higher incomes is to achieve job skills and work at a full time job
  • child allowances seem attractive to the "won't somebody please think of the children" crowd. Many kids are, indeed, living in poverty. But we've had increasing government safety nets for kids since the LBJ era, and more are living in poverty as at any time since then. There are much more direct ways to combat the problem:
    • boosting child income tax deductions/exemptions to what it really costs to raise (an average) kid - effectively putting millions of wage earners in a zero percent IRS bracket;
    • making a serious effort to collect the huge back amounts owed on child support, instead of having it go to liquor, gambling, medicinal marijuana; muscle cars; and iPhone upgrades
    • empowering (requiring) child protective services to intervene aggressively in situations where kids are being raised in the midst of abuse, violence, and drugs
  • Nobody has anything against worker owned cooperatives. Nobody has anything against reforming the tax and regulatory structure to make these easier to establish. Most people should try to remember the recent "green energy" boondoggles and immediately cross out plans for federal grants and loans to politically connected guys with unworkable "business plans" who claim they have a great idea for a frozen yogurt chain using locally sourced ingredients.
 
here's how a credentialed economist might respond to this article:

  • universal basic incomes have never worked, anywhere. they simply accelerate the transition from unskilled labor to automation/robotics. The only successful path to higher incomes is to achieve job skills and work at a full time job
  • child allowances seem attractive to the "won't somebody please think of the children" crowd. Many kids are, indeed, living in poverty. But we've had increasing government safety nets for kids since the LBJ era, and more are living in poverty as at any time since then. There are much more direct ways to combat the problem:
    • boosting child income tax deductions/exemptions to what it really costs to raise (an average) kid - effectively putting millions of wage earners in a zero percent IRS bracket;
    • making a serious effort to collect the huge back amounts owed on child support, instead of having it go to liquor, gambling, medicinal marijuana; muscle cars; and iPhone upgrades
    • empowering (requiring) child protective services to intervene aggressively in situations where kids are being raised in the midst of abuse, violence, and drugs
  • Nobody has anything against worker owned cooperatives. Nobody has anything against reforming the tax and regulatory structure to make these easier to establish. Most people should try to remember the recent "green energy" boondoggles and immediately cross out plans for federal grants and loans to politically connected guys with unworkable "business plans" who claim they have a great idea for a frozen yogurt chain using locally sourced ingredients.

Yes, but we're transitioning to a robot workforce anyway. It will cause a huge upheaval in the workforce regardless of what we do or don't do in the policy arena. And the EITC is largely the same concept but as work becomes harder to find, fewer and fewer will be able to access it. One note on that is the guaranteed job idea where unemployment offices become employment offices and do training and help with finding work but also provide public works to help people get and/or improve work skills. The guaranteed income would have to be less than the "employment office" income which would have to be less than the minimum wage. Comme si comme sa.

As for the child allowance that would be the last thing on my list but there is a way to limit it - to only the first two kids for instance. Or make the guaranteed income lower for singles and a bit more for couples and then maybe a flat family level regardless of the number of kids. The appeal of ever larger population declines as the robot workforce increases so we should be careful of arguments based on the "benefits" of population growth.
 
Back
Top