New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Don't be Stupid

justoffal

Senator
Let me begin by stating a core belief that I hold. Inanimate objects are not the source of anything but inanimateness. People are and always have been the problem. Now I suppose we could go to extremes and say that Volcanoes are not people and they can be a real problem but then again we cannot legislate against volcanoes or earthquakes or the trend of human nature either for that matter and so I submit to you that we exercise the futile if we ignore the real causes and deal only with the symptoms.

The events of early Friday December 14, 2012 in a Connecticut grammar school are certainly tragic and horrifying. Could it have been prevented? Yes.....but how? Let's say for the moment that we limit the choices of second amendment hardware only to those that fire single shot rounds. Does this somehow fix human nature?

In places where guns are impossible to get massacres still happen with guns that are obtained impossibly...and with alternative weapons up to and including human bombs made with grocery store available items. Imagine a killer armed to the teeth with a powerful explosive device entering the school cafeteria at lunch time. Surely a hundred count casualty event. Do we then ban Charcoal? Sulfur powder? Pipes and matches? How would this help if we did?

Look...I am as angry and disgusted as anyone else....I have a grandson that attends the elementary school right down the street from where we live and I am scared to death that there could be a copycat event in the works.

Should he stop going to school? Can I quit my job and go with him? Can I keep him home and home-school him? I did it with his father and it turned out just fine but I am much older now and the wife is just not up to the task of a little one anymore.

I see no reason for an average citizen to have an assault rifle in their gun safe. But mind you I have seen people with single shot pistols shoot multiple targets in only seconds time with enormous accuracy. A good pistol, well made and in the hands of a practiced shooter can be just as overpowering as an assault rifle and just as deadly.

Let's say the theater shooter used a rapid fire pistol instead of his assault rifle...is there anyone here who can say that it would have kept the casualty count down? And when we ban pistols what then? Sling shots? Hammers? Butter knifes????

I don't and never did belong to the NRA. I can remember Charlton Heston speaking for them many times and always with dignity and eloquence. I guess what I took from that was his ardor and zeal for the right to self defend.. I never read it as gun craziness or blood thirsty, barbaric ranting. I know that others did and do read it that way. Most NRA members that I know are kind, responsible human beings who wouldn't hurt a fly unless it broke into their house at night looking like a human with an intent to do them harm. That particular human trait isn't going away any time soon I'm afraid.

I can't help but notice that all three high profile shooters in the last two years were mentally Ill. Apparently the school shooter was both autistic and medicated. Hmmm......could pharmaceuticals be more dangerous that guns? Why yes.....I think they can be.

Still It wouldn't break my heart to see assault weapons banned. I don' t own one and probably never will. However I do think it is nothing more than a attempt to address the symptoms. An ineffectual, feel good ...do nothing law that will absolutely not decrease the number of these tragic events because guns don't cause them in the first place. But if we must then I really couldn't care less except to say that we will not escape the slippery slope. We will no doubt now be called haters of children. It's what the predictable left does.

Bad things are gong to happen. No matter how many laws you make or precautions you take....bad things are gong to happen. Heartbreaking things...unimaginably painful things.....they will happen. They happen every day..all over the world and they happen with bigger and badder tragedies than the shootings we have seen in the past dozen or so months in our own little corner of peace and security here on this globe of human beings. I wish they didn't happen but I know they will continue and I know they will never be eliminated no matter how intensely we wish it to be so or even if we legislate ad infinitum non stop for the next twenty years. The two phenomena are not intrinsically related.

In the final analysis we need God...yes even liberals do. They may not believe in him but they recognize the need for him with the continual making of too many laws to keep track of...far beyond our humnan ability to enforce or to obey for that matter and the continuing agglomeration of authority into very few hands...they don' know it but that is exaclty who they are trying to be.

JO
 
It's illegal to own a gun in MEXICO brain-master....but they far surpass us in brutal shooting murders. Hey....how bout them gun control laws in Mexico huh?

Here read this pile of Crap of you're into BS it will make you feel good as you descend into total dreamworld mode.
 
Wow,,,Comparing The US to Mexico...Brilliant....All these Fvckin Right Wing Gun Nuts need to shut up
 
Your post is misalinged.....however I will respond

I don't care about the issue one way or another. If all the guns were gone tommorow it wouldn't bother me. What I do care about is the false idea that we wll thereby suddenly bring about utopia. It's insane as well as naive and totally disregrards the positive aspects of gun ownership.

To ban assault riifles is virtually meaningless unless what the left really wants is all of the guns and then I would have to wonder why that would be excactly. Thre are so many other deadly instruments that are never considered for such bans. Cars for insatnce.

JO
 
Keep waving that bloody toddler shirt....that's really effective.

For what it's worth the cause and the effect are not lost on me. I understand exactly what the control advocates are claiming. It seems to make sense at first until you consiider and remember that people are the ultimate culprits. Sure I get it....take the potential away from the impulse nut and he's less dangerous. If it's an answer it's only part of an answer. IF the government succeeds in banning all firearms I'm sure as hell not gong to spend my time with a protest sign trying to bring them back. I'm more concerned with where they would go with that new found power in the after math.

Feel like going to jail because you skipped a rock across the pond?

Thiink it's silly?

JO
 
JO,
'
It is the left and only the left that is responsible for all of the school shooting that have happened since 1990. With the passage of the Federal Gun Free School Zone Act and the signing it into law by President Clinton, stating that it would make our school safer from gun violence was a crock, just like everything else the left has proposed. What this act has done was to make our schools from the primary grades through the secondary and graduate classes a shooting gallery for anyone who feels that society in general has let them down.

The left is passing this law has also turned our children over to the whims of every deviant and demented son of a bitch this nation has produces over the last 50 years. I would like to take this time to thank them for screwing our children and taking their childhood away from them.

ORR
 
We know what works. Every other wealthy nation on earth has tighter gun control laws than we do, and in all of them violent crime is much less prevalent. We could fix this, if we wanted. But, we instead value gun ownership above public safety. That's a choice we can make as a society, if it's the will of the majority of people. But let's be honest about what we're choosing. Just as when we choose to raise the speed limit from 55 to 65 we're choosing to allow more people to die in car accidents, because we value other things more, when we choose to keep gun control loose, we're choosing to allow things like what happened in Connecticut happen more often than would otherwise occur. No doubt it would be comforting to believe, as many apparently do, that we're giving nothing up in the trade-off – that the violent crime rate would be the same or even higher if we had tight gun-control laws. But that's a lie that stupid people tell themselves. Deep down anyone with a brain knows the truth. That doesn't mean that one has to support gun control. It just means that one has to be honest about what is being given up in order to defend our current extreme gun permissiveness.
 
Wow,,,Comparing The US to Mexico...Brilliant....All these Fvckin Right Wing Gun Nuts need to shut up

wow, every time you open your mouth you show how empty your head is...

go back to your racist illogical rants little girl, and leave the critical thinking to those than have the capacity..

you do not..
 
Right you are

JO,
'
It is the left and only the left that is responsible for all of the school shooting that have happened since 1990. With the passage of the Federal Gun Free School Zone Act and the signing it into law by President Clinton, stating that it would make our school safer from gun violence was a crock, just like everything else the left has proposed. What this act has done was to make our schools from the primary grades through the secondary and graduate classes a shooting gallery for anyone who feels that society in general has let them down.

The left is passing this law has also turned our children over to the whims of every deviant and demented son of a <img src=images/smilies/animated/censored.gif> this nation has produces over the last 50 years. I would like to take this time to thank them for screwing our children and taking their childhood away from them.

ORR

In fact if we look at the demographic profile of the last three shooters who were they? Total left wing lunatics I think.
 
How do you know that the numbers would change? How many more people would die in the commision of violent crimes that might otherwise live if not for gun ownership? There is a trade off here. Perhaps we do pay a price for this particular right but I will repeat the tired old mantra that just happens to be true. Automobiles are even deadlier than guns both by instant and by total and yet we see the need for them. Perhaps that is not a perfect parallell but who is to say that the trade off is worth making the change? Are you willing to tell a young woman who has to walk down dark allyways at night to get home that she cannot have a handgun to protect herself? If you take that handgun away from her are you willing to accept the responsiblity for her vulnerable state?
 
I'm open minded about this, and if the evidence came to suggest the net impact of gun control was negative, I'd oppose it. But, for now, the evidence I've seen suggests the net impact is positive (both the result the last time we restricted guns, in the early Clinton years, and the outcomes of tighter gun laws in our international peers). And that makes sense to me -- a gun is a much better offensive weapon than defensive one. I can have the world's finest private arsenal of firearms and it doesn't make me one bit safer against someone who has a shabby little Saturday Night Special and the drop on me. If he's got he gun out, aimed and loaded, he can kill me at will, without those guns of mine doing the slightest bit of good to defend me.
 
How do you know that the numbers would change? How many more people would die in the commision of violent crimes that might otherwise live if not for gun ownership? There is a trade off here. Perhaps we do pay a price for this particular right but I will repeat the tired old mantra that just happens to be true. Automobiles are even deadlier than guns both by instant and by total and yet we see the need for them. Perhaps that is not a perfect parallell but who is to say that the trade off is worth making the change? Are you willing to tell a young woman who has to walk down dark allyways at night to get home that she cannot have a handgun to protect herself? If you take that handgun away from her are you willing to accept the responsiblity for her vulnerable state?

Who is this woman who needs to walk down dark alleyways at night to get home?

Autos are not only an imperfect parallel, they are no parallel at all. Begin with purpose...and go from there. The purpose of vehicles is to transport goods and people. The purpose of a gun is to kill. Whether offensive, defensive...or as a hunting tool...the purpose is singular...to kill.
 
I guess what you are saying is that posession of a gun promotes the idea of violence in the mind of a person who might think better of it? Is that what you are saying?
 
I guess you would need to be familiar with big city life ....

Recently I had to go to Downtown Boston to renew my engineering license. This is the place...aupload.wikimedia.org_wikipedia_commons_thumb_5_59_McCormack_B3987f165852e57ea4b56d71ff863c34b.jpg

It was a huge pain in the ass...when I got to the Public saftey office and did my business I asked the clerk, a young lady, how do you get into work everyday? She told me she takes the subway and keeps a handgun in her purse.

So there's one for ya.

JO
 
Fair enough....I am abivolent about the matter by and large.......but I do fear the onset of the slippery slope of uber control. Frankly it just cannot be done. Might this be a baby step that makes things better in the short run? Perhaps it is.

JO
 
I guess you would need to be familiar with big city life ....

Recently I had to go to Downtown Boston to renew my engineering license. This is the place...aupload.wikimedia.org_wikipedia_commons_thumb_5_59_McCormack_B0ef35d92607798fd6390078ec02875d9.jpg

It was a huge pain in the ass...when I got to the Public saftey office and did my business I asked the clerk, a young lady, how do you get into work everyday? She told me she takes the subway and keeps a handgun in her purse.

So there's one for ya.

JO

Well...let's see.... I grew up in Baltimore...drove taxi there and in San Francisco for many years, almost always at night...lived on Capitol Hill in Seattle...and on the near north side of Chicago...so...I'm more than familiar with city life.

The woman you mention does not appear to have to walk down dark alleyways at night. She does mention the subway...
 
Your TP is the most verbose blatheration of a bumper sticker that I have ever seen.

"Guns don't kill people. People do."

Like most winger obfuscations, the obvious is missing from the false premise.

Try adding, "People with guns do" and take the rest of the day off.
 
Here is the thing...the key is mass murder. That means types of weapons we allow, like guns with 100 rounds or sixty rounds etc. where mass murder is a possibility. The second part we have to look at is who exactly is it that is doing these types of things and how are they getting the weapons? If you know that most of these horrors are caused by legal guns then you start getting a clue on what issues we are confronted with.

Oddly the criminal element is more one on one crime. These mass killings are ordinarily young people who have issues and have access to guns. We need to fix that as buying a gun by the sanest person in the family does not insure that the most insane person of the family does not own or have access to that household gun.

The old "guns don't kill" argument is just stupid in the face of all these mass gun slaughters we are seeing. What we can't be is stupid and go on pretending that the subject should be anything but guns and mentally challenged people and access and guns that can kill many in a short time with magazines or the ability to slaughter many more people than our country ever imagined when gun ownership was protected by the Constitution.

Good gun owners and non-gun owners need to get together and hammer something positive out of this to save lives.
 
Yep....I think you are defintely familiar with big city life. I have never been to Baltimore but I have been warned. I hear it can be a real jungle...

To tell you the truth if I were that young woman (Trust me I look horrible in skirts! :) ) I would do much more than just carry a gun in my purse. I would find some safer way to come and go...maybe with a group? I don't think it is as effective to carry an equalizer as it is simply to avoid the situations that would require one. Boston subways are filled with hundreds of rape crimes each year....they are a very, very bad place for a you attractive woman to be.

JO
 
Back
Top