New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Editing double standards

I dont think it is a matter of deleting things not agreed with. There is plenty of that. It is more a matter of deleting over the top vitriol and nonsense... always has been

yer yer ------------- I don't think any mod should be able to delete in any thread they are participating in as a poster.

Perfectly legit arguments disappearing mid argument with a mouse are really not Cricket.
 
I keep hearing of BB and kinda wish I'd been there...sounds like quite a crew! Lol!

What I don't like is the deletion of some posts that are no worse than others...but those "others' don't get deleted. I don't think ANY post should be deleted. If someone is really saying something wrong, then they should eventually be temporarily banned.

BB was like The Wild West ---------
 
yer yer ------------- I don't think any mod should be able to delete in any thread they are participating in as a poster.

Perfectly legit arguments disappearing mid argument with a mouse are really not Cricket.

That's how it used to be.........if a mod was participating in a thread, that mod did not prune the thread. In those days, we pruned.........we rarely ever deleted entire threads. It's just not fair to posters for moderators to just take the whole thread away because one part of it has gone bad. But...........
 
I don't have permission to join the other thread with this subject line, so I'll start my own. I've been messing around with these various political forums for some time now. One of the things that's remained consistent throughout, is that the righters AND lefters seem absolutely convinced that the moderators and administrators are out to get them. I suppose this suggests that the mods and admins are doing something right.

Fairsheet hit the nail on the head. Both left and right are pm'ing me daily about how unfair and biased the moderating is.

I don't see any moderation bias here at PJ at all.

Remember we can only moderate the posts that are reported as we don't have a big staff.
 
yer yer ------------- I don't think any mod should be able to delete in any thread they are participating in as a poster.

Perfectly legit arguments disappearing mid argument with a mouse are really not Cricket.

There are only 3 mods. Under your idea most big threads would go unmoderated.
 
There are only 3 mods. Under your idea most big threads would go unmoderated.

So it is ok for a mouse to nibble away at the posts a mouse disagrees with/dislikes when in a heated discussion? No matter that no rules had been broken? No report buttons pushed?
 
So it is ok for a mouse to nibble away at the posts a mouse disagrees with/dislikes when in a heated discussion? No matter that no rules had been broken? No report buttons pushed?
Give us an example of a thread(s) where that has happened. We can review the deleted and edited posts to verify your claim.
 
So it is ok for a mouse to nibble away at the posts a mouse disagrees with/dislikes when in a heated discussion? No matter that no rules had been broken? No report buttons pushed?

Who said that?

I hope you realize I haven't read one Leilani or Nina post until today.

How can we moderate 700+ posts a day with 3 moderators?

The answer is we cannot. If its not reported, then assume it wasn't moderated.
 
yer yer ------------- I don't think any mod should be able to delete in any thread they are participating in as a poster.

Perfectly legit arguments disappearing mid argument with a mouse are really not Cricket.

which argument disappeared? I know of no such deletions.
 
So it is ok for a mouse to nibble away at the posts a mouse disagrees with/dislikes when in a heated discussion? No matter that no rules had been broken? No report buttons pushed?
Very few posts are permanently deleted. If you give us a link to the thread(s),we can review them. I assume whatever you are referring to happened recently.
 
I think it was this one

France Pivots To Putin, Cyprus Offers Moscow Military Base, Germany-US Splinter On Ukraine
Scrolled all the way through the thread. No evidence that any posts were deleted or edited by a moderator.
 
Back
Top