New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Excess Labor Microcosm

Arkady

President
To picture the problem of excess labor in microcosm, imagine a greatly simplified, self-contained economy. Let's say you have 100 people on a space ship making a 20-year voyage to a nearby star. On the ship, everyone has a chore (cleaning the bathrooms, growing the food, etc.), and to incentivize people into doing their chores, there's a system of "ship's scrip" you earn by doing your chores, that can be used to buy up necessities and little luxuries. At the start, if everyone puts in a 40-hour day, the work that needs to get done gets done, and enough scrip is issued that everyone has all the necessities and a handful of luxuries. But then let's say someone comes up with a clever innovation that eliminates the necessity for some of the chores -- e.g., a way to use compostable vessels for serving food, thus cutting down on the amount of time that has to be used for both dishes and gardening chores. This leads to an excess labor problem -- what to do with those hours that used to be used on now-obsolete tasks.

There are lots of ways a society can deal with that problem. One way is to come up with new chores to fill that time, which would boost the output of luxuries, raising people's quality of life and putting those workers back to work. But, in a space ship, there are material, energy, and space constraints that might limit the amount of luxury goods and services you can have, so that might not be an option. So, another option would be to split up the remaining chores equitably, so that, for example, rather than everyone working 40 hours per week, the average would be shifted to 38 hours per week, with two extra hours for free time for the average person. The person who invented the labor-saving technology might be given a somewhat disproportionate reduction in his required hours, as an incentive for more people to come up with labor-saving methods. Yet another option would be to reward the person who invented the improvement with the scrip that would have been earned for that work, into perpetuity, while the displaced workers are rendered unemployed (and therefore poverty-stricken, and a stability risk to the whole society). Another option would be the Luddite option of outlawing the innovation, to maintain stability. Another option would be to just pay the scrip to the displaced workers, even though they're no longer earning it. Another option would be to split the scrip between the displaced workers and the innovator (with the idea that they're less of a stability threat if they're being paid not to do anything).

Of those options, I think the best is to set aside just enough extra luxury or leisure for the innovator to incentivize further innovations, while equitably spreading the balance of the gain across the society. Unlike the luddite solution, this doesn't throw away the value of an innovation that could be making everyone's lives better, and unlike the "winner-takes-all" solution, it doesn't create an underclass that's a threat to the society.

This was an issue futurists used to think about a lot, as it became clear that productivity gains would allow fewer people to create far more value per hour of work. Most futurists wrongly envisioned work weeks continuing to fall (as they had been), so that if people wound up three or four times more productive per hour, they'd only have to work one third or one fourth as many hours. By this point, in the US, we could easily have a twenty-hour work-week, if we'd gone that way. But, instead, we went with something like that "winner takes all" approach. The economic elite (and their heirs, as with the Walton family, for example) have become mind-blowingly wealthy, while we've built a persistently elevated unemployment rate that has undercut wages. Your typical worker today is creating far more value than his father or grandfather, per week, and yet seeing very little extra compensation, as the value of that extra production flows to the top, with elevated unemployment preventing the laboring class from demanding a bigger cut of the prize.

This is a choice. We don't need to have 8% unemployment and falling wages. We don't need to have desperately poor people. We could take a bigger cut from the economic "winners," the way they did in earlier generations (when the top bracket paid as much as 92%), and we could use that to finance government services that spread some of that extra wealth among the less fortunate. Or we could impose shorter work-weeks more paid vacations, more maternity and paternity leave, etc., so that the common man gets a share of the new prosperity in the form of extra leisure time. Instead, right now, we're choosing to make our economy serve the elite in a single-minded manner.
 
Ok in real english...we are losing more jobs and we need Republicans to give more so we dont have to give them jobs and they will vote democratic. You gotta laugh at the guy who doesnt like capitalism yet claims to be wealthy.
 
Unlike Drumcollie, who I guess is going to become a specialist in 'real English', I think this is an excellent analogy, Arkady. I especially like and agree with your third paragraph, outlining what would indeed appear to be the best solution for this 'spaceship'. And there's nothing remotely 'anti-capitalist' about that solution, either.
 
Drummy can't think beyond his worship of the GOP....


on-topic, Arkady, Big Theories on Economics are sorely lacking. Few Democrats want to propose things that would be smeared as "Euro-socialism" or "soaking the successful"....of course they get that anyway when somebody suggest the wealthy paying a rate they paid during the Clinton "depression" of the 90s.

And the GOP has the economics of brain damaged plutocrats...."Cut taxes, cut taxes more, keep cutting taxes. Now we have huge deficits, so we must dismantle everything done since 1890." And if they got that, they'd demand more tax cuts until all that was left was Defense.....THEN they'd push for a Flat Tax that the rich could escape and we'd be back to Feudalism....i.e. the peasants paying for the Noble's soldiers.
 
ark - i think i disagree

as automation idles the unskilled and semi-skilled blue collar workforce, the government has continued to expand. this isn't about churning out luxury goods for the 1%. it's about finding ways to transfer wealth from the makers to the takers. jobless benefits are extended over and over, "teaching assistants" and crossing guards proliferate in the schools; private trash collection becomes a government service; citizens are paid to patrol everything from animal shelters to handicapped parking spaces to non smoking zones and check for violations. in the meantime police, firefighters, civil engineer and infrasture maintenance - government jobs which require real skills - cannot be filled, because the skills of the unemployed are insufficient to do these more important jobs.

our destination is greece - where half the economy was nationalized - not just trash collection, but the state airline (all forms of transportation, actually); hotels, restaurants, even tour guides. the greek national airline had 3 times as many baggage handlers, clerks, janitors, etc as any of its competitors. this is the unhappy end of ever expanding government, until it all comes crashing down when the "wealthy" flee to a more rational place to earn their living rather than being taxed into oblivion
 
ark - i think i disagree

as automation idles the unskilled and semi-skilled blue collar workforce, the government has continued to expand. this isn't about churning out luxury goods for the 1%. it's about finding ways to transfer wealth from the makers to the takers. jobless benefits are extended over and over, "teaching assistants" and crossing guards proliferate in the schools; private trash collection becomes a government service; citizens are paid to patrol everything from animal shelters to handicapped parking spaces to non smoking zones and check for violations. in the meantime police, firefighters, civil engineer and infrasture maintenance - government jobs which require real skills - cannot be filled, because the skills of the unemployed are insufficient to do these more important jobs.

our destination is greece - where half the economy was nationalized - not just trash collection, but the state airline (all forms of transportation, actually); hotels, restaurants, even tour guides. the greek national airline had 3 times as many baggage handlers, clerks, janitors, etc as any of its competitors. this is the unhappy end of ever expanding government, until it all comes crashing down when the "wealthy" flee to a more rational place to earn their living rather than being taxed into oblivion

As I pointed out in another thread, automation and mechanization is HOW America became rich, and HOW we became the scientific and technological leader of the world. Yet you continue to portray it as a bad thing. You are sounding more and more like a Neo-Luddite. The Neo-Luddite philosophy is downright dangerous.
 
ASOT, the "We're becoming....or We will be Greece" analogy fails on many levels. Population, resources, innovation, manufacturing, electoral politics, etc.

If America "became Greece"....then you're talking the total collapse of the country that guys like worldlyB so dreamily look forward to. To fall that far, that fast....would demand it, for it to be an ACCURATE analogy.

I think you're listening to too much Sean Hannity.
 
Ah, yes, let's spend more money we don't have to "finance government services that spread some of that extra wealth among the less fortunate". That should work...after all, it's worked great everywhere else it's been done (the USSR, Cuba, North Korea, China, Greece, Italy, Spain, etc, etc)
 
We are not having choosing to have our economy serve the elite. The elite have fairly or unfairly, depending on your point of view, capitalized on the weaknesses of others.

Your analogy has left of another solution. That possibility is one where the displaced worker, having access to the same amenities and services as everyone else, figures out a way to continue to make himself relevant and useful despite being partially automated out of a job. You see that is the solution where people continue to be industrious - continuing to work and press ahead, rather than lazy - and have more leisure time.

Your analogy reinforces why socialism doesn't work. The average person will only do exactly what they have to do to get their job done. So, when automation comes along and makes the work easier or faster, instead of figuring out what other productive activities should be done, or what else they could be doing to possibly do an EVEN better job, they figure out how to do the bare minimum to meet the results they met prior to automation. And, rather than continuing to put out X amount of effort -and channel that effort into something else productive in some way, they seek to figure out how to lessen the effort - be it in actual physical exertion or time.

And, you see this in jobs where technology has been introduced to make the job faster or better. I see it in my profession. Everyone uses computerized accounting software anymore. But, the scary thing is that people coming out of school - don't actually know how to do accounting without the computer. And, the problem is that what happens when the computer doesn't work, or is wrong? How will you ever know that or be able to figure it out when it is wrong? But, instead of junior people coming into the professsion and trying to learn to be the best accountants they can be, they figure that why do they have to work the hours that their predecessors did when we have all this new fangled computer stuff. Not realizing that there is soooo much they could be doing to learn and better themselves.

And, here is the thing, those people who want to take more leave, more time off. They aren't the ones who worry then when the software doesnt' work, or when there is a deadline. They aren't the ones who worry when the entire system crashes, and 6 months of data has to be reconstructed. THEY aren't the ones who deal with that. They will be the ones running around like chicken with its head cut of, screaming for someone to do something.

It is all the people who run around behind all these people who want to do their bare minimum of a job and call it a day, who worry about everything like that. Who stay late, come in early, etc - because while everyone else thinks their job should be easier, these people know that automation doesn't necessarily mean an improvement in quality, or in output, etc.

So, would I accept that we should all just be able so share in the joys of the rewards of others. No, because I know slowly but surely things will begin to fall apart. Slowly but surely people will reduce their output and their effort. And, eventually, there really will be no one there who knows what to do or how to do something or how to fix anything. So, by far, I would prefer a system that rewards individual effort. If you are willing to work 50 hours a week - and you do work 50 hours a week. You should make more and have more and live a better quality of life that that person who only wants to work his 35. Because that guy will come looking to the industrious worker to save his bacon, eventually.

connie
 
The current debate around the minimum wage, hints at this problem. As I noted elsewhere - back in the day - when I first started working for minimum wage, as an adult by the way - the minimum was sufficient for me to get myself ahead if I so chose to do so. I should add though, that that minimum wage came along with very good healthcare insurance provided by my employer.

Anyway...although it was "enough", if I scrimped, and saved, and put in the effort, it definitely wasn't enough to encourage me to get fat, happy, and lazy! Back then, it WAS fair to tell someone to get off their ass, go to work, and make something of themselves. Alas...the minimum wage hasn't kept up with inflation....even as some of the arguments above, seem to rely on the feeling that it has.

-And I know....I don't think anyone actually mentioned the minimum wage by name, but there's absolutely no evidence to suggest that our inexorably shrinking minimum wage has been of benefit to anyone...except maybe the top 2%.
 
Back
Top