New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Facts do matter!

Well, once again we've started a debate over the source of the numbers rather than their accuracy.

Fundamentally, the numbers supplied are sound. About half of all people don't pay taxes, many of them actually pay less than zero taxes, and high-end earners pay more taxes than the poverty strickent.

None of this is exactly a shock, if you follow the policy debates and have any common sense.

Most honest working people are willin gto pay a fair share, and the debate comes down to "what is fair," a sliding scale almost anywhere it is applied. Obama and the Democrats want to raise taxes on rich people. I'm all for that, except for one thing: I want the funds segregated so that every dime of that new revenue is not put into new programs, but is instead pumped into eliminating the debt, with a goal toward both debt and deficit reduction.

and of course you know that's what Obama proposed negotiating the debt ceiling-3trillions in debt reduction in exchange for eliminating Bush tax cuts for the wealthy.
THe radical party refused to consider even 1 dollar of increase
 
I have sucked the money out of the nation, hired foreign workers, because I can pay them below what minimum wage is here, put the difference in my pocket and I'm now whining about all those who can't pay taxes in America because I won't pay them more than minimum wage here, fired a bunch of them and hired foreign replacements (Only I can get rich, not the lower class) and now there are lots of unemployed (who don't pay taxes) and people who don't make enough to pay taxes.

My statement was in response to this statement. But then, if you were actually debating and not just bating, you would know that.
 
do you guys sit up nights counting your money and saying to your selfs, oh poor me, I'm making so much I have to pay more taxes than those who are at the poverty level.
Are you guys clling for a system where there are no deductions, one tax rate for everyone?

You do understand if this happens there will still be a need to help everyone out that needs help.
So lets just put it at no deductions and all income is taxed at 35%, sounds good to me. No sales taxes or state taxes, just one straight tax of 35% of every single taxable dollar.
 
Yes, facts do matter, and the American Enterprise Institute feels no particular loyalty to facts if they don't fit what the AEI sales pitch is.

Brooks' claim contradicts itself.

He makes the claim (which he does not support) that people in the middle class or lower get more from the government than they pay in taxes. This is because almost half the population does not pay income taxes.

But they all pay the taxes that fund the safety net programs, which are the programs that the middle class and poor use. The people who DON'T pay to fund those programs are people like Mitt Romney, who takes most of his income in capital gains and pays relatively little in payroll taxes. But that inconvenient fact is left out of the conservative narrative.

The fact that middle and lower class Americans have been getting poorer over the last decade is omitted as well. Also omitted is the fact that defiecits in these program's funding is caused by a great recession. But in the Gucci loafered halls of the AEI, recession and rising poverty rates are abstract concepts not to be discusses when peddling the policies that have aggravated these condidtions.

It isn't like organizations like the Tax Foundation or the American Enterprise Institute are real think tanks. What they really are is conservative public relations operations selling policy.

And when you're selling, the only facts that matter are the ones that push your product.
 
and if thisis not enough we can have a surtax of 5/10%. We can pay down the deficit in no time like this.
 
You have to be kidding.

It's Limbaugh's classic bait-and-switch. He'll first talk about "Half the country doesn't pay any taxes".....then tell his audience (who, by his reckoning, MUST include a LOT of people "not paying taxes") that they are...

"paying too much in taxes". His "data" is to defend the rich....his ratings demand that he pretend Joe the Plumber or Fred the Carpenter are multi-millionaries "just like him".
 
First of all Reppy...I have made no claim either way...have refused to do so until you answer my initial question...link me to where Rush or Fox have claimed the working class is paying too much in taxes...I see where Rush says "higher taxes are a direct assault"...now, show me where he says the current amount they are paying is too much.
 
I'm guessing you can provide the link then? Reppy can't, maybe you can give him some assistance in this endeavor...show me where Fox or Rush have said that the working class are "paying too much in taxes"...mind you, not "higher taxes" like Reppy tried to pawn off...but that they are currently paying too much. Then we'll get to the next question (btw, which is another political play on words).
 
According to the Tax Foundation those making around $110k pay in taxes about what they get back in government benefits. The upper 1% pay $377k more in taxes than they receive in benefits. From this data one would think the gap between the 2 groups would be narrowing. In fact, the opposite is happening. Can anyone explain this?

awww.cbpp.org_images_cms__6_25_10inc_f1.jpg
 
what people don't understand is if they want people who make less than 33,000 who end up paying 2.5% of the taxes to pay more, that it would mean that they also would end up paying more, since even when your making 1,000,000 you get the same tax brackets on the way up. You get the same standard deductions and you get the same the individual deduction. so if you take that away from them and kept the tax rates standard for each income you would end up paying much more. Is that what your wanting.

Isn't it rather stupid to think you can fix the problems we have on the backs of people who are at or below poverty levels. Since 90 million tax tapers make a total of 87% of all taxable income and 90 million people make 13% of the income, you would be paying much more at the top 50% if you got rid of deductions that everyone gets now.

so what are you saying, take the tax deductions that the bottom people get and keep those for the top?
 
Back
Top