New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

False equivalency arguments - classified docs ..

There are a lot of posters bleating the comparisons between Trump and Biden are a false equivalency, comparing apples and oranges...

Let's digest..

1. Both had left their respective offices, President and vice President, and presumably followed similar procedures in the reporting of what was being removed

2. Both are in possession, were in possession, of classified materials and other items, that are the property of the United States

3. Upon leaving office whether president or vice president, by law these items are the property of, and belong to, the United States of America

4. Trump was in possession of such items

5. Biden was in possession of such items

That's the point where we are presently in the ark with President Biden and the items found in not one but two offices, left uncontrolled for years, potentially exposing sensitive classified information


Trump's behavior, refusals, and so on are irrelevant in this apples to apples comparison.
It just cannot be sugar coated. These threads are unbelievably condemning of fundamental integrity of Democratic Party posters in this forum. Again and again they pledge their very own personhood to party, insisting upon the essential goodness of Biden conduct and history of conduct.

…to the point of declaring that this matter is no big deal (sensible don), that a private office is not in possession of the holder of that private office (Bugsy), and that the prior incidence of Trump having documents and being a combative, weasel, douche about it (he was/is, of course) somehow affords Biden differential, deferential treatment and uncommon benefit of the doubt (Middleview).

Of course we don’t know all the facts. Neither do we know all the specific contents of the documents. The fact is, however, the very different treatment of Biden/Trump by media, poster, and government agencies alike is very, very stark. These Democrats simply double down on these double standards…almost as if shattering American political and demographic unity is their specific objective. Half the country has no faith in the FBI, the IRS, the Justice Department, national media, etc. Again and again, we see raids on gimpy, aged geezer members of one party…and deference and overly respectful courtesy extended to the other. Rhetorically, again and again, we see presumption of guilt for one party…assumption of innocence for the other. The most hawkish, embittered, angry, judgmental, instantaneously-summary-conclusion-drawing in this forum are suddenly transformed into Gumby-like contortionists, flexibly forgiving…no wait - there is NOTHING to forgive…they simply retreat into gooey liquid puddles of nonstandard, adopting hushed, reverential, RIGID INTRANSIGENT default position of “one of ours = spotless lambism”.

These people are clowns. They are unserious, and their abject intentional joyful dereliction of civic stewardship on this renders them unfit and unworthy of standing to weigh in on any other.

These are no mere hacks and propagandists. They are that…plus (yep, I’m going to say it) unAmerican enemy within. And…they won’t stop wrecking the American union every chance they get…from their shut-in stations in underachieving basements across this nation. It really stinks that Trump is as horrible as he is - in part because it gave inferior losers like this a voice (that resonates among fellow losers). The animation of idiots in the Michigan woods by jerks like Trump gives weight to the asinine imaginings of countervailing idiots in basements.

And there you have it.
 
Let me ask you a question..

If you own a vacation property, and you're not present in it, is it still your property?

Are the contents of said vacation property still in your possession, or do they cease to be your possessions because you're not physically present in the vacation home?

Similarly if you have files locked in a file cabinet stored somewhere. But you're not present with them they're still in your possession correct because you stored them there?

The documents we're referring to are the work product of the former vice President of the United States. They are in fact the possession of the United States government. But in fact and reality they were found to be in the possession of Joseph Biden, whether he was present standing next to them or not.

Your inapt analogy and theories are fascinating but, getting back to my point, Biden, unlike Trump, is not in possession of the documents. Again, they were in a locked office and Biden was in the White House. Do you consider that you are in possession of some documents in some office where you used to work?
 
It just cannot be sugar coated. These threads are unbelievably condemning of fundamental integrity of Democratic Party posters in this forum. Again and again they pledge their very own personhood to party, insisting upon the essential goodness of Biden conduct and history of conduct.

…to the point of declaring that this matter is no big deal (sensible don), that a private office is not in possession of the holder of that private office (Bugsy), and that the prior incidence of Trump having documents and being a combative, weasel, douche about it (he was/is, of course) somehow affords Biden differential, deferential treatment and uncommon benefit of the doubt (Middleview).

Of course we don’t know all the facts. Neither do we know all the specific contents of the documents. The fact is, however, the very different treatment of Biden/Trump by media, poster, and government agencies alike is very, very stark. These Democrats simply double down on these double standards…almost as if shattering American political and demographic unity is their specific objective. Half the country has no faith in the FBI, the IRS, the Justice Department, national media, etc. Again and again, we see raids on gimpy, aged geezer members of one party…and deference and overly respectful courtesy extended to the other. Rhetorically, again and again, we see presumption of guilt for one party…assumption of innocence for the other. The most hawkish, embittered, angry, judgmental, instantaneously-summary-conclusion-drawing in this forum are suddenly transformed into Gumby-like contortionists, flexibly forgiving…no wait - there is NOTHING to forgive…they simply retreat into gooey liquid puddles of nonstandard, adopting hushed, reverential, RIGID INTRANSIGENT default position of “one of ours = spotless lambism”.

These people are clowns. They are unserious, and their abject intentional joyful dereliction of civic stewardship on this renders them unfit and unworthy of standing to weigh in on any other.

These are no mere hacks and propagandists. They are that…plus (yep, I’m going to say it) unAmerican enemy within. And…they won’t stop wrecking the American union every chance they get…from their shut-in stations in underachieving basements across this nation. It really stinks that Trump is as horrible as he is - in part because it gave inferior losers like this a voice (that resonates among fellow losers). The animation of idiots in the Michigan woods by jerks like Trump gives weight to the asinine imaginings of countervailing idiots in basements.

And there you have it.

Zzzzz….THUD!

;-)
 
Your inapt analogy and theories are fascinating but, getting back to my point, Biden, unlike Trump, is not in possession of the documents. Again, they were in a locked office and Biden was in the White House. Do you consider that you are in possession of some documents in some office where you used to work?

cool. if thats the game. then neither was trump.

a locked office in a center that bears his name, where he has an office, his possessions were stored, and so on...

but, i see, because biden wasnt physically next to he box(es) they arent his...

presumably if trump wasnt found standing next to his items, they arent his either.

got it. thanks.
 
cool. if thats the game. then neither was trump.

a locked office in a center that bears his name, where he has an office, his possessions were stored, and so on...

but, i see, because biden wasnt physically next to he box(es) they arent his...

presumably if trump wasnt found standing next to his items, they arent his either.

got it. thanks.

First, your dodge is noted. It’s quite telling.

But let’s say you’re right and he’s in “possession” of classified documents. He’s the president. Isn’t he entitled to possess them?
 
First, your dodge is noted. It’s quite telling.

But let’s say you’re right and he’s in “possession” of classified documents. He’s the president. Isn’t he entitled to possess them?
I see you've regrouped and have your new angle working.

There was no dodge. I said what I said. It's quite telling that you have to call everything a Dodge isn't it

Anyway back to reality in the fact of the matter. Confidential documents have now been found in not one, not two, but three locations belonging to biden. Documents from the Obama era and elsewhere, which should not be in his possession because they're the possession of the United States government
 
I see you've regrouped and have your new angle working.

There was no dodge. I said what I said. It's quite telling that you have to call everything a Dodge isn't it

Anyway back to reality in the fact of the matter. Confidential documents have now been found in not one, not two, but three locations belonging to biden. Documents from the Obama era and elsewhere, which should not be in his possession because they're the possession of the United States government

I believe you agree that presidents can possess classified documents. No question about that. You may have some claim that it was illegal to have them in the places he had them. Some kind of hypertechnical charge. Got a statute he was violating due to the places he had them, like his home?
 
There are a lot of posters bleating the comparisons between Trump and Biden are a false equivalency, comparing apples and oranges...

Let's digest..

1. Both had left their respective offices, President and vice President, and presumably followed similar procedures in the reporting of what was being removed

2. Both are in possession, were in possession, of classified materials and other items, that are the property of the United States

3. Upon leaving office whether president or vice president, by law these items are the property of, and belong to, the United States of America

4. Trump was in possession of such items

5. Biden was in possession of such items

That's the point where we are presently in the ark with President Biden and the items found in not one but two offices, left uncontrolled for years, potentially exposing sensitive classified information


Trump's behavior, refusals, and so on are irrelevant in this apples to apples comparison.
“ … presumably followed similar procedures …”
Based on what?
 
There are a lot of posters bleating the comparisons between Trump and Biden are a false equivalency, comparing apples and oranges...

Let's digest..

1. Both had left their respective offices, President and vice President, and presumably followed similar procedures in the reporting of what was being removed

2. Both are in possession, were in possession, of classified materials and other items, that are the property of the United States

3. Upon leaving office whether president or vice president, by law these items are the property of, and belong to, the United States of America

4. Trump was in possession of such items

5. Biden was in possession of such items

That's the point where we are presently in the ark with President Biden and the items found in not one but two offices, left uncontrolled for years, potentially exposing sensitive classified information


Trump's behavior, refusals, and so on are irrelevant in this apples to apples comparison.
And you are completely ignoring the differences.
 
I believe you agree that presidents can possess classified documents. No question about that. You may have some claim that it was illegal to have them in the places he had them. Some kind of hypertechnical charge. Got a statute he was violating due to the places he had them, like his home?
Good grief. THIS post should be PINNED TO THE TOP OF THIS PAGE…lest any other poor soul ever waste his precious time on this earth exchanging posts with Bugsy. This is so far beyond servile and integrity-bereft that it defies words.
 
I believe you agree that presidents can possess classified documents. No question about that. You may have some claim that it was illegal to have them in the places he had them. Some kind of hypertechnical charge. Got a statute he was violating due to the places he had them, like his home?
I believe the attorney general is going to comment on it later today. Anyway the question at hand isn't what documents does he have in his possession related to his current administration. The question at hand is why did he have documents related to the Obama administration, while he was out of office and no longer vp, stored in offices and apparently in his garage for years, rather than returned to the United States government it's rightful owner.
 
Good grief. THIS post should be PINNED TO THE TOP OF THIS PAGE…lest any other poor soul ever waste his precious time on this earth exchanging posts with Bugsy. This is so far beyond servile and integrity-bereft that it defies words.

Will you stop spamming the board with your incessant whining? The sane people here are discussing the document issues. You should stop making your noise.
 
“ … presumably followed similar procedures …”
Based on what?
How do you mean based on

Are we both able to agree that there are procedures governing the transit and removal of confidential documents from the possession of the United States government?

Or do you join in with others pretending that no such procedures exist?
 
And you are completely ignoring the differences.
I've outlined the similarities above. The differences haven't come into play yet. But we are learning that they're not quite so different now are they. CNN is currently discussing how apparently the Biden administration was rather deceptive in its disclosure of where else it may have had documents stored and or hidden. Because this review of his home and other locations was apparently conducted a couple days ago
 
I believe the attorney general is going to comment on it later today. Anyway the question at hand isn't what documents does he have in his possession related to his current administration. The question at hand is why did he have documents related to the Obama administration, while he was out of office and no longer vp, stored in offices and apparently in his garage for years, rather than returned to the United States government it's rightful owner.
Bugsy is now on record referring to this as potential “past issue” in “technical” conflict with some obscure rule.

BWAHAHA!

Are mods allowed to top-page-pin particularly egregious cases of cartoonishly bizarre, over the top Baghdad Bobisms? I believe there are two DOOZIES here that have no equal anywhere across the interwebs…
 
I believe the attorney general is going to comment on it later today. Anyway the question at hand isn't what documents does he have in his possession related to his current administration. The question at hand is why did he have documents related to the Obama administration, while he was out of office and no longer vp, stored in offices and apparently in his garage for years, rather than returned to the United States government it's rightful owner.

OK, so you might have a claim that he was out of compliance in the past, although he is now entitled as president to have classified documents. We’ll need to see the facts to make that judgment.
 
Back
Top