New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Fascinating Economic Stat 2

Arkady

President
What was the longest period of time our country ever went with a net decrease in the number of people working for the government?

The answer may surprise you: THIS is the longest we've ever gone without a net increase of government jobs.

Right now, there are 21,898 million people working for government in the US. In March 2006, there were 21,903. That's a nine-year run with a net decline in government employment. Going back to when the labor department started collecting data, in the 1930s (and almost certainly right back to the founding, though official stats aren't available before the 1930s), there was no other nine-year period in our history when there wasn't a net expansion of government payrolls.

To put it in perspective, in the nine years following Reagan taking office, government payrolls expanded by 1,791,000 jobs, net.

So, the record-long run of uninterrupted job creation we've been experiencing is particularly fascinating, since it's been through a period when the private sector had to do it all and then some. It wasn't like the Reagan years when government bloat helped the labor market.
 
What was the longest period of time our country ever went with a net decrease in the number of people working for the government?

The answer may surprise you: THIS is the longest we've ever gone without a net increase of government jobs.

Right now, there are 21,898 million people working for government in the US. In March 2006, there were 21,903. That's a nine-year run with a net decline in government employment. Going back to when the labor department started collecting data, in the 1930s (and almost certainly right back to the founding, though official stats aren't available before the 1930s), there was no other nine-year period in our history when there wasn't a net expansion of government payrolls.

To put it in perspective, in the nine years following Reagan taking office, government payrolls expanded by 1,791,000 jobs, net.

So, the record-long run of uninterrupted job creation we've been experiencing is particularly fascinating, since it's been through a period when the private sector had to do it all and then some. It wasn't like the Reagan years when government bloat helped the labor market.
That simply cannot be true. Everyone knows all Democrats (Democrats??) do is increase the size of government. Sheesh.
 
It is one of your patented "fascinating" but meaningless statistics. Perhaps you missed the big shift to contract work? Anyone who reads your bullsh*t and thinks it is an accurate picture of how things are should have their head examined. WTF is the difference between a state social worker in the PA Department of Welfare and an SEIU social worker working for a community organizer outfit funded by state outlays? They are both government employees but only the bureaucrat counts in your number. Do you really think we could increase total government spending by 50% since 2005 and not add a single new government worker? Hahahaha!
 
It is one of your patented "fascinating" but meaningless statistics. Perhaps you missed the big shift to contract work? Anyone who reads your bullsh*t and thinks it is an accurate picture of how things are should have their head examined. WTF is the difference between a state social worker in the PA Department of Welfare and an SEIU social worker working for a community organizer outfit funded by state outlays? They are both government employees but only the bureaucrat counts in your number. Do you really think we could increase total government spending by 50% since 2005 and not add a single new government worker? Hahahaha!
As you know, this has also been an uncommonly long period of falling real government spending per capita. So, although a shift to contractors might factor in (just like it might in other eras to which we are comparing) the big factor is the obvious one: government has been shrinking, which is nearly unprecedented for any substantially lengthy period in American history.

This must be why all those anti-big-government conservatives are so overjoyed with the direction of the country since Obama took office. Hehe. Just kidding: I'm perfectly aware that he's black.
 
As you know, this has also been an uncommonly long period of falling real government spending per capita. So, although a shift to contractors might factor in (just like it might in other eras to which we are comparing) the big factor is the obvious one: government has been shrinking, which is nearly unprecedented for any substantially lengthy period in American history.

This must be why all those anti-big-government conservatives are so overjoyed with the direction of the country since Obama took office. Hehe. Just kidding: I'm perfectly aware that he's black.

Yet it is still well above the levels we enjoyed when the Clinton economy was booming:

Screen Shot 2015-04-23 at 9.08.24 AM.png

And how about projections for the future:

Screen Shot 2015-04-23 at 9.06.34 AM.png

So once again, the facts deconstruct your narrative. There is no (real) "austerity" and government spending is still way too high to support robust growth in the private sector while you keep complaining loudly that it should go up. I think it's time someone told you to shut up!
 
Yet it is still well above the levels we enjoyed when the Clinton economy was booming:

View attachment 27000

And how about projections for the future:

View attachment 26999

So once again, the facts deconstruct your narrative. There is no (real) "austerity" and government spending is still way too high to support robust growth in the private sector while you keep complaining loudly that it should go up. I think it's time someone told you to shut up!
Your chart shows the austerity clearly. Thank you for your assistance! As for future projections, we'll see how that plays out in reality. But, that chart is worthless since its current rather than constant dollars.
 
Your chart shows the austerity clearly. Thank you for your assistance! As for future projections, we'll see how that plays out in reality. But, that chart is worthless since its current rather than constant dollars.

It is not "austerity" if it is almost 50% higher on a real basis than when the economy was most recently in a period of sustained growth in jobs and incomes. It just isn't no matter what your preference for government spending is, that's your preference, not Keynes'...
 
thanks for (not) pointing out that we are winding down the size of military . . . yawn

you're making this too easy for the rest of us. its as if you're not even trying any more.
 
thanks for (not) pointing out that we are winding down the size of military . . . yawn

you're making this too easy for the rest of us. its as if you're not even trying any more.
Are you attempting to suggest that this record-long decline in government employment is driven by shrinkage of the military? If so, that's an interesting guess, but is, in fact, entirely wrong. The BLS employment stats I'm using don't include military personnel:

http://www.bls.gov/opub/btn/volume-2/revisions-to-jobs-numbers.htm

Government employment covers only civilian employees; military personnel are excluded.​

This epic long period of government payroll shrinkage is without even factoring in the simultaneous shrinkage of military personnel. In fact, it's despite an increase in DoD civilian employment. Since January 2009, the total number of civilian government jobs has fallen by 681,000 jobs, even as the number of civilian Department of Defense jobs has grown by 14,000 jobs. While most of the rest of the government has been slashing deeply, the DoD has actually been staffing up!

See: BLS Series Id: CES9091911001
 
It is not "austerity" if it is almost 50% higher on a real basis than when the economy was most recently in a period of sustained growth in jobs and incomes. It just isn't no matter what your preference for government spending is, that's your preference, not Keynes'...
Yes, I understand that you use a different definition of "austerity." But step away from the word games and consider the substance of the argument. I wrote "As you know, this has also been an uncommonly long period of falling real government spending per capita." You posted a chart demonstrating clearly that this was an uncommonly long period of falling real government spending per capita. So I thanked you your assistance in driving my point home. I'd have preferred if your chart stretched back before 1990, so people could see just how unusual these cuts were. I'd also have preferred if your chart used a logarithmic scale so that detail wasn't lost in the past. But even what you posted was sufficient to underscore what I'd written. So, thanks!
 
Yes, I understand that you use a different definition of "austerity." But step away from the word games and consider the substance of the argument. I wrote "As you know, this has also been an uncommonly long period of falling real government spending per capita." You posted a chart demonstrating clearly that this was an uncommonly long period of falling real government spending per capita. So I thanked you your assistance in driving my point home. I'd have preferred if your chart stretched back before 1990, so people could see just how unusual these cuts were. I'd also have preferred if your chart used a logarithmic scale so that detail wasn't lost in the past. But even what you posted was sufficient to underscore what I'd written. So, thanks!

Thanks? For what? Pointing out how wrong you are? To most (normal) people, reducing real government spending per capita from 50% more to only 45% more than when the economy last performed well on its own (without "stimulus"), more than six years after the recession ended (and 15 years after the last time the economy performed well on its own - without "stimulus"), would not be included in their idea of "austerity." You know...you gotta start somewhere...baby steps? That sort of thing?

Your suggestion that it is tantamount to suiciding our economic future is not supported by that chart, I'm afraid.
 
Thanks? For what?
For posting a chart that so clearly illustrates the point I made, obviously. I didn't have a chart, I only had the raw data, so I have you to thank for such a striking illustration of the facts I'd provided.
 
For posting a chart that so clearly illustrates the point I made, obviously. I didn't have a chart, I only had the raw data, so I have you to thank for such a striking illustration of the facts I'd provided.

Like I said...

To most (normal) people, reducing real government spending per capita from 50% more to only 45% more than when the economy last performed well on its own (without "stimulus"), more than six years after the recession ended (and 15 years after the last time the economy performed well on its own - without "stimulus"), would not be included in their idea of "austerity." You know...you gotta start somewhere...baby steps? That sort of thing?

Your suggestion that it is tantamount to suiciding our economic future is not supported by that chart, I'm afraid.
 
hooray sequesters and shutdowns!

too bad that posse of $95,000 a year "caligraphers" at the white house wasn't reducted though.

i've i'd know it was such a lucrative profession i would have taken up calligraphy in college.
 
What was the longest period of time our country ever went with a net decrease in the number of people working for the government?

The answer may surprise you: THIS is the longest we've ever gone without a net increase of government jobs.

Right now, there are 21,898 million people working for government in the US. In March 2006, there were 21,903. That's a nine-year run with a net decline in government employment. Going back to when the labor department started collecting data, in the 1930s (and almost certainly right back to the founding, though official stats aren't available before the 1930s), there was no other nine-year period in our history when there wasn't a net expansion of government payrolls.

To put it in perspective, in the nine years following Reagan taking office, government payrolls expanded by 1,791,000 jobs, net.

So, the record-long run of uninterrupted job creation we've been experiencing is particularly fascinating, since it's been through a period when the private sector had to do it all and then some. It wasn't like the Reagan years when government bloat helped the labor market.


Rather pathetic overall. Why have we spent billions on computers and other technology if it was not to eliminate personnel positions? We should have significantly dropped positions considering all the functions that in every day work can now be automated.
 
Rather pathetic overall. Why have we spent billions on computers and other technology if it was not to eliminate personnel positions? We should have significantly dropped positions considering all the functions that in every day work can now be automated.

That's how government works. Their top priority is perpetuating their own bureaucracy. When I consulted on a large ERP business transformation project for a major state government organization, we pitched them on how this system could reduce headcount in several key areas (HR, finance, procurement, etc). The first thing they said was that they weren't going to let anyone go. In fact, they had planned to add headcount to deal with "the new system". WTF??
 
Rather pathetic overall.

Here I'll have to agree. Orthodox economic theory would say we should be BOOSTING government employment in a time like the aftermath of the financial meltdown, not cutting it. So, it's pathetic we decided to cut government payrolls when those jobs were needed most. But, pathetic or not, it is fascinating that this has been a record-long run of government job cuts.

Why have we spent billions on computers and other technology if it was not to eliminate personnel positions?

As you know, trillions of dollars have been spent throughout the economy over the course of decades on computers and technology, and yet the long-term trend has been for there to be more and more jobs, not fewer. The productivity enhancements from these technologies do not need to be realized through job destruction. It can show up as rising quality of life. And that's true whether we're talking about the private sector or public sector. When government gets more productive, it doesn't mean we must have fewer people providing the same quality of service; it can mean we have the same number of people providing higher quality of service.
 
Here I'll have to agree. Orthodox economic theory would say we should be BOOSTING government employment in a time like the aftermath of the financial meltdown, not cutting it. So, it's pathetic we decided to cut government payrolls when those jobs were needed most. But, pathetic or not, it is fascinating that this has been a record-long run of government job cuts.



As you know, trillions of dollars have been spent throughout the economy over the course of decades on computers and technology, and yet the long-term trend has been for there to be more and more jobs, not fewer. The productivity enhancements from these technologies do not need to be realized through job destruction. It can show up as rising quality of life. And that's true whether we're talking about the private sector or public sector. When government gets more productive, it doesn't mean we must have fewer people providing the same quality of service; it can mean we have the same number of people providing higher quality of service

The goal should always be to cut personnel and therefore overhead while providing the same or better service. Anything else is inefficent. Merely because other entities are inefficient and thus are a drag on our overall productivity - doesn't mean, and certainly shouldn't mean that Govt should follow suit. Every dollar the Gov't pays out in salary is a dollar taken by another member of society. That money belongs first and foremost to the taxpayers so the Gov't is by obligation required to spend that as wisely as possible and only on absolutely necessary services.

There is never a reason to expand Gov't and certainty not to artificially plump up the economy. Economies should have great gains and great contractions. And, people need to learn and adapt and prepare - or they suffer. Either way - it is necessary to clean out the deadweight and to come back leaner and meaner.
 
The goal should always be to cut personnel and therefore overhead while providing the same or better service.

Business people disagree with you. Their goal is to maximize the value of the business. If that can be done by cutting personnel, great. If it can be done by increasing personnel, that's great too. The most successful businesses are those that have done a lot more adding of staff than cutting staff. For example, if you go back to the 1970s, you'll find that Walmart had VASTLY fewer employees than it has today. Obviously, during the time in between, the goal of management wasn't always to cut personnel. Same with Apple and Exxon and Microsoft.

Governments are the same. Pretty much every government in the world has increased staffing over pretty much any sufficiently sustained period (recall: our run of nine years without adding government staff is almost certainly the longest such period in all of American history). The only time you'll find long-term declines in government staffing is during outright collapses of nations -- for example, Rome falling apart and descending into a dark age.

The goal shouldn't be to shrink government, any more than the goal should be to grow it. The goal should be to get an optimal balance -- a level where you're getting the best service out of government you can without the diminishing returns of crowding out something even better you could have if that money and those personnel were available to the private sector. There's no hard and fast rule about what level of government employment that entails, but historically the more sophisticated and prosperous societies became, the bigger the government they tend to favor -- when we were a poor agrarian nation, for example, we had relatively few government workers per capita compared to today, and in the Middle Ages, when nations were dirt poor, the relative sizes of governments were even smaller. Based on those historical trends, we should expect government not only to grow in absolute terms, over time, but actually to grow relative to the size of the population and the economy, as a nation gets more sophisticated and prosperous.
 
What was the longest period of time our country ever went with a net decrease in the number of people working for the government?

You're kidding, 50,000 out of a bloated enterprise of 22 million in which retirements of people who weren't needed anyway is a fantastic fact? Really?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top