New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Fixing Education

Arkady

President
I listened to a podcast this morning about the Finnish education system. As you may know, Finland has become arguably the most successful nation in the world at educating its residents. There are international tests of student achievement (the PISA tests) on which Finland has repeatedly finished first or at least in the top three across the three tested subject area. That's despite Finland spending considerably less on education than the US, which often doesn't even finish in the top twenty.

It's difficult for me to process Finland's success, since it runs against some of my starting assumptions about education. For example, I've long been a proponent of standardized testing to track student, teacher, and school performance, and also a fan of detailed curricula set at the national level. Those ideas are based on how education systems are set up in other top-performing nations, especially in Asia. And, just as a general matter, I think it's hard to decide what to do if you aren't measuring results. But Finland is different. They have almost no testing and they have a great deal of teacher flexibility in setting the details of the curricula and the methods of teaching. Yet, it demonstrably works well for them.

I still haven't given up on my beliefs about setting curricula and testing, but I now accept that, while those may be normal features of highly successful educational systems, they're not indispensable features. The indispensable feature is having high quality teachers. That's the feature that unites Finland, South Korea, elite private schools, and the more successful US public schools.

In Finland, experienced teachers earn more than people with their level of education do on average, whereas in the US experienced teachers earn less. Perhaps even more importantly, in Finland teaching is a highly esteemed profession, treated as being on par with medicine and law. In the US, a combination of contempt for the public sector, anti-intellectualism, and cynical anti-unionism have combined to subject teachers to a level of scorn not seen in any of the successful systems.

In Finland, teaching is seen as such a prestigious and desirable career that the primary schools can get away with accepting only 10% of those who apply to become teachers.... and that's with a pool of applicants who all have master's degrees. That allows the Finnish system to take only the best of the best to educate their kids. And they retain that quality, with teachers leaving the profession at only a third the rate of US teachers.

Studies suggest there is a gigantic difference between a good teacher and a mediocre one, in terms of the educational outcomes for the students in their charge. It's the single most important factor aside from parental wealth -- far more important than other things one might emphasize, like access to technology or the quality of the physical schoolhouse. So, when you look at how the Finns have transformed teaching into an elite profession, it's suddenly not so surprising that they can do so well. The kinds of people who, in the US, become investment bankers or lawyers at white shoe firms often choose education in Finland.

We should be able to replicate Finland's success, with or without standardized testing and curricula reform, if we can attract and retain the best people in the teaching profession. We could start by doing more to make university and masters programs affordable to those who go into teaching -- for example, with programs providing deferred loan repayments followed by full loan forgiveness for those who go into public school teaching and stick with it for ten years. We can also work on the kinds of things that make it more appealing to be a professor -- sabbaticals, for example, and more generous policies towards paid maternity and paternity leave. But, mostly, we'd need to bring about a cultural shift in attitudes about education and educators. You can get away with paying people less and working them harder if they're getting the intangible benefits of "bragging rights" in the society (the military is a good example), but right now we don't offer teachers that kind of cultural prestige.

Unfortunately, we're probably headed in exactly the wrong direction. Most reform efforts focus on things that will make life tougher on teachers (more oversight, more testing, less job security), and there's no serious effort to counter those rising difficulties with other benefits (higher pay, more perks, more prestige). In fact, those who claim to care most about education are often those who are doing the most to browbeat and shame teachers, making it all the harder to attract and retain the best talent.
 
Last edited:
While I agree with your post, I think it needs to be pointed out that while having superior teachers is a key element in achieving an above average education, parental involvement in their childrens education is equally important.
 
I think teaching and investment in teachers is just one element in a continuum... As CM states above, parental involvement, and student committment are equal to, if not more important in the success sought.

I think too often we diminish and distill standards in order to statistically capture the most 'success'. It is an artificial construct without merit.

If we were to examine Finnish, or South Korean, or what have you superior education systems...I think what we would learn about student committment and investment would put our own to shame.

Further, I'd be willing to bet... that in a hypothetical scenario... were we to put Finnish teachers into the American system.. they'd soon be off put by the laxity of committment....
 
I think teaching and investment in teachers is just one element in a continuum... As CM states above, parental involvement, and student committment are equal to, if not more important in the success sought.

I think too often we diminish and distill standards in order to statistically capture the most 'success'. It is an artificial construct without merit.

If we were to examine Finnish, or South Korean, or what have you superior education systems...I think what we would learn about student committment and investment would put our own to shame.

Further, I'd be willing to bet... that in a hypothetical scenario... were we to put Finnish teachers into the American system.. they'd soon be off put by the laxity of committment....

And I'd be willing to bet that in Finnland, or South Korea, students STRIVE for excellence, and their parents and peers support them in that endeavor 100%.

Whereas....striving for excellence in THIS country often gets derided and sneered at as "acting white".
 
And I'd be willing to bet that in Finnland, or South Korea, students STRIVE for excellence, and their parents and peers support them in that endeavor 100%.

Whereas....striving for excellence in THIS country often gets derided and sneered at as "acting white".


Let me be first to ask.... cause I feel it coming...through my screen..

why 'acting white'? no other gradation of student strives?
 
you make some great points. that said, here's what's different between the USA and finland

10 - education majors in US colleges have the lowest SAT scores of any profession requiring a 4 year degree. THE lowest.

9 - it is almost impossible to fire a teacher for incompetence or derelection of duty. a teacher can commit a felony, and then be placed on leave for 2 years or longer while fighting dismissal charges. the number of teachers dismissed in any district is typically less than 1/10th of 1% annually.

8 -america has a huge problem with pot, other narcotics, and gang violence that is not present in finnish society

7 - significant portions of the US student population are not native english speakers, and need ESL instruction to proceed in school

6 - do finnish students get 3 months off in the summer to go play?

5 - school districts and teachers unions are notorious for creating curriculums around the "inventory" of tenured staff they have, rather than student needs or parent demands. kids will be shunted into remedial reading programs to fill up the classes if funding loss is at risk. kids take spanish rather than latin, japanese, chinese, or russian because unions are "heavy" with spanish teachers.

4 - i'm willing to guess that finnish schools have a more effective discipline system for chronic violent students than a 3 day suspension.

3 - we have already doubled US teacher salaries - in real, inflation dollars - over the past 25 years, and SAT scores haven't budged

2 - US parent apathy is legendary. Although middle class suburban parents will show up for elementary school semester progress meetings, by high school nobody shows up any more. Kids who need the most encouragement and guidance from their parents - from single family households, lower income homes, both parents working, etc - seem to get the least. Kids have cell phones and facebook accounts, but don't turn in their homework.

1 - i'm willing to bet Finnish teachers don't spend millions of dollars a year fighting standardized testing.
 
Let me be first to ask.... cause I feel it coming...through my screen..

why 'acting white'? no other gradation of student strives?

I dunno why those who sneer at the desire for excellence call it that....

It's not MY "invention".
 
you make some great points. that said, here's what's different between the USA and finland

10 - education majors in US colleges have the lowest SAT scores of any profession requiring a 4 year degree. THE lowest.

9 - it is almost impossible to fire a teacher for incompetence or derelection of duty. a teacher can commit a felony, and then be placed on leave for 2 years or longer while fighting dismissal charges. the number of teachers dismissed in any district is typically less than 1/10th of 1% annually.

8 -america has a huge problem with pot, other narcotics, and gang violence that is not present in finnish society

7 - significant portions of the US student population are not native english speakers, and need ESL instruction to proceed in school

6 - do finnish students get 3 months off in the summer to go play?

5 - school districts and teachers unions are notorious for creating curriculums around the "inventory" of tenured staff they have, rather than student needs or parent demands. kids will be shunted into remedial reading programs to fill up the classes if funding loss is at risk. kids take spanish rather than latin, japanese, chinese, or russian because unions are "heavy" with spanish teachers.

4 - i'm willing to guess that finnish schools have a more effective discipline system for chronic violent students than a 3 day suspension.

3 - we have already doubled US teacher salaries - in real, inflation dollars - over the past 25 years, and SAT scores haven't budged

2 - US parent apathy is legendary. Although middle class suburban parents will show up for elementary school semester progress meetings, by high school nobody shows up any more. Kids who need the most encouragement and guidance from their parents - from single family households, lower income homes, both parents working, etc - seem to get the least. Kids have cell phones and facebook accounts, but don't turn in their homework.

1 - i'm willing to bet Finnish teachers don't spend millions of dollars a year fighting standardized testing.



Good points ASOT. You and Barb have both hit on what I think is the biggest. Parental and student apathy.

My kids are just getting into school. We live in the county that was ranked with the top schools in the state ( yes we beat out Mont. and Howard Counties), in a State which depending on what ranking you are looking at is ranked the best - if not the best int he top 5 on practically ever list I have ever seen. In short - my kids are in good schools in a state with good education policies....our elementary school has less than 2% of the kids on free and reduced lunches. By and large, I would say the feeder area is upper middle class. The neighborhood where the school is has an average home sales price of $440,000.

So, you can't blame the extreme lack of parental participation that I have witnessed just this year on the host of things we usually blame it on. We aren't dealing with poor people who are working 6 jobs to keep food on the table. We aren't dealing with people who lack transportation - every family on my block owns at least three vehicles. We are not dealing with people who themselves don't speak English as their primary language - less than 5% of the students are minority. There is virtually no crime. No gang activity, etc.

So, what is it that makes the soccer fields every Sat and Sun completely overrun with parents and families -but back to school night, reading awareness night, evening of the arts ( kids displaying their artwork) , science fair night, parental conferces, etc so freaking poorly attended?

Apathy. Pure and simple Apathy on the part of the parents and the children. Misplaced priorities. DS is reading on a second grade level. We are trying to improve that over the summer. We want him up to a third grade level when he goes back to school. But, friends of ours had a son who didn't even complete the whole list of sight words for the year. He is a smart kid - their excuse - he doesnt' really do well when we try to work with him on it. He spends enough time in school - we don't want to have to do a lot of school work at home. I can't TELL you how many times I have come accross this attitude. In what is a good school - in a good school district - in well off community. And, it is frightening. If these kind of people are not pushing their kids for academic excellence.... who the hell is? the answer is likely no one.

connie
 
Good points ASOT. You and Barb have both hit on what I think is the biggest. Parental and student apathy.

My kids are just getting into school. We live in the county that was ranked with the top schools in the state ( yes we beat out Mont. and Howard Counties), in a State which depending on what ranking you are looking at is ranked the best - if not the best int he top 5 on practically ever list I have ever seen. In short - my kids are in good schools in a state with good education policies....our elementary school has less than 2% of the kids on free and reduced lunches. By and large, I would say the feeder area is upper middle class. The neighborhood where the school is has an average home sales price of $440,000.

So, you can't blame the extreme lack of parental participation that I have witnessed just this year on the host of things we usually blame it on. We aren't dealing with poor people who are working 6 jobs to keep food on the table. We aren't dealing with people who lack transportation - every family on my block owns at least three vehicles. We are not dealing with people who themselves don't speak English as their primary language - less than 5% of the students are minority. There is virtually no crime. No gang activity, etc.

So, what is it that makes the soccer fields every Sat and Sun completely overrun with parents and families -but back to school night, reading awareness night, evening of the arts ( kids displaying their artwork) , science fair night, parental conferces, etc so freaking poorly attended?

Apathy. Pure and simple Apathy on the part of the parents and the children. Misplaced priorities. DS is reading on a second grade level. We are trying to improve that over the summer. We want him up to a third grade level when he goes back to school. But, friends of ours had a son who didn't even complete the whole list of sight words for the year. He is a smart kid - their excuse - he doesnt' really do well when we try to work with him on it. He spends enough time in school - we don't want to have to do a lot of school work at home. I can't TELL you how many times I have come accross this attitude. In what is a good school - in a good school district - in well off community. And, it is frightening. If these kind of people are not pushing their kids for academic excellence.... who the hell is? the answer is likely no one.

connie


Fact of the matter is...(at least in my opinion)..the curriculum of any given grade..does not push for more from kids, other than what may be considered 'sufficient' to achieve whatever requirement there are of the grade.

our guy is just through first. and he ate it up. though if it werent for our augmenting with reading, writing, etc.. I don't think he would be where he is presently. (he's at a 3rd 4th level if not better...)

interesting think is... where we discuss it with teacher/staff.. it kind of disconcerting that they reply with..'we'll he meets the criteria', rather than offer more to meet his need...
 
Fact of the matter is...(at least in my opinion)..the curriculum of any given grade..does not push for more from kids, other than what may be considered 'sufficient' to achieve whatever requirement there are of the grade.

our guy is just through first. and he ate it up. though if it werent for our augmenting with reading, writing, etc.. I don't think he would be where he is presently. (he's at a 3rd 4th level if not better...)

interesting think is... where we discuss it with teacher/staff.. it kind of disconcerting that they reply with..'we'll he meets the criteria', rather than offer more to meet his need...


Good point, Phil. It doesn't seem like many of the educators are pushing for excellence either. I am not sure it it is class size, that they are afraid it won't be well received by a parent, that they don't make to make the other kids who aren't keeping up "feel bad", etc. Its hard to say. I think that my son's teacher was more than capable of teaching him more and imparting more to him. I loved her enthusiasm. She was terrific.

But, yeah, we got a "good job" for son, and not much in the way of suggestions for improvement or current advancement even when I asked. DS's reportcard had Exceeded Expectations in EVERY aspect of the cirriculum. Every one. And, really, while I love my son and think he is totally awesome... there is NO WAY he should have been exceeding all expecation. If he was - then the expectations were far too low.

And, don't even get me started on the first grade readiness book they sent home to work on over the summer... it is a joke. Seriously - this is stuff he was doing in pre-school. I gave it to DD who is two years younger. And, I bought DS some first grade workbooks online.

connie
 
Good points ASOT. You and Barb have both hit on what I think is the biggest. Parental and student apathy.

My kids are just getting into school. We live in the county that was ranked with the top schools in the state ( yes we beat out Mont. and Howard Counties), in a State which depending on what ranking you are looking at is ranked the best - if not the best int he top 5 on practically ever list I have ever seen. In short - my kids are in good schools in a state with good education policies....our elementary school has less than 2% of the kids on free and reduced lunches. By and large, I would say the feeder area is upper middle class. The neighborhood where the school is has an average home sales price of $440,000.

So, you can't blame the extreme lack of parental participation that I have witnessed just this year on the host of things we usually blame it on. We aren't dealing with poor people who are working 6 jobs to keep food on the table. We aren't dealing with people who lack transportation - every family on my block owns at least three vehicles. We are not dealing with people who themselves don't speak English as their primary language - less than 5% of the students are minority. There is virtually no crime. No gang activity, etc.

So, what is it that makes the soccer fields every Sat and Sun completely overrun with parents and families -but back to school night, reading awareness night, evening of the arts ( kids displaying their artwork) , science fair night, parental conferces, etc so freaking poorly attended?

Apathy. Pure and simple Apathy on the part of the parents and the children. Misplaced priorities. DS is reading on a second grade level. We are trying to improve that over the summer. We want him up to a third grade level when he goes back to school. But, friends of ours had a son who didn't even complete the whole list of sight words for the year. He is a smart kid - their excuse - he doesnt' really do well when we try to work with him on it. He spends enough time in school - we don't want to have to do a lot of school work at home. I can't TELL you how many times I have come accross this attitude. In what is a good school - in a good school district - in well off community. And, it is frightening. If these kind of people are not pushing their kids for academic excellence.... who the hell is? the answer is likely no one.

connie

although i served up the term "apathy", and am overjoyed when erudite members like you agree with me, "apathy" probably needs to be nuanced

one way to get at this is to recognize that its easier to set out a lawn chair at a soccer game, and watch your daughter yell with happiness "mommy - watch me" as she races across the field to kick the ball. easier than going to a classroom, sitting at a toddler sized chair/desk combo, and being handed a folder of completed tests and assignments and hearing "betsey is mostly doing very well, but . . . "

teachers like to explain the lack of SAT score progress by pointing out that "parents have these kids for 16 hours a day -we have them for 6 or 7." yeah but half the time i have my daughter she's asleep, and we do't do homework continuously during the remaining waking hours at home.

parents and kids apathy seems to converge when you ask your daughter "what are you reading in english class", and she hands you an 8th grade textbook of short stories written by academics on politically correct age appropriate themes, rather than classic young adult literature which we might have encountered ourselves. there's no basis for a conversation that begins "yes I read that book too when I was your age - tell me, what do you think about . . . "

of course, for some parents, who work in blue collar jobs, or no jobs at all, the value of an education is a mystery, hence the apathy. they see school as a warehouse to keep kids off the street and away from the gangs, and if that doesnt work its not their (the parents fault). when they turn the TV on at night they see news reports of about high unemployment rates among recent college grads, how they're working at mcjobs alongside dropouts, and their skepticism that much of the educational process is a "beside the point" irrelevant exercise . .. that skepticism is reinforced.

how does someone like abraham lincoln go from being a railsplitter with a 6th grade education to a respected attorney, then president? intellectual curiosity. how does ernest hemingway go on to write amazing books? a teacher who captivated his imagination at an early age with interesting topics.

in beteween are your kids and mine - "above average" students who aren't going to become president and aren't lucky enough to have teachers who are passionate about their subjects - they interchangeably teach "language arts" "geometry" "earth science" and "history" depending on who quit last year.

i dont excuse apathy, but i undestand it.
 
Good point, Phil. It doesn't seem like many of the educators are pushing for excellence either. I am not sure it it is class size, that they are afraid it won't be well received by a parent, that they don't make to make the other kids who aren't keeping up "feel bad", etc. Its hard to say. I think that my son's teacher was more than capable of teaching him more and imparting more to him. I loved her enthusiasm. She was terrific.

But, yeah, we got a "good job" for son, and not much in the way of suggestions for improvement or current advancement even when I asked. DS's reportcard had Exceeded Expectations in EVERY aspect of the cirriculum. Every one. And, really, while I love my son and think he is totally awesome... there is NO WAY he should have been exceeding all expecation. If he was - then the expectations were far too low.

And, don't even get me started on the first grade readiness book they sent home to work on over the summer... it is a joke. Seriously - this is stuff he was doing in pre-school. I gave it to DD who is two years younger. And, I bought DS some first grade workbooks online.

connie


The more i think about it, the more i think 'apathy' pegs it. True, many teachers strive, as do many students. But in the race to homgeny..or parity... the bar inevitably is lowered..rather than raised. In so doing, it raises, or spreads the range of kids captured and deemed 'successful' according to the measures of the day. But it's a bar, now so low, that it should be easily attained by a majority, rather than an ever diminishing number.

What's our reaction (as an education system)... take the bar lower.

Blech.
 
Finnish demography is profoundly different from that of the U.S. In fact, it might be hard to find another modern, democratic nation in the world, that's more different from the U.S.

That's not to say that we shouldn't at least study and consider the Finnish model. But, we'd be seriously remiss to try assuming the Finnish model as our model.

Funny little aside....ALL of these modern, democratic, educational systems we so envy and admire, envy and admire our system as much as we do theirs. How can that be, since by many purely obejctive measures, they're outperforming us?

The answer's simple. Even as we may not recognize it, they do. They see the REMARKABLE success we've had, despite the our demographic challenges that're umpteen times greater than ANY of them must confront.
 
although i served up the term "apathy", and am overjoyed when erudite members like you agree with me, "apathy" probably needs to be nuanced

one way to get at this is to recognize that its easier to set out a lawn chair at a soccer game, and watch your daughter yell with happiness "mommy - watch me" as she races across the field to kick the ball. easier than going to a classroom, sitting at a toddler sized chair/desk combo, and being handed a folder of completed tests and assignments and hearing "betsey is mostly doing very well, but . . . "

teachers like to explain the lack of SAT score progress by pointing out that "parents have these kids for 16 hours a day -we have them for 6 or 7." yeah but half the time i have my daughter she's asleep, and we do't do homework continuously during the remaining waking hours at home.

parents and kids apathy seems to converge when you ask your daughter "what are you reading in english class", and she hands you an 8th grade textbook of short stories written by academics on politically correct age appropriate themes, rather than classic young adult literature which we might have encountered ourselves. there's no basis for a conversation that begins "yes I read that book too when I was your age - tell me, what do you think about . . . "

of course, for some parents, who work in blue collar jobs, or no jobs at all, the value of an education is a mystery, hence the apathy. they see school as a warehouse to keep kids off the street and away from the gangs, and if that doesnt work its not their (the parents fault). when they turn the TV on at night they see news reports of about high unemployment rates among recent college grads, how they're working at mcjobs alongside dropouts, and their skepticism that much of the educational process is a "beside the point" irrelevant exercise . .. that skepticism is reinforced.

how does someone like abraham lincoln go from being a railsplitter with a 6th grade education to a respected attorney, then president? intellectual curiosity. how does ernest hemingway go on to write amazing books? a teacher who captivated his imagination at an early age with interesting topics.

in beteween are your kids and mine - "above average" students who aren't going to become president and aren't lucky enough to have teachers who are passionate about their subjects - they interchangeably teach "language arts" "geometry" "earth science" and "history" depending on who quit last year.

i dont excuse apathy, but i undestand it.



I understand the "apathy" when it comes from people, like you indicated who lack education themselves, or have blue collar jobs and make decent money and didn't need any formal education themselves or those who are simply too overwhelmed trying to keep food on the table and a roof over their heads.

What I don't get at ALL is the apathy of other parents like you and me. Who aren't living high on the hog, but aren't worried about where the next meal is going to come from. Who aren't taking world tours, but don't worry about where the rent is coming from. Who are educated themselves and recognize that education is the future - yet don't make education a priority for their children. But, by golly soccer is or football is, or dance is, etc. What is happening when average to well off people are apathetic of the value of education? Pretty scary, yet, I saw it first hand for myself.

And, I agree with the apathy from some of the teachers. While salaries are lower than other countries, they ALSO have a substantial amount of time off, considerable job security, and other beneifts. For many people - its a reasonable trade off. I have several friends and family members who are teachers and they don't complain about their pay relative to their counterparts. I make quite a bit more than my SIL who is a teacher. But, I am here at work today, she is not. I won't be retiring when I am 50, she will be, etc..... its about what you value.

But, so much of it comes down to the parents. We don't sit there and do homework 24/7 either. BUT - we do make them turn off the dang TV or at least limit the majority of TV viewing to educational programs. We read books. When they play games on the computer they are educational games. We create our own crafts. We go to museums, to the zoo. When we take regular vacations we talk about the things where we are, how they differ from home, what is new of fun about that. EVERY day is a chance to learn something. And, its our job as parents to keep our kids learning. My kids are "advanced" for their age groups, but its not because they have an abundence of extra intelligence. Its that I think the standard for what is expected at their age level is woefully low and refuse to accept those standards.

connie
 
The more i think about it, the more i think 'apathy' pegs it. True, many teachers strive, as do many students. But in the race to homgeny..or parity... the bar inevitably is lowered..rather than raised. In so doing, it raises, or spreads the range of kids captured and deemed 'successful' according to the measures of the day. But it's a bar, now so low, that it should be easily attained by a majority, rather than an ever diminishing number.

What's our reaction (as an education system)... take the bar lower.

Blech.


You are right, Phil. The bar is continually lowered rather than raised.
 
While I agree with your post, I think it needs to be pointed out that while having superior teachers is a key element in achieving an above average education, parental involvement in their childrens education is equally important.

Agreed. That's another cultural factor I'd like to see us address, though I'm not sure exactly how to do so on a systematic basis.

People
How many Blacks, Mexicans, and Rednecks does Sweden have?

Why do you ask? We were talking about Finland.
 
Back
Top