Arkady
President
I listened to a podcast this morning about the Finnish education system. As you may know, Finland has become arguably the most successful nation in the world at educating its residents. There are international tests of student achievement (the PISA tests) on which Finland has repeatedly finished first or at least in the top three across the three tested subject area. That's despite Finland spending considerably less on education than the US, which often doesn't even finish in the top twenty.
It's difficult for me to process Finland's success, since it runs against some of my starting assumptions about education. For example, I've long been a proponent of standardized testing to track student, teacher, and school performance, and also a fan of detailed curricula set at the national level. Those ideas are based on how education systems are set up in other top-performing nations, especially in Asia. And, just as a general matter, I think it's hard to decide what to do if you aren't measuring results. But Finland is different. They have almost no testing and they have a great deal of teacher flexibility in setting the details of the curricula and the methods of teaching. Yet, it demonstrably works well for them.
I still haven't given up on my beliefs about setting curricula and testing, but I now accept that, while those may be normal features of highly successful educational systems, they're not indispensable features. The indispensable feature is having high quality teachers. That's the feature that unites Finland, South Korea, elite private schools, and the more successful US public schools.
In Finland, experienced teachers earn more than people with their level of education do on average, whereas in the US experienced teachers earn less. Perhaps even more importantly, in Finland teaching is a highly esteemed profession, treated as being on par with medicine and law. In the US, a combination of contempt for the public sector, anti-intellectualism, and cynical anti-unionism have combined to subject teachers to a level of scorn not seen in any of the successful systems.
In Finland, teaching is seen as such a prestigious and desirable career that the primary schools can get away with accepting only 10% of those who apply to become teachers.... and that's with a pool of applicants who all have master's degrees. That allows the Finnish system to take only the best of the best to educate their kids. And they retain that quality, with teachers leaving the profession at only a third the rate of US teachers.
Studies suggest there is a gigantic difference between a good teacher and a mediocre one, in terms of the educational outcomes for the students in their charge. It's the single most important factor aside from parental wealth -- far more important than other things one might emphasize, like access to technology or the quality of the physical schoolhouse. So, when you look at how the Finns have transformed teaching into an elite profession, it's suddenly not so surprising that they can do so well. The kinds of people who, in the US, become investment bankers or lawyers at white shoe firms often choose education in Finland.
We should be able to replicate Finland's success, with or without standardized testing and curricula reform, if we can attract and retain the best people in the teaching profession. We could start by doing more to make university and masters programs affordable to those who go into teaching -- for example, with programs providing deferred loan repayments followed by full loan forgiveness for those who go into public school teaching and stick with it for ten years. We can also work on the kinds of things that make it more appealing to be a professor -- sabbaticals, for example, and more generous policies towards paid maternity and paternity leave. But, mostly, we'd need to bring about a cultural shift in attitudes about education and educators. You can get away with paying people less and working them harder if they're getting the intangible benefits of "bragging rights" in the society (the military is a good example), but right now we don't offer teachers that kind of cultural prestige.
Unfortunately, we're probably headed in exactly the wrong direction. Most reform efforts focus on things that will make life tougher on teachers (more oversight, more testing, less job security), and there's no serious effort to counter those rising difficulties with other benefits (higher pay, more perks, more prestige). In fact, those who claim to care most about education are often those who are doing the most to browbeat and shame teachers, making it all the harder to attract and retain the best talent.
It's difficult for me to process Finland's success, since it runs against some of my starting assumptions about education. For example, I've long been a proponent of standardized testing to track student, teacher, and school performance, and also a fan of detailed curricula set at the national level. Those ideas are based on how education systems are set up in other top-performing nations, especially in Asia. And, just as a general matter, I think it's hard to decide what to do if you aren't measuring results. But Finland is different. They have almost no testing and they have a great deal of teacher flexibility in setting the details of the curricula and the methods of teaching. Yet, it demonstrably works well for them.
I still haven't given up on my beliefs about setting curricula and testing, but I now accept that, while those may be normal features of highly successful educational systems, they're not indispensable features. The indispensable feature is having high quality teachers. That's the feature that unites Finland, South Korea, elite private schools, and the more successful US public schools.
In Finland, experienced teachers earn more than people with their level of education do on average, whereas in the US experienced teachers earn less. Perhaps even more importantly, in Finland teaching is a highly esteemed profession, treated as being on par with medicine and law. In the US, a combination of contempt for the public sector, anti-intellectualism, and cynical anti-unionism have combined to subject teachers to a level of scorn not seen in any of the successful systems.
In Finland, teaching is seen as such a prestigious and desirable career that the primary schools can get away with accepting only 10% of those who apply to become teachers.... and that's with a pool of applicants who all have master's degrees. That allows the Finnish system to take only the best of the best to educate their kids. And they retain that quality, with teachers leaving the profession at only a third the rate of US teachers.
Studies suggest there is a gigantic difference between a good teacher and a mediocre one, in terms of the educational outcomes for the students in their charge. It's the single most important factor aside from parental wealth -- far more important than other things one might emphasize, like access to technology or the quality of the physical schoolhouse. So, when you look at how the Finns have transformed teaching into an elite profession, it's suddenly not so surprising that they can do so well. The kinds of people who, in the US, become investment bankers or lawyers at white shoe firms often choose education in Finland.
We should be able to replicate Finland's success, with or without standardized testing and curricula reform, if we can attract and retain the best people in the teaching profession. We could start by doing more to make university and masters programs affordable to those who go into teaching -- for example, with programs providing deferred loan repayments followed by full loan forgiveness for those who go into public school teaching and stick with it for ten years. We can also work on the kinds of things that make it more appealing to be a professor -- sabbaticals, for example, and more generous policies towards paid maternity and paternity leave. But, mostly, we'd need to bring about a cultural shift in attitudes about education and educators. You can get away with paying people less and working them harder if they're getting the intangible benefits of "bragging rights" in the society (the military is a good example), but right now we don't offer teachers that kind of cultural prestige.
Unfortunately, we're probably headed in exactly the wrong direction. Most reform efforts focus on things that will make life tougher on teachers (more oversight, more testing, less job security), and there's no serious effort to counter those rising difficulties with other benefits (higher pay, more perks, more prestige). In fact, those who claim to care most about education are often those who are doing the most to browbeat and shame teachers, making it all the harder to attract and retain the best talent.
Last edited: