New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Fixing Education

I think teaching and investment in teachers is just one element in a continuum... As CM states above, parental involvement, and student committment are equal to, if not more important in the success sought.

I think too often we diminish and distill standards in order to statistically capture the most 'success'. It is an artificial construct without merit.

If we were to examine Finnish, or South Korean, or what have you superior education systems...I think what we would learn about student committment and investment would put our own to shame.

Further, I'd be willing to bet... that in a hypothetical scenario... were we to put Finnish teachers into the American system.. they'd soon be off put by the laxity of committment....

Regarding student commitment, one of the interesting things about the Finnish system is that students do a lot less homework than here. So, although they may be more academically committed in other ways, it isn't showing up as a "grind it out" attitude about the work.

Still, I think you're on to something about the attitudes. I think you can see that even within the US. I often get accused of being a snob, and it's a fair accusation. I'm an intellectual elitist, and that's a fairly common "failing" in my region (Eastern Massachusetts). But as off-putting as that might be, I think it goes a long way towards explaining the success the "snobby" areas of the country have, academically. Massachusetts has high test scores, low drop-out rates, low rates of juvenile delinquency, and high rates of people going on to higher education, and it's because people see great value in intellectual distinction. Culturally, it's not an area that mistakes ignorance for authenticity. It's not an area where we dismiss our best and brightest as pointy-headed nerds. I think that as long as much of the country thinks "misunderestimate" is charmingly folksy, and politicians stoke anti-elitist sentiment to make it easier to dismiss the policy imperatives revealed by hard science, our educational system will continue to be in trouble.
 
And I'd be willing to bet that in Finnland, or South Korea, students STRIVE for excellence, and their parents and peers support them in that endeavor 100%.

Whereas....striving for excellence in THIS country often gets derided and sneered at as "acting white".

This isn't just a racial thing. That anti-elitism also poisons academic achievement within the white community, within many cultural settings in this country. It obviously doesn't take the form of concerns about "acting white," in that case, but it's still there.... often in the form of a kind of redneck pride and contempt for the "eggheads." It takes the form of contempt for science and high culture, and a dismissal of any publication that communicates beyond the fifth-grade level as part of the "liberal media." It takes the form of people who proudly misuse words and speak in heavy dialect in settings where proper diction is called for.
 
10 - education majors in US colleges have the lowest SAT scores of any profession requiring a 4 year degree. THE lowest.

If that's true (and it seem plausible enough), that points to the issue I was talking about. If you want to get top-notch people to get into education, you need to make it a lucrative, prestigious, or otherwise desirable profession. We're going the other way. We're making teaching even less desirable, so we should expect the quality to drop even further.

9 - it is almost impossible to fire a teacher for incompetence or derelection of duty.


I'd be surprised if it's any easier in Finland, since their teachers are unionized and, generally speaking, Europe has much more protective labor laws than the US. Regardless, if we make it easier to fire a teacher, realize that this decrease in job security makes the job less desirable, which will worsen the quality of applicants. So, unless we offset that change with something to make the position more desirable, thing will get worse.

8 -america has a huge problem with pot, other narcotics, and gang violence that is not present in finnish society

I don't know much about Finnish society. However, at least when it comes to pot, Europe is generally pretty laid back. I did a quick search and it appears Finland's marijuana laws are more liberal than in most of the US -- mild fines are the usual penalty for getting caught using. They also seem to be fairly liberal when it comes to other narcotics -- focusing on treatment of addiction as a medical issue, and needle exchanges to limit the harm drug addicts do to themselves.

7 - significant portions of the US student population are not native english speakers, and need ESL instruction to proceed in school

I wonder if we could decrease our problems with more bilingualism in school. Much of our ESL population is Spanish-speaking, so simply by having more Spanish-oriented schools, we could have people learn English more gradually, without derailing their learning in other areas. Finland, for example, has two official languages (Finnish and Swedish). Canada, which also outperforms the US, has two (English and French). Switzerland, another high performer, has four. So does Singapore. Perhaps our insistence on being a strictly English-speaking country, in the face of demographic realities, is holding us back.

6 - do finnish students get 3 months off in the summer to go play?

Yes. They get around three months, though the schedule is a little different from ours (May through mid August).

5 - school districts and teachers unions are notorious for creating curriculums around the "inventory" of tenured staff they have, rather than student needs or parent demands. kids will be shunted into remedial reading programs to fill up the classes if funding loss is at risk. kids take spanish rather than latin, japanese, chinese, or russian because unions are "heavy" with spanish teachers.


Would you advocate more government support for teacher training, so that we have more teachers to meet student needs and parent demands. As I understand it, teachers in the US typically have their continuing education at their own cost, whereas Finland covers it as a government expense.

4 - i'm willing to guess that finnish schools have a more effective discipline system for chronic violent students than a 3 day suspension.


No clue. The US, obviously, has more of a violence problem overall, so it may not be a big issue there.

3 - we have already doubled US teacher salaries - in real, inflation dollars - over the past 25 years, and SAT scores haven't budged


SAT scores are recalibrated on a regular basis. More importantly, the pool of students who take the SATs has expanded enormously (it used to be a test for the elite going on to top colleges, now it's a test for almost everyone). So, I'm not sure if anything meaningful can be said about whether they've budged or not, over that period. But, overall, test scores have improved in the US:

http://nationsreportcard.gov/ltt_2008/ltt0002.asp
http://nationsreportcard.gov/ltt_2008/ltt0003.asp

2 - US parent apathy is legendary. Although middle class suburban parents will show up for elementary school semester progress meetings, by high school nobody shows up any more. Kids who need the most encouragement and guidance from their parents - from single family households, lower income homes, both parents working, etc - seem to get the least. Kids have cell phones and facebook accounts, but don't turn in their homework.

One feature of the Finnish system is a lot less homework. That appeals to me. I found homework to be soul-deadening and worthless. If I've already mastered the concept, doing ten or eleven problems putting the same concept into practice is really just an exercise in trying to keep myself awake enough that I don't make dumb errors. I used to get crap grades just because I didn't bother with the homework, but why would I, other than for grade grubbing, when I knew I'd already mastered the material? As for parent apathy, I agree, but the question is what can we do about that. How do we foster a culture where academic achievement is celebrated. How, for example, do we make our heroes scientists and authors, not reality TV showoffs and athletes?

1 - i'm willing to bet Finnish teachers don't spend millions of dollars a year fighting standardized testing.


They don't have to, since nobody is spending millions of dollars a year trying to impose it on them. The Finnish system is almost completely free of it.
 
Finnish demography is profoundly different from that of the U.S. In fact, it might be hard to find another modern, democratic nation in the world, that's more different from the U.S.

That's not to say that we shouldn't at least study and consider the Finnish model. But, we'd be seriously remiss to try assuming the Finnish model as our model.

Funny little aside....ALL of these modern, democratic, educational systems we so envy and admire, envy and admire our system as much as we do theirs. How can that be, since by many purely obejctive measures, they're outperforming us?

The answer's simple. Even as we may not recognize it, they do. They see the REMARKABLE success we've had, despite the our demographic challenges that're umpteen times greater than ANY of them must confront.

Do you have examples of, say, Finnish people admiring our remarkable educational success?
 
I understand the "apathy" when it comes from people, like you indicated who lack education themselves, or have blue collar jobs and make decent money and didn't need any formal education themselves or those who are simply too overwhelmed trying to keep food on the table and a roof over their heads.

What I don't get at ALL is the apathy of other parents like you and me. Who aren't living high on the hog, but aren't worried about where the next meal is going to come from. Who aren't taking world tours, but don't worry about where the rent is coming from. Who are educated themselves and recognize that education is the future - yet don't make education a priority for their children. But, by golly soccer is or football is, or dance is, etc. What is happening when average to well off people are apathetic of the value of education? Pretty scary, yet, I saw it first hand for myself.

And, I agree with the apathy from some of the teachers. While salaries are lower than other countries, they ALSO have a substantial amount of time off, considerable job security, and other beneifts. For many people - its a reasonable trade off. I have several friends and family members who are teachers and they don't complain about their pay relative to their counterparts. I make quite a bit more than my SIL who is a teacher. But, I am here at work today, she is not. I won't be retiring when I am 50, she will be, etc..... its about what you value.

But, so much of it comes down to the parents. We don't sit there and do homework 24/7 either. BUT - we do make them turn off the dang TV or at least limit the majority of TV viewing to educational programs. We read books. When they play games on the computer they are educational games. We create our own crafts. We go to museums, to the zoo. When we take regular vacations we talk about the things where we are, how they differ from home, what is new of fun about that. EVERY day is a chance to learn something. And, its our job as parents to keep our kids learning. My kids are "advanced" for their age groups, but its not because they have an abundence of extra intelligence. Its that I think the standard for what is expected at their age level is woefully low and refuse to accept those standards.

connie

I wonder if our diminishing economic mobility is contributing to academic apathy. If you have a sense that the game is rigged --that the kids of the rich will be rich and the kids of the poor will be poor-- it's hard to get excited about playing the game better. I'm reminded of a high school basketball game I went to where the refs were home-towners for the opposing team and made a series of shockingly horrible calls in favor of their favored team early in the game. After that, the quality of play went to crap on both sides, since both had gotten the message that the game wasn't going to be decided by who works harder.
 
Do you have examples of, say, Finnish people admiring our remarkable educational success?

The best ecamples of this for you if you're interested, would be the Finnish Education establishment. That's who I learned this truth from. But as I say....they're really smart and really motivated. So, they recognize that in order to learn from the best, one needs to learn from everyone's strengths. Only a moron and/or a Fox/GOP, would think that he's got all the answers and there's nothing he can learn from those who confront bigger challenges than he.
 
The best ecamples of this for you if you're interested, would be the Finnish Education establishment. That's who I learned this truth from. But as I say....they're really smart and really motivated. So, they recognize that in order to learn from the best, one needs to learn from everyone's strengths. Only a moron and/or a Fox/GOP, would think that he's got all the answers and there's nothing he can learn from those who confront bigger challenges than he.


What's a Fox/GOP?
 
I wonder if our diminishing economic mobility is contributing to academic apathy. If you have a sense that the game is rigged --that the kids of the rich will be rich and the kids of the poor will be poor-- it's hard to get excited about playing the game better. I'm reminded of a high school basketball game I went to where the refs were home-towners for the opposing team and made a series of shockingly horrible calls in favor of their favored team early in the game. After that, the quality of play went to crap on both sides, since both had gotten the message that the game wasn't going to be decided by who works harder.

I don't think the average person considers the decrease in economic mobility and are likely to be completely unfazed by it. They have what they have. . The rich have always been rich and their kids will likely be rich, etc. Yet, even in this country with reduced economic mobility - people do still move up.

But, in my example you are talking about upper middle class people here ( in the example I gave) and their hold on that ledge is tenuous at best. They don't have family money, they don't come from money and they are likely the first higher wage earners in their family. One job loss, one bad career move and they plummet till the bottom. If they were concerned about economic mobility - they would be continuing to force pressure their kids to excel academically because not being "old" money they know their kids will still have to outperform many. But, yet - they are still not heavily vested in academic excellence, but yet are more vested in things like excellence in sports.

Personally, I would attribute the apathy I see in that socioeconomic level more to sheer laziness. It is a LOT of work to make your children's education a major priority in your home and in their lives. It means that you design your family time around educational opportunities. It means you pass on things like sports, time with friends, parties, etc. Quite frankly, I don't think most of them are willing to make that sacrifice.

connie
 
Agreed. That's another cultural factor I'd like to see us address, though I'm not sure exactly how to do so on a systematic basis.

People


Why do you ask? We were talking about Finland.

How many Blacks Mexicans and rednecks does Finland have?
 
so what we are saying is we pay people to do a job, they perform poorly at the job...and the ones performing poorly have a union that blocks all attempts to replace them...

if only all jobs offered tenure...
 
so what we are saying is we pay people to do a job, they perform poorly at the job...and the ones performing poorly have a union that blocks all attempts to replace them...

if only all jobs offered tenure...

What I'm saying is this. One of the most important ingredients to successful education is good teachers. In a country that lacks a draft for teachers (and which now lacks the kinds of social limits that used to make teaching one of the only available professions for the best and brightest women), you need a compelling reason for people to choose teaching as a profession, if you want to attract sufficient talent to the field. With some mix of pay, benefits, quality of life, and prestige, you need to compensate them in a way that makes the position competitive with other positions available to smart, educated, well-spoken, hard-working, and charismatic people. Not only are we failing to do that, right now, we're actually moving in the wrong direction. By trying to turn the screws on teachers, with less job security, more red tape, and more bureaucratic second-guessing, along with more anti-teacher propaganda, without offsetting those difficulties with improvements in other areas, we're making teaching even less attractive, and we should expect a corresponding decline in teacher quality.

Lawyers are probably a decent benchmark, since you're aiming for people with similar abilities: a combination of people skills, deft verbal communication, and advanced academic knowledge. So, how do you get a bright, hard-working young person to choose teaching over the law? There are a lot of strategies, but keep in mind that the finest law grads command STARTING base salaries of $160,000 per year, plus bonuses that can bring them close to $200,000. Now consider that, for such lawyers, the sky's the limit for compensation once they have some experience under the belt -- equity partners at the big firms make seven-figure incomes. Obviously, we can't realistically compensate public school teachers in a way that competes with that on pay. But if we want to be luring people from a similar talent pool, we're going to need some sort of a sales pitch to distract from that pay gap.

How would YOU improve teacher quality?
 
What I'm saying is this. One of the most important ingredients to successful education is good teachers. In a country that lacks a draft for teachers (and which now lacks the kinds of social limits that used to make teaching one of the only available professions for the best and brightest women), you need a compelling reason for people to choose teaching as a profession, if you want to attract sufficient talent to the field. With some mix of pay, benefits, quality of life, and prestige, you need to compensate them in a way that makes the position competitive with other positions available to smart, educated, well-spoken, hard-working, and charismatic people. Not only are we failing to do that, right now, we're actually moving in the wrong direction. By trying to turn the screws on teachers, with less job security, more red tape, and more bureaucratic second-guessing, along with more anti-teacher propaganda, without offsetting those difficulties with improvements in other areas, we're making teaching even less attractive, and we should expect a corresponding decline in teacher quality.

Lawyers are probably a decent benchmark, since you're aiming for people with similar abilities: a combination of people skills, deft verbal communication, and advanced academic knowledge. So, how do you get a bright, hard-working young person to choose teaching over the law? There are a lot of strategies, but keep in mind that the finest law grads command STARTING base salaries of $160,000 per year, plus bonuses that can bring them close to $200,000. Now consider that, for such lawyers, the sky's the limit for compensation once they have some experience under the belt -- equity partners at the big firms make seven-figure incomes. Obviously, we can't realistically compensate public school teachers in a way that competes with that on pay. But if we want to be luring people from a similar talent pool, we're going to need some sort of a sales pitch to distract from that pay gap.

How would YOU improve teacher quality?

People seem to have no problem bullying, berating, and "pinch-pennying" the professionals who teach their children. I seriously doubt that ANY would do so as regards their doctor.
 
How to make education better?

Cut the department of education. Give the power to the states, and make schools local entities, so they can curtail to their own populace.

One size does not fit all, which is what the federal government stands upon.
 
so what we are saying is we pay people to do a job, they perform poorly at the job...and the ones performing poorly have a union that blocks all attempts to replace them...

if only all jobs offered tenure...

If you're willing to pay for a Mercedes, you get a Mercedes. If all you've got, or all you're willing to part with, is Yugo money, all you'll get is a Yugo. No amount of chest-thumping, braying, threatening, and "replacing" can turn that Yugo into a Mercedes. But...if bottomline - you're not going to pay more than Yugo money come hell or high water, you'd best take real good care of that Yugo, so's at least it'll get your from point A to point B.
 
How to make education better?

Cut the department of education. Give the power to the states, and make schools local entities, so they can curtail to their own populace.

One size does not fit all, which is what the federal government stands upon.

To the extent the Feds are currently involved in public education, it's a direct result of the state's failures in this regard. I've yet to hear anyone describe how sure.....it was important for the Feds to step in at one time, but NOW...everyone would better off without them.
 
If you're willing to pay for a Mercedes, you get a Mercedes. If all you've got, or all you're willing to part with, is Yugo money, all you'll get is a Yugo. No amount of chest-thumping, braying, threatening, and "replacing" can turn that Yugo into a Mercedes. But...if bottomline - you're not going to pay more than Yugo money come hell or high water, you'd best take real good care of that Yugo, so's at least it'll get your from point A to point B.

no, see we pay for a mercedes and get a yugo...
 
Back
Top