New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Fumbling Obamacare

It's about goals. My goal is to improve the lives of Americans. Obama's goal was to secure himself a job for eight years. I have nothing but admiration in his political acumen when it comes to accomplishing that second goal, but the first one is what concerns me.

He accomplished passage of the PPACA, flawed as it may be. Neither you, me, Bill or Hillary Clinton, nor any other President within my lifetime has managed that much.

He now wants the legislation to survive for long enough to evolve into what you, I and the President would have liked for PPACA to have been to begin with. Political progress is slow and ugly, but the alternative is no progress.
 
Well, I would also think its about getting voters. Voters who may not be really happy to have their hours cut and or be laid off. But, you are probably right, right now its about campaign funds. Screw the individuals who will be left with a smaller paycheck next year.

In case you haven't noticed (and you may well have not), many voters are stupid and easily led about by high-dollar marketing campaigns.

Unfortunate, but true.
 
Most of the modern, western, capitalist, democratic states' healthcare regimes, came into being over the several decades post WWII. Alas for us, Medicare (for 65 and up) was a heavy enough political lift in and of itself, that we'd be naive and/or disengenuous to suggest that we should have created Medicare for all back then - no matter how good an idea it might've been.

50 years later, that political lift would've been umpteen times greater and umpteen times LESS plausible. Pres. Obama made specific note of that when he suggested that IF we'd tackled this issue 50-60 years ago, we could've done it way differently from what's politically plausible today.

Weenie-whining about how Obama should've done this better somehow, is useless navel-contemplative gas. And as to those on the Fox/right who're criticizing it? We'll note that currently, the GOP has NO alternative on the table whatsoever.
 
In case you haven't noticed (and you may well have not), many voters are stupid and easily led about by high-dollar marketing campaigns.

Unfortunate, but true.

Well I do agree with that, hence why I called them sheep, but out of work is out of work... and it may not be so easy to lead someone whose employer has outright blamed Obamacare for their troubles.
 
Well I do agree with that, hence why I called them sheep, but out of work is out of work... and it may not be so easy to lead someone whose employer has outright blamed Obamacare for their troubles.

That's why there is some politicking going on with this roll-out. It is reactive, yet necessary for long-term strategy.

BTW: I don't like it any more than anyone else does, I've just outgrown my youthful idealism and accepted the fact that politics is politics.
 
I never complained about the original timeline. Three plus years seemed a bit slow for implementing a law that everyone had already known the key terms of for a year before it was even passed. But I figured that exceedingly timid timeline was conservative, in the classic sense of the word, and I could accommodate Obama's conservatism. But, my patience is stretching thin. An already-timid timeline is being delayed even more for the exclusive benefit of big corporations.

Let's compare that to the history of Medicare -- A VASTLY MORE AMBITIOUS REFORM. It was signed into law on July 30, 1965. It was implemented less than a year later on July 1, 1966, with 19 million people enrolling. By the time Medicare was as old as the Affordable Care act already is, new laws had actually expanded it, to cover some younger people (Medicaid). The Social Security system, likewise, was launched in about a year (with the first person who'd reached eligibility retiring five years after it was signed).

I get that Obama was never going to be as bold as LBJ or FDR when it came to domestic policy, but he's not even as bold as George W. Bush. When Bush pushed through Medicare Part B, in December of 2003, he didn't say that those benefits wouldn't start until 2007, much less delaying it, by executive fiat, until 2008. The prescription drug benefit started January 1, 2006, just over two years from signing. Obama "out-conservatives" the arch-conservative. He is a painfully timid politician when it comes to his domestic agenda. That's especially odd compared to his foreign policy agenda, where he is happy to throw our military into battle without so much as a Congressional authorization, much less years of delay.
That's a fair criticism. LBJ and GWB were certainly better at getting members of their own party to bend in the legislative process. Giving Max Baucus,Ben Nelson,Blanche Lincoln and Joe Lieberman a free hand in drafting the PPACA was a mistake. Now that it's full implementation time,none of them are around to see it through. The illness and death of Ted Kennedy in 2009 was a real blow to healthcare reform too.
 
I was always skeptical of the Affordable Care Act. Put it this way: if you took the forty richest countries in the world and arrayed our healthcare systems from most to least socialized, the US would come out as the very least socialized, with an appreciable margin between itself and the next-closest country... and that's AFTER Obamacare is finally completely phased in. It was a reform built around the goal of preserving corporate profits -- a reform designed by the conservative think tank the Heritage Foundation, and previously championed by Republican standard-bearer Mitt Romney. Yet, despite it essentially being a Republican package that would leave us as an outlier among advanced nations, I supported passage because I thought it was at least a small step in the right direction. Unfortunately, Obama seems intent on making it an even smaller step, or at least a slower one.

First Obama delayed implementation on the rules about businesses providing insurance. Now he's delaying implementation on the rules about maximum levels people can be required to spend:

http://www.salon.com/2013/08/13/another_obamacare_setback/

I get that this is a big, complicated reform, but how did Obama fail to get his ducks in a row after all this time? The whole point of the painfully slow roll-out (it became law well over three years ago) was to provide ample time for implementation. How is it that Obama feels he needs to provide big insurers and companies even more time to adapt to changes they've seen coming since 2008, and that they knew about definitively since early 2010?

From the perspective of the little guy, these delays are a disaster. The Mandate is going into effect (the little guy doesn't have a high-priced lobbyist to buy a one year reprieve from the Obama team), but the things that made the Mandate palatable (employer mandates and price controls for some insurers), will be delayed. The opposite pattern could have been explained more easily --delaying the mandate for individuals by a year, while forcing the big companies to comply with the original timeline-- since the big companies have the expertise and resources not to have been taken by surprise by any of this. But insisting on a strict timeline for the little guy while powerful corporations get the rules bent is the kind of thing you see when money is running the show.


Another thing...this isn't really a 'fumble'. It's by design. This latest extension/delay is a political stunt to keep premiums from rising even more (as they will once out of pocket costs are capped) until after the midterms.
 
It took less than a year to roll out Medicare, which is far more ambitious -- being a single-payer socialized system.
The US population in 1965 was far smaller and less diverse than it is now. We're talking too about an economy way different than it is now. I don't think the circumstances are comparable at all.
 
He accomplished passage of the PPACA, flawed as it may be. Neither you, me, Bill or Hillary Clinton, nor any other President within my lifetime has managed that much.

He now wants the legislation to survive for long enough to evolve into what you, I and the President would have liked for PPACA to have been to begin with. Political progress is slow and ugly, but the alternative is no progress.
Fair enough. I can't argue with the fact that, by being willing to push an exceedingly modest, conservative-friendly reform, Obama got passed the biggest improvement in healthcare since the early 1970s. It's an argument in favor of having modest, achievable ambitions. But, I still think there's a limit to that, and he's pushing it. This law has been in effect well over three years, and major aspects of it will still be lingering, unimplemented a year from now. That's over a full presidential term to phase in.
 
What was the makeup of Congress?
Congress isn't factoring in to the decision to delay these provisions by yet another year. That's all Obama. Like I said, I didn't complain about the initial slow three-plus-year timeline. I'm just complaining about the administration delaying even farther beyond that.
 
The US population in 1965 was far smaller and less diverse than it is now. We're talking too about an economy way different than it is now. I don't think the circumstances are comparable at all.
The circumstances are different in that we have far more international examples of successful systems to draw on, today, whereas Medicare was relatively ambitious by the standards of its own time. Plus, these days, we have more economies of scale.
 
Congress isn't factoring in to the decision to delay these provisions by yet another year. That's all Obama. Like I said, I didn't complain about the initial slow three-plus-year timeline. I'm just complaining about the administration delaying even farther beyond that.

You didn't answer my question. You dodged. Medicare was passed under a strong Democratic majority in both Houses and the Republican Party at that time was not nearly so radically right-wing as it is today. Still, they did oppose the passage of Medicare, and they have continuously opposed the program since it's inception. If they win a majority in Congress and the presidency again in the near future, they may well repeal Medicare along with PPACA.
 
I get that this is a big, complicated reform, but how did Obama fail to get his ducks in a row after all this time?

I'm sure it was someone else's fault. Probably Bush.
 
I get that this is a big, complicated reform, but how did Obama fail to get his ducks in a row after all this time?

I'm sure it was someone else's fault. Probably Bush.

I'm sure you have a coherent thought somewhere inside your noggin, if only it could find it's way out of there.
 
That's why there is some politicking going on with this roll-out. It is reactive, yet necessary for long-term strategy.

BTW: I don't like it any more than anyone else does, I've just outgrown my youthful idealism and accepted the fact that politics is politics.


I fully expect politics to be politics. The unfortunately thing is though that it is the individual who gets screwed either way. And, I just wonder if the individual will be smart enough to realize he was going to get screwed either way... or if he will not figure that out until next year's mid-terms. The thing is, I think businesses were slow to enact hoping that some sort of repeal or stay would be granted. So, now it has... but if they feel like this is going to be the last opportunity for a stay, are they going to start making major changes in their workforce and policy now or in the next 12 months... or are they going to wait until after the mid-terms to start the layoffs or hour reductions.....

I think if they go ahead with their plans - to reduce the number of staff eligible for benefits now it will be too early. I thin a year from now would be perfect to have a bunch of unhappy disgruntled people going to the polls who have realized how Obamacare may have cost them a decent job or decent income. On the other hand.... waiting until then could play right into a democrat who is saying that they will fix this problem, and the last thing I think any employer wants is the idea that has been floated around removing the 30 hour requirements for benefits, or lowering the 50 employee floor......

The reality is though Obamacare in its present form is going to cost jobs or hours for many people. I won't go so far as to say it wasn't a lie that it wouldn't. I really think more that it was a stark naivete which made legislators think that business owners wouldn't take such "drastic" measures. I think they overestimated two things - a business owner's concern for his employees and the business owner's willingness to sacrifice some bottom line to keep happy employees. After watching employers cut employee pay for several years during the worst of the recession and seeing the deteroriating relationship between many of my clients and their rank and file employee - I wasn't surprised. In happier times - this could have maybe gone through. But, right now as employers are digging out of a horrible recession and as employees have been feeling increasing unappreciated, and employers sort of feeling like an employee should just be happy he has a freaking job... its not really the time to tell an employer you have to give one more thing to a workforce he probably largely already sees as ungrateful.

connie
 
You didn't answer my question. You dodged. Medicare was passed under a strong Democratic majority in both Houses and the Republican Party at that time was not nearly so radically right-wing as it is today. Still, they did oppose the passage of Medicare, and they have continuously opposed the program since it's inception. If they win a majority in Congress and the presidency again in the near future, they may well repeal Medicare along with PPACA.
I didn't dodge. I merely pointed out that I didn't see the relevance to the discussion. If I were complaining about the initial timetable, then the different composition of Congress in '65 would be highly relevant, since one could argue that LBJ was able to push for an aggressive roll-out because he had a big majority, whereas Obama had to make do with an absurdly slow roll-out because he had no votes to spare to get it passed. But that doesn't explain why Obama has to slow the already-glacial pace of roll-out still farther -- not by Congressional action, but by the fiat of his own administration.

You mention the risk of Medicare being repealed. I see that as far-fetched, given the political bloodbath any time someone even tries to limit it a bit. But, as a thought experiment, I wonder if repeal of Medicare might actually be a positive thing, long term. Sure, it would result in a big increase in death rate among the elderly, which would be a massive tragedy. But it would also change the dynamics in favor of a more sweeping healthcare reform, of the sort every other wealthy nation has. One of the reasons it's been so hard to get reform here is that a huge chunk of the population has no reason to support it, since they already get their single-payer, highly-socialized government healthcare. Throw in the relatively socialized medical care of government employees, including our military and millions and millions of vets, and you remove some of the people with the most reliable records of actually showing up to vote from the political calculus in favor of first-world-style healthcare reform. If those people were thrown back into the mix with the rest of us, it would be harder to block real reform.
 
I get that this is a big, complicated reform, but how did Obama fail to get his ducks in a row after all this time?

I'm sure it was someone else's fault. Probably Bush.

If you have followed this strand, you will note that even President Obama's shortcomings testify to his utter brilliance in calculation, tactic, and abiding patience.

The apologetics approach is two-pronged: Republicans caused dilution and electoral realities cause deferment of the more onerous aspects of the legislation. Presidential brilliance inheres in his recognition of the lay of the land - and his keen capacity to read and react. He remains - as always - the spotless lamb. :-/
 
If you have followed this strand, you will note that even President Obama's shortcomings testify to his utter brilliance in calculation, tactic, and abiding patience.

The apologetics approach is two-pronged: Republicans caused dilution and electoral realities cause deferment of the more onerous aspects of the legislation. Presidential brilliance inheres in his recognition of the lay of the land - and his keen capacity to read and react. He remains - as always - the spotless lamb. :-/



Yes. When he screws up, its due to his uncommon brilliance. Makes perfect sense, if you drink enough kool-aid.
 
Back
Top