New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Help re: posting rules /etiquette

Spamature

President
I am not sure if so called :"call out" post are allowed So if I wanted to use a poster's posts in a top post and it uses a poster's post along with the posters screen name in the post or in the title to make a point

Is this kind of post allowed ?
 
I am not sure if so called :"call out" post are allowed So if I wanted to use a poster's posts in a top post and it uses a poster's post along with the posters screen name in the post or in the title to make a point

Is this kind of post allowed ?

It is in Crossfire.
 
That seems like a restrictive policy. I thought crossfire is a closed forum for insults and what not. Yet some subjects brought up by other posters (not this one in particular )may deserve to be considered or rebutted in there own post. Especially if they use several posts created by another poster to flesh out the point you want to make.
 
That seems like a restrictive policy. I thought crossfire is a closed forum for insults and what not. Yet some subjects brought up by other posters (not this one in particular )may deserve to be considered or rebutted in there own post. Especially if they use several posts created by another poster to flesh out the point you want to make.

All I can say is, myself, if I'm going to do a call otu I do it in Crossfire to avoid any penalties.
But maybe one of the mods can clarify it in more detail.


hey Mod's you gy's listening? Got a question here????

anyone, anyone, anyone ?????
 
Here's the pertinent section of the posting rules on that:
-No starting threads about other members to bash them, hate on them, illustrate a point or induce further political discussion of an issue, anything.
 
Here's the pertinent section of the posting rules on that:

Well even though I don't consider the post to bash or be hateful towards the poster. It does illustrate a further point and whether it induces further political discussion is not up to me.

So I have to message who to be allowed to post in that forum ?
 
It's probably better to avoid putting a poster's name in the subject line (unless it's happy birthday wish). That would remove the feeling that someone is being called out. If the intent of posting something that another poster said, just make a comment, put the other person's post in a quotation box, and talk about it. If your purpose is to mock that poster, then it will not be received well by the moderators and administrators. If the purpose is just to expand discussion on the topic, that intent will be obvious and the discussion will begin.



Well even though I don't consider the post to bash or be hateful towards the poster. It does illustrate a further point and whether it induces further political discussion is not up to me.

So I have to message who to be allowed to post in that forum ?
 
Ok so as long as I don't put the person's name in the title It's ok to use their post to make a point on a subject. I am not a mind reader so I have no idea as to whether or not the post will feel mocked by the post. But I think they have unwittingly made a very valid point on a recent and an ongoing political topic in the news.
 
To be safe I would have to say that you would likely be better off not to copy/paste their words or name them. But I would suggest you use your own post and words and PM the poster to see if it is of interest to that poster. It would be hard to tell without seeing it if it would be done correctly. The second thing you can do is PM the post to Dave and explain your intent to see if he gives you a pass.

I'll add that it is really great that you asked! Dave may be able to help you out.
 
To be safe I would have to say that you would likely be better off not to copy/paste their words or name them. But I would suggest you use your own post and words and PM the poster to see if it is of interest to that poster. It would be hard to tell without seeing it if it would be done correctly. The second thing you can do is PM the post to Dave and explain your intent to see if he gives you a pass.

I'll add that it is really great that you asked! Dave may be able to help you out.

Ughhh... so much bureaucracy when its really just a simple question.

The post is in regards to contraception and how women of child bearing age who might have been of the same mind as the poster was earlier in their life could benefit from postponing child birth until they had an epiphany of their own.

I think these two threads below make a valid point in when taken together and posing the question if this poster was a teenage female why would poster here be in favor of this person having children Especially when they make that they more than likely would not have been ready for the responsibility of parenting.

Personally I think it makes a better argument when someone right here in this forum is giving an account in their own words.



https://www.politicaljack.com/forum...-LOSERS&p=141728&highlight=liberal#post141728


https://www.politicaljack.com/forum...estion-for-smart-liberals&p=226330#post226330

In the second post he discusses parental rights. And that leads to the question of what greater parental right is there than the right to for an individual to make the decision on when or whether they become a parent.
 
I know bureaucrats are a pain! I PM'd this post link to Dave so hang in there and he may chime in since it is a good question. Dave has factual applications so he can probably help a lot more with this. ;)
 
If you want to debate with someone specific, just jump into the thread you wish to talk about and do it in there. You can reference other posts they make within that thread.
 
Ok so as long as I don't put the person's name in the title It's ok to use their post to make a point on a subject. I am not a mind reader so I have no idea as to whether or not the post will feel mocked by the post. But I think they have unwittingly made a very valid point on a recent and an ongoing political topic in the news.

Be careful Spamature. For instance, if you were to use a word like say..."Nincompoop" in your top-post subject line, there are certain other posters who may assume you're implying something untoward about them personally. I'm not sure HOW they know it...but they know for certain, that you're talking about them and thus, they may feel insulted.
 
If you want to debate with someone specific, just jump into the thread you wish to talk about and do it in there. You can reference other posts they make within that thread.

But references or quotes outside of that thread are off limits ?

As referenced in my first reply to Minotaur
 
But references or quotes outside of that thread are off limits ?

As referenced in my first reply to Minotaur

I don't mind you referencing something they said in other threads with a response to a post, or providing a link to it within a debate (assuming it came from this forum). It's starting a thread that we want to avoid, because it tends to lead to a ton of issues.
 
I don't mind you referencing something they said in other threads with a response to a post, or providing a link to it within a debate (assuming it came from this forum). It's starting a thread that we want to avoid, because it tends to lead to a ton of issues.

On one hand there are times when the posts within a thread turn out to be better starting places for a discussion that the top post they originated from. On the other hand I have seen where posters take things into directions they shouldn't go. That being said, I have no desire to be party to something that'll cause issues.
 
Back
Top