New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Hobby Lobby

What are you talking about?


Your opinion.
P.S. Abortion isn't the topic of debate here. Make a thread if you want to debate it and I won't involve myself.


What does this have to do with the discussion. Tie it in.
Play dumb all you want. But those example of being compelled that you offered are substantially different than the one under discussion. You compare apples and oranges. When the compact found in the constitution was made a lot of concessions were made as to what the government could do (i.e. compel) but the first 10 concession were what the government could not do and in order of importance.

Abortion is murder and tens of millions believe that to be the case. And in time it may well become many more than that.
 
Play dumb all you want. But those example of being compelled that you offered are substantially different than the one under discussion. You compare apples and oranges. When the compact found in the constitution was made a lot of concessions were made as to what the government could do (i.e. compel) but the first 10 concession were what the government could not do and in order of importance.

Abortion is murder and tens of millions believe that to be the case. And in time it may well become many more than that.

Again, what are you talking about?

For the given case, abortion isn't murder, legally, given that the Supreme Court has not overturned Roe vs Wade. So, for the purposes of this case, freedom of religion, it is perfectly legal and therefore is irrelevant. What happens in the future is debatable.
 
I'm still trying to wrap my head around how the Hobby Lobby reasoning is meant to work. It seems to stand for the idea that some types of businesses shouldn't have to contribute money that could ultimately indirectly pay for things that offend certain state-supported religious beliefs, if they don't want (e.g., if your religion objects to IUDs, the state defers to that faith, but if your religion objects to the use of blood products, you deserve no such deference). But businesses have ALWAYS had to contribute money that could ultimately indirectly pay for things that offend the religious beliefs of their owners. For example, taxes go to make war, even if you have a religious objection to war. Even when it comes to birth control, this is true. Your taxes indirectly pay for various kinds of birth control -- for example, condoms distributed to our soldiers. So, why is it OK for religious people to have to fund things they object to if the money flows through Uncle Sam but not if it flows through a private insurer?

And why doesn't this work the other way. I mean, the money that goes to the insurer isn't really the business's money, anyway. It's money that's mandated for an EMPLOYEE'S benefit, by law. It's the employee's money. It may be handed from the employer to the insurer, but the employer effectively just held it in trust for the employee, much in the same way as employee earnings that get direct deposited by the employer into the employee's retirement account. So, if it is, by law, money earmarked for the employee's benefit, why isn't it the employee's faith that counts, rather than the employer's?

It's a fairly appalling ruling, mainly for all the reasons Ruth Bader Ginsberg laid out in her dissent. The practical effect – the specific intended outcome of the ruling – is obnoxious enough. But the really appalling thing about the decision is the precedent it sets. And in that sense all these folks arguing back and forth about how the decision does or doesn't impact a woman's access to this or that form of birth control – important as that is – are missing a larger point.

When you have a court ruling that overturns previously well-accepted, on-point precedent and does so without enunciating any broad, overarching principle to supplant the principles that animate the precedent being overturned, and fails to delve deeply into legislation and/or case law that would support the decision, and seeks to narrowly circumscribe the application of the decision without giving much guidance to allow lower courts to understand why those particular boundaries are worthy of special respect, then odds are pretty good that you're looking at a bad decision that's going to be troublesome down the road. And that's exactly what we've got here, as far as I can see.

Reduced to its basics, the decision in this case amounts to saying that the owners of some for-profit businesses can opt out of certain legal obligations if they have religious objections to those obligations. Why these business operators and not others? We don't really know. Why business owners/operators and not other citizens? We don't really know. Why these legal obligations and not others? We don't really know. Why these religious objections and not others? We don't really know. That's a recipe for a lot of messy further litigation, plain and simple. Not really what we want Supreme Court decisions to accomplish...

One simply has to suspect that this judgment was cobbled together higgledy-piggledy to justify a particular result that five members of the court wanted to reach. Namely, they wanted to assert the existence of a right based on religious belief to opt out of government-mandated support of anything that could be construed to be “abortion.” More broadly, one imagines that they wanted to make a statement about the supposed primacy – under certain, very specific circumstances – of “moral values.” And they were willing to torture the law to do it.

Really, the freaking Supreme Court shouldn't be engaging in such shenanigans.

The irony here is that one outcome of this decision will almost certainly be to drive “health care” further into the arms of the federal government. Tactical victory – sort of – and strategic loss... It'd be funny if it wasn't almost certain to involve so much needless waste and corrosive acrimony.

Cheers.
 
Last edited:
10431499_10152302091973432_4067017500667816942_n.png
 
Again, what are you talking about?

For the given case, abortion isn't murder, legally, given that the Supreme Court has not overturned Roe vs Wade. So, for the purposes of this case, freedom of religion, it is perfectly legal and therefore is irrelevant. What happens in the future is debatable.
Many people call it murder. Many.
 
Play dumb all you want. But those example of being compelled that you offered are substantially different than the one under discussion. You compare apples and oranges. When the compact found in the constitution was made a lot of concessions were made as to what the government could do (i.e. compel) but the first 10 concession were what the government could not do and in order of importance.

Abortion is murder and tens of millions believe that to be the case. And in time it may well become many more than that.

Murder? You talk big about Murder!!!

When Bush went in and murdered 100's of thousands of Iraqi prople was that murder???
 
I'm still trying to wrap my head around how the Hobby Lobby reasoning is meant to work. It seems to stand for the idea that some types of businesses shouldn't have to contribute money that could ultimately indirectly pay for things that offend certain state-supported religious beliefs, if they don't want (e.g., if your religion objects to IUDs, the state defers to that faith, but if your religion objects to the use of blood products, you deserve no such deference). But businesses have ALWAYS had to contribute money that could ultimately indirectly pay for things that offend the religious beliefs of their owners. For example, taxes go to make war, even if you have a religious objection to war. Even when it comes to birth control, this is true. Your taxes indirectly pay for various kinds of birth control -- for example, condoms distributed to our soldiers. So, why is it OK for religious people to have to fund things they object to if the money flows through Uncle Sam but not if it flows through a private insurer?

And why doesn't this work the other way. I mean, the money that goes to the insurer isn't really the business's money, anyway. It's money that's mandated for an EMPLOYEE'S benefit, by law. It's the employee's money. It may be handed from the employer to the insurer, but the employer effectively just held it in trust for the employee, much in the same way as employee earnings that get direct deposited by the employer into the employee's retirement account. So, if it is, by law, money earmarked for the employee's benefit, why isn't it the employee's faith that counts, rather than the employer's?

The SCOTUS ruling made perfect sense to me.
It was narrow enough while saving our freedom of religion that the First Amendment promises us.
 
Murder? You talk big about Murder!!!

When Bush went in and murdered 100's of thousands of Iraqi prople was that murder???
Iraqis killed Iraqis in genocidal numbers. Moslem killing moslems as is happening today in that region nobody can deal with effectively when bound by political correctness. But you are too shallow to really understand. You are a mere political tool.
 
Many people call it murder. Many.
Yes, many people call it murder but abortion is settled law. This was about religious freedom, not abortion.

"So what is the difference between your examples and examples that cross into freedom of conscience type issues?"
What are you talking about? Be specific.
 
Yes, many people call it murder but abortion is settled law. This was about religious freedom, not abortion.

"So what is the difference between your examples and examples that cross into freedom of conscience type issues?"
What are you talking about? Be specific.
Settled law??!?

Bwahhahahah..

Laws change and nothing is permanent.
 
Last edited:
There was NO infringement on anyone's religion involved. Zero. Nada. Zip.
Yes, there was. Hobby Lobby said so, and the Christian belief validates it. Remember, we HAVE to take into account the little guy's opinion.. you know, the black person, the gay person.. are they offended? In today's culture, to remain consistant, you'd HAVE to say that nobody else can tell Hobby Lobby what they are supposed to think offends them, or it's insensitive.
The Hobby Lobby plutocrats were welcome to practice their religion any way they saw fit. They simply had to provide certain benefits to their employees, as required by federal law. That doesn't implicate religious freedom.

With so much alternatives offered, your argument doesn't much hold up.
 
Back
Top