New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Hobby Lobby

Then a decision needs to be made. Either stick to your faith and get out of a non-religious business where you would have to deal with people in a strictly non-religious way or go with the law using the same logic that allows you to do business with the likes of China.

We are a nation of faith. Would you have us strip it all? No head cover for the devout. No religious observance for this holiday or other.

Scour it all?

No more room in the land of freedom?
 
I'm still trying to wrap my head around how the Hobby Lobby reasoning is meant to work. It seems to stand for the idea that some types of businesses shouldn't have to contribute money that could ultimately indirectly pay for things that offend certain state-supported religious beliefs, if they don't want (e.g., if your religion objects to IUDs, the state defers to that faith, but if your religion objects to the use of blood products, you deserve no such deference). But businesses have ALWAYS had to contribute money that could ultimately indirectly pay for things that offend the religious beliefs of their owners. For example, taxes go to make war, even if you have a religious objection to war. Even when it comes to birth control, this is true. Your taxes indirectly pay for various kinds of birth control -- for example, condoms distributed to our soldiers. So, why is it OK for religious people to have to fund things they object to if the money flows through Uncle Sam but not if it flows through a private insurer?

And why doesn't this work the other way. I mean, the money that goes to the insurer isn't really the business's money, anyway. It's money that's mandated for an EMPLOYEE'S benefit, by law. It's the employee's money. It may be handed from the employer to the insurer, but the employer effectively just held it in trust for the employee, much in the same way as employee earnings that get direct deposited by the employer into the employee's retirement account. So, if it is, by law, money earmarked for the employee's benefit, why isn't it the employee's faith that counts, rather than the employer's?

What don't you get? Some believe that abortions are murder. Blood products save lives. Most faiths accept blood products and it is up the the patient to decline the blood product. And if there was a market that declined to pay for blood products, at one time in the very recent past they could have been accommodated. I think they still could but for the Marxist state overlords you worship.

And the argument about taxes going to war doesn't wash either. An employer choosing how to compensate an employee does not compare to the use of collected taxes (how taxes are spent is a matter of state and how compensation is dispensed is a matter of commerce). You invariably compare apples to oranges, why?

Insurance has only since Obamacare been mandated compensation. Why do you talk about it as if it is a long standing mandate?
 
We are a nation of faith. Would you have us strip it all? No head cover for the devout. No religious observance for this holiday or other.

Scour it all?

No more room in the land of freedom?
You can wear your religious paraphernalia - crosses, head cover. As far as observance for religious holidays go, if it means days off from work during workdays ..... no. Why should businesses have to forego profit-making days for their employees' religion? If people want to use their vacation and take a day off, as long as their employer agrees that's fine. That's what people who don't belong to the [seeming] state-sanctioned religion do. If the employer wants to close up shop on a particular religious holiday, the employer can do so.

We are not a nation of faith, we are a secular nation.
 
You can wear your religious paraphernalia - crosses, head cover. As far as observance for religious holidays go, if it means days off from work during workdays ..... no. Why should businesses have to forego profit-making days for their employees' religion? If people want to use their vacation and take a day off, as long as their employer agrees that's fine. That's what people who don't belong to the [seeming] state-sanctioned religion do. If the employer wants to close up shop on a particular religious holiday, the employer can do so.
Correct.
We are not a nation of faith, we are a secular nation.
Incorrect.
 
Then a decision needs to be made. Either stick to your faith and get out of a non-religious business where you would have to deal with people in a strictly non-religious way or go with the law using the same logic that allows you to do business with the likes of China.
Jackass nonsense.

YOU as a consumer choose who you want to do business with.
 
Jackass nonsense.

YOU as a consumer choose who you want to do business with.

Black and white capitalist denial of real world situations. Once and entity (person or corporation) enters the businesses world, they make many decisions based, in-part, upon the laws that affect them. This should be just one of them.
 
Black and white capitalist denial of real world situations. Once and entity (person or corporation) enters the businesses world, they make many decisions based, in-part, upon the laws that affect them. This should be just one of them.
This country is and was founded on religious liberty and the requirement for government to observe that beyond all else. It is the primary amendment of rights.
 
We are a nation of faith. Would you have us strip it all? No head cover for the devout. No religious observance for this holiday or other.

Scour it all?

No more room in the land of freedom?

We are a nation of many very different faiths and none at all. If people want to cover their heads for any reason and it has no impact on others, more power to them. Religious observance for holidays is a private matter.

There should be room in the land of freedom for non-Christians. There is no war on Christianity. What there is, is push-back for the Christian domination and bullying that has occurred in this hemisphere since 1492. There has not been religious freedom in this country but we have been moving in that direction. Maybe we will get there one day.
 
This country is and was founded on religious liberty and the requirement for government to observe that beyond all else. It is the primary amendment of rights.

Yes, but it has been a Christian idea of liberty. If the government were to really observe it, Hobby Lobby would be told to suck it up.
 
Yes, but it has been a Christian idea of liberty. If the government were to really observe it, Hobby Lobby would be told to suck it up.
Contrary to erroneous belief Christ was not a communist. He would not compel anything. Neither should the state.

And he wouldn't condone murder.
 
Contrary to erroneous belief Christ was not a communist. He would not compel anything. Neither should the state.

And he wouldn't condone murder.

What Christ was or would do is a personal matter of opinion. Not everyone believes in Christ.

The state compels many things and that is a necessity for a society of hundreds of millions of people trying to live together.
 
What Christ was or would do is a personal matter of opinion. Not everyone believes in Christ.
You brought him up. And it is very clear that Christ was/is about free choice in these matters.
The state compels many things and that is a necessity for a society of hundreds of millions of people trying to live together.
Like what?
 
Actually IUDs are a rather unpopular method of birth control. Once in place, it can stay in place for up to 5 years--and longer for those who are not too concerned about hygiene, etc. So, it is not a continual birth control expense. Only about 5% of women use them--how many of that 5% do you think work for Hobby Lobby?
 
You brought him up.

Like what?

I brought up Christianity as a set of loosely tied faiths that have dominated this hemisphere (and most of the world). You brought Christ, the son of God, up. Not the same thing.

Like what? Seriously? They compel people to pay taxes for things that they don't like such as entitlements, war, mass-transit. They compel businesses to get licenses to operate. They compel some businesses to have special licenses and certifications for specific purposes such as carrying passengers. They compel businesses to carry insurance. On and on. One of the biggest complaints of many is the sheer number of regulations that compel them to do or not do many things.
 
You can wear your religious paraphernalia - crosses, head cover. As far as observance for religious holidays go, if it means days off from work during workdays ..... no. Why should businesses have to forego profit-making days for their employees' religion? If people want to use their vacation and take a day off, as long as their employer agrees that's fine. That's what people who don't belong to the [seeming] state-sanctioned religion do. If the employer wants to close up shop on a particular religious holiday, the employer can do so.

We are not a nation of faith, we are a secular nation.


no we're a nation of faith.

plain and simple.

(and... i'm not at all religious.. in case some Phil.s a bible thumping nut craving passes your way..)
 
We are a nation of many very different faiths and none at all. If people want to cover their heads for any reason and it has no impact on others, more power to them. Religious observance for holidays is a private matter.

There should be room in the land of freedom for non-Christians. There is no war on Christianity. What there is, is push-back for the Christian domination and bullying that has occurred in this hemisphere since 1492. There has not been religious freedom in this country but we have been moving in that direction. Maybe we will get there one day.


I don't believe there is a war on Christianity...

I do believe that mane feel all to free to piss upon same though...

there is religious freedom. I may worship as I please should I so choose. this is America, after all...
 
I may worship as I please should I so choose. this is America, after all...

As long as your worship doesn't impact me. Then, I could not care less about your beliefs and faith and I don't think the government should protect your ability to impose them on anyone.
 
no we're a nation of faith.

plain and simple.

(and... i'm not at all religious.. in case some Phil.s a bible thumping nut craving passes your way..)
OK, perhaps we are an impasse due to a definition of terms. I have no faith and I live in this country. There is no test of faith to live here. There is no (legal) test of faith to be an elected official. One is not asked one's faith when one immigrates here. So in what way are we a "nation of faith" except by tradition (not law)?
 
I brought up Christianity as a set of loosely tied faiths that have dominated this hemisphere (and most of the world). You brought Christ, the son of God, up. Not the same thing.

Like what? Seriously? They compel people to pay taxes for things that they don't like such as entitlements, war, mass-transit. They compel businesses to get licenses to operate. They compel some businesses to have special licenses and certifications for specific purposes such as carrying passengers. They compel businesses to carry insurance. On and on. One of the biggest complaints of many is the sheer number of regulations that compel them to do or not do many things.

Thank you.

So what is the difference between your examples and examples that cross into freedom of conscience type issues? Are trivial examples after it is all said and done the same as those surrounding murder? Yes, yes... war is killing while abortion is murder. Get over it. And we do have conscientious objector status for those perceived to be honest in the matter.
 
Thank you.
So what is the difference between your examples and examples that cross into freedom of conscience type issues?
What are you talking about?

abortion is murder. Get over it.
Your opinion.
P.S. Abortion isn't the topic of debate here. Make a thread if you want to debate it and I won't involve myself.

And we do have conscientious objector status for those perceived to be honest in the matter.
What does this have to do with the discussion. Tie it in.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top