New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Holder gets one right – Fox gets it wrong . . .

angry-imam.jpg​

Attorney General Eric Holder has extradited Osama Bin Laden’s “son in law” to NYC, to face charges related to encouraging people to attack America.
Fox says he should be sent to Gitmo, presumable to endure whatever has replaced water-boarding.

I’ve long argued that the geneva convention protects “enemy combatants”, and that if we intend to conduct a trial (as opposed to holding a prisoner until cessation of hostilities) then the US constitution applies, no matter where you were born or who you married. Showing Gitmo prisoners in clean cells, with hot meals, and nothing more to complain about except boredom and no free HBO might go a long way toward defusing the muslim outrage Al Qaeda leverages as a recruiting tool.

Of course, the federal courts are a crapshoot, depending how competent the US prosecutor is, whether the presiding judge is buddies with the prosecution or defense, and whether some showboating left wing attorney intends to put “america” on trial, rather than defend the accused on the actual charges.
No matter what happens we will, however, get a taste of what it would have been like to put Osama Bin Laden on trial rather than a bullet in his head. The best possible outcome is that the in-law doesn’t engage in such a ruckus as to require courtroom removal or some sort of restraint, and that Al Qaeda makes daily threats of (but doesn’t carry out) another WTC type bombing.

America needs a reminder of what equal justice under the law actually means, and the thought processes of those who yesterday (again) exhorted their followers to kill random “Jews, Christians, and Americans”. (note to Al Qaeda – most Americans probably are Christians, so I don’t think you need to be so redundant. Why not add “Unbelievers” to the list? And more photos of gays being hung, and women being lashed for adultery couldn’t hurt your image among the faithful either.)

full disclosure - I've always wondered how you can have a religion that hangs gays, but celebrates "dancing boys"? That seems like a huge bit of cognitive dissonance.
 

Attorney General Eric Holder has extradited Osama Bin Laden’s “son in law” to NYC, to face charges related to encouraging people to attack America.
Fox says he should be sent to Gitmo, presumable to endure whatever has replaced water-boarding.

I’ve long argued that the geneva convention protects “enemy combatants”, and that if we intend to conduct a trial (as opposed to holding a prisoner until cessation of hostilities) then the US constitution applies, no matter where you were born or who you married. Showing Gitmo prisoners in clean cells, with hot meals, and nothing more to complain about except boredom and no free HBO might go a long way toward defusing the muslim outrage Al Qaeda leverages as a recruiting tool.

Of course, the federal courts are a crapshoot, depending how competent the US prosecutor is, whether the presiding judge is buddies with the prosecution or defense, and whether some showboating left wing attorney intends to put “america” on trial, rather than defend the accused on the actual charges.
No matter what happens we will, however, get a taste of what it would have been like to put Osama Bin Laden on trial rather than a bullet in his head. The best possible outcome is that the in-law doesn’t engage in such a ruckus as to require courtroom removal or some sort of restraint, and that Al Qaeda makes daily threats of (but doesn’t carry out) another WTC type bombing.

America needs a reminder of what equal justice under the law actually means, and the thought processes of those who yesterday (again) exhorted their followers to kill random “Jews, Christians, and Americans”. (note to Al Qaeda – most Americans probably are Christians, so I don’t think you need to be so redundant. Why not add “Unbelievers” to the list? And more photos of gays being hung, and women being lashed for adultery couldn’t hurt your image among the faithful either.)

full disclosure - I've always wondered how you can have a religion that hangs gays, but celebrates "dancing boys"? That seems like a huge bit of cognitive dissonance.

Clinton put the Blind Bomber in jail,where he still is. Right thing to do.make it publicn!
 
Clinton put the Blind Bomber in jail,where he still is. Right thing to do.make it publicn!

maryanne - and can you believe that guy got "conjugal visits"? his friends and supporters served up some muslim girl for marriage after he was incarcerated, and then sent her in to do her duty with a total stranger.
 
The GC does protect 'enemy combatants' -- a Bush term, belligerents/unlawful belligerents, or now, with the MCA of 2009 unprivileged belligerents, the fact of the matter is that combatants are still subject to detention, as POWs, for the duration of the conflict. The AUMF is still in effect.

If a persons belligerency is unlawful, ie war crimes, then the prisoner must be afforded Due Process to contest those charges against him.

Classic case is Rudolf Hess who flew to England in a bizarre attempt to broker peace. The English captured him, and held him as a POW until the end of the war, at which point he was put on trial for war crimes, found guilty and sentenced to life in prison.

War criminals need to be convicted (Boumediene case), POWs do not (Hamdi case)
 
The GC does protect 'enemy combatants' -- a Bush term, belligerents/unlawful belligerents, or now, with the MCA of 2009 unprivileged belligerents, the fact of the matter is that combatants are still subject to detention, as POWs, for the duration of the conflict. The AUMF is still in effect.

If a persons belligerency is unlawful, ie war crimes, then the prisoner must be afforded Due Process to contest those charges against him.

Classic case is Rudolf Hess who flew to England in a bizarre attempt to broker peace. The English captured him, and held him as a POW until the end of the war, at which point he was put on trial for war crimes, found guilty and sentenced to life in prison.

War criminals need to be convicted (Boumediene case), POWs do not (Hamdi case)

connor - i havent seen the actual charges against "son in law" but it seems self evident that is not an actual "enemy combatant" who risks his own life. he's more in the zone of a "recruiting tool" (pun alert) and to the extent that he has attempted to convince others to commit war crimes against civilians those charges seem appropriate.
 
Ok, well, then, fine, but then he's not an enemy combatant protected by the GC, he's a criminal subject to prosecution protected by Due Process, speedy trial, right to attorney, etc. You might be right in the sense that we actually see an extradition here.
 
The GC does protect 'enemy combatants' -- a Bush term, belligerents/unlawful belligerents, or now, with the MCA of 2009 unprivileged belligerents, the fact of the matter is that combatants are still subject to detention, as POWs, for the duration of the conflict. The AUMF is still in effect.

If a persons belligerency is unlawful, ie war crimes, then the prisoner must be afforded Due Process to contest those charges against him.

Classic case is Rudolf Hess who flew to England in a bizarre attempt to broker peace. The English captured him, and held him as a POW until the end of the war, at which point he was put on trial for war crimes, found guilty and sentenced to life in prison.

War criminals need to be convicted (Boumediene case), POWs do not (Hamdi case)

So no POW's can also be War Criminals?

I think a better way of articulating it in general terms is that every "soldier" non-American or American is not a war criminal for enlisting and taking an oath to carry out the orders of those who may be ordering that which could be considered crimes against humanity. They are however able to be detained from carrying out their orders IF captured by those they were carrying out orders against and held until hostilities end. In the case of very difficult to define unofficially "declared" "wars", what really is a POW and where in any foreseeable future, is any potential or possible construct for an "end to hostilities"?

With regard to a "war on terror" we have essentially involved ourselves in a Catch 22 of sorts. One of the strongest recruiting tools and raison d'etres for terrorist groups are the hypocrisies (real or perceived) of western powers, nevermind if those terrorists, by their calls for violence and hatred, are also being hypocritical on many levels. They, just like people within our own nation, use nationalism (or their culture and/or religion) to pit people against people, generalize and project anger and hatred upon whole nations and cultures outside their own. Hitler was just one such westerner who enthralled too many people before they realized the power they handed him, with the same ideas that any fear and hate mongers from any position, any nation, any culture, any religion, stir up, promote and endorse.

Our claims of fairness and justice are the very things that portray us as hypocritical when we don't get them right or are not consistent in their application and when we don't, we are essentially giving fodder to the very causes we would like to dismantle. Waterboarding and unfair or unjust detention, the controversial use of drones in nations that are themselves divided or with a portion of their people caught inbetween and held hostage to conflicting sides. If they give support and permission for us to do our policing in their nations with our drones, they are subject to attacks within their own nations by those they give permission to us to go after. If they do not give us permission, they are under pressure from us or deemed to be against us and harboring those who are against us.

Essentially we contribute our portion to a self perpetuating "war" unless we can come up with some innovative means to change the entire dynamic getting all sides to see the futility of their "causes" or "defenses" and recognize and realize how they actually fuel the fire and fan the flames rather than do things that will extinguish them.
 
What country's armed service did the man in question represent?

What is his serial number?

GC is for armed services men who are representing their country.

I call BS.
 
What country's armed service did the man in question represent?

What is his serial number?

GC is for armed services men who are representing their country.

I call BS.

sw - i may be mistaken, but i believe the geneva convention covers "irregulars" (no uniform or serial number). what it doesn't cover is "spying". if you impersonate a member of the opposing army with a uniform, or are simply a plainclothes spy, the rule provide for trial (and execution) rather than detention until the end of hostilities.
 
sw - i may be mistaken, but i believe the geneva convention covers "irregulars" (no uniform or serial number). what it doesn't cover is "spying". if you impersonate a member of the opposing army with a uniform, or are simply a plainclothes spy, the rule provide for trial (and execution) rather than detention until the end of hostilities.

I suppose I will get slammed for being naive, but what person doesn't have a country?

If there are no people that don't have a country, and the person wasn't military, then he is a criminal.

Very confusing.
 
If he's a criminal...he gets a trial, extraditiion if a foreign national.

If he's a POW....he gets the GC and like every POW in history, some indication that he will be released.


I'm pretty good with that old standard.
 
I suppose I will get slammed for being naive, but what person doesn't have a country?

If there are no people that don't have a country, and the person wasn't military, then he is a criminal.

Very confusing.

sw - in the context of the "war on terror", someone like bin laden is a "man without a country". he had birth citizenship in Egypt (or was it Saudi Arabia?) , but was expelled permanently as a condition of his release from prison after trying to overthrow the government.
 
Why bother with all that?

Just label him an 'enemy combatant' and drone his ass. Just make sure he's around a few innocents first.

Isn't that the new standard?
 
Back
Top