New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

How about that?

If it is owned by the US government, then it is owned by the people of the United States.

The allegation was that Bundy's family had been ranching there for a hundred years and long before the BLM came along. Neither statement was true.
 
That is actually exactly what I charge; I get $100 per hour for private lessons, and that is pretty much all I do anymore is privates. I got frustrated trying to give group classes, too much stuff ended up being irrelevant to too many folks. And the logistics of group classes were more of a challenge too, privates are just easier to schedule.

Charge for what Frey? Crime prevention? Apprehension? Justice Department policy?
 
Found it -- I was right that you had offered it. You offered this Texas Ranger report: http://www.txdps.state.tx.us/director_staff/public_information/Branch_Davidian_2/BD part1.pdf

And this is what I responded at the time, "I hadn't seen the Texas Ranger report before. One of the weapons (exhibit A) was definitely not a machinegun, as it was an AR-15 with the gas system removed. Removing the gas system would make it a single shot, as without a gas system there is nothing to cycle the AR-15 action. The others were not opened, and the Ranger said it was impossible to determine if they were full-auto or not without opening them."

The conversation occurred in March, 2013.

The guns, some of which MAY have been modified (but this is, in my opinion, unproven), may not have been accessible to all Davidians. That's about all you can factually say, and given that, there's probably no charge that can be made, at all, against the survivors although I believe the one who was charged was convicted.

Wow...2013. The link does not connect to the document anymore. Now you have to search archives. I'll go with the Danforth report...
 
Charge for what Frey? Crime prevention? Apprehension? Justice Department policy?
I teach physical security, how to keep from being violently assaulted. And the techniques and tactics for that are different for different people. A 35 yr old single woman who lives alone faces different threats than a 23 yr old guy who is out and about with his buddies drinking every weekend, or a 60 yr old man who owns a liquor store in a sketchy neighborhood. That's why I have being doing mostly private classes. I've done a few for teenagers getting ready to go off to college to (I was contracted by the parents), and one for a woman who was being stalked by a crazy ex. Lots of scenario training and some discussion and demonstration of physical techniques, as well as how to tell when they are being targeted, and what to do about it. I spend a good bit of my time explaining how assaults actually happen versus what they have been led to believe by martial arts instructors or movies. I talk about how the law views a use-of-force in a self-defense incident, and how to stay out of jail for injuring or killing a skell who attacks them.
I also do security audits of residences and businesses; if I can get in, so can a bad guy.
 
1. It's a 6th Amendment violation.

No it isn't. They had a trial by an impartial jury. They were informed of the nature of the complaint and were confronted with witnesses.

The accusation was that some information was withheld from the defense. The specific documents were not at all relevant, in my opinion, to whether or not Bundy had committed the specific offenses he was accused of.

That is why I was looking for the exact rule or law that pertains to the documents in question. It is much like the Secret Identities act. Clearly the Bush folks revealed Valerie Plame's identity...but the exact wording of the law says that intent to reveal a covert agent must be in evidence. How do you prove intent? If the prosecutor in the Bundy case didn't think those documents were relevant, then if intent is required...good luck proving anyone broke the law.
 
Wow...2013. The link does not connect to the document anymore. Now you have to search archives. I'll go with the Danforth report...

I'll go with the report you brought to the table that I cited above. The Texas Rangers were the force that recovered the weapons as evidence -- if they didn't open them it's unlikely the prosecutors did. BTW, the link works fine for me.
 
I teach physical security, how to keep from being violently assaulted. And the techniques and tactics for that are different for different people. A 35 yr old single woman who lives alone faces different threats than a 23 yr old guy who is out and about with his buddies drinking every weekend, or a 60 yr old man who owns a liquor store in a sketchy neighborhood. That's why I have being doing mostly private classes. I've done a few for teenagers getting ready to go off to college to (I was contracted by the parents), and one for a woman who was being stalked by a crazy ex. Lots of scenario training and some discussion and demonstration of physical techniques, as well as how to tell when they are being targeted, and what to do about it. I spend a good bit of my time explaining how assaults actually happen versus what they have been led to believe by martial arts instructors or movies. I talk about how the law views a use-of-force in a self-defense incident, and how to stay out of jail for injuring or killing a skell who attacks them.
I also do security audits of residences and businesses; if I can get in, so can a bad guy.

How we got here....

You think law enforcement should only involve catching someone after a crime has been committed in which someone was hurt and I think crime prevention is a good idea.
If you are breaking the law related to converting guns to full auto...why would I think you are not about to break other laws related to the use of those guns?

Seems naive at best.


You responded:
The guy who has never dealt with any serious violent crime firsthand, is telling the guy who makes a living off the lifetime worth of experience in the topic he has, that his beliefs and opinions seem "naive"...... wow.

You teach lessons in something that has nothing at all to do with law enforcement policy....Your security audits have nothing to do with the evaluation as to whether or not someone breaking the law by converting a semi to full auto is likely to commit other crimes....Do you see the problem with your logic?

Your opinion on crime prevention (which is don't even try) vs apprehension after the fact is no more informed than mine.

It is like a mechanic trying to teach a class on aerodynamics as it pertains to the gas mileage on a car.
 
How we got here....

You think law enforcement should only involve catching someone after a crime has been committed in which someone was hurt and I think crime prevention is a good idea.
If you are breaking the law related to converting guns to full auto...why would I think you are not about to break other laws related to the use of those guns?

Seems naive at best.


You responded:
The guy who has never dealt with any serious violent crime firsthand, is telling the guy who makes a living off the lifetime worth of experience in the topic he has, that his beliefs and opinions seem "naive"...... wow.

You teach lessons in something that has nothing at all to do with law enforcement policy....Your security audits have nothing to do with the evaluation as to whether or not someone breaking the law by converting a semi to full auto is likely to commit other crimes....Do you see the problem with your logic?

Your opinion on crime prevention (which is don't even try) vs apprehension after the fact is no more informed than mine.

It is like a mechanic trying to teach a class on aerodynamics as it pertains to the gas mileage on a car.
You don't know anything about how violent crime works, (and your misunderstanding on my opinions about crime-prevention proves that)...... what I know about it, what I teach, has prevented far more violent assaults than any law restricting possession of any item.
Violent people are dangerous; objects are just objects, and they can't do shit by themselves. That's why prisons are dangerous despite the fact that none of the inmates have guns.
A non-violent individual with a safe full of belt-fed full-auto firearms is still a non-violent individual. Who is he hurting? If the answer is "no one", then why do you feel like it's okay to send a bunch of tax agents who like to cosplay like they are commandos, to provoke a firefight in a compound full of women and children?


Do you see the problem with your logic?
 
I'll go with the report you brought to the table that I cited above. The Texas Rangers were the force that recovered the weapons as evidence -- if they didn't open them it's unlikely the prosecutors did. BTW, the link works fine for me.

I click on it and get "the page you are looking for can't be found."

I don't know what the date on that report was or what happened after that report. Danforth, a republican who was pretty hostile to the administration, stated that there were machine guns.

At least the thread I think you are talking about has one broken link to US News.
 
You don't know anything about how violent crime works, (and your misunderstanding on my opinions about crime-prevention proves that)...... what I know about it, what I teach, has prevented far more violent assaults than any law restricting possession of any item.
Violent people are dangerous; objects are just objects, and they can't do shit by themselves. That's why prisons are dangerous despite the fact that none of the inmates have guns.
A non-violent individual with a safe full of belt-fed full-auto firearms is still a non-violent individual. Who is he hurting? If the answer is "no one", then why do you feel like it's okay to send a bunch of tax agents who like to cosplay like they are commandos, to provoke a firefight in a compound full of women and children?


Do you see the problem with your logic?

Do try to keep track of what you've actually read. Where did I say the ATF raid was well planned or even necessary?

If you don't like the law against converting semi-auto weapons to full auto then work to get the law changed. In the meantime arguing that it is stupid for ATF to enforce the law is a useless exercise.

How they should have enforced the law is a completely different thread.

In the meantime, I'm so glad we have an expert here on "how violent crime works"...whateverthef*ck that means.
 
I click on it and get "the page you are looking for can't be found."

I don't know what the date on that report was or what happened after that report. Danforth, a republican who was pretty hostile to the administration, stated that there were machine guns.

At least the thread I think you are talking about has one broken link to US News.

It worked for me the first time, and now it's not working. In any case, it worked when yo ucited it and I quoted the essential portions. The bottom line is, whatever was claimed about those weapons, they weren't disassembled by the Rangers, who were the organization most likely to do so. You can't tell if they've been modified if you don't check.

For what it's worth, I think some were probably modified, but it wasn't worth the loss of life to go after them.

I'll stipulate to another thing, it's the only thing that has ever made me doubt my own mental health. I was working as a newspaperman at the time of the Branch Davidian fiasco and I am confident I read an AP wire story about the raid -- the day before it happened. That is what I remember from the time. I've thought about this on and off for the interceding 20-plus years, and I must have an out-of-sequence memory. But what is in my actual memory is that I read the AP story before going home from work, and then the raid happened the next day. Feel free to write me off as a wacko if you haven't done so already. This is the only time something like that has happened to me.
 
I'll go with the report you brought to the table that I cited above. The Texas Rangers were the force that recovered the weapons as evidence -- if they didn't open them it's unlikely the prosecutors did. BTW, the link works fine for me.

I click on it and get "the page you are looking for can't be found."

I don't know what the date on that report was or what happened after that report. Danforth, a republican who was pretty hostile to the administration, stated that there were machine guns.
 
Do try to keep track of what you've actually read. Where did I say the ATF raid was well planned or even necessary?

If you don't like the law against converting semi-auto weapons to full auto then work to get the law changed. In the meantime arguing that it is stupid for ATF to enforce the law is a useless exercise.

How they should have enforced the law is a completely different thread.

In the meantime, I'm so glad we have an expert here on "how violent crime works"...whateverthef*ck that means.
Be grateful that you don't know what it means.

BTW, I'm nursing a couple of significant bruises I got a few days ago when a student had a flashback and went apeshit on me. If I hadn't been wearing eye-pro, I'd be a cyclops right now. Because the truth is, most of the people who pay me have either been victims of a serious assault, or someone close to them has. Because nobody even knows that they need what I teach, or places any real value on it, unless they are victims or know one well enough to see what kind of trauma that assault left behind. You can get a month's worth of BJJ classes for what I charge for an hour, after all.
And sometimes, that trauma-drama comes out, especially during scenario training, and someone has a meltdown. Sometimes they get scared all over and freeze and sometimes they try to kill me because all they see is the face of their attacker.

What I do is serious..... maybe not to you, but to a lot of other people who are unfortunate enough to be members of a club that nobody wants to join. So fvck you very much for your disrespectful and ignorant attitude.
 
Be grateful that you don't know what it means.

BTW, I'm nursing a couple of significant bruises I got a few days ago when a student had a flashback and went apeshit on me. If I hadn't been wearing eye-pro, I'd be a cyclops right now. Because the truth is, most of the people who pay me have either been victims of a serious assault, or someone close to them has. Because nobody even knows that they need what I teach, or places any real value on it, unless they are victims or know one well enough to see what kind of trauma that assault left behind. You can get a month's worth of BJJ classes for what I charge for an hour, after all.
And sometimes, that trauma-drama comes out, especially during scenario training, and someone has a meltdown. Sometimes they get scared all over and freeze and sometimes they try to kill me because all they see is the face of their attacker.

What I do is serious..... maybe not to you, but to a lot of other people who are unfortunate enough to be members of a club that nobody wants to join. So fvck you very much for your disrespectful and ignorant attitude.

"how violent crime works" is a meaningless statement. "How it happens"..."What motivates violent crime"..."Who is responsible for violent crime" are all useful topics...
"How violent crime works" doesn't mean shit. It is a vague claim you are using to argue that somehow, what you teach people has some kind of noticeable impact on nationwide crime. Run for office.

The fact is that the opinions you've expressed here show a closed mind unwilling to even consider policies that might have an impact on nationwide crime. Your unwillingness to actually engage in debate makes me wonder how you manage to adapt at all to any change in the real world.

You were born too late. Dodge city, circa 1875, would have been more your style.

Oh, and when you start showing respect, you'll get it back.
 
"how violent crime works" is a meaningless statement. "How it happens"..."What motivates violent crime"..."Who is responsible for violent crime" are all useful topics...
"How violent crime works" doesn't mean shit. It is a vague claim you are using to argue that somehow, what you teach people has some kind of noticeable impact on nationwide crime. Run for office.

The fact is that the opinions you've expressed here show a closed mind unwilling to even consider policies that might have an impact on nationwide crime. Your unwillingness to actually engage in debate makes me wonder how you manage to adapt at all to any change in the real world.

You were born too late. Dodge city, circa 1875, would have been more your style.

Oh, and when you start showing respect, you'll get it back.
Bullshit.
 
I'll go with the report you brought to the table that I cited above. The Texas Rangers were the force that recovered the weapons as evidence -- if they didn't open them it's unlikely the prosecutors did. BTW, the link works fine for me.

Gimme a link to that thread, plz. All I found was a link to US World News.
 
Back
Top