New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

How about that?

"If you are breaking the law related to converting guns to full auto...why would I think you are not about to break other laws related to the use of those guns? "

So we are in agreement...you were wrong in implying that I'd posted this; How is having a bunch of guns an indicator that someone is going to commit a violent crime?
 
I'm sorry QT, but I'm posting while I run around doing other stuff; I can't watch a 90 minute video right now.

In 20 more days that land was theirs forever.

An ex member, who the Davidians had thrown out, was the person who began to spread the sexual and the gun accusations. Social services found no abuse but after time some Newspaper hacks took it up. Another ex member used the gossip as evidence in his divorce from his wife, a member, -accused Kerosh of raping and making a 79 year old Grandmother pregnant --- That is how the 'I am God' came about -- in court in answer to that accusation, of making a 79 year old woman pregnant, Kerosh sarcastically said ' If I had done that, I would be God'
He did trade in guns --- went to gun shows and talked bible and guns - offered to show all papers ect

For anyone else ----


At about 27.00 is about the warrant -for a gun which does not exist.
 
Last edited:
I'll go with the report you brought to the table that I cited above. The Texas Rangers were the force that recovered the weapons as evidence -- if they didn't open them it's unlikely the prosecutors did. BTW, the link works fine for me.

Found one report from the Texas rangers: This was as they were removing evidence from a locker.

It is noteworthy that on K 199, the safety was in the rear position, which is a full-automatic position to the AR-15/M-16 rifle family system.

https://web.archive.org/web/20110220034240/https://www.txdps.state.tx.us/director_staff/public_information/Branch_Davidian_2/BD part1.pdf

Another from the Treasury dept
https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/waco/treasury.html

By the way...I found it interesting that in the trial of one Davidian...his lawyer questioned the constitutionality of a prohibition on the possession of machine guns. He was later convicted of charges related to illegal guns.

Six of the eight Branch Davidians appealed both their sentences and their convictions. They raised a host of issues, challenging the constitutionality of the prohibition on possession of machine guns, the jury instructions, the district court's conduct of the trial, the sufficiency of the evidence, and the sentences imposed. The United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit vacated the defendants' sentences for use of machine guns, determining that the district court had made no finding that they had "actively employed" the weapons, but left the verdicts undisturbed in all other respects, in United States v. Branch,[73] 91 F.3d 699 (5th Cir. 1996), cert. denied (1997

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waco_siege
 
In 20 more days that land was theirs forever.

An ex member, who the Davidians had thrown out, was the person who began to spread the sexual and the gun accusations. Social services found no abuse but after time some Newspaper hacks took it up. Another ex member used the gossip as evidence in his divorce from his wife, a member, -accused Kerosh of raping and making a 79 year old Grandmother pregnant --- That is how the 'I am God' came about -- in court in answer to that accusation, of making a 79 year old woman, Kerosh sarcastically said ' If I had done that, I would be God'
He did trade in guns --- went to gun shows and talked bible and guns - offered to show all papers ect

For anyone else ----


At about 27.00 is about the warrant -for a gun which does not exist.

One of the Davidians was convicted of possession of a machine gun and in his trial claimed that it was not illegal to have one....
 
No it isn't. They had a trial by an impartial jury. They were informed of the nature of the complaint and were confronted with witnesses.

The accusation was that some information was withheld from the defense. The specific documents were not at all relevant, in my opinion, to whether or not Bundy had committed the specific offenses he was accused of.

That is why I was looking for the exact rule or law that pertains to the documents in question. It is much like the Secret Identities act. Clearly the Bush folks revealed Valerie Plame's identity...but the exact wording of the law says that intent to reveal a covert agent must be in evidence. How do you prove intent? If the prosecutor in the Bundy case didn't think those documents were relevant, then if intent is required...good luck proving anyone broke the law.

Withholding information from the defendants = not informing them of the cause of the complaints.
 
Withholding information from the defendants = not informing them of the cause of the complaints.

The information that the defense claimed was withheld was about surveillance on his house and had nothing at all to do with the standoff on BLM lands.
 
Found one report from the Texas rangers: This was as they were removing evidence from a locker.

It is noteworthy that on K 199, the safety was in the rear position, which is a full-automatic position to the AR-15/M-16 rifle family system.

The position of the safety is immaterial if the gun can't fire. It appears most of what they found lacked gas systems and couldn't fire.

https://web.archive.org/web/20110220034240/https://www.txdps.state.tx.us/director_staff/public_information/Branch_Davidian_2/BD part1.pdf

Another from the Treasury dept
https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/waco/treasury.html

By the way...I found it interesting that in the trial of one Davidian...his lawyer questioned the constitutionality of a prohibition on the possession of machine guns. He was later convicted of charges related to illegal guns.

Six of the eight Branch Davidians appealed both their sentences and their convictions. They raised a host of issues, challenging the constitutionality of the prohibition on possession of machine guns, the jury instructions, the district court's conduct of the trial, the sufficiency of the evidence, and the sentences imposed. The United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit vacated the defendants' sentences for use of machine guns, determining that the district court had made no finding that they had "actively employed" the weapons, but left the verdicts undisturbed in all other respects, in United States v. Branch,[73] 91 F.3d 699 (5th Cir. 1996), cert. denied (1997

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waco_siege

I couldn't remember what had happened on the machine gun charges. I've long wondered, if they were modifying the M-16s and AK 47s as described in the treasury report (I have my doubts about these reports as I've never seen the guns in question), where were they modifying them and how, with what tools? None of the maps I've seen of the compound have included a machine shop, and that's pretty much a minimum for making a functioning conversion.[/QUOTE]
 
The position of the safety is immaterial if the gun can't fire. It appears most of what they found lacked gas systems and couldn't fire.


I couldn't remember what had happened on the machine gun charges. I've long wondered, if they were modifying the M-16s and AK 47s as described in the treasury report (I have my doubts about these reports as I've never seen the guns in question), where were they modifying them and how, with what tools? None of the maps I've seen of the compound have included a machine shop, and that's pretty much a minimum for making a functioning conversion.
[/QUOTE]

Most of what they found? The Texas Rangers were emptying out a storage locker. There were exactly three AR-15 type weapons in that locker. Where did you read that most of what they found were inoperable? In the report I provided you, one weapon had it's gas system removed. Another had the suppressor welded in place and the gas system couldn't be observed.
 

Most of what they found? The Texas Rangers were emptying out a storage locker. There were exactly three AR-15 type weapons in that locker. Where did you read that most of what they found were inoperable? In the report I provided you, one weapon had it's gas system removed. Another had the suppressor welded in place and the gas system couldn't be observed.[/QUOTE]

In the report that neither of us can now open, but it was there. There's another factor here -- my guess is that you'd trust the reports. I do not trust them, as the investigators in question have every motive to find what they said they were looking for, and no motive NOT to find it, given the fiasco that was the rest of the operation. If there WERE fully automatic weapons, owned or modified illegally, on the Branch Davidian compound, there were other ways to secure them.
 
Most of what they found? The Texas Rangers were emptying out a storage locker. There were exactly three AR-15 type weapons in that locker. Where did you read that most of what they found were inoperable? In the report I provided you, one weapon had it's gas system removed. Another had the suppressor welded in place and the gas system couldn't be observed.

In the report that neither of us can now open, but it was there. There's another factor here -- my guess is that you'd trust the reports. I do not trust them, as the investigators in question have every motive to find what they said they were looking for, and no motive NOT to find it, given the fiasco that was the rest of the operation. If there WERE fully automatic weapons, owned or modified illegally, on the Branch Davidian compound, there were other ways to secure them.

So now the Texas Rangers, FBI and ATF, as well as a judge and jury are all in cahoots.
That is what it would take to create this lie that there were 48 illegally converted rifles.
You say the Texas Rangers report said most of the AR-15s and AK-47s were inoperable.
Meanwhile the inventory in the treasury report would have had to be fraudulent.

The FBI did not initiate the raid. The ATF did. The FBI is the source of the inventory. While the ATF could have wanted to cover things up...why would the FBI care? You seem to think that the FBI lab would risk their jobs and a major scandal by testifying under oath in a trial that there were illegal machine guns when there weren't.

From the FBI report

WEAPONS RECOVERED FROM THE BRANCH DAVIDIAN COMPOUND: TREASURY SUMMARY OF REPORT PREPARED BY THE FBI FOR PROSECUTORS AND THE ILLEGAL WEAPONS RECOVERED

Machine Guns

The FBI determined that 46 semiautomatic firearms had been modified to fire in full automatic mode:

22 M-16 Type Rifles

20 AK-47 Type Rifles

2 Heckler and Koch SP-89

2 M-11/Nine

The FBI also determined that two AR-15 lower receivers had been modified to fire in full automatic mode.
 
Last edited:
So now the Texas Rangers, FBI and ATF, as well as a judge and jury are all in cahoots.
That is what it would take to create this lie that there were 48 illegally converted rifles.
You say the Texas Rangers report said most of the AR-15s and AK-47s were inoperable.
Meanwhile the inventory in the treasury report would have had to be fraudulent.

The FBI did not initiate the raid. The ATF did. The FBI is the source of the inventory. While the ATF could have wanted to cover things up...why would the FBI care? You seem to think that the FBI lab would risk their jobs and a major scandal by testifying under oath in a trial that there were illegal machine guns when there weren't.

From the FBI report

WEAPONS RECOVERED FROM THE BRANCH DAVIDIAN COMPOUND: TREASURY SUMMARY OF REPORT PREPARED BY THE FBI FOR PROSECUTORS AND THE ILLEGAL WEAPONS RECOVERED

Machine Guns

The FBI determined that 46 semiautomatic firearms had been modified to fire in full automatic mode:

22 M-16 Type Rifles

20 AK-47 Type Rifles

2 Heckler and Koch SP-89

2 M-11/Nine

The FBI also determined that two AR-15 lower receivers had been modified to fire in full automatic mode.

I think it is possible, if not likely, that yes the law enforcement people who were in charge of what was widely recognized as a fiasco, did whatever was necessary to cover their own backsides. The ones you listed were all involved with the raid in some capacity, and there was unified command from the DoJ at the site, after the initial raid (itself a sub-fiasco).

I admit my concern in the area is speculative -- I could be completely wrong. But I also remember, quite clearly, the days and weeks after the fire when the ATF/FBI/Rangers et alia failed to produce any of these weapons. None appeared publicly until trials that were more than a year later.

Further, the Rangers are right, unless you disassemble the guns (or fire them) you don't know if they've been modified. So how did the FBI determine that modifications had been made? Where's that report?

At the end of the day, the Branch Davidians may have modified weapons -- I don't know where or how. The attempt to secure these weapons and charge the people who modified them was, to say the least, bungled.
 
I think it is possible, if not likely, that yes the law enforcement people who were in charge of what was widely recognized as a fiasco, did whatever was necessary to cover their own backsides. The ones you listed were all involved with the raid in some capacity, and there was unified command from the DoJ at the site, after the initial raid (itself a sub-fiasco).

I admit my concern in the area is speculative -- I could be completely wrong. But I also remember, quite clearly, the days and weeks after the fire when the ATF/FBI/Rangers et alia failed to produce any of these weapons. None appeared publicly until trials that were more than a year later.

Further, the Rangers are right, unless you disassemble the guns (or fire them) you don't know if they've been modified. So how did the FBI determine that modifications had been made? Where's that report?

At the end of the day, the Branch Davidians may have modified weapons -- I don't know where or how. The attempt to secure these weapons and charge the people who modified them was, to say the least, bungled.

It would have been FBI labs responsibility to examine the weapons. Do you think the Davidians didn't have a lawyer? Do you think he did not have an opportunity to have his own experts examine the guns?

None of the defense attorney's questioned whether or not there were machine guns. One questioned the Constitutionality of a ban on converting semi to full auto. Others questioned if there was evidence that they personally had been in possession of a machine gun or had knowledge of them.
 
It would have been FBI labs responsibility to examine the weapons. Do you think the Davidians didn't have a lawyer? Do you think he did not have an opportunity to have his own experts examine the guns?

None of the defense attorney's questioned whether or not there were machine guns. One questioned the Constitutionality of a ban on converting semi to full auto. Others questioned if there was evidence that they personally had been in possession of a machine gun or had knowledge of them.

What were they accused of? What was the evidence? What was the verdict of the jury? Why have the jury since said that none of the accused should be in prison and have since been petitioning for a retrial?
 
It would have been FBI labs responsibility to examine the weapons. Do you think the Davidians didn't have a lawyer? Do you think he did not have an opportunity to have his own experts examine the guns?

None of the defense attorney's questioned whether or not there were machine guns. One questioned the Constitutionality of a ban on converting semi to full auto. Others questioned if there was evidence that they personally had been in possession of a machine gun or had knowledge of them.

Perhaps your questions were irrelevant to the charges.
 
Perhaps your questions were irrelevant to the charges.

Given your lack of curiosity, you may never know...but the information if both in this thread or in the history of the case and charges against the defendants...one of whom was found guilty of possession of an illegal firearm.
 
What were they accused of? What was the evidence? What was the verdict of the jury? Why have the jury since said that none of the accused should be in prison and have since been petitioning for a retrial?

Use your google...the charges are easy to find.

Who is petitioning for a re-trial?
 
Given your lack of curiosity, you may never know...but the information if both in this thread or in the history of the case and charges against the defendants...one of whom was found guilty of possession of an illegal firearm.

I was questioning your knowledge ---- which is lacking. I was not questioning my knowledge.
 
Back
Top