New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

How I really feel.

If you could wave a magic wand - would you choose:

  • No private ownership of firearms

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • All firearms registered and licensed

    Votes: 13 59.1%
  • Unlimited freedom to own & operate

    Votes: 6 27.3%
  • Maintain the current status quo

    Votes: 3 13.6%

  • Total voters
    22

NightSwimmer

Senator
It appears to me that partisanship plays a significant role in predetermining one's position regarding private gun ownership. I'm curious about the private thoughts that lie behind the public statements concerning proposed gun control legislation.

This poll is anonymous. To the best of my knowledge, even the admins of this site have no means to track how users vote in a private poll. I'd like to know people's innermost thoughts on the subject of private gun ownership in America.

I really like the concept of having a poll as a feature of a public forum. I wish that The Fray had provided this technology. That said, this feature goes to waste if users choose not to participate.
 
I believe all firearms should be registered and licensed. I guess that makes me a Nazi,Commie, Marxist, traitor to the Constitution.
 
Night,I hate guns with a passion for good reason,but I voted for Checks and registration. I could care less what anyone thinks about me on the subject.Guns are dangerous,just like cars,and those who own them have a responsibility.

I would also insist on insurance for those who have them.Thzt includes those in my house,that I never touch. I leave them alone because of who they belonged to.I would never shoot them. That includes the WW 2 German Luger.I will donate that. Had several offers to buy it. It will go along with the Holocaust pictures taken with a Brownie.
 
I believe all firearms should be registered and licensed. I guess that makes me a Nazi,Commie, Marxist, traitor to the Constitution.


I hope not, OG. ;)

Thanks for participating. I hope that this thread doesn't descend into a partisan urination tournament -- we have plenty of those already. There's no requirement for any participants to reveal how they voted unless they just want to. That's why I made it an anonymous poll.
 
Night,I hate guns with a passion for good reason,but I voted for Checks and registration. I could care less what anyone thinks about me on the subject.Guns are dangerous,just like cars,and those who own them have a responsibility.

I would also insist on insurance for those who have them.Thzt includes those in my house,that I never touch. I leave them alone because of who they belonged to.I would never shoot them. That includes the WW 2 German Luger.I will donate that. Had several offers to buy it. It will go along with the Holocaust pictures taken with a Brownie.


Thanks for participating, MaryAnne.

That Luger was a fine piece of engineering work, for it's time. It could be very valuable.

For the benefit of our younger posters, I want to clarify that the Brownie was a low cost camera introduced by Kodak in 1900, and not a young Girl Scout. ;)
 
It would appear that despite the low sampling your poll is going the way the big ones do (80/20).
 
I believe all firearms should be registered and licensed. I guess that makes me a Nazi,Commie, Marxist, traitor to the Constitution.

No Gaff, I feel the same way. As I have stated on here many times, I have been collecting guns for over 50 years and have most every one I bought. The ones requiring registration, have been, and the vast majority of my purchases have been done through a FFL dealer. Registering and licensing does not go against the Constitution, which only states that we have the right to bear arms.

I would rather register my guns with the government than join that looney bin bunch calling itself the NRA nowadays. Every time I see that Frenchie guy on TV defending the right to kill children, I wish that the state still had mental institutions for his ilk.
 
I would like to see all firearms registered and licensed.

However, I am not delusional enough to believe that will ever happen. Criminals don't care about "registered and licensed" laws. They are criminals. They flout laws.

And just because all firearms are registered and licensed doesn't mean that stupid people won't leave them out for toddlers to stumble upon.

And the crazy massacre people all used registered and licensed weapons as far as I can remember.

Confiscation of all weapons carries the same problem. Black market weapon sales would soar.

It is a problem. I really do not like guns at all. But the solution must be one that manages to touch the heart of criminals and nuts more than it touches law-abiders. I don't know what that solution is. Mandatory strong sentencing might deter criminals. But crazy people usually plan to go out in a blaze of glory so they won't care about that.

I wish we could magically say "people. be responsible" and have everyone man up and be responsible. But that won't happen either.

I have no globally-promising solution.
 
I would like to see all firearms registered and licensed.

However, I am not delusional enough to believe that will ever happen. Criminals don't care about "registered and licensed" laws. They are criminals. They flout laws.

And just because all firearms are registered and licensed doesn't mean that stupid people won't leave them out for toddlers to stumble upon.

And the crazy massacre people all used registered and licensed weapons as far as I can remember.

Confiscation of all weapons carries the same problem. Black market weapon sales would soar.

It is a problem. I really do not like guns at all. But the solution must be one that manages to touch the heart of criminals and nuts more than it touches law-abiders. I don't know what that solution is. Mandatory strong sentencing might deter criminals. But crazy people usually plan to go out in a blaze of glory so they won't care about that.

I wish we could magically say "people. be responsible" and have everyone man up and be responsible. But that won't happen either.

I have no globally-promising solution.


Mandatory sentencing has proved to be an abject failure in reducing crime, but that's really off-topic for this thread. I just wanted to learn what people's preference would be regarding private gun ownership -- not whether they think that their preference is practically applicable.

Anyway, thanks for participating.
 
Excuse me for straying off topic. I thought it was regarding the gun control issue. Foolish of me to assume that.
But your dismissive response to a thoughtful answer is duly noted.
You'll get no more than chum from me from now on.
:thumb:

Mandatory sentencing has proved to be an abject failure in reducing crime, but that's really off-topic for this thread. I just wanted to learn what people's preference would be regarding private gun ownership -- not whether they think that their preference is practically applicable.

Anyway, thanks for participating.
 
Excuse me for straying off topic. I thought it was regarding the gun control issue. Foolish of me to assume that.
But your dismissive response to a thoughtful answer is duly noted.
You'll get no more than chum from me from now on.
:thumb:


I didn't mean to be dismissive. It's just that, with so many other threads already discussing the details of possible gun control measures and the associated problems with implementing them, I had hoped to keep this thread primarily as a place to simply host the poll. When I said that I was getting off-topic, I was merely explaining that I didn't want to delve too deeply into tangents myself. That's why I kept my response so brief. I don't agree that mandatory sentencing is effective, but (as I said), that is a different topic.

Sorry for the misunderstanding. I'm trying to get some work done in the office and check in here every now and then at the same time.


Later,
NS
 
Unlimited ownership.

An armed society is a polite society.

Really, you think the country has gotten more polite with more guns?

the poll results:
I think reasonable people should have a reasonable right to own a firearm of their choice as permitted by the laws of our land. So I vote for #2 above.
but aren't #3/#4 really the same in todays world. I also believe that people who own a gun should be responsible for it's use, in as far as what they did to make sure it didn't fall into the hands of someone who shouldn't have gotten a hold of it. If a person followed a reasonable path and somehow a gun fell into the hands of someone who used it, then I would say oh well, maybe we need to think it over and do more.
Background checks along with gun safety training is not enough, we need to have a set policy on storage of guns. Along with mandatory Jail sentence for a crime while using or in possession a gun.
 
Really, you think the country has gotten more polite with more guns?

the poll results:
I think reasonable people should have a reasonable right to own a firearm of their choice as permitted by the laws of our land. So I vote for #2 above.
but aren't #3/#4 really the same in todays world. I also believe that people who own a gun should be responsible for it's use, in as far as what they did to make sure it didn't fall into the hands of someone who shouldn't have gotten a hold of it. If a person followed a reasonable path and somehow a gun fell into the hands of someone who used it, then I would say oh well, maybe we need to think it over and do more.
Background checks along with gun safety training is not enough, we need to have a set policy on storage of guns. Along with mandatory Jail sentence for a crime while using or in possession a gun.


No. I wouldn't say that options #3 and #4 are the same. Option 3 would allow ownership and operation of machine guns, for instance.

In hindsight, I considered adding more options to include:

Status Quo + Universal Background Checks

Status Quo + Assault Weapons Ban

Status Quo + Both of the Above

Thing is, the list could get very long and eventually render the poll results meaningless. I'm not looking for workable solutions here -- just trying to get a feel for what people would prefer in an ideal world. Hence the poll title "If you could wave a magic wand".
 
No problem.


I didn't mean to be dismissive. It's just that, with so many other threads already discussing the details of possible gun control measures and the associated problems with implementing them, I had hoped to keep this thread primarily as a place to simply host the poll. When I said that I was getting off-topic, I was merely explaining that I didn't want to delve too deeply into tangents myself. That's why I kept my response so brief. I don't agree that mandatory sentencing is effective, but (as I said), that is a different topic.

Sorry for the misunderstanding. I'm trying to get some work done in the office and check in here every now and then at the same time.


Later,
NS
 
Although one can hardly consider this a scientific poll with so few people, however I do see the trend being strong even here. I'm glad I'm a part of the 60%.

Yes, I would have liked 'universal background checks' added to the choice I voted for but hey those that want one surely want the other.....I hope!
 
Back
Top