New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Hypocrisy Test

Well, perhaps to YOU having the highest corporate tax rate in the world is "normal".

As I've said, I'd be happy with something that reduced the nominal rate while boosting effective rates to the OECD average (currently effective rates are below average). But Bush's plan is to lower the effective rate still farther below the average for the OECD. Where he ought to be raising and tightening corporate AMT, he's instead eliminating it.

You clearly think you pay attention to economics and taxes and think 1% economic growth is something to emulate. Perhaps you've accepted the Obama cartel's new "normal". Actual normal people have not.

As you should know, Europe pursued a disastrous policy of reducing government spending even more sharply than the US did. They fell for the conservative snake oil sales pitch to a greater degree than we did, and have suffered some dire consequences from that. I'd hate to emulate that.

Ah yes, so now you decide you don't want to talk about debt

I do want to talk about debt. It's just that to do so in a meaningful way with you, I first have to educate you about the basic facts. If you would take the time to come to these discussions with at least a rudimentary understanding of the basics, we wouldn't have to waste so much time on the preliminaries. Your lifetime of intellectual laziness has a cost for both of us.
 
Last edited:
in arkady's universe "economic growth" is evil, because it just leads to more "corporate drones" and "climate change"

he aspires to a world where everyone works for the government - but never drives to work. the telecommunte from their Yurts, and send emails all day advising how to tweak various government giveaways.
Actually, I think economic growth is great. I've been trying to get us back to the robust economic growth of the FDR/Truman, Kennedy/Johnson, and Clinton years. Unfortunately, the dumber members of our forum prefer Republican-style economic underperformance.
 
I think Arkady is blinded by his insane, raging jealousy of rich people. .
Just to set your mind at ease, I actually AM a rich person. And the proposals I support would significantly enhance my own effective tax rates. This isn't about jealousy. It's about wanting good policy. But, what I'm not is one of you "tug the forelock" types, who are such spineless authoritarians that you trip all over yourselves to advanced the interests of your economic betters. I understand that the perspective of a genuinely patriotic person like me, who is looking to improve the lives of the American people, is incomprehensible to your kind. So I suppose I'm wasting my breath even trying to explain it.
 
Actually, I think economic growth is great. I've been trying to get us back to the robust economic growth of the FDR/Truman, Kennedy/Johnson, and Clinton years. Unfortunately, the dumber members of our forum prefer Republican-style economic underperformance.

Ah yes, you love economic growth so much, you want to emulate tax policy in Europe where it averages less than ONE PERCENT!

Hilarious!
 
Just to set your mind at ease, I actually AM a rich person. And the proposals I support would significantly enhance my own effective tax rates. This isn't about jealousy. It's about wanting good policy. But, what I'm not is one of you "tug the forelock" types, who are such spineless authoritarians that you trip all over yourselves to advanced the interests of your economic betters. I understand that the perspective of a genuinely patriotic person like me, who is looking to improve the lives of the American people, is incomprehensible to your kind. So I suppose I'm wasting my breath even trying to explain it.

Cool... what kind of jet do you have?
 
As I've said, I'd be happy with something that reduced the nominal rate while boosting effective rates to the OECD average (currently effective rates are below average). But Bush's plan is to lower the effective rate still farther below the average for the OECD. Where he ought to be raising and tightening corporate AMT, he's instead eliminating it.

You don't seem to catch on quickly. Why would you want to emulate the tax policy of a region with such low economic growth? You are talking out of both sides of your mouth. You really don't seem to understand even rudimentary economic principles, as evidenced by you continuing to cling to the tax policies of the Eurozone. Wow.

As you should know, Europe pursued a disastrous policy of reducing government spending even more sharply than the US did. They fell for the conservative snake oil sales pitch to a greater degree than we did, and have suffered some dire consequences from that. I'd hate to emulate that.

You need to pay closer attention. Europe's economic growth has been CRAP for over 20 years. Any austerity ventured into was as a direct result of European big government socialism- in other words, because of people who believe like YOU. And if you hate to emulate it, quit promoting things that guarantee we do, like Euro-style taxes and big government social programs. Oh that's right- we won't have a debt crisis until January 2016 as far as you're concerned.

I do want to talk about debt. It's just that to do so in a meaningful way with you, I first have to educate you about the basic facts. If you would take the time to come to these discussions with at least a rudimentary understanding of the basics, we wouldn't have to waste so much time on the preliminaries. Your lifetime of intellectual laziness has a cost for both of us.

Ah yes, "in a meaningful way", meaning I accept all Obama's debt as wonderful and necessary and become a hawk on debt the day he leaves office. Do you really think you're leading anyone here to believe otherwise?
 
Jeb Bush has debuted a tax plan that would cause gigantic increases in deficits, in order to further increase the wealth of the ruling class. .

I don't belong here in this thread. I'm not a green eye shade number cruncher. I don't know how to manipulate data to my advantage in such discussions. I don't spend all my time doing that. I don't spend sleepless nights wondering what I should include in my spreadsheet and what to exclude.

All I can do is point out that without exception these screeds/analyses always stop with how much rich folks save in taxes. That's the end of the story... and it's therefore assumed by the low info reader that they put it under their pillows.

Fact is they invest it in something, or they put it in a bank which lends it out to people who want to start a business or by a home, or car, or send their kids to college. Or, as a last resort, they buy a yacht. In every case that money is circulating, and while it's circulating (spent) it creates jobs. The faster it circulates the better. Even college professors spend money. And when money is spent it is taxed.

So has anyone ever calculated how much in taxes actually is returned to to federal, state, and local coffers as a result?

Maybe you or Lukey know what that amounts to?
 
I don't belong here in this thread. I'm not a green eye shade number cruncher. I don't know how to manipulate data to my advantage in such discussions. I don't spend all my time doing that. I don't spend sleepless nights wondering what I should include in my spreadsheet and what to exclude.

All I can do is point out that without exception these screeds/analyses always stop with how much rich folks save in taxes. That's the end of the story... and it's therefore assumed by the low info reader that they put it under their pillows.

Fact is they invest it in something, or they put it in a bank which lends it out to people who want to start a business or by a home, or car, or send their kids to college. Or, as a last resort, they buy a yacht. In every case that money is circulating, and while it's circulating (spent) it creates jobs. Even college professors spend money. And when money is spent it is taxed.

So has anyone ever calculated how much in taxes actually is returned to to federal, state, and local coffers as a result?

Maybe you or Lukey know what that amounts to is?

Or buy stocks, to take advantage of those tasty capital gains rates.

;-)
 
Or buy stocks, to take advantage of those tasty capital gains rates.

Always nice to hear from a Marxist. But the fact of the matter remains that the speed of circulating money is exponentially better for tax revenue purposes than a stagnant socialist economy whatever the capital gains tax rate is. Punched it up a bit, but don't push the Bolshevic solution that if only the Czar and is family were executed in the basement everything will eventually be all right. It didn't work then and it won't work now.

Meaning, capital gains are taxed as well. Meaning, more marginal revenue. All you need do is get over your programmed ideology and subsequent knee jerk offerings here and embrace reality and simple physics. The faster an object moves the more energy it has.
 
Last edited:
Always nice to hear from a Marxist. But the fact of the matter remains that the speed of circulating money is far better for tax revenue purposes than a stagnant socialist economy whatever the capital gains tax rate is. Punched it up a bit, but don't push the Bolshevic solution that the Czar and is family should be executed in the basement and everything will eventually be all right. It didn't work then and it won't work now.

Meaning, capital gains are taxed as well. Meaning, more marginal revenue. All you need do is get over your programmed ideology and knee jerk offerings here and embrace reality and simple physics. The faster an object moves the more kinetic energy it has.

Hey, the markets have tripled under Obama. Along with the capital gains receipts that accompany skyrocketing markets. Not bad for those you absurdly call Marxists.

Watch and learn.

;-)
 
QUOTE="Bugsy McGurk, post: 1413887, member: 11902"]Hey, the markets have tripled under Obama. Along with the capital gains receipts that accompany skyrocketing markets. Not bad for those you absurdly call Marxists.
[/QUOTE]

The stock market hasn't tripled and whatever gains it has made are due to the Fed pumping $85 billion a month of "liquidity" into the system to the sole benefit of the 1% ers who circulate the money. Circulation is the be all and end all of money when it comes to having a robust economy.

But it is nice to know that all of sudden you now appreciate capital gains receipts, just not the people who paid them. You hate them...cuz you're a Bolshevic, Marxist, and more than likely a loser with your hand out.

The only thing here that's absurd here is your two-step dance.
 
Last edited:
QUOTE="Bugsy McGurk, post: 1413887, member: 11902"]Hey, the markets have tripled under Obama. Along with the capital gains receipts that accompany skyrocketing markets. Not bad for those you absurdly call Marxists.

The stock market hasn't tripled and whatever gains it has made are due to the Fed pumping $85 billion a month of "liquidity" into the system to the sole benefit of the 1% ers who circulate the money. Circulation is the be all and end all of money when it comes to having a robust economy.

But it is nice to know that all of sudden you now appreciate capital gains receipts, just not the people who paid them. You hate them...cuz you're a Bolshevic, Marxist, and more than likely a loser with your hand out.

The only thing here that's absurd here is your two-step dance.[/QUOTE]

Burns, eh?

Those Dem presidents you call Marxists oversee far better economies. You should be used to that by now. Maybe someday you'll get deprogrammed and learn that everything you think to be true is false.
 
I don't know what GDP projection they use. But they have a history of being overly conservative in their projections.

Hahahaha! No they don't - it's just the opposite. And why is it you are a font of information until I ask a simple question that would reveal a key piece of data that undermines your entire argument - and then suddenly you have no clue? You are a propagandist, plain and simple.
 
You seem to be confused about the difference between debt and deficits. Even if there is not presently a debt crisis, we're certainly close, and could easily go over with the kinds of much-larger deficits Jeb! is looking to bring about. The numbers aren't hard to figure out. Debt is currently 103.6% of GDP, and projected to fall every year as far out as the CBO can project. The current level is high, but we've been higher and have come back from it. It was 118.9% back in 1946. So, there's no need to panic. As in '46, we're now set on a path where we fully expect to pull back from the brink, as long as we don't do anything stupid. But doing something stupid is just what Bush plans.

He plans a tax cut along the lines of what his brother pushed through, and we saw what that did. Debt, which had fallen from 64.9% of GDP in the mid '90s all the way to 54.6% in 2001, surged back up with Dubya's tax cutting. By the time Obama's tax increases finally kicked in, for 2013, debt was already 100.8% of GDP. That's a 46.2-point increase in debt during that period of the Bush-level taxes. We may not be in a debt crisis today with debt at 103.6% of GDP and falling, but how about if it's 150% and rising? That would be a crisis.

Oops:

Over the next 10 years, the outlook does not differ substantially from the one we described in March. Under an assumption that current laws generally remain in place, deficits as a percentage of GDP are estimated to remain below this year's level for the next three years but then begin to rise.

https://www.cbo.gov/publication/50777
 
in arkady's universe "economic growth" is evil, because it just leads to more "corporate drones" and "climate change"

he aspires to a world where everyone works for the government - but never drives to work. the telecommunte from their Yurts, and send emails all day advising how to tweak various government giveaways.

He must think of it as evil, as he wants to emulate tax policy that all but insures less than 1% economic growth.
 
Oops:

Over the next 10 years, the outlook does not differ substantially from the one we described in March. Under an assumption that current laws generally remain in place, deficits as a percentage of GDP are estimated to remain below this year's level for the next three years but then begin to rise.

https://www.cbo.gov/publication/50777

The poor guy.... all that pecking away at his keyboard. Clearly this hasn't worked out for him as he planned.
 
The poor guy.... all that pecking away at his keyboard. Clearly this hasn't worked out for him as he planned.

He's not a dumb guy, which is why I suggest he is a propagandist. He knows the facts, but he uses his (lawyerly) debate tactics in an attempt to pull of the equivalence of getting the guilty party off scott free by conflating and disguising the facts about the case. I see right through that so that makes me his biggest enemy around here. And it's a role I relish (because I'm pretty good at it).
 
If you don't own physical gold in place of bonds/treasuries in your investment strategy you are making a mistake and you're enabling the Federal government to keep on increasing the national debt.

or

If you don't buy physical gold instead of bonds/treasuries, then you're a big part of the problem with what is wrong with government because you're enabling their behavior. STOP buying treasuries buy gold.
 
He's not a dumb guy, which is why I suggest he is a propagandist. He knows the facts, but he uses his (lawyerly) debate tactics in an attempt to pull of the equivalence of getting the guilty party off scott free by conflating and disguising the facts about the case. I see right through that so that makes me his biggest enemy around here. And it's a role I relish (because I'm pretty good at it).

There's no question he's quite intelligent. However, I do think he's a bit delusional about his powers of persuasion.
 
Back
Top