New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Hypocrisy Test

Cool... what kind of jet do you have?
Did someone suggest to you I have a jet? Who, exactly? Or was that some sort of hallucination you were suffering? If so, you ought to look into psychiatric care, as you may be a danger to yourself and others.
 
You don't seem to catch on quickly. Why would you want to emulate the tax policy of a region with such low economic growth?

I don't. Did you hear me bring up creating a VAT? Currently, most of Europe has flatter taxes than we do, and I'm arguing for more progressive taxes than we currently have, so I'm arguing for moving in the opposite direction as their structure. The only way it would be more like them is in bringing in more revenue overall -- which wouldn't just be more like Europe, but more like just about every other developed nation in the world (Chile and Mexico being the exceptions).

You really ought to pay closer attention to tax questions if you want to discuss the topic intelligently.
 
I don't belong here in this thread. I'm not a green eye shade number cruncher. I don't know how to manipulate data to my advantage in such discussions. I don't spend all my time doing that. I don't spend sleepless nights wondering what I should include in my spreadsheet and what to exclude.

All I can do is point out that without exception these screeds/analyses always stop with how much rich folks save in taxes. That's the end of the story... and it's therefore assumed by the low info reader that they put it under their pillows.

Fact is they invest it in something, or they put it in a bank which lends it out to people who want to start a business or by a home, or car, or send their kids to college. Or, as a last resort, they buy a yacht. In every case that money is circulating, and while it's circulating (spent) it creates jobs. The faster it circulates the better. Even college professors spend money. And when money is spent it is taxed.

So has anyone ever calculated how much in taxes actually is returned to to federal, state, and local coffers as a result?

Maybe you or Lukey know what that amounts to?
Regardless of what policies we choose, some of that flows back into the economy. If we started a program to hand out money to jobless drug users so they can get high, they'd spend that money, and so would their dealers, and some of it would flow back into the economy, the same as the money that goes to rich people when you cut upper-class taxes. But that doesn't mean those things are a good idea.
 
Hahahaha! No they don't

It depends who is president. When a Republican is president, the economy tends to underperform relative to CBO forecasts, whereas when a Democrat is president, it tends to outperform.

And why is it you are a font of information until I ask a simple question that would reveal a key piece of data that undermines your entire argument - and then suddenly you have no clue?

What makes you think that key piece of data would undermine rather than bolster my argument? Be specific, please.
 
For years, a large majority of major politicians and commentators on the right (and in the self-proclaimed center) pretended to be deeply concerned about deficits, when that gave them an excuse to demand increasingly austere government budgets. Republicans forced government shutdowns over the issue, and op-ed writers pushed for reduction of social security benefits and savage cuts to the social safety net. Well, now we get to see if this was a genuine (albeit newly developed) principle, or simply a fig leaf for an anti-government agenda. Jeb Bush has debuted a tax plan that would cause gigantic increases in deficits, in order to further increase the wealth of the ruling class. Will the supposed deficit hawks speak out against it? Or will it be a flashback to the Bush and Reagan years, when deficits were treated as not mattering?

Bush's plan calls for reducing marginal tax rates. He has set this up to do nothing to provide tax relief to poorer workers, who are actually struggling to pay. The 10% bracket remains 10%. But for the rich, it'll be a monumental windfall: the 39.6% bracket goes down to 28%. Let's say you're Jeb Bush, and you brought in $7.4 million last year. This change would mean about $850,000 more in take-home pay. But, of course, you don't get something for nothing. That $850,000 has to come from somewhere else: higher payments from the less fortunate (either that amount today, or a whole lot more through the magic of debt with compound interest in the future), or else further cuts to spending. Keep in mind US spending is already the third-lowest of any developed nation on a per/GDP basis (behind only Mexico and Chile, which barely even qualify as developed nations).

That's not the only aristocracy-favoring change Bush embedded in his plan. When you come from old, old money like the Bush's, your real constituency are people with family compounds and second yachts. So, instead of the mortgage interest rate deduction being limited to the first $1 Million of debt, as currently, the tax value is capped at 2% of AGI, so that rich people's write offs can be higher than the write-offs of the middle class, even for a given amount of debt. If you earn $50,000, the maximum tax value of the mortgage interest deduction will be just $1,000 for you, but if, like Jeb!, you earned $7.4 million, go ahead and write off up to $148,000. Jeb! also eliminates the phase-outs for personal exemptions and itemized deductions, and eliminates personal AMT. These changes have absolutely no value for the majority of Americans, but they're a very big deal for the rich.

Jeb! also slashes the top corporate tax rate by 15 points. Keep in mind that US corporations already pay a below-average effective tax rate by the standards of the developed world generally, and they pay vastly less of the overall tax burden in this country than they did in our economic golden age. Corporate AMT is also eliminated, which not only makes it easier for well-represented corporations to dodge taxes entirely, but also increases the incentive for economically inefficient behavior corporations engage in merely to lower tax liability (with AMT, such tax-dodging measure reach a point of diminishing returns and companies stop bothering, but without AMT, there's no limit to how low you can go).

Jeb! also makes sure that rich folks who don't actually work for a living get a bonus in take home pay, relative to those who do something productive with their lives. If you're some snot-nosed trust-fund brat living off a portfolio, you get to pay just 20% on your capital gains, dividends, and interest. If you hire a professional, like a doctor, lawyer, or accountant, they could be paying up to 28% on their earnings, for the "sin" of having actually done something to deserve the money, but you get to coast by with just a 20% cut taken.

Jeb! also screws over small-time savers. The change to a 20% rate on interest may be a windfall to the rich, who previously paid at ordinary income rates, which were higher for them. But for the poor, it represents a tax hike. If you're some small-time saver just trying to build up a little cushion in a savings account, previously your interest might be taxed at just your 10% ordinary rate. Now, that'll be doubled, to help to finance that windfall for the rich.

Probably the most indefensible change, though, would be eliminating the estate tax. Already, even most multi-million-dollar estates are tax free: only if the net value of the estate is over $5.43 million is even a dime of it taxed. But, if you're sitting around waiting for Pappy to die so you can get your hands on part of the Bush family fortune, that cap probably seems much too low, so Jeb! want to get rid of estate taxes entirely. As a result, someone who earns many millions of dollars through his own genius and hard work will be heavily taxed, while someone who "earns" the exact same amount for sitting on his ass and having his name show up in the right will pays NOTHING. As with the reduction of investment tax rates, the principle here is clear: actual productive labor needs to be punished -- the less someone does to deserve his money, the more of that money he should get in take-home pay. The "little people" who actually make their way through hard work, are the ones who should support the country, not the children of the aristocracy. For someone like Bush, who was born into multi-generational wealth, that probably makes perfect sense.

It takes real effort to make Donald Trump look like he's not the dumbest, most vicious guy in a field of candidates. But Jeb! has done it.
TL; DR. Where was the test?
 
Oops:

Over the next 10 years, the outlook does not differ substantially from the one we described in March. Under an assumption that current laws generally remain in place, deficits as a percentage of GDP are estimated to remain below this year's level for the next three years but then begin to rise.

https://www.cbo.gov/publication/50777
I hadn't seen that. It's good to see that deficits will be lower than currently for three years. If the CBO is right and they then start to rise, we have some easily available tools to deal with that. Taxes are relatively low (relative both to where they were in the Clinton years and where they are in most developed nations), so we can increase those to boost revenues without expecting much in the way of bad side effects.

Moreover, as you know, we also have an obscenely bloated military, that spends about four and a half times as much as the next-closest country's military. Especially with recent news that the second-place military is cutting 300,000 troops, we'll have more scope than ever to scale back to a sanely-funded military, saving hundreds of billions of dollars per year.

So, we have lots of options to get our deficit down even as an aging demographic puts new strains on the nation.

Further good news (as I earlier informed you) is that the CBO tends to be overly pessimistic when Democrats are president, so actual performance will probably be better than they're projecting. For example, consider where they projected we'd be just a few years back, when Obama had just taken office:

https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/111th-congress-2009-2010/reports/08-25-budgetupdate.pdf

They thought that by 2015 the deficit would be $558 billion, rising to $620 billion next year! Now they says the deficit's for 2015 will be just $426 billion, which will fall to $414 billion in 2016.

https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/f...015-2016/reports/50724-Update-OneColumn_1.pdf

Will we continue to beat CBO expectations by such huge margins? Tough to say. A lot of it depends on whether we get a Democratic president after 2016. When you have smart deficit-fighting measures like Obamacare, you can make excellent progress even while improving quality of life for millions of Americans. But, if we go back to some imbecilic tax-cutting scheme like those of Reagan and Bush, while shifting even more government spending into the military sector (rather than somewhere with better multipliers) then we'll probably prove the CBO projections wrong in the other direction.
 
Last edited:
TL; DR. Where was the test?
The test is simply whether those who have spent the Obama years posing a deficit hawks (in order to give them a platform from which to demand savage social spending cuts), will speak out against the Bush tax plan, which would greatly increase the deficit. Or will they suddenly find (again) that they don't think deficits matter, thereby showing their prior stance to be a pretense?
 
The test is simply whether those who have spent the Obama years posing a deficit hawks (in order to give them a platform from which to demand savage social spending cuts), will speak out against the Bush tax plan, which would greatly increase the deficit. Or will they suddenly find (again) that they don't think deficits matter, thereby showing their prior stance to be a pretense?
There's validity to your point, but also an oversimplification.

Trickle-down economics is BS. GHW Bush was right to call it "Voodoo economics". OTOH, Obama's priority coming into office wasn't to fix the budget (which he should have done!) but to increase the costs by imposing his healthcare plan.

I supported, and still do, healthcare reform, but we don't have it. President Obama's naivete coming into office led him to push an agenda which didn't fix the problems of rising healthcare costs. It certainly didn't fix any of the problems you've pointed out caused by the Bush administration. It just added to them.
 
There's validity to your point, but also an oversimplification.

Trickle-down economics is BS. GHW Bush was right to call it "Voodoo economics". OTOH, Obama's priority coming into office wasn't to fix the budget

My criticism of Obama is essentially the opposite. He put too much emphasis on fixing the budget, at a time when we ought to have been increasing deficits in order to accelerate out of the Great Recession. It was the mistake of 1937 all over again, and Obama was largely responsible for it. That said, I do give him credit for Obamacare, since even though it decreased deficits, it did so in a way that probably didn't reduce overall economic stimulus, and it moved us towards a solution to one of the nation's most long-standing and glaring problems. And we've been enjoying much lower healthcare cost increases ever since than we had in the pre-Obamacare era.
 
Last edited:
By criticism of Obama is essentially the opposite. He put too much emphasis on fixing the budget, at a time when we ought to have been increasing deficits in order to accelerate out of the Great Recession. It was the mistake of 1937 all over again, and Obama was largely responsible for it. That said, I do give him credit for Obamacare, since even though it decreased deficits, it did so in a way that probably didn't reduce overall economic stimulus, and it moved us towards a solution to one of the nation's most long-standing and glaring problems. And we've been enjoying much lower healthcare cost increases ever since than we had in the pre-Obamacare era.

I disagree, but admit that we need a half century of distance to see the final results before declaring, with finality, "woulda, coulda, shoulda".
 
Regardless of what policies we choose, some of that flows back into the economy. If we started a program to hand out money to jobless drug users so they can get high, they'd spend that money, and so would their dealers, and some of it would flow back into the economy, the same as the money that goes to rich people when you cut upper-class taxes. But that doesn't mean those things are a good idea.

In other word you're dodging the question.

Unless you put the money under the mattress or bury it all flows back into the economy.
Be it through a bank an investment or consumption. How fast it circulates directly affects how much in new taxes is generated.

In my MBA studies it was called "circulating capital flow speed". Same would be true with taxes. Simple example is inventory turnover. A company turning it's inventory over 3x a year generates more profit than a company that turns it twice. The faster money flows through the system the more taxes are generated.

The question then becomes how long does it take for a rich man's $100,000 tax cut to generate $100,000 in new state, local, and federal taxes.

I don't know that there's anyway to calculate or approximate the answer, but it's a fact that it is returned. In a robust economy, something we now refer to as the good old days, it's returned sooner rather than later.
 
In other word you're dodging the question.

Unless you put the money under the mattress or bury it all flows back into the economy.
Be it through a bank an investment or consumption. How fast it circulates directly affects how much in new taxes is generated.

In my MBA studies it was called "circulating capital flow speed". Same would be true with taxes. Simple example is inventory turnover. A company turning it's inventory over 3x a year generates more profit than a company that turns it twice. The faster money flows through the system the more taxes are generated.

The question then becomes how long does it take for a rich man's $100,000 tax cut to generate $100,000 in new state, local, and federal taxes.

I don't know that there's anyway to calculate or approximate the answer, but it's a fact that it is returned. In a robust economy, something we now refer to as the good old days, it's returned sooner rather than later.
The "good old days," in terms of strongest rates of economic growth, were between the mid-1930s and the late 1960s. Care to guess what the top bracket paid in income taxes back then?
 
It depends who is president. When a Republican is president, the economy tends to underperform relative to CBO forecasts, whereas when a Democrat is president, it tends to outperform.



What makes you think that key piece of data would undermine rather than bolster my argument? Be specific, please.

Oops:

In CBO's forecast, the growth of real GDP picks up after 2011, averaging 4.1 percent annually from 2012 through 2014 and closing the gap between GDP and its potential level (the amount of production that corresponds to a high use of labor and capital) by the end of 2014.

https://www.cbo.gov/publication/21670
 
The "good old days," in terms of strongest rates of economic growth, were between the mid-1930s and the late 1960s. Care to guess what the top bracket paid in income taxes back then?

Correlation isn't necessarily causation. There's a WHOLE LOT of variables you are assuming away as potentially being the cause of that economic growth in spite of high tax rates. It's as silly as your notion that we can simply adopt Scandinavian economic and social policies and be as successful as they are with them. It's economic myopia of the worst kind. But you might be onto something on the income tax.

I'm becoming rather disgusted at the conspicuous consumption excesses of the economic elites and I'm certainly amenable to raising marginal rates on income in excess of some notion of "enough is enough." Let them go back to building wealth through the long term capital gains that are passed on to the next generation. All this monetization and $400,000 cars and 100 foot yachts and gold plated jets are beginning to offend my sense of decorum.
 
All this monetization and $400,000 cars and 100 foot yachts and gold plated jets are beginning to offend my sense of decorum.
I suspect that if you brought back a bunch of mid-20th-century Republican millionaires, they'd be equally offended on similar grounds. The culture was different then. There was more of a sense of "noblesse oblige" among the wealthy, and a certain sense of shame about showing off their wealth.

You can even see it in pop culture. If you look back at the highly successful music acts of the 50s and 60s, they weren't singing about how much money they had, even though they had a hell of a lot of it. There weren't Beatles songs about drinking bottles of Dom by the case, or Rolling Stones articles about how many Rolls Royces they had, or Beach Boy tunes about their mad stacks of Benjamins. And when the actors of the era let the press into their lives, it was to emphasize what normal people they were, to make them more approachable to their audiences, rather than to show off their insane "cribs" and their jet-set lifestyles. And the celebrity business people of the era emphasized their philanthropic side and their innovative role in creating good jobs, rather than bragging about their gold toilets, Trump-style. That started to change in the early 80s, and seems to have gotten worse ever since. I'm not sure why.

One possibility is that the gap between rich and poor has just grown so huge that the rich are in a whole different mental world now than everyone else. Back when a CEO earned 20 times what a basic worker earned, there were still plenty of shared touchstones of experience. Now that they make 300 times as much as typical worker, they're practically different species.
 
The "good old days," in terms of strongest rates of economic growth, were between the mid-1930s and the late 1960s. Care to guess what the top bracket paid in income taxes back then?

Why do I bother with you? You won't address my point, you're smart enough to understand it but refuse to even address it...which means you can'r argue with it . That's satisfying in itself, so thanks

You do know that anybody reading this understands what I said...and now they know you're a partisan hack.
 
I suspect that if you brought back a bunch of mid-20th-century Republican millionaires, they'd be equally offended on similar grounds. The culture was different then. There was more of a sense of "noblesse oblige" among the wealthy, and a certain sense of shame about showing off their wealth.

You can even see it in pop culture. If you look back at the highly successful music acts of the 50s and 60s, they weren't singing about how much money they had, even though they had a hell of a lot of it. There weren't Beatles songs about drinking bottles of Dom by the case, or Rolling Stones articles about how many Rolls Royces they had, or Beach Boy tunes about their mad stacks of Benjamins. And when the actors of the era let the press into their lives, it was to emphasize what normal people they were, to make them more approachable to their audiences, rather than to show off their insane "cribs" and their jet-set lifestyles. And the celebrity business people of the era emphasized their philanthropic side and their innovative role in creating good jobs, rather than bragging about their gold toilets, Trump-style. That started to change in the early 80s, and seems to have gotten worse ever since. I'm not sure why.

One possibility is that the gap between rich and poor has just grown so huge that the rich are in a whole different mental world now than everyone else. Back when a CEO earned 20 times what a basic worker earned, there were still plenty of shared touchstones of experience. Now that they make 300 times as much as typical worker, they're practically different species.

Haha! The Beatles were singing about the "tax man." But frankly when the income tax rates were high it likely provided an incentive to plow profits back into the business rather than take a big payout and we miss that incentive in our economy today. It was a savings account for the next generation (and beyond). Then when the progressives tried to limit the salary compensation (by limiting the corporate tax deduction to $1 million) it unleashed the stock option mania which has really perverted corporate finance. I think the key is to set tax rates high enough on the top end to get people building businesses again instead of looking for a quick cash out flip transaction but it will also take a roll back of the regulatory overreach and the employment mandates to give people who desire to build a business in America a fighting chance against their Chinese and Indian counterparts.
 
Did someone suggest to you I have a jet? Who, exactly? Or was that some sort of hallucination you were suffering? If so, you ought to look into psychiatric care, as you may be a danger to yourself and others.

To me and my peers and/or the circles I run in, rich means having enough for your own jet. You're not rich. No big deal.
 
The "good old days," in terms of strongest rates of economic growth, were between the mid-1930s and the late 1960s. Care to guess what the top bracket paid in income taxes back then?

Ever heard of cause and effect?
 
Back
Top