New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Indentured Servants?

Barbella

Senator
Some posters here assert that having restrictions on abortion amounts to reducing women to "indentured servant" or "slave" status. I'd argue that, in one way or another, most of us are "indentured servants" or "slaves".

For example....if I don't work, I don't get paid. Therefore, I'm an indentured servant to my desire to eat and have a roof over my head. I don't see how I have much of a choice in this matter....it's almost like "slavery"!

There are lots of things I really don't want to do. I hate doing laundry....but unless I want to run around in dirty, smelly clothes, I have no choice but to wash them. Slavery!

I'm a slave to my horses. They expect me to feed them, pamper them, and clean up after them every single day, no matter if I feel like it or not. AND they expect me to PAY for their upkeep! The nerve!

Oh, and my KIDS! They insist that I be there for them when they need me! What do they think I am....an indentured servant? Then again...guess what? I AM there for them....my love for them makes me their slave!

There are thousands of laws, rules, and regulations in our society. Why in the world should abortion be exempt? Especially since MOST people are perfectly agreeable to keeping abortion legal in the first trimester, but DO want to see certain restrictions in the second and third? The majority of countries already DO just that....and they're absolutely right.

Other than medical emergencies, women who want an abortion need to be encouraged to do it as early as possible in their pregnancy....if their own lack of responsibility and common sense prevents them from making up their minds about this matter early on, then they obviously need a little push. Making abortion illegal in the second and third trimester (exempting sound medical reasons) may help to do just that.
 
Some posters here assert that having restrictions on abortion amounts to reducing women to "indentured servant" or "slave" status. I'd argue that, in one way or another, most of us are "indentured servants" or "slaves".

For example....if I don't work, I don't get paid. Therefore, I'm an indentured servant to my desire to eat and have a roof over my head. I don't see how I have much of a choice in this matter....it's almost like "slavery"!

There are lots of things I really don't want to do. I hate doing laundry....but unless I want to run around in dirty, smelly clothes, I have no choice but to wash them. Slavery!

I'm a slave to my horses. They expect me to feed them, pamper them, and clean up after them every single day, no matter if I feel like it or not. AND they expect me to PAY for their upkeep! The nerve!

Oh, and my KIDS! They insist that I be there for them when they need me! What do they think I am....an indentured servant? Then again...guess what? I AM there for them....my love for them makes me their slave!

There are thousands of laws, rules, and regulations in our society. Why in the world should abortion be exempt? Especially since MOST people are perfectly agreeable to keeping abortion legal in the first trimester, but DO want to see certain restrictions in the second and third? The majority of countries already DO just that....and they're absolutely right.

Other than medical emergencies, women who want an abortion need to be encouraged to do it as early as possible in their pregnancy....if their own lack of responsibility and common sense prevents them from making up their minds about this matter early on, then they obviously need a little push. Making abortion illegal in the second and third trimester (exempting sound medical reasons) may help to do just that.

My compliments, Wulk. An excellent take on a touchy subject. Gramps/
 
The only slavery lefties want is for taxpayers to be slaves to the government and ie to the non-working, entitlement-minded leeches of America. But hey....that's just my perspective.....

LOL!
 
Some posters here assert that having restrictions on abortion amounts to reducing women to "indentured servant" or "slave" status. I'd argue that, in one way or another, most of us are "indentured servants" or "slaves".

For example....if I don't work, I don't get paid. Therefore, I'm an indentured servant to my desire to eat and have a roof over my head. I don't see how I have much of a choice in this matter....it's almost like "slavery"!
Nope. Because there is no government coercing you to work. You can CHOOSE to beg. to stand in line at the soup kitchen, to spend your day fishing at the fishing pier.

Nor is there any government coercion in making you do laundry, nor keep horses, nor even to keep your kids. You can put them into orphanages and foster homes.

Nor can you be forced to donate blood to save your children

Nor can you be forced to donate any organ to save your children

You may CHOOSE to do so, but you cannot be COERCED INVOLUNTARILY to do so


Now a woman who has a fetus and does not want to carry it to term should have all the same rights as you have to walk away. When The Government uses legal force to take away that decision, it is coercion into involuntary servitude.

And it doesn't matter how soon or late the decision is made, the fact of the matter is, it is still their body.


In fact the "servitude clause" of Am 13 was put into the Constitution SPECIFICALLY to allow sharecroppers from being coerced into de facto slavery simply because they had not quite understood the consquences of the contracts they VOLUNTARILY SIGNED. IE at any point that they opted to, their servitude to any prior contract became Involuntary.

Same with a woman that is hosting a fetus - regardless of whether or not that servitude is to a hypothetical "fetal person" or to The Government's "interest in promoting life".
 
The only slavery lefties want is for taxpayers to be slaves to the government and ie to the non-working, entitlement-minded leeches of America. But hey....that's just my perspective.....

LOL!
Sure and a perspective that is ignorant of the fact that even CONSERVATIVE organizations like The Tax Foundation http://www.taxfoundation.org/research/show/22685.html show that Conservative Red regions of the country ARE the "entitlement minded leaches of America" it tells us something about how well you have reasoned out that perspective


FACTS MATTER
got any?
 
And if a woman wants an abortion in the first trimester, she's perfectly free to do so. She absolutely has that choice.
 
And if a woman wants an abortion in the first trimester, she's perfectly free to do so. She absolutely has that choice.
And precluding her from doing so after the 1st trimester is no differnt than forcing a sharecropper to complete his servitude regardless of how involuntary.

involuntary servitude has no time limit.

And it is an absolute constitutional prohibition that the Supreme court punted on in Roe. Repeal Roe or cripple it too much and this becomes the avenue. Part of what made it viable to ignore it in Roe was that there was no notion of an abortion that did not directly affect the fetus. But with RU 486 and other drugs which do not cross the placental boundary, you are now in the same realm of rights as your local bank's lobby during a killer winter freeze.

you cannot violate property rights to compell the bank to open its doors to the homeless even if that means some of them die.
You cannot even prevent them from evicting the homeless into a killer freeze with nowhere to go.

On what CONSTITUTIONAL BASIS does a woman have less rights over her body than a bank has over its lobby?
 
If a woman is pregnant and can't make up her mind about whether she wants an abortion or not, her servitude becomes VOLUNTARY. She HAD the choice earlier on in her pregnancy....if she decides to blithely ignore the time constraints she should operate under, that's her CHOICE.

There's nothing "involuntary" about choosing.
 
If a woman is pregnant and can't make up her mind about whether she wants an abortion or not, her servitude becomes VOLUNTARY. She HAD the choice earlier on in her pregnancy....if she decides to blithely ignore the time constraints she should operate under, that's her CHOICE.

There's nothing "involuntary" about choosing.

Being forced to servitude is never voluntary. People want to impose arbitrary restrictions (e.g., first trimester) on when abortions should be available, but the choice as to whether or when to abort a child should be the woman's to make at any point during her pregnancy. I think too many people think the decision to abort is easy for a woman to make, and pass their judgments according to their views on this "easy" decision. I think they are wrong in believing the choice is easy to make. Since time women have been choosing when, and whether, to have children. Prior to abortions being available, studies of extant hunter-gatherer cultures (as few as have remained to study for the past 80 or so years) show that women have to make the agonizing choice of whether to leave their babies to die in the event of births spaced too closely together or twins or the death of the father. The choice of what to do with a pregnancy/birth that is not good (for whatever reason) has been the woman's choice to make and I believe should remain under the purview of the woman who bears the child. And it is easy to dismiss women's choices if you clump them under statistical numbers. It is much more painful and difficult to evaluate each of those choices individually. And that is how those choices are made - one woman at a time. WRT indentured servitude - it is not so far in the past (and not in the past at all in many countries) when women were indeed slaves to their wombs. As far as laws in the US go, I say 'never again.'
 
Real slavery still exists in this world. Claiming everyone who doesn't get what they want all the time is a slave is just one more injustice done to those who truly are slaves.
 
The only slavery lefties want is for taxpayers to be slaves to the government and ie to the non-working, entitlement-minded leeches of America. But hey....that's just my perspective.....

LOL!

Isn't it funny how God took a mans rib and created a loud speaker of sorts.
 
The only slavery lefties want is for taxpayers to be slaves to the government and ie to the non-working, entitlement-minded leeches of America. But hey....that's just my perspective.....

LOL!

I'm a "leftie" and that's not my view. Care to alter your generalization?
 
Difference is each & every task you have cited were YOUR CHOICE huh?

Best Regards
Lobato1


Some posters here assert that having restrictions on abortion amounts to reducing women to "indentured servant" or "slave" status. I'd argue that, in one way or another, most of us are "indentured servants" or "slaves".

For example....if I don't work, I don't get paid. Therefore, I'm an indentured servant to my desire to eat and have a roof over my head. I don't see how I have much of a choice in this matter....it's almost like "slavery"!

There are lots of things I really don't want to do. I hate doing laundry....but unless I want to run around in dirty, smelly clothes, I have no choice but to wash them. Slavery!

I'm a slave to my horses. They expect me to feed them, pamper them, and clean up after them every single day, no matter if I feel like it or not. AND they expect me to PAY for their upkeep! The nerve!

Oh, and my KIDS! They insist that I be there for them when they need me! What do they think I am....an indentured servant? Then again...guess what? I AM there for them....my love for them makes me their slave!

There are thousands of laws, rules, and regulations in our society. Why in the world should abortion be exempt? Especially since MOST people are perfectly agreeable to keeping abortion legal in the first trimester, but DO want to see certain restrictions in the second and third? The majority of countries already DO just that....and they're absolutely right.

Other than medical emergencies, women who want an abortion need to be encouraged to do it as early as possible in their pregnancy....if their own lack of responsibility and common sense prevents them from making up their minds about this matter early on, then they obviously need a little push. Making abortion illegal in the second and third trimester (exempting sound medical reasons) may help to do just that.
 
Back
Top