Arkady
President
Earlier I posted the following, showing a strong correlation between places people are poorly educated and places Trump is doing well:
https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/education-and-the-2016-election.94524/#post-1675753
If you compare the expected margin in each state to the percentage of people in each state with Bachelor's degrees, you'll find a coefficient of correlation of about 80.2 -- a strong positive correlation. (and the p-value shows strong statistical significance). Basically, if a lot of people in a state have college educations, Trump is screwed there.
That had me wondering what the data would look like if we looked at IQs, rather than education. Unfortunately, I don't know of any state-by-state IQ testing outcomes. The problem is that to be valid you'd need to either test nearly everyone, or you'd need to test a truly random sampling, and it's tough to do either, since people voluntarily opt in or out of IQ testing.
So, here's the closest thing I could find. The vast majority of eighth graders nation-wide take the NAEP tests every few years. Since drop-out rates are negligible in eighth grade, you're testing similar selections of people in all states. So that we're doing our best to test IQ, rather than just English fluency (which would tend to skew results for border states), I've only looked at the NAEP math results.
Here are the highest and lowest states using that method.
Highest:
Massachusetts
New Hampshire
Vermont
North Dakota
Minnesota
Wisconsin
Montana
Utah
New Jersey
Colorado
Lowest:
Mississippi
Alabama
Hawaii
California
Louisiana
Oklahoma
South Carolina
Arkansas
Nevada
New Mexico
There's some correlation there. Among the high-IQ states, Clinton is expected to win seven of ten, and among the low-IQ states, Trump is expected to win six of ten. But that's much weaker correlation than when it comes to the education stats. I expect that in this case racial factors are disrupting the correlation -- Trump is utterly despised by minorities, who are more likely to score lower on the NAEP tests. So, there are two extremely white high-IQ states in Trump's camp (North Dakota and Montana, which are 6th and 7th whitest), plus Utah (18th whitest), and meanwhile there are high-minority low-IQ states in the Clinton Camp (e.g. Hawaii, California, Nevada, and New Mexico, which are 50th, 49th, 46th, and 48th whitest, respectively).
https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/education-and-the-2016-election.94524/#post-1675753
If you compare the expected margin in each state to the percentage of people in each state with Bachelor's degrees, you'll find a coefficient of correlation of about 80.2 -- a strong positive correlation. (and the p-value shows strong statistical significance). Basically, if a lot of people in a state have college educations, Trump is screwed there.
That had me wondering what the data would look like if we looked at IQs, rather than education. Unfortunately, I don't know of any state-by-state IQ testing outcomes. The problem is that to be valid you'd need to either test nearly everyone, or you'd need to test a truly random sampling, and it's tough to do either, since people voluntarily opt in or out of IQ testing.
So, here's the closest thing I could find. The vast majority of eighth graders nation-wide take the NAEP tests every few years. Since drop-out rates are negligible in eighth grade, you're testing similar selections of people in all states. So that we're doing our best to test IQ, rather than just English fluency (which would tend to skew results for border states), I've only looked at the NAEP math results.
Here are the highest and lowest states using that method.
Highest:
Massachusetts
New Hampshire
Vermont
North Dakota
Minnesota
Wisconsin
Montana
Utah
New Jersey
Colorado
Lowest:
Mississippi
Alabama
Hawaii
California
Louisiana
Oklahoma
South Carolina
Arkansas
Nevada
New Mexico
There's some correlation there. Among the high-IQ states, Clinton is expected to win seven of ten, and among the low-IQ states, Trump is expected to win six of ten. But that's much weaker correlation than when it comes to the education stats. I expect that in this case racial factors are disrupting the correlation -- Trump is utterly despised by minorities, who are more likely to score lower on the NAEP tests. So, there are two extremely white high-IQ states in Trump's camp (North Dakota and Montana, which are 6th and 7th whitest), plus Utah (18th whitest), and meanwhile there are high-minority low-IQ states in the Clinton Camp (e.g. Hawaii, California, Nevada, and New Mexico, which are 50th, 49th, 46th, and 48th whitest, respectively).