New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Interesting Case

I think each school has a right to establish a dress code, and it should be consistent. If a student has a problem with it, they should either acquiesce or go to school elsewhere.

I wouldn't argue with that. I think that the issue in this case is whether the rule is being applied consistently.
 
We're not talking here, about testing athletes for PEDs. There's an argument in favor of such testing simply as a way to keep the playing field level. The problem with PEDs is that they create an unhealthy arms race among competitors, where people get dominated by opponents who are less talented and hard-working simply due to advanced chemistry, and so they feel the need to step up and risk their health the same way, and you get a potential spiral of damaging behavior. If schools limited the tests only to athletes in competitive sports and only PEDs, I wouldn't object. However, that's not what they're doing. They're also testing for drugs that are anything but performance enhancing (like marijuana) and they're testing ALL extra-curriculars, including things like the student newspaper or the math club. That's not about leveling the playing field to prevent students from having to poison themselves to compete on even footing. It's about controlling kids.

It's a testy subject, Arkady. So many drugs are getting into the schools every day, and ruining childrens lives. I'm not talking about a little grass, I'm talking about the drugs that are potentially dangerous like the new one 'Molly'.

http://www.clickondetroit.com/news/...ids/-/1719314/21438274/-/5opjcoz/-/index.html
 
It's a testy subject, Arkady. So many drugs are getting into the schools every day, and ruining childrens lives. I'm not talking about a little grass, I'm talking about the drugs that are potentially dangerous like the new one 'Molly'.

http://www.clickondetroit.com/news/...ids/-/1719314/21438274/-/5opjcoz/-/index.html


Historically, our civil rights have never been trampled upon without first providing a "good reason" for doing so. Thinking of the children is certainly an old standby.
 
Historically, our civil rights have never been trampled upon without first providing a "good reason" for doing so. Thinking of the children is certainly an old standby.

In the hands of some people it can work that way. I just hate seeing kids f**king their minds up or killing themselves.
 
No. You think we're "saving" them by searching their lockers?

They're far more likely to escape MDMA use unscathed than to come out of being imprisoned as psychologically intact, functional citizens.

I don't know, man. When you have 12 yr olds picked up for selling MDMA, or mimics, and you see the number of kids who see them as dangerous dropping, as well as the usage rising, I'd say you're seeing the beginnings of an epidemic.
 
If we want to get all PC about his.. the term "boobies" has obvious sexual connotations, and could make girls feel uncomfortable with lots of guys wearing them.

There's no political point behind them, just pretty much trying to push the envelope for no reason. I'd say let the school decide, but if it has to be a federal mandate, don't allow them.
 
I don't know, man. When you have 12 yr olds picked up for selling MDMA, or mimics, and you see the number of kids who see them as dangerous dropping, as well as the usage rising, I'd say you're seeing the beginnings of an epidemic.

Well, when you put it that way, I guess it's obvious that jack-booted thugs and cages are the only solution.
 
I think each school has a right to establish a dress code, and it should be consistent. If a student has a problem with it, they should either acquiesce or go to school elsewhere.
If there were a whole bunch of schools available, with a wide range of rules, that might be enough. Then you could choose the one that best fits what you're looking for. But, especially in rural areas, kids, as a practical matter, have one "choice" of school. As such, I'm for treating public schools as essentially public squares -- and just as the government can't say "if you don't like our speech rules in this public square, go find another one," it shouldn't be saying that with regard to public schools.
It's a testy subject, Arkady. So many drugs are getting into the schools every day, and ruining childrens lives. I'm not talking about a little grass, I'm talking about the drugs that are potentially dangerous like the new one 'Molly'.

http://www.clickondetroit.com/news/...ids/-/1719314/21438274/-/5opjcoz/-/index.html
People have been freaking out about the supposed rising risk of drugs for sixty years, at least. But it's no reason to conduct unreasonable searches and seizures -- in schools or elsewhere. If there's a reasonable, individualized suspicion of illegal conduct, that justifies a search. But invading the privacy and assaulting the dignity of hundreds of innocents in the hopes of catching a few guilty people betrays our national ideals.
 
In the hands of some people it can work that way. I just hate seeing kids f**king their minds up or killing themselves.
Well, given that teen pregnancy and dropout rates are at an all-time low and teen violent crime rates are down greatly over the last twenty years, while academic performance has improved, it's not like there's some sudden crisis to deal with. If ever there were a time for treating students as actual Americans with civil rights, isn't this it?
 
No. You think we're "saving" them by searching their lockers?

They're far more likely to escape MDMA use unscathed than to come out of being imprisoned as psychologically intact, functional citizens.
Yep. Nearly all my friends from high school illegally used mind altering substances. We all grew up to be solid, contributing members of society. If we'd been randomly searched, discovered, and expelled or jailed, for that harmless youthful experimentation, I'm betting that wouldn't be the case.
 
Well, given that teen pregnancy and dropout rates are at an all-time low and teen violent crime rates are down greatly over the last twenty years, while academic performance has improved, it's not like there's some sudden crisis to deal with. If ever there were a time for treating students as actual Americans with civil rights, isn't this it?

Oh Arkady, please... Think of the children!
 
If we want to get all PC about his.. the term "boobies" has obvious sexual connotations, and could make girls feel uncomfortable with lots of guys wearing them.

There's no political point behind them, just pretty much trying to push the envelope for no reason. I'd say let the school decide, but if it has to be a federal mandate, don't allow them.
If you're uncomfortable with the sexual connotations, and you're unconvinced by the political value of the message of awareness, you have available to you a simple solution: don't wear the bracelet. The question is why you should be able to impose your view on others.

Take your avatar as an example. I consider it the very height of bad taste. What kind of a sicko would use that little space to display a human being getting tortured to death? I have trouble imagining anything as crass and disturbing as that. But that doesn't make me want to censor it. Nobody is forcing me to post a similar pic of some other ancient tool for making people suffer and die. We each get to choose for ourselves, and that's fine. Even if you wanted to wear that unimaginably vulgar image on a necklace as a public school student, I'd defend your right to do so. So longer as less tasteless students weren't likewise forced to don your torture porn iconography, it's fine.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top