New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Is this discrimination?

Me? I think the hospital should have never granted the patients request in this matter, and the nurse is justified in her lawsuit because she was prevented from doing her job because of her race.

Agreed. I think they should have told the moron to go find another hospital for his little Nazi.
 
Its discrimination on the part of the patient. It is the hospital complying with a patient request. Assuming she was not docked pay or prohibited from working her shift at all, just prohibited from dealing with this particular patient, and issue that no one outside of management should have known since it was in the patient chart that no one else should have been privy too, I don't see what the "damages" were. And, why the hospital should be liable for them. If they had not acquiesced to the patient demands they would likely have been sued by the patient.

connie
 
Its discrimination on the part of the patient. It is the hospital complying with a patient request. Assuming she was not docked pay or prohibited from working her shift at all, just prohibited from dealing with this particular patient, and issue that no one outside of management should have known since it was in the patient chart that no one else should have been privy too, I don't see what the "damages" were. And, why the hospital should be liable for them. If they had not acquiesced to the patient demands they would likely have been sued by the patient.

connie

Sued by the patient on what legal grounds connie? He could have refused service and gone elsewhere.
 
Under the Patients Bill of Rights as adopted by the American Hospital Association. The one that says that Hospitals would respect the patients decision making and other care decisions and be aware of cultural racial differences. Essentially, they didn't provide him the standard level of care by not respecting is cultural opposition to having a black nurse. Much like if a muslim woman patient would refuse to have a male gynecologist treat her.

http://mhcc.maryland.gov/consumerinfo/hospitalguide/patients/consumer_help/bill_of_rights.htm

connie

ETA - I realize this isn't law. But, if the hospital participates they are accepting that the will strive to treat patients in this manner. And, a patient has a right to respect certain dignaties will be afforded them.

Besides - anyone can sue for anything. Whether it moves on is a whole other issue.
 
Under the Patients Bill of Rights as adopted by the American Hospital Association. The one that says that Hospitals would respect the patients decision making and other care decisions and be aware of cultural racial differences. Essentially, they didn't provide him the standard level of care by not respecting is cultural opposition to having a black nurse. Much like if a muslim woman patient would refuse to have a male gynecologist treat her.

http://mhcc.maryland.gov/consumerinfo/hospitalguide/patients/consumer_help/bill_of_rights.htm

connie

ETA - I realize this isn't law. But, if the hospital participates they are accepting that the will strive to treat patients in this manner. And, a patient has a right to respect certain dignaties will be afforded them.

Besides - anyone can sue for anything. Whether it moves on is a whole other issue.

The patients bill of rights, which you linked, doesn't say anything at all about a patient having the right to refuse care from particuar staff members because of the staff member's race. The only mention of race at all, which isn't in the enumerated patients rights, is that the hospital should "be aware of cultural, racial, language, religious, age, gender, and other differences as well as the needs of persons with disabilities," which is clearly a mandate on the hospital staff to treat people regardless of cultural, racial, language, etc., differences; it is NOT permission for patients or their families to demand an "all white" care staff.

As for your comparison to a Muslim woman not wanting a male gynecologist, there is a clear difference between a religious prohibition on having a male gynecologist and a racist insistence on not having a black caregiver. What would the father have done if there was an emergency and the only attending immediately available was black? Let his kid die? The hospital should NOT have complied with this ridiculous demand. If the dude wanted to sue, the hospital would have won handily.
 
You think there is a difference because you want to just dismiss this man's beliefs. There is likely NO difference to him. That is the point.

The statement says the patient has a right to control his care. That would be choosing the staff. And considerations of race and cultural issues should be taken. This is a race - cultural issue. I doubt the hosptial would have won so handily. I person should have the right to choose their care-giver - or request a different one.

connie
 
You think there is a difference because you want to just dismiss this man's beliefs. There is likely NO difference to him. That is the point.

The statement says the patient has a right to control his care. That would be choosing the staff. And considerations of race and cultural issues should be taken. This is a race - cultural issue. I doubt the hosptial would have won so handily. I person should have the right to choose their care-giver - or request a different one.

connie

There's a difference because one is a religious proscription against strange (i.e., non-family) men seeing a Muslim woman naked. However, in cases of emergencies - such as a woman bleeding out or something - a non family member man could see her naked, so she could be seen in that case by a male physician.

Religions proscriptions (another example would be not serving Jewish people pork in the hospital) are protected. Racist ones, not so much. Nor should anyone want them to be. If I were the hospital administrator I would have told that man that the nurse in question was the nurse for that area and if he didn't like it he could find another hospital. Same as I would tell someone coming into my restaurant and wanting to be served only by white servers. Tough shit, find another restaurant.
 
How would respecting the patient's family's views in this area be any different from, for example, respecting a Jehovah's Witness patients right to not receive a blood transfusion. In both cases, the care is being rejected on cultural grounds that have nothing to do with medicine.
 
That is your right as a business owner. I think there is a difference when we are talking about health care options though. I doubt you can just up and move your baby to another NICU - particularly when that hospital would likely have to sign you out and coordinate your transfer.
 
I think racisim is a deeply held personal belief based on nothing but a bunch of made up drivel. So, certainly like a religion.
 
I think racisim is a deeply held personal belief based on nothing but a bunch of made up drivel. So, certainly like a religion.


You are under no obligation to respect religious beliefs, but respecting racism is rather twisted, in my humble opinion.

I'm confident that certain posters on this forum would have taken a totally different attitude toward this situation had the father been a member of the Black Panthers and he'd demanded that no white nurses attend to his baby's care.
 
I don't respect racisim. I recognize to those who are racist to the extent they would be neo-nazis and would refuse the care of an Black nurse or Dr. are as fanatically about it as many are about their religion. Doesn't make either right. But, it is naive to think that these people don't take it as seriously. It isn't a passing fad or idea for them. And, I don't think minimizing its significance to them accomplishes anything.
 
I don't respect racisim. I recognize to those who are racist to the extent they would be neo-nazis and would refuse the care of an Black nurse or Dr. are as fanatically about it as many are about their religion. Doesn't make either right. But, it is naive to think that these people don't take it as seriously. It isn't a passing fad or idea for them. And, I don't think minimizing its significance to them accomplishes anything.


So then, you favor the idea of our official government policy condoning deference to racism in the same manner that it condones deference to religious beliefs?
 
Nope. But, we are allowed as individuals to discriminate. You can still organize hate groups. I can still refuse to be treated by someone that I hated, if I felt that way. And, that would be OK, and I would expect that my service provider would honor my request. What is not legal is for the service provider decline to provide services to me. That is what our government protects. Not the other way around.

connie
 
Back
Top