New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Is This Racist?

Zam-Zam

Senator
I leave it for you to decide for yourself:


Your folk never used all this sheit [sic] to protect my folk from your slave-holding, murdering, adulterous, baby-raping, incestuous, snaggle-toothed, backward-a**ed, inbreed [sic], imported criminal-minded kin folk. You can keep sending me stuff like you have however because it helps me explain to my constituents why they should protect that 2nd amendment thing AFTER we finish stocking up on spare parts, munitions and the like.


- Alabama State Rep. Joe Mitchell (D-Mobile)


Complete text: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/03/27/joe-mitchell-alabama_n_2966361.html



Is that how a state legislator should talk? Are we fine with that?
 
Yes. And, he sounds like a loon.

ETA - I would like to see the letter the constituent first wrote.


connie
 
Let me ask you this, Zam. Is it racist if one of your compatriots naturally assume, in a statement, that someone of color sells drugs?
 
That depends. Is Rep. Mitchell white? If he is not, he can not be racist.

Only the white devil can be.

Because--prisons aside--there is nowhere in U.S. society where Blacks have the power to systematically oppress whites the way Blacks are systematically oppressed by whites on a daily basis. That said, Mr. Mitchell sounds a bit pissed off. Probably not the best way to bridge racial gaps.
 
I'll give credit to Connieb and Bdtex: They both answered the question directly. That's becoming a lost art.
 
I leave it for you to decide for yourself:


Your folk never used all this sheit [sic] to protect my folk from your slave-holding, murdering, adulterous, baby-raping, incestuous, snaggle-toothed, backward-a**ed, inbreed [sic], imported criminal-minded kin folk. You can keep sending me stuff like you have however because it helps me explain to my constituents why they should protect that 2nd amendment thing AFTER we finish stocking up on spare parts, munitions and the like.


- Alabama State Rep. Joe Mitchell (D-Mobile)


Complete text: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/03/27/joe-mitchell-alabama_n_2966361.html



Is that how a state legislator should talk? Are we fine with that?

The racial element wasn't obvious from what you quoted, but he certainly sounds horrible. With perhaps thousands of state legislators, and a brain-dead national electorate, though, it's surprising we don't have more jackasses like that in office.
 
Because--prisons aside--there is nowhere in U.S. society where Blacks have the power to systematically oppress whites the way Blacks are systematically oppressed by whites on a daily basis. That said, Mr. Mitchell sounds a bit pissed off. Probably not the best way to bridge racial gaps.


"..there is nowhere in U.S. society where Blacks have the power to systematically oppress whites the way Blacks are systematically oppressed by whites on a daily basis."??????????

Meaning what exactly? That this somehow means the ugly trait of racism is limited to only one race? THAT sounds racist to me, but hey, I am the first to admit that I am no lib so it isn't as if I am free to just re-define things to suit my personel views and opinions the way so many others do, huh?

All that I can do is refer to dictionaries, try to see exactly how it is racism can be limited to one race, care to see what I found?


rac·ism noun \ˈrā-ˌsi-zəm also -ˌshi-\
Definition of RACISM
1: a belief that race is the primary determinant of human traits and capacities and that racial differences produce an inherent superiority of a particular race
2: racial prejudice or discrimination


1: "a belief that race is the primary determinant of human traits...." Hummmmmmmmm....

Like beliving only one race is capable of possessing the trait of racism perhaps???????

2: "racial prejudice or discrimination"

Like beliving only one race can be racist? Isn't THAT in and of itself a prejudice?


But lets check another, shall we?


rac·ism/ˈreɪsɪzəm/ Show Spelled [rey-siz-uhm] Show IPA
noun
1. a belief or doctrine that inherent differences among the various human races determine cultural or individual achievement, usually involving the idea that one's own race is superior and has the right to rule others.
2. a policy, system of government, etc., based upon or fostering such a doctrine; discrimination.
3. hatred or intolerance of another race or other races.


Well, #1 does mention the belief that one race has the right to rule another, but it doesn't mention that having the ability to do so is a factor........

#2 goes with the discrimination that could be involved, but discrimination isn't exactly unique to any one race now is it? As evidenced by the discrimination that some have against whites for being the only race capable of racism.

And then we have #3 there......... "hatred or intolerance of another race or other races".......
WOW........ if one had not been told differently one might get the impression from reading your post that you seem to be awfully intolerant of another race.........Hummmmm....


But lets keep going, surely we will find "racism" defined as "Blacks are systematically oppressed by whites on a daily basis", as you claim.


World English Dictionary
racism or racialism (ˈreɪsɪzəm, ˈreɪʃəˌlɪzəm)

— n
1. the belief that races have distinctive cultural characteristics determined by hereditary factors and that this endows some races with an intrinsic superiority over others
2. abusive or aggressive behaviour towards members of another race on the basis of such a belief



Seems #2 sticks out here.........

"abusive or aggressive behaviour towards members of another race". But let me guess, THAT too is something YOU never see or hear of save when it involves whites towards any other race, am I right or what?



Oh well, sorry to tell you this skippy, but it would appear that your claim that only one race can possess the racism trait is, well, a racist view.
 
Those were extremely offensive comments by Rep. Joe Mitchell. Most certainly, he would not get my vote. Yes, I would classify his remarks as racist.
 
Those were extremely offensive comments by Rep. Joe Mitchell. Most certainly, he would not get my vote. Yes, I would classify his remarks as racist.


I tend to agree.



In the days before e-mail and twitter, one could make a rant like that and, as long as there weren't too many witnesses, simply deny it later. Those days are gone for good.


Not being white, I was curious as to what those who are thought of this. Thanks for the input.
 
Well first of all, you broke up definitions to suit your supposition. The fact is, by and large whites have far more economic superiority over blacks, and therefore actually can enforce discrimination. I don't know how old you are, but it wasn't that long ago that racism stemming from whites was the norm. Affirmative Action gave blacks the ability to more easily integrate themselves into American society. But oh, along comes the move to abolish Affirmative Action, and therefore remove that aid.

But can racism infect both races? Sure it can, but I'd someone to show me evidence if they think blacks have more racism amongst them than whites.
 
It's what I expect from Democrats. I love to see this kind of behavior because it confirms my belief that Liberal Leaders are unscrupulous, obnoxious, uncultured pigs.
 
At least you have you to care about your obnoxious opinions. But I see you and Marvy Martian couldn't answer up back at the other post.
 
I leave it for you to decide for yourself:


Your folk never used all this sheit [sic] to protect my folk from your slave-holding, murdering, adulterous, baby-raping, incestuous, snaggle-toothed, backward-a**ed, inbreed [sic], imported criminal-minded kin folk. You can keep sending me stuff like you have however because it helps me explain to my constituents why they should protect that 2nd amendment thing AFTER we finish stocking up on spare parts, munitions and the like.


- Alabama State Rep. Joe Mitchell (D-Mobile)


Complete text: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/03/27/joe-mitchell-alabama_n_2966361.html



Is that how a state legislator should talk? Are we fine with that?

Yes, it sounds racist and it sounds no better coming from him than it does coming from people whose ancestors enslaved and owned black people in America between the 16th and the 19th century and supported things like Jim Crow laws into the 1960's, just 50 years ago.

Hving read all the exchanges said to be included. Mitchell seems to offer explanation for his offensive e-mail and what ancestors of slaves or recipients of racial discrimination and harm as a result when so many blacks in America were considered the "property" of others in addition to a long period well after the Emancipation Proclamation was made and legal slavery no more are compared to the ancestors of those who kept them as slaves.

I suppose what he points to is what might be more obvious to some, is that any harm felt by the ancestors of those whose ancestors were slave owners, or those that weren't beaten bombed in the 1950's or 1960's because of their race does not compare to the harm done to those who were beaten and bombed because of their race and that makes it difficult to make a claim of "racism" in reverse. He explains this when he speaks of how those without the power, because they don't have power, might be able to string a bunch of offensive words together and through them at those who do have the power and they may be racial, but they can't be "racism" because they don't have any action or power behind them in the same way the acts that do, because those behind them have power, can truly be called "racism".


I would like to see a full quote of both the e-mail sent to Joe Mitchell as well as his full response if the above is not all of it. Having grown up in a Republican family and with some of that family still remaining in that party I get e-mails on a regular basis. Some of them are pretty offensive. It's hard not to respond with anger and emotion, but we can work on resisting the temptation. I would also be interested in seeing some sort of authentication of the e-mails and as already mentioned, the full exchange back and forth.

I wouldn't say an e-mail like this would help Mitchell's position on gun control or anything else, then it might have been worse, he could have been waving a gun around while saying what he said.

Going to read the full exchange now.
 
Back
Top